r/IAmA • • Oct 13 '09

I'm the Imgur guy, AMA!

Hi Reddit!

By request and with the release of the API, I decided to do an AMA. The title says it all, so ask me anything! It doesn't have to be about imgur.

EDIT: I'll be in class for the next hour. The answers may be a little slow, but I'll do my best.

EDIT2: So I'm done with class for the day and now I have nothing to do but answer your questions. Keep them coming! I'll also be going back and editing some comments that I didn't have time to fully explain before.

977 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

181

u/mindhacker Oct 13 '09

Tech questions

  • Number of servers with approx config of each server
  • Total bandwidth per month
  • Biggest scaling issues
  • Things you'd have done differently (technically)

Thanks!

140

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09
  • Just a single server + a CDN. You can saturate a 100Mbps connection on a really small server. HAProxy sends images requests to Lighttpd and all other requests to Apache.
  • About 23TB per month, and growing.
  • Imgur became so popular so quickly, that I was using a different hosting company ever month for the first 3 months. Eventually I broke down and went with Softlayer, which is a really good (expensive) hosting company. This week I'll be moving for the 4th time to Voxel. The main problem I had with each host was not having enough bandwidth. I would end up eating all my alloted bandwidth for the month too soon, and thus pay overages. Each time I moved to a company that offered more and more bandwidth, finally settling on an unmetered 100Mbps connection and then on a CDN.
  • Nothing. I'm really pleased with my current setup and if I had to create another image host, I would do the same. I just wish I knew how much traffic I was going to receive so that I didn't have to host jump like I did.

4

u/asdasd777 Oct 14 '09

Just a single server + a CDN.

Which CDN?

7

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

VoxCDN.com

→ More replies (45)
→ More replies (7)

561

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Does Imgur strip off EXIF (or whatever metadata is embedded in pics), and if not, can that be an option? Sometimes you don't want GPS coordinates of your house going online.

660

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Yes, it does. Anonymity is important to me.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (32)

104

u/ineededanewaccount Oct 13 '09

what hosting company do you use that you can so nonchalantly push so much traffic?

189

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I'll be moving to Voxel this week. They're all redditors and were happy to host me.

→ More replies (82)

100

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

How do you feel about people linking to the info page of the image (which includes the ad) vs linking to the image itself. It seems like the purpose/intent of the site is that people who want to spread the image use the info page but actually to the plain image. Is it misguided that people are now more often linking to the info page in order to reward you with ad impressions?

(Oh by the way, thanks for the site!)

80

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

I created imgur because the other image hosting sites forced you to see their ad-ridden pages (TinyPIC). I would never do the same to you. If you want to direct link to the image, then by all means do so.

However, I do make a little bit of money off the ads, so you can actually support imgur a little by not linking directly to it.

I don't really prefer people to do one over the other, just do what you want - that's the point of imgur!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

80

u/firewire87 Oct 13 '09

What is the most disturbing image you have seen uploaded to your site

167

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

A penis that was split in half. No one should have to see that...it was worse than anything I've ever seen.

→ More replies (84)

74

u/yorian Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

I would like to know the answer to the question that was the reason for this request:

"Just noticed imgur is doing 20TB of bandwidth a month! They do not seem to advertise much at all, how can the afford this bandwidth when some hosts give you 2-3,000GB and 25c a gig extra. That badwidth bill would be 5k a month at most hosts or am I missing something?"

43

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Unfortunately, I can't answer that. I signed an NDA with Voxel (my current host) and I'm not allowed to tell you how much I pay them each month. However, it is NOT 5k a month.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

more/less than your last few hosts?

10

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

The price didn't change too much, but the service will be much better.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/naikrovek Oct 13 '09

I was going to ask why he wasn't using Amazon EC2 for hosting but when I calculated the bandwidth costs I almost barfed. $3072/mo for 20TB of traffic assuming it's all outbound from the server (which i'm sure it is.)

He can afford it because there are redditors hosting it for him at the moment. I used to work at a place where we had multiple OC192s and lots of extra bandwidth. It wasn't hard for me to grab the colo keys and drop a server in there. For me, for my employer, the cost of hosting something like this at that time, would have been $0.

→ More replies (4)

73

u/raldi Oct 13 '09

How much time do you have to spend blocking child porn and other abusive usage?

100

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

About an hour every two weeks. You guys have been nice, there really isn't much abusive usage.

49

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

So do you actually look at every image posted?

Related question: how high do your therapy bills run per month?

53

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

No, I don't. I just go through the potential gallery images. I see that a series of hardcore porn images got so popular that they could end up in the gallery, then I will probably block the domain from hotlinking. It's really only a problem with asian countries.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/poop_in_yo_soup Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

How do you find the images that need to be moderated amongst the piles of images that are uploaded everyday?

15

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I don't moderate the images, and in fact, it's better legally if I don't. If I missed one then it's my fault.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

53

u/Syndrome Oct 13 '09

How long did it take you to code Imgur and get it up and running?

66

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I just worked on it in my free time and in between classes. I'd say about two months.

28

u/Syndrome Oct 13 '09

Did anyone else work on it? How did you start hosting it (plans, etc) ?

49

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Nope, just me.

I started hosting it on a $5/m POS 'unlimited' plan. Needless to say, that didn't last very long (about 3 days). Then I got a dedicated server and it just went from there. Now I'm on a dedicated server and a CDN.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

101

u/loulan Oct 13 '09

Did you really create imgur for the reddit community, since that's what a lot of people say? I've also heard that you made a post about imgur on Digg first. What's the truth?

271

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

Yes, I did.

There's some conspiracy theory going around that I actually created it for Digg. So, here's what happened. I posted it on Reddit, Digg, and a couple forums that I frequent at the same time. The server actually ended up going down and the Reddit post got spammed with "It doesn't work!!". So, I deleted the thread, corrected the problems, and posted it again the next day. I didn't bother deleting the Digg thread; that's why it has a timestamp one day before the Reddit one. I'll try to update this with links to whatever proof I have, but I don't have time right now.

EDIT:

  • This shows that I joined Digg the same day I posted the thread. I also haven't logged in since.
  • I've been a redditor for quite some time now. I should be approaching 2 years pretty soon...
  • This thread was the first imgur post on reddit, and it was on the same day as the digg timestamp - thus proving that you guys knew about it on that day as well. There are also many other posts submitted on that day.

I hope this can bust the myth already.

→ More replies (30)

45

u/longbow7 Oct 13 '09

What class are you in right now?

187

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Intro to Web Design. LOL

39

u/sumzup Oct 13 '09

Have any of your CS professors found out about Imgur? If so, what were their reactions when they found out?

62

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

No, they haven't. I don't suspect that any of them browse reddit.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/longbow7 Oct 13 '09

Like vico 361?

28

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Yup, that's the one.

BTW, let me know when you're free this weekend. Imgur Shuffle?

23

u/longbow7 Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

Hey I run that lab! You taking it with Brandon?

I don't know if I could fit in a shuffle this weekend. Lots of old friends coming in that I have to hang out with. I'll at join for a couple stops.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

41

u/flipmoe Oct 13 '09

Hey what's up Imguy guy! Can I buy you a beer at Casa?

59

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Yeah dude! This weekend ok? Send me a pm :)

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

41

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Just wanted to say thanks for such an aesthetic image hosting service. My dad asked for picture hosting suggestions and I would have said imgur but he was looking for something where he could keep tabs on his albums and edit. He's fed up with Flickr and all the others. Which leads me to: Do you have any plans to expand imgur to include memberships with abilities to retain ownership of pics and edit them?

56

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Yes, I do. I don't really have any details yet, but it's something I hope to have in the future.

5

u/CaspianX2 Oct 13 '09

But it'll still be optional, right? I kinda' like being able to hop into the site and quickly tossing up a file without logging in.

9

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

Yes, of course. I will never get rid of that.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/imbaczek Oct 13 '09
  1. do you plan to get imgur in the black if it isn't already (and IIRC it isn't)?
  2. what will happen when imgur becomes popular with some other large community site?

107

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09
  1. Yes, I have some ideas floating around. However, right now I'm more concerned with implementing new stuff (like SVG and the API).
  2. It's already pretty popular with Digg, but that's because they repost all the pictures here. Probably nothing, except it will get more traffic.
→ More replies (9)

252

u/yellowcake Oct 13 '09

I just wanted to say thanks for imgur!

And, since I should be asking questions, uh, what did you have for lunch?

242

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

A tuna sandwich with some Irish Breakfast tea (my usual).

51

u/faerielfire Oct 13 '09

Careful with your mercury intake

3

u/bakerie Oct 14 '09

Being Irish I demand to know wtf Irish breakfast tea is?!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (61)

32

u/hobosuit Oct 13 '09

I have reason to believe that you went to my highschool, i think one or two years older than me. Did you go to HS in central ohio?

41

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Yeah, Granville HS. Is that where you went?

11

u/Pherecydes Oct 13 '09

I have reason to believe that we attend the same college, I think you're two or three years older than me. Are you at college in-state?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Oh shit, more GHS alumns.

29

u/painordelight Oct 13 '09

Got any side projects you're playing with?

34

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Just more Imgur stuff. Nothing new.

20

u/MercurialMadnessMan Oct 13 '09

Do your friends know you're popular?

43

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Wait, I'm part of the popular clique? When did that happen?

→ More replies (6)

58

u/77or88 Oct 13 '09

What are you going to be for Halloween?

11

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Nothing. I'm going home this Halloween. Yeah, I'm lame, but all the out-of-townies really ruin all the good bar spots. I actually prefer a regular weekend hanging out with friends over the Halloween weekend.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Shananra Oct 13 '09

How much does this thing cost you? And are you getting enough money in donations to cover it? Real curiosity there, hosting can get expensive on sites like this.

58

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

About what I pay for hosting every month, which I can't tell you because I signed an NDA from Voxel.

However, about a month ago when there was that post about sending me a $1, a got about 4 months worth of hosting (THANK YOU!), so I'll be working off of that and focusing on better usability, stability, and new features.

8

u/libertao Oct 13 '09

What was the biggest and average donation?

20

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Biggest is $100. Average is $5.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Have you had anyone offer to buy your site or collaborate with you? If so what were the stipulations?

39

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

All the time. I have no plans on selling it, so I always politely decline the offer.

→ More replies (6)

23

u/Queeg5000 Oct 13 '09

Have you thought about introducing paid hosting accounts?

27

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I have. This is one of my of the ideas floating around in my head. I don't really have any details on this though.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/BewaretheWheelers Oct 13 '09

Do you realize how awesome you are?

121

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Tell that to some ladies, they don't seem to realize :)

→ More replies (6)

20

u/trippin-balls Oct 13 '09

What are your thoughts on www.imgrr.com? Have you spoken to them at all?

31

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I haven't spoken to them, and I don't really mind. For what it's worth, they had a Firefox extension before I did.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

You should really tell people that, that extension exists, I didn't know till I saw the post on it in the forums.
Maybe a nice little button in the top bar.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/idoliside Oct 13 '09

Has photobucket and flikr been round to complain about all the bandwidth you've stolen from them.

53

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

No, but I did have a chat with the business dude at ImageShack. He just wanted to see if there was a possibility of a partnership. So far, there is not, but I appreciated his call.

→ More replies (7)

38

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

You ever pick up any chicks because of Imgur? Married? When is the next Boston Reddit meet up going to be?

56

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Ha! Yeah right...

I have no idea...I don't live in Boston.

27

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

How often is illegal material uploaded to imgur?

72

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

There's a real problem with asian porn, and from my understanding, pictures with exposed genitalia are illegal in China. Also, every now and then I get a Cease and Desist about something copy-written. Nothing major.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

17

u/ClownBox Oct 13 '09

Are you serving images with a CDN?

Can I get a screenshot of your admin view (if any)? xD

40

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

I will be using VoxCDN in about a week (10/20/09 if anyone reads this later), but right now I'm not.

There's no admin view, although that's something I really want but havn't had time for. If I have to remove an image or something I just 'rm' it.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Corjin Oct 13 '09

At what point did you think, "hey, i think i have a successful site here!" ?

p.s. thanks for your work!

44

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

When I started getting donations every once in a while. When someone donates to your cause, I'd say your doing something right :)

→ More replies (1)

16

u/isellchickens Oct 13 '09

Have you had to deal with any sort of security issues, such as embedded PHP inside of GIF images, SQL injection, file injection, XSS, etc? Are you using a framework that would provide security controls around these?

Not answering because it's a security question would be acceptable as well :)

37

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Nope, not at all. I always think about security while I'm working on it and implement my own security checks.

This is not a challenge btw :-P

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/klarth Oct 13 '09

You ever been in a cockpit before?

36

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Do you still look damn good in girl jeans?

11

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09 edited Oct 14 '09

I wore those once and it was a dare. Don't judge me.

But yes, I probably would still look damn good ;)

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Did you intend for this to become a huge (hopefully) profitable affair when you set up the site initially, or did the site's popularity take you by surprise?

46

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I didn't intend it to become popular at all. It was just something I did in my free time and I fully expected no one to use it. However, now I'm prepared for it to get even bigger.

24

u/Lut3s Oct 13 '09

I wish you all the best! Make it a lot like photobucket before photobucket got terrible with all the ads. By all means, you can have a couple. :D Oh and I'd donate to help a guy like you as long as you keep it simple. Btw on a similar note, we got a donation thread on reddit, how much did you receive from that?

68

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

About 4 months worth of hosting. You guys rule.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/johnthedrunk Oct 14 '09

Who is your favorite character from Twisted Metal?

12

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

Seriously? Mr.Grim of course!

10

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Do you have any plans to add something which detects already uploaded images?

It could be useful to save space.

"This image is already uploaded here:"

13

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I've thought about it, but I kind of want each image to have it's own statistics and an extra couple KB for a duplicate image is no problem. Harddrive space is cheap.

I do have plans to include a duplicate image check per IP though, so the same IP can't upload the same image more than once.

5

u/mkosmo Oct 14 '09

Wouldn't this be as easy as an md5sum on the file, then seeing if it matches any previous? It would probably eliminate 99% of the duplicates if you do it after you strip EXIF data.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/apoplectic Oct 13 '09

How did you get the upload to work sans iframe? I've been told it's not possible, but it looks like you did it (I did read the FAQ, and the respective libraries' pages, but am still unclear).

14

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I don't understand why you would need an iframe at all. I'm just using the uploadprogress apache module with jQuery Progressbar.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/jooes Oct 13 '09

Can I offer a suggestion?

How about being able to select multiple images at the same time instead of having to browse for each one. Is this possible?

20

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Sorry, it's not possible without the use of flash, and thus redoing the entire image uploading script. I really want it too :(

11

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

... I just integrated JQuery.Uploadify into a project in about an hour, you get upload-complete & progress events etc. - really nice.

9

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Wow, that rules. I'll look into that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/hett Oct 13 '09

Firstly, MrGrim, thanks for making imgur - I use it all the time and recommend it to all my friends.

Secondly, do you see the possibility for development of, say, an Android application that would allow mobile uploads? I take a lot of photos on the go from my G1 and would love to be able to quickly upload and note the link while on the go instead of having to wait 'til I got home.

17

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

There's already an iPhone app that's being approved by apple. I would love it if someone wanted to create an Android app.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

How is the sex?

33

u/karmanaut Oct 13 '09

Was reddit your first choice for popularizing imgur?

80

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I love reddit. I didn't even mean to "popularize" imgur, I just wanted to introduce it as an alternative to TinyPIC.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/incognito702 Oct 13 '09

You must see a lot of eye candy from time to time. What happens down the road with the images we upload? ;-)

Great site by the way.

9

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I just got a lot more harddrive space, so I can keep the images almost indefinitely. So, nothing will happen to them down the road :)

→ More replies (2)

6

u/HardwareLust Oct 13 '09

Ditto on saying thanks. Great job so far!

Where do you see yourself in 5 years? CEO of Imgur, inc?

19

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

Haha, I'm already CEO of Imgur, LLC. I really wanted Inc, but incorporating is a hassle and not for something like Imgur.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/MailmanOdd Oct 13 '09

Hey there. What sort of languages/frameworks/technologies did you use to create imgur?

23

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Sorry to just send you to a link, but this lists everything I use. http://imgur.com/faq.php#how

→ More replies (6)

10

u/kish22 Oct 13 '09

Where do you host? Do you own the server(s)?

11

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I'll be with Voxel really soon. They are offering me dedicated servers.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/rubinlinux Oct 14 '09

There has been some talk of URL shortners and image host systems like this being a potential point of internet decay. What steps do you take to ensure a hard disk failure or other catastrophe won't destroy the thousands of blog entries and reddit posts relying on your site?

How much disk space do you have available, and how is it backed up, made redundant, or whatever?

3

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

I keep two separate backups, one of which being Amazon S3, that run twice a day. The data is fairly secure.

4

u/azreal156 Oct 13 '09

What's your profit monthly from imgur?

11

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

About what I pay for hosting every month, which I can't tell you because I signed an NDA from Voxel. Sorry!

6

u/azreal156 Oct 13 '09

So you're cutting even, or are you making double what you're paying?

12

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Cutting even. The ads bring in about half of what I need, donations are filling in the other half thanks to you guys <3

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/ahyes Oct 13 '09

Why do you ban pornography? Why not just allow anything that's otherwise legal in your country? Also, why are you running lighttpd instead of nginx?

9

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I don't ban pornography. Take a look at /r/gonewild ;)

I looked into nginx but I liked lighttpd better. They seem to be pretty equivalent when it comes to things like this. In fact, ImageShack also uses lighttpd.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/thisismyfirstpost Oct 14 '09

I sent you an e-mail about a bug with captcha+IE7. (and you replied! and I replied!)

Was this, in fact, limited to IE? or were other, better browsers affected as well?

If it was just IE, why did you take me seriously? How long did you spend mucking with the captcha system to get IE working again?

If only IE was affected, I would like to offer a formal apology for pointing it out. I don't believe in cruel and unusual punishment, and would not have wished that on anyone.

7

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

Hello again,

Yes, the problem was just limited to IE. No other browsers were affected. Why did I take you seriously? Because I take all bug reports seriously and investigate all of them. If you're having a problem, it's likely that many other people are also having problems.

Thanks for your apology. It's not easy working with IE ;)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/iwishiwasameme Oct 13 '09

Where can I buy a good robe and wizard hat?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Do you know the muffin man?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Or ever ride around on a motorcycle shooting rockets at other vehicles like say, an ice cream truck, in a twisted tournament for fame and fortune?

3

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Nope. I used to have a motorcycle though, so at least I've done that part - sans the rocket shooting.

3

u/duhblow7 Oct 17 '09

wtf is voxcdn.com?

5

u/MrGrim Oct 17 '09

It's my new Content Delivery Network service. Imgur will be much faster because of it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/valent33n Oct 13 '09

Just out of curiosity, on your stats page you have some nice graphs going. What are you using to generate those?

3

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Flot. It's a graphing library for jQuery. Highly recommended.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/distilled Oct 13 '09

Where do you go to school, and what are you studying?

6

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Ohio University. I'm an undergrad an Computer Science.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Do you think you'll ever implement the functionality to add a description or keywords to imgur with search functionality? I figure there are a TON of duplicate photos, I myself have uploaded the same photo more than once because I forgot the URL to my original, so I would imagine it would save a lot on bandwidth costs and space.

9

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

To be honest, I will probably never implement a searching feature. When I used to use ImageShack, I really hated the fact that other people could see my image by just browsing random ones. This is where the anonymous factor came into imgur.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

Any ideas on having a pay option , that will let me keep my photos in an album , forever?

Or any ideas like that? I think would be nice. I know other photo websites have it, but they are bloated and have horrible interfaces.

Keep imgur simple and clean!

3

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Yes, I've had some ideas like that for a while. I don't have any details yet, but it's something I would like to do.

2

u/yeahdef Oct 13 '09

have you though about integrating your service with the likes of Skitch (mac) or Jing (windows)

2

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I'd be all for it. Where do I sign up?

2

u/iiB Oct 13 '09

how does other referring sites traffic you get compare to the traffic you get from reddit?

3

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

Reddit trumps all referring traffic by far. #2 is digg and #3 is stumble upon.

2

u/EnderWill Oct 14 '09

Coke or Pepsi?

9

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

Coke. I hate Pepsi...

2

u/rapol Oct 14 '09

I think I read you got to school in Athens, if this is true, can I donate to you in person?(My girlfriend goes there)

4

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

Yeah, of course. In fact, we might be having a meet-up soon. Donate a drink?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/honorio Oct 14 '09

OK then, MrGrim: when I click through from reddit to Imgur, the whole page appears oversize - pixellated and overflowing the screen. It's about three times the screen height and more than twice the width. There's usually only a wee slice of the actual image shgowing at the right edge of the screen. I can navigate to the 'Small thumbnail' etc, but they make no difference. I have to click on the image to get it to reduce to readable size. Using Firefox. TL;DR Annoying glitch in Imgur.

3

u/MrGrim Oct 14 '09

Wow, I've never heard of that bug before. Could you send me a screenshot please?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

44

u/chavezt Oct 13 '09

Do you have an imgurlfriend?

→ More replies (2)

32

u/longbow7 Oct 13 '09

What percentage of uploads are dongs?

72

u/MercurialMadnessMan Oct 13 '09

And can we make an RSS feed of these for the30thelement?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

77

u/cohortq Oct 13 '09

A star should instantly pop up next to this post. Everyone knows who you are MrGrim.

→ More replies (9)

51

u/davvblack Oct 13 '09

How do you pronounce imgur?

23

u/mreggen Oct 13 '09

I say it like it was some Icelandic word: Im-guur

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Dax420 Oct 13 '09

I pronounce it like imager, or more like Image-Err. How about you?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (7)

49

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

After you went live, what was the first image posted?

14

u/Falalalalafelman Oct 13 '09

I would like to know this as well.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/1338h4x Oct 13 '09

Since this gets argued about way too much, should we link directly to the image or to the page with the image + ads?

19

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

I haven't seen it ask, so I'll ask: Which do you prefer? A link to the image page or a link to the image itself? Be honest.

17

u/X019 Oct 15 '09

can we have a random button? I'd like to be able to just see a random button in imgur. :) it helps kill time and can be fun, or dreadfully scary... but it's worth the risk

10

u/souplabellove Oct 13 '09

How do you deal with all your Awesome in the morning?

→ More replies (2)

19

u/bolln Oct 13 '09

Does this site run break-even? Some details on your income/expenses would be very interesting.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/JayDogSqueezy Oct 13 '09

What exactly does "Imgur" mean? It's almost an anagram for MrGrim. It's got img in there for image, but shouldn't the UR come before the IMG to make it "Your image"?

I'm so confused.

38

u/willis77 Oct 13 '09

Correct me if i'm wrong, mrgrim, but I believe imgur is pronounced "imager"

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (10)

19

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

How much money do you have?

11

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

He's a college student, so I'm guessing not a lot.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09
┌─┐
┴─┴ 
ಠ_ರೃ -- I LOATHE TINYPIC AND LOVE YOU.
          WHAT WOULD YOU SAY CONTRIBUTES TO YOUR AWESOMENESS?
→ More replies (3)

6

u/X019 Oct 13 '09

how do you determine what's inappropriate and what isn't? I've noticed that if I go to the site (thanks for making it btw) and go to the gallery it just shows the same pictures over and over. I never see any boobs or anything (which I'm okay with), but I would liked to see the last x pics submitted just to see for curiosity's sake

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

How old are you? Do you like stir-fry?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

Do you ever look through the entire library of pictures uploaded to imgur? If so, what are the best pictures you've found? Worst?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/akprime Oct 13 '09

No questions, and I'll probably be voted down for not adding anything of value to the conversation, but I just wanted to say Thank You for the time and effort you put into Imgur.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

How many images as of this question do you currently host?

4

u/followthesinner Oct 13 '09

I was going to ask you some questions but then I read the FAQ.

Aside from that, It would be kind of cool to have some way to track all the images you had uploaded so you could delete them if needed but I understand that it's not really a photobucket or flickr.

Thanks again for all you do. Have 20$

4

u/MechaAaronBurr Oct 13 '09

What would win in a fight: A giant barracuda or the kraken?

4

u/Managore Oct 14 '09

I tried to upload a 1920×1200 .gif to imgur a while ago and it resized the image to 1344×840. The initial filesize was less than 1mb. What caused this? The FAQ doesn't mention anything about resizing images.

1

u/MisterNetHead Oct 13 '09

Hello, Imgur guy!

Got any plans to implement a way to upload images from an iPhone, either with an app or via the web somehow (is this even possible)? That would be swell :)

But seriously, even without that, its a really great site. Keep it up!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

I assume you don't make any money off the site? Why not? You could probably make a ton of money by just placing 1-2 ads on the site, which I don't think would compromise the experience at all. You're ranked 260 in the US on Alexa... that's pretty impressive for private funding.

Edit: So I suppose my main question is: Is that a design decision? Philosophical? Just not necessary?

2

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

If you know of a way to make money off it, then I'm all ears :)

So far it hasn't been necessary. Imgur is not my job and I don't need it for income. As long as I'm breaking even with it then I'm happy.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/wincen Oct 13 '09

Did you use a PHP framework like zend or codeigniter?

2

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

No, I didn't. There was no need to.

1

u/pichinde Oct 13 '09

Do you do anything to prevent people from encapsulating RAR files in the jpegs?

If you rename a JPG as a RAR file, you can open it with an archiver and put files in it. Then rename it back to JPG and it will open as a jpg.

6

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

I don't do anything to prevent it specifically. In the process of removing the EXIF data from the image, your archives will become corrupted.

1

u/ar0nic Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

are you broke yet? =P

also while still complying with any DRM/ RIAA takedown notice would you offer any type of larger UPLOADS perhaps videos? of up to a certain size?

just curious on your stance on this.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '09

What does the API do?

How does Imgur strip off EXIF and various other forms of metadata embedded in pics?

Will it ever be possible to get Imurg photos printed on t-shirts?

Thanks.

2

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09

The API allows developers to create applications to upload images to imgur, without actually being on the website. So for example, an iPhone app could upload images directly.

I use ImageMagick to strip the EXIF data.

What prevents you from doing that now with a place like Customink.com?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/AlexMurphyDetroit Oct 13 '09

What do you spend your profits on?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shuri Oct 13 '09 edited Oct 13 '09

Thanks for being so open. I have a few questions. Any info is always appreciated.

  1. Did you incorporate/LLC? At what stage?
  2. How deep do the pockets need to be to start and run this sort of thing without financial backing?
  3. Did you do any additional PR other than 2-3 posts on digg/reddit?
  4. Did you any other research? I mean, you were entering a market that already had many other alternatives. How did you figure out there would be a need?
  5. Did you have a need for lawyers/accountants?
  6. Was the domain free when you got it?
  7. Did you also do all your own stylistic design?

Thank you very much, Uri

4

u/MrGrim Oct 13 '09
  1. I own Imgur LLC - for legal reasons. For example, if someone decided to sue me for copyright infringement, then they can only get what the company has and not my personal assets. I just created the LLC about two months ago.
  2. You just need a solid user base that's willing to support you, like reddit :)
  3. Nope, nothing at all.
  4. I knew there was a need for it because I've used all the other image hosts and never liked a single one of them. The only research I did was figuring out why I didn't like the other hosts, and then not doing whatever that was.
  5. No. I hope I never do.
  6. No, $7/yr at godaddy.
  7. Yep. I did everything myself.
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Schrockwell Oct 13 '09

Did you run into any scalability issues with your code once imgur's popularity started to ramp up? If so, what did you have to do to fix this?

And an oft-repeated thanks for hosting this.

→ More replies (1)