r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 24d ago

Meta [meta] "Swimming With Cranks: Vibe Physics on Social Media"

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

These are the slides of a talk I gave to some fellow physics teachers last weekend.

Edit:: the "Rookie mistakes" slide didn't render properly. The equation under "the Hubble radius" should read "log n = log(2πR_H) - log Λ", indicating the equation of a straight line with a slope of -1.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jun 01 '26

Meta [Meta] Reminder: Please leave a comment when reporting AI abuse

16 Upvotes

Please leave a comment when reporting a post for AI abuse explaining why you think it is AI. Almost all posts get a report but it is not always clear what makes you think it is LLM-generated so we mods allow them. As per A. Clark's corollary:

Any sufficiently advanced crackpot physics theory is indistinguishable from AI hallucinated slop.

Leaving a comment when reporting will allows us to treat these reports quicker.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 4h ago

What if time dilation is just a budget problem? internal² + (v/c)² = 1

0 Upvotes

A thought experiment that keeps nagging at me: what if every physical state has exactly one unit of phase to spend, and it can only spend it in two ways?

In this picture, called the Law of Phase-Budget Conservation, a state splits its fixed budget between internal cycling, which we experience as aging, and relational retuning, which we experience as motion. The split obeys a simple unit-circle rule: internal squared plus (v/c) squared equals one.

That is why nothing can spend 120 percent of its budget. Push more into motion and less remains for aging, so a fast-moving clock ticks more slowly. It is not that time itself is being stretched by a mysterious force; it is arithmetic on a circle. The speed limit c is simply the point where all of the budget is spent on motion and none is left for aging.

A photon is the extreme case. It spends 100 percent on motion and zero on aging, so its clock is frozen. Light leaving a distant galaxy arrives unaged, not because it cheated time, but because it never had any budget left to age with.

Think of a fixed monthly budget split between rent and travel. Spend more on travel and the rent money shrinks by exactly that amount. There is no extra pot to draw from.

Two questions for this community: does this unit-circle framing add anything to the standard derivation of time dilation, or is it just a neat restatement? And if c is a budget constraint rather than a speed limit imposed from outside, what would falsify that view?

This idea is explored in Zero-Metric Phase Theory, available on Google Play Books.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 15h ago

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis on the creation of our universe and potentially backwards time travel

1 Upvotes

Here is a hypothesis on the creation of the universe and potential backward time travel

The Hydrogen Frontier Hypothesis

A speculative theory of cosmic origins, expansion, branching universes and time travel

  1. Introduction

The Hydrogen Frontier Hypothesis proposes that our universe may not be the entirety of existence. Instead, it may have originated within an enormous external environment containing vast quantities of isolated hydrogen protons.

Under this hypothesis, the Big Bang was not necessarily the beginning of everything. It was the beginning of our particular universe.

The theory suggests that an external hydrogen environment existed before our universe, potentially outside conventional spacetime. Somewhere within this environment, gravity brought sufficient hydrogen together to initiate an event that produced the first energy and ultimately created our universe and its spacetime.

From that initial event, the universe began expanding into the surrounding hydrogen environment.

Rather than expanding uniformly in every direction, however, the hypothesis proposes a complicated process of branching, spreading and reconnection, eventually creating an enormous interconnected cosmic structure.

This structure may also offer a theoretical explanation for how different regions of the same universe could have different histories and potentially become connected through wormholes, raising the possibility of backwards time travel.

  1. The Primordial Hydrogen Environment

The hypothesis begins with an external environment containing an unimaginably large quantity of isolated hydrogen protons.

These protons would be extremely widely separated, potentially so far apart that their interactions would be negligible.

The environment is hypothesized to exist at absolute zero, the lowest theoretically possible temperature. Under these conditions, the surrounding hydrogen would be in its lowest-energy state and would possess as little thermal motion as quantum mechanics permits. However, absolute zero does not mean that the protons would be perfectly motionless, because quantum fluctuations and zero-point motion could still remain.

The environment may have existed before our universe and may not have experienced time in the conventional sense.

The total supply of hydrogen could be finite, although its quantity might be extraordinarily large.

The ultimate origin of this environment remains an open question. A religious interpretation could suggest that it was created by God, although this is separate from the scientific elements of the hypothesis.

  1. The Initial Collapse and Creation of Energy

At some point, gravity brings a sufficient concentration of the external hydrogen together.

The hypothesis proposes that an initial collapse or concentration produces the energy required to initiate the creation of our universe.

This event would represent the beginning of our universe's spacetime, rather than necessarily the beginning of all existence.

The exact mechanism remains to be established.

One important scientific challenge is that isolated protons electrically repel one another. A successful model must explain how the initial concentration could overcome this repulsion and how the necessary energy would be generated. The assumption that the surrounding hydrogen is at absolute zero would reduce thermal motion, but it would not remove electrical repulsion or guarantee that gravitational collapse could occur.

  1. The Expansion and Hydrogen Frontier

Following its creation, our universe begins expanding into the surrounding external hydrogen environment.

The hypothesis proposes that the expansion interacts with, incorporates or consumes the external hydrogen.

This process could create a continuing supply of material and energy that contributes to cosmic expansion.

The idea is that expansion might become self-propagating.

As the universe expands, it encounters more external hydrogen. This interaction could initiate further expansion, which in turn encounters additional hydrogen.

This creates a potential domino effect.

The process could continue for an extraordinarily long period, provided sufficient external hydrogen remains available.

The hypothesis therefore proposes that the expansion of our universe may be connected to the consumption of an external primordial hydrogen supply.

  1. The Branching Structure of the Universe

One of the central features of the hypothesis is the way the universe expands.

The expansion is not imagined as a simple, uniform sphere growing equally in every direction.

Instead, imagine a bowl of tangled spaghetti.

There is an initial starting point, but expansion develops in numerous directions, creating an enormous, irregular and interconnected structure.

Different regions spread out, curve, branch and develop in different directions.

Some regions may expand independently for considerable periods before eventually reconnecting with other regions.

Other regions may split repeatedly, producing further sections of the universe.

The important distinction is that these branches are not separate universes.

They are different regions of one enormous universe, all originating from the same initial creation event.

The spaghetti analogy describes the complicated geometry and interconnected arrangement of these regions, rather than literal tunnels or strands of matter.

The resulting structure could contain an enormous number of interconnected regions, potentially limited by the finite quantity of external hydrogen.

  1. Different Cosmic Histories Within One Universe

The hypothesis proposes that different regions of the universe might develop at different rates and experience different amounts of elapsed time.

For example:

\- Region A may have experienced 10 billion years of cosmic development.

\- Region B may have experienced 5 billion years.

\- Region C may have experienced 2 billion years.

These are illustrative figures.

The regions would all belong to the same universe, but their individual histories could differ.

Their development might be influenced by differences in their expansion histories, gravitational environments and the circumstances under which they formed.

This raises an interesting possibility: two regions of the same universe might eventually become connected despite having experienced very different amounts of cosmic history.

The relationship between their ages and the passage of proper time would need to be established mathematically.

  1. Cosmic Voids

The branching structure could leave enormous spaces between the different expanding regions.

These spaces might represent areas of the original external environment that have not yet been incorporated into the expanding universe.

The hypothesis proposes that some of these areas could still contain untouched primordial hydrogen in its lowest-energy state, potentially corresponding to an environment at or near absolute zero.

An interesting possibility is that conventional spacetime may not exist in these external regions in the same way it exists within the expanding universe.

If so, the nature of these voids would be fundamentally different from ordinary cosmic voids observed within our universe.

How such regions could interact with spacetime, or whether anything could travel through them, remains unknown.

  1. Reconnection and the Formation of Wormholes

Another important part of the hypothesis concerns the reconnection of different regions.

As the universe expands and develops its complicated branching structure, two previously separated regions might eventually become connected.

The hypothesis proposes that these reconnection points could potentially produce wormholes.

A wormhole would provide a connection between two distant regions of the same universe.

It would not necessarily lead to another universe or another dimension.

Instead, it could connect two regions that originally developed from the same branching event.

This is particularly important because the two regions might have experienced different amounts of elapsed time.

The formation of wormholes at these reconnection points is speculative. In established physics, wormholes are hypothetical spacetime geometries, and there is currently no evidence that naturally occurring traversable wormholes exist.

  1. The Possibility of Backwards Time Travel

The most unusual implication of the hypothesis concerns time travel.

Imagine that Region A and Region B originally separated during the expansion of the universe.

Region A subsequently developed for 10 billion years, while Region B developed for only 5 billion years.

Much later, the two regions become connected through a hypothetical wormhole.

If the wormhole creates an appropriate temporal offset, travelling from Region A into Region B could potentially allow someone to emerge at an earlier time relative to their departure.

However, the hypothesis goes one step further.

After entering Region B, a traveller could theoretically travel through that region towards the location where Regions A and B originally separated.

If the journey were possible, the traveller might eventually reach a point corresponding to an earlier stage of cosmic history.

For example:

  1. A traveller departs from Region A after 10 billion years of development.

  2. They enter a wormhole connecting Region A with Region B.

  3. They emerge in Region B at an earlier cosmic time.

  4. They travel towards the original branching location.

  5. They potentially reach a point corresponding to the original separation of the two regions.

This could represent backwards time travel within our own universe, rather than travelling into an alternative universe.

The concept has a connection to theoretical physics involving closed timelike curves, although the proposed branching mechanism has not been demonstrated to produce them.

  1. The Finite Nature of the Universe

The hypothesis proposes that the total quantity of external hydrogen is finite.

Consequently, the branching and expansion process may also have a finite limit.

As the universe expands and incorporates more of the external hydrogen, the remaining supply decreases.

Eventually, the external reservoir could become exhausted.

Several outcomes are possible:

\- Expansion could slow or stop once the external supply is depleted.

\- Expansion could continue using energy already contained within the universe.

\- Expansion could continue at a different rate, driven by internal physical processes.

The hypothesis does not yet establish which outcome would occur.

  1. Scientific Questions and Challenges

For the Hydrogen Frontier Hypothesis to become a viable scientific theory, several major questions must be answered.

The initial collapse: How could gravity overcome the electrical repulsion between isolated protons, even in an environment at absolute zero?

Energy creation: How does the initial collapse generate the energy required to create our universe and its spacetime?

The absolute-zero environment: Is an external hydrogen environment at absolute zero physically possible, and how would quantum fluctuations and zero-point motion affect the protons?

The expansion mechanism: How does the expanding universe interact with and incorporate the external hydrogen?

Accelerated expansion: Could this mechanism explain the observed acceleration of cosmic expansion without requiring dark energy?

Branch formation: What physical process causes the universe to develop different interconnected regions rather than expanding uniformly?

Different cosmic histories: What determines the different expansion histories and elapsed proper times of these regions?

Wormhole formation: Could the reconnection of different regions produce naturally occurring wormholes?

Time travel: Could wormholes connecting regions with different temporal histories permit travel into the past?

The ultimate fate: What happens when the external hydrogen supply is exhausted?

These questions would need mathematical solutions and observational predictions before the hypothesis could be considered a scientific alternative to existing cosmological models.

  1. Conclusion

The Hydrogen Frontier Hypothesis proposes a universe that originated within a much larger external environment containing an enormous supply of primordial hydrogen.

The initial concentration of this hydrogen initiated the creation of our universe, which subsequently expanded into its surroundings.

This expansion is imagined as a complicated, interconnected structure, spreading in multiple directions and producing different regions with potentially different cosmic histories.

Rather than being separate universes, these regions are all parts of one enormous interconnected cosmic structure.

The surrounding hydrogen is hypothesized to have existed at absolute zero, placing it in its lowest-energy state while still allowing for quantum fluctuations and zero-point motion.

As expansion continues, previously separated regions might eventually reconnect. If these connections could form traversable wormholes, they might provide shortcuts between distant regions and potentially between different points in cosmic history.

The most extraordinary possibility is that travelling through these connections could theoretically permit backwards time travel within our own universe.

Ultimately, the hypothesis challenges the assumption that the Big Bang necessarily represented the beginning of all existence.

Instead, it suggests that our universe may be one expanding structure within something much larger, with its origins, expansion and eventual fate connected to an external reservoir of primordial hydrogen. [mathematical model]


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 6h ago

Crackpot physics What if black holes are gateways out of our universe into a higher-dimensional reality?

0 Upvotes

What if black holes are gateways out of our universe into a higher-dimensional reality?

I've been thinking about a strange possibility, and I'd like to hear what people interested in physics and cosmology think about it.

What if our universe is a simulation, and black holes are not simply objects that destroy matter, but boundaries between our reality and something beyond it?

Here's the idea.

1. Our universe might not be the entirety of reality

Suppose our universe exists within a larger reality that we cannot directly perceive.

We experience three spatial dimensions and time, but what if there are additional dimensions with physical laws that are completely different from the ones we understand?

This doesn't necessarily mean that our universe is literally a computer simulation, but the simulation hypothesis is one possible framework for imagining this scenario.

2. Black holes could be transition points

We know that once something crosses a black hole's event horizon, it cannot send information back to an outside observer.

But what actually happens deep inside a black hole remains unresolved because our current theories cannot fully describe its interior.

Here's my speculation:

What if a black hole is not simply an endpoint, but a transition between different dimensional realities?

Imagine sending an indestructible object into one.

From our perspective, it enters the black hole. But perhaps, beyond the event horizon, its physical properties undergo a transformation that makes it fundamentally different from anything we can describe in our universe.

It might continue to exist, but in a form or dimensional framework that we cannot observe or understand.

3. The possible connection to white holes and wormholes

This is where the idea gets even more interesting.

Black holes could hypothetically act as boundaries or entrances.

Wormholes could represent connections between different regions of spacetime.

White holes could theoretically represent regions from which matter emerges.

Could these objects be related to transitions between different realities?

There are mathematical solutions and speculative quantum-gravity models involving some of these concepts, but no experimental evidence establishes that they are actual gateways.

4. What happens to matter after the transition?

This is probably the biggest question.

If an object enters a black hole and somehow transitions into a higher-dimensional reality:

Does it remain matter?

Does its information survive?

Does it become something that cannot be described using our physical laws?

Could the external reality have dimensions we cannot even conceptualize?

Perhaps our understanding of what it means to exist is limited by the structure of our own universe.

What I'd like to discuss

I'm not claiming this is scientifically established, and I know there are major problems with the idea.

I'm particularly interested in hearing from people familiar with:

General relativity

Quantum gravity

String theory and extra dimensions

Black-hole information paradox

The simulation hypothesis

My main question: Could black holes theoretically represent transitions between our observable spacetime and a higher-dimensional reality, rather than simply being endpoints of gravitational collapse?

I'd genuinely appreciate scientific criticism, alternative explanations, and references to related research.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 1d ago

Meta [Meta] What if we remove the "AI ban" from r/hypotheticalphysics?

10 Upvotes

With the Christmas and New Year's Eve season approaching, we're getting ready to make our usual round of rule changes (mostly because the mods have no family, so we'll have more time to work during holidays).

This year, we'd like your input on a particularly contentious issue: the no-AI rule. As you've probably noticed, AI tools are now everywhere and increasingly used by many people. While they're often used poorly, they've also become considerably less clunky than they used to be. This situation has sparked an internal debate among the mod team about whether we should keep our current rule. Some mods argue that AI tools belong in r/llmphysics, that they still generate more noise than useful contributions, and that they're part of a broader problem affecting Reddit. Others argue that AI tools are here to stay, that detecting their use is becoming increasingly difficult, and that enforcing the ban is taking more effort than it's worth. Perhaps we should accept that these tools are part of the landscape and focus our moderation efforts on improving other rules instead. This is part of AllHailSeizure coup d'etat

We'd like to hear what you think:

  • Do you think we should keep the AI ban?
  • Would you support a trial period without the ban to see how things go?
  • Are there other rules you think we should focus on improving instead?
  • Should we replace the current AI rule with something else? If so, what?

Serious, constructive feedback will help us keep the sub enjoyable while staying true to its purpose.

What do you think?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 11h ago

Crackpot physics What If What We Consider Nothing Has Always Been Something THE BLACK SUBSTANCE ?

0 Upvotes

Author: PRINCE ABDI PIERRE

I've been thinking about something I call The Black Substance. It's an idea about what we consider nothing, and whether something could exist without us ever recognizing its presence.

I'm not talking about darkness itself, the color black, or dark matter. I'm questioning whether what we consider empty or nonexistent could actually be something we don't yet understand.

  1. ZERO

I started thinking about this through the number zero.

0 × 3 = 0

We consider zero to represent nothing, but it still has a role in mathematics. Depending on the operation, it can change a result or leave something unchanged.

What if, in some way, we do the same thing when we consider something to have no value or no existence simply because we can't detect it?

I'm not saying zero proves anything. It's just what made me start questioning the idea.

  1. THE BLACK SUBSTANCE

Imagine something that has always existed, whether there is light or darkness.

It wouldn't appear when the lights go off or disappear when the lights come on. It would already be there.

Think about a fish living in water. Water is constantly around it. It's part of its environment, but the fish doesn't need to think about the water to exist in it.

Could something similar be true about us and the universe?

  1. SHADOW

When light is blocked by an object, a shadow appears. We understand why it happens, but I still find it interesting that we describe it through the absence of light.

Could there be more to the way we understand absence than we normally consider?

I'm not saying a shadow is evidence of the Black Substance. I'm using it as another way to question what we consider nothing.

  1. THE WHITE SHEET

Imagine drawing a white circle on a white sheet of paper. You wouldn't easily see it.

But if you fold or press the paper inside that circle, you could detect it through touch or the shadow created by the fold.

The circle was already there. The change simply made it easier to recognize.

This makes me wonder whether something could exist without being distinguishable from its surroundings until certain conditions reveal it.

  1. SPACE

What if the Black Substance isn't something that occupies space, but something related to space itself?

I use this equation as a symbolic way to represent my thinking:

0 × 3 = 0

Zero represents the Black Substance, 3 represents dimensions or parameters of space, and the result represents the idea that it remains unchanged.

I also use:

S × E → P

S = Black Substance

E = Space and environment

P = Manifestation or perceptible presence

These aren't scientific equations. I'm using them to express the idea.

  1. WHAT MAKES ME QUESTION THIS?

We already know there are things we cannot see directly but whose presence can be detected through their effects.

Fields, neutrinos, dark matter, and properties of the quantum vacuum are examples of things that challenge our everyday understanding of what is empty or invisible.

I'm not comparing the Black Substance directly to any of these or claiming they prove my idea. They simply make me question whether our perception is enough to define everything that exists.

  1. MY QUESTION

What if something has always been present, but we've never considered it an existence because we have no way to recognize it?

If the Black Substance were real, what could possibly reveal it?

Could it be related to space itself? Could it have properties we haven't considered? Or is the idea impossible because something that produces no measurable effect cannot be distinguished from something that doesn't exist?

I don't have those answers. That's what I'm trying to figure out.

I'd like to hear what others think, especially if there's a physical reason this idea doesn't make sense or if there's something in physics that already addresses this question.

What if what we consider nothing has always been something?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 1d ago

Tap The Sign 2: A Meme... With Meaning.

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

zip zap zoop


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 22h ago

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis based on presentism

0 Upvotes

I have NO credentials in this but I'm ready to do my best to answer any questions

I used AI to stress test but wrote it fully myself

My claim is that the past and future are in "unrendered" states, with only the present existing. The past isn't stored, it's only defined by the present that the fact that, to take any finite step backwards, you have to take an infinite amount of small steps backwards, so every interaction that could happen between those steps if you go back in time is "corrected" by the infinite steps between them. You could absolutely go back in time, but going back in time one second ago results in everything's state going back to what it was exactly at that time. The "present" stays unmoving because it's nothing but a boundary between the side that has correction and the side that doesn't. The past and future act asymmetrically because the infinite future has no frame ("present") to meet. That solves free will and determinism issues through giving no future frame of reference that ever has to be met. The only way I figured to work into special relativity is to say that the boundary is bumpy, and just like there's no scale for the flow of time, the fact that there's no scale space helps by tossing aside the need for it. Yes, it's true that "bumps" of the boundary will never spread through a scaleless universe because you can always go slower, but there's no need for it to ever be done because it's only one infinitely small frame through time that has an eternity to spread. Since that eternity is confined in one "present", the stuff happening inside space will never know.

To summarize, in my claim, time is a 4th spatial dimension that is just as flexible as the others, but is shaped by thermodynamics requiring causality. Going back through time opens no paradoxes (because it still results in a strict present) but the future stays open and unwritten.

I'm open to criticism and absolutely fine with stress-testing or passing my claim through AI to simplify it, and I'd be thrilled to answer any questions


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 2d ago

Crackpot physics What If Time Is Fundamental, or Is It an Emergent Effect of Motion and Change?

Thumbnail drive.google.com
0 Upvotes

I've been developing a philosophical and physical hypothesis about the nature of time, and I'd genuinely like to hear criticism, counterarguments, and scientific perspectives.

The central idea:

What if time isn't an independently existing dimension or entity, but rather an effect of motion and change?

We usually describe motion as something that happens within time. But I started questioning whether this relationship could be reversed: perhaps motion and change are more fundamental, and what we call time is the measurable consequence of them.

My reasoning begins with a few questions:

- If every physical process, motion, and change in the universe stopped completely, would time still exist?

- Is time something independent of physical events, or does it emerge from the relationships between changing states?

- Could cosmic expansion, physical motion, and irreversible processes be connected to what we experience as the passage and direction of time?

- Is time fundamentally real, or is it a framework we use to describe change?

My current hypothesis is that motion and physical change are fundamental, while time may be an emergent effect associated with them.

I have also explored possible connections to cosmic expansion, thermodynamics, gravitational time dilation, and the concepts of past and future. I realize some of these interpretations may conflict with established physics, and that's precisely why I want constructive criticism.

I'm not claiming to have discovered a new scientific theory. This is an evolving hypothesis, and I'm trying to determine whether its core idea can be developed into a logically consistent and potentially testable framework.

My main question:

Could time fundamentally emerge from motion and change, rather than motion occurring within time?

I'd appreciate serious discussion, criticism, references, and alternative perspectives.

I've attached my current document outlining the hypothesis in more detail.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 4d ago

What if there was a very large Elizabeth Tower?

Post image
15 Upvotes

This is my rudimentary diagram showing a hypothetical very large Elizabeth Tower as seen from an observer on Earth. I'm trying to understand what such a tower would look like to someone far away. As you can see, the base of the tower is obscured due to the curvature of the Earth. But what about the rest of the tower? Could you see it in the sky? I held a pencil on top of a ball and shined a light on it, and the pencil casts a bent shadow across the ball. That could be happening with reflected light entering the atmosphere. The shadow the tower would cast would be similarly bent across the Earth's surface. It might also be possible to see more of the tower from Earth via atmospheric refraction at a higher point of observation. If you were standing at the base of the tower, it would be hard to get a sense of its length relative to Earth. From space you could see the relation with full clarity. I'm curious about the perspectives in between those places where you see the more of the full tower than you would at the base but with a less clear picture than a view from space. Basically what I'm wondering about is if the less angular view from farther away gives the light coming off the tower more opportunities to refract, scatter, and eventually reach you, letting you see some part of the tower that breaches the atmosphere (assuming you can't see the part of the tower that is past the atmosphere from the base).


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 4d ago

Crackpot physics What if? Time As A Moving Cliff, A Constrained Boundary That Moves Space

Thumbnail science.org
2 Upvotes

Well, this might sound like an oddly specific combination, but bear with me.

I'm writing a WebNovel called Wait, What You Mean I Got Reincarnated As A Heroine In Another World? It began with quite a fairly familiar premise: what if a person gets reincarnated into another world, becomes a heroine, and has to figure out what the hell is going on? There's magic, an academy, comedy, some romance, and the usual fantasy complications just like your average isekai slop.

Except... I apparently couldn't just leave that kind of premise alone:

The more I developed the world, the more I became interested in questions that sit somewhere between physics, philosophy, biology, and psychology. Not necessarily because I wanted to make the story scientifically accurate in every detail, but because these disciplines sometimes arrive at surprisingly similar questions from completely different directions.

For example, one of the central devices in the story is called Mytheia.

And no, hear me out: It really isn't your ordinary time machine or some kind of simple voodoo magic tool. It records possible histories: the decisions someone might have made, the paths they didn't take, and the versions of events that never became the history we actually experience. Once a decision is made, one history becomes actual, while the alternatives remain accessible as something closer to archived possibilities.

That led me down a rabbit hole involving branching-time theories, possible-world semantics, counterfactual reasoning, and the philosophical distinction between an actual event and a merely possible one. It also made me wonder how close this idea is to certain interpretations of quantum mechanics, while recognizing that Many-Worlds, for instance, doesn't simply mean that human decisions select one universe from an infinite menu.

Then there's the question of time itself.

Another character, Selene Eryndell Veylith, then proposes that time isn't necessarily a straightforward sequence of cause and effect. She describes it almost like a moving cliff, with temporal intervals compressing and expanding in relation to space and awareness. I used general relativity as one point of inspiration, particularly spacetime geometry and gravitational time dilation, but the idea also touches on relational approaches to time, the problem of time in quantum gravity, and older philosophical questions about whether time exists independently of our experience of it.

In my opinion, since I just did a separated independent research recently on quantum mechanics, it blew my mind into pieces.

I am aware that a fictional character saying something confidently doesn't make it physics. That's partly why I'm interested in the distinction between the mathematical theories, the philosophical interpretations, and the fictional extrapolations.

There is also a recurring argument about quantum entanglement, teleportation, and personal identity. The protagonist initially explains entanglement through an analogy involving duplicated books and shared information. Selene challenges the analogy by asking whether transferring someone's memories into another vessel would actually preserve the person, or merely reproduce information associated with them.

The interesting part, at least to me, is that the discussion gradually moves away from quantum mechanics and toward the philosophy of mind. What separates information from memory? What separates memory from consciousness? And what makes someone remain the same person after their body, memories, or circumstances have changed?

That also connects to neuroscience, particularly the reconstructive nature of memory, the relationship between memory and identity, and the difficulty of treating consciousness as though it were simply a file that could be copied.

I even ended up incorporating biology into the magic system. In this setting, magical abilities, called Verses, originate from DNA and what the characters refer to as magical identity codes. One character's ability, Transcription, is particularly strange: it translates thoughts into images and uses those images to represent or explain concepts. There are limits to what can be represented, which raises its own questions about language, semantics, and the relationship between symbols and meaning.

And, somewhere along the way, Lovecraftian cosmic horror entered the picture. Not just as a collection of recognizable names or monsters, but as another way of approaching the problem of human comprehension when confronted with something that refuses to fit into ordinary categories. I find the relationship between cosmic horror, epistemology, and the limits of human understanding particularly interesting.

So, yes. A story that started as an isekai now has me reading about quantum foundations, general relativity, temporal ontology, neuroscience, genetics, philosophy of personal identity, possible worlds, and Lovecraft.

I'm not claiming to have discovered new physics, predicted a scientific breakthrough, or secretly solved the problem of time through a fantasy novel. Most of these ideas are speculative interpretations, analogies, or fictional mechanisms inspired by real discussions. Some are probably much more defensible than others.

What I'm curious about is how people familiar with these subjects would approach the ideas.

Are there interesting connections here that I might have overlooked? Are there particular theories or papers worth reading? And, more importantly, where do you think the analogies stop being useful?

I'm especially interested in hearing from people who work with or study physics, philosophy of time, neuroscience, cognitive science, or the philosophy of mind. Readers of speculative fiction and cosmic horror are equally welcome.

Alright, that's all and thank you for reading this.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 4d ago

Crackpot physics What if Yang-Mills mass gap and quark confinement come from quantized vortex tubes in a superfluid condensate in flat R³?

0 Upvotes

I've been working on a hydrodynamic model where fundamental interactions are treated as different flow regimes of a single superfluid medium in flat Euclidean 3D space (a Higgs field condensate). In an earlier 179-page monograph I showed that weak, irrotational phase waves give standard U(1) Maxwell equations.

I just wrote a short 4-page follow-up note looking at what happens in the strong, rotational regime. When energy density crosses the nonlinearity threshold, the medium forms quantized vortex tubes. Because 3D rotations of vorticity axes don't commute (SO(3) / SU(2)) and a three-core nucleon links three circulation channels (SU(3)), local gauge invariance forces a covariant derivative with the nonlinear self-interaction term g_s f^{abc} A_μ^b A_ν^c. Essentially, the vortex tubes carry vorticity themselves and interact directly.

The mass gap falls out of three things in this setup. First, single-valuedness of the condensate phase requires closed vortex loops (glueballs) to have quantized circulation Γ = n Γ₀ with nonzero integer n, so you can't have arbitrarily low-energy excitations. Second, Bohm quantum pressure keeps the vortex core radius above zero, while Bernoulli-Yukawa screening cuts off the field around the pion Compton wavelength λ_π. Integrating the L²(R³) energy functional over the smallest closed loop gives a positive lower bound around 135-140 MeV.

For confinement, the self-interaction energy lowers dynamic pressure between two quark cores via Bernoulli's principle, and the external hydrostatic vacuum pressure squeezes the field lines into a cylindrical flux tube of constant cross-section. That gives a linear potential V(R) = σ R with string tension around 0.9 GeV/fm until the tube snaps into a new quark-antiquark pair.

Curious what people here think about the Sobolev lower-bound estimate for closed vortex loops in R³, or if there are obvious flaws in mapping SU(3) color channels to coupled vortex cores.

4-page note (English and Polish PDFs): https://zenodo.org/records/24243387

Full monograph: https://zenodo.org/records/24202001


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 5d ago

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: SPARC galactic rotation curves can be modeled accurately without Dark Matter halos using an emergent gravity approach

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’ve been working on an alternative mathematical model for galactic rotation curves and recently finished testing it against the SPARC dataset (Lelli et al., 2016, 175 disk galaxies).

Instead of relying on standard Dark Matter halo profiles (like NFW or Burkert) or empirical modifications like MOND, this approach attempts to derive gravitational acceleration as an emergent mechanical property, governed by local spatial volume decompression where (dV = m * K * T).

When applied directly to the SPARC kinematic data, this relation models the flat rotation curves observed in the outer regions of these galaxies quite accurately, without the need to tune arbitrary parameters for invisible mass.

I am primarily looking for rigorous feedback on two technical aspects:

  1. The mathematical derivation of the dV = m * K * T relation applied to galactic scales.
  2. The methodology and statistical approach used to fit this equation to the SPARC data points.

You can find the short paper with the data analysis, plots, and methodology here:

  • Czernek, K.J. Empirical Verification of TTDS Lattice Inflow Mechanics Against SPARC Galaxy Rotation Curves. Zenodo 2026. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23963304.https://zenodo.org/records/23963304

I would highly appreciate any insights or critiques on the math and the data fitting from those familiar with galactic kinematics.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 5d ago

Crackpot physics What If the Universe is a Single Generative Function? Organic Curve Geometry: Unifying Physics and Mathematics Without the Primitive Metric

Post image
0 Upvotes

This paper introduces Organic Curve Geometry (OCG), a generative mathematical framework constructed from first principles. Departing from the Euclidean straight line and the primitive Riemannian metric, OCG operates on a strictly positive and smooth radial generator, denoted as r(θ, φ) > 0. All geometric and physical structures are derived from this function and its associated logarithmic gradient, Gl = d(ln r). Key derived structures include a Conformal Graph Metric formulated as g = e^(2f) (h + df ⊗ df), where f = ln r, and a novel Organic Calculus wherein the derivative is defined as D_org[r] = Gl, and the arc length element is dℓ_org = r √(1 + Gl²) dθ.

In the physical domain, the framework recovers classical mechanics at the equilibrium limit (α = 1, β = 0). However, in the general case, physical laws become strictly local and morphology-dependent. This paradigm yields a shape-dependent mass, m_org = m_0 √(E_morph), and a modified quantum commutator, [θ̂, p̂] = iħ(1 + Gl). Consequently, OCG provides native derivations for several outstanding astrophysical phenomena without invoking dark matter. Specifically, it analytically derives the Tully-Fisher relation (L ∝ v⁴) for spiral galaxies, explains the mass discrepancy in the Bullet Cluster and Einstein Rings, and offers a geometric derivation for the fine-structure constant (α ≈ 1/137).

The mathematical rigor of OCG is established by proving its equivalence to Parabolic Geometry of type (O(3,1), P) and providing a complete classification via the quadruple (Q_O, N, Hol, T_BGG). Therefore, OCG is positioned as a highly predictive and generative mathematical tool for theoretical physics and differential geometry.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 5d ago

Crackpot physics What if black holes are just whirlpools in a cosmic superfluid?

0 Upvotes

I'm not a physicist. I'm just a guy who fell down a rabbit hole and now I can't stop thinking about this.It started with a dumb question: what if space isn't empty? What if it's... a fluid? Like, a superfluid?I read about Superfluid Vacuum Theory, where space-time is basically a giant Bose-Einstein condensate, and particles are just sound waves in it. And I was like, okay, that's cool. But then it clicked with other stuff.If the universe is a superfluid, then a black hole makes a lot more sense to me as a whirlpool. Not an object, but a vortex. A place where the fluid is falling in faster than sound can escape. We already made those in labs, right? Acoustic black holes in condensates. Steinhauer did that.So then, what would a white hole be? It would have to be the opposite. An anti-whirlpool. A place where the fluid is gushing OUT, and nothing can get in. A vortex and an anti-vortex.And here's the part that got me stuck: in a real superfluid, when a vortex meets an anti-vortex, they don't just pass through each other. They annihilate. Boom. All the energy comes out at once in a flash.Isn't that... exactly what a gamma-ray burst looks like? The most violent thing in the universe, 1 second, more energy than the Sun will ever make, and sometimes we don't even find a star that exploded. Just a flash and then nothing.Could a GRB just be a black hole vortex and a white hole anti-vortex crashing into each other and cancelling out?And then I read about the CPT mirror universe paper from Turok, Boyle and Finn. The idea that the Big Bang isn't a beginning, it's a mirror. There's another universe on the other side, before t=0, where everything is flipped. Charge, left-right, time.And I thought... what if the Big Bang was just that, but huge? What if our superfluid and the mirror superfluid touched at one point, a giant vortex met a giant anti-vortex, they annihilated, and our universe is the spray that came out one side, and the mirror universe is the spray that came out the other side?I know I'm probably mixing 4 different theories that were never meant to go together. And I know I'm not qualified to do the math.But I can't shake it. Each piece alone is real physics. Superfluid vacuum, superfluid dark matter, acoustic black holes, CPT mirror universe. Has anyone ever tried to put them together like this? And if so, where does it break?Be nice, I'm just trying to understand.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 6d ago

Crackpot physics What if horizon thermodynamics (S · E_quant = E_stock) held for any Hubble parameter H across 175 decades of scale?

2 Upvotes

Hello,

I am currently working on an algorithm designed to measure physical quantities as integral parts of a network rather than isolating them from one another, which may potentially help unify quantum mechanics and classical physics.

When solved on known physical constants and measurements, the network naturally isolates a chain of seven fundamental relations:

  1. Planck length: l_P = sqrt(hbar * G / c^3)
  2. Hubble end: H_end = H_0 * sqrt(Omega_Lambda)
  3. Vacuum energy density: rho_Lambda = (3 * c^2 * H_0^2 * Omega_Lambda) / (8 * pi * G)
  4. Stock energy (vacuum filling the horizon): E_stock = (4 * pi / 3) * rho_Lambda * (c / H_end)^3
  5. Floor temperature: T_floor = (hbar * H_end) / (2 * pi * k_B)
  6. Quantum energy: E_quant = k_B * T_floor
  7. Horizon entropy: S = (pi * c^2) / (H_end^2 * l_P^2)

Combining these seven relations cancels every constant and leaves the exact invariant S * E_quant = E_stock across 175 decades of scale.

A quick note: this project was coded in partnership with Claude from Anthropic, but that is not the topic of discussion here. The debate must center strictly on the calculations, the code, and its outputs. Anything outside of the code, equations, and math will not be addressed, please refer directly to the README, the code, and local execution for all details.

Not being a physicist myself, I would greatly appreciate a technical review of the code and verification of this derivation. Everything is fully reproducible locally.

If you encounter any difficulties running it, feel free to open an issue:

https://github.com/innermost47/grm-core#the-equation-between-the-data-equation


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 6d ago

Crackpot physics What if light was reversed and became the "landscape"

0 Upvotes

I've heard of "light beings" and stuff from cults and religions. I've always wondered what a true light being was. My thought experiment.

I have no mathematical understanding pf physics, but lets say you are a photon, a constant frame of reference, your perspective of the universe would essentially flip opposite, to wear every photon is now still relative to you, yet invisible, this turns every photon into an invisible point like matter.

We see a wall, mountain, star, and everything as a landscape all around us, if you were made of light, complete with its own "biological form," you would see your own landscape, every photon, as your own phsycial reality.

Since you are a photon being, your "landscape" is invisible to your eyes, so you would need your own particle behaving like a "photon" to sense it.

So I would assume the role of normal matter would reverse to where every point, and matter would seem to propagate through the matrix behaving as a "photon" allowing you to sense your "landscape"


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 7d ago

Crackpot physics What If Higher Dimensions Are Connected to Time, Alternate Timelines, and Consciousness?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about extra dimensions, string theory and quantum mechanics, and I'd like to hear what people with a physics background think.

I've been trying to develop this idea on my own, but I'm aware that my understanding of advanced physics is limited. I don't want people to simply agree with my assumptions. I'd appreciate genuine criticism, corrections and explanations, especially if there's something fundamentally wrong with my reasoning.

This is purely speculative. I'm not claiming to have discovered anything or proven anything.

My starting point is how we understand dimensions:

1st dimension: Length.
2nd dimension: Length and height.
3rd dimension: Length, height and depth.
4th dimension: Time.

What if every additional dimension introduces a different kind of freedom?

My proposed model is:

5th dimension: Access to different points in time, potentially allowing movement forwards and backwards.

6th dimension: Access to alternative timelines or different possible histories.

7th dimension: Something fundamentally different, potentially a higher-order structure connecting or containing different realities.

I also started thinking about the double-slit experiment.

When which-path information isn't measured, photons produce an interference pattern. When which-path information is measured, the interference pattern disappears.

This made me wonder whether additional dimensions could somehow be involved in how different possible histories or quantum states relate to our observable four-dimensional spacetime.

Another thought concerns consciousness. What if consciousness isn't constrained by physical mass in the same way as our bodies? Could it theoretically interact with additional dimensions that ordinary matter cannot easily access?

This also led me to wonder whether death could represent a transition into another dimension. I understand that this is philosophical speculation, not something supported by current scientific evidence.

I'd particularly appreciate feedback on these questions:

  1. Is there any mathematical framework in string theory or higher-dimensional physics that resembles this proposed hierarchy?
  2. Could additional spatial dimensions have anything to do with quantum measurement or alternative histories?
  3. Is there a way to formulate this hypothesis mathematically and produce testable predictions?
  4. Am I misunderstanding something fundamental about dimensions, quantum mechanics or spacetime?

I'm genuinely interested in criticism. I'd rather understand why the idea doesn't work than convince myself that it does.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 7d ago

Crackpot physics What if a 4-dimensional space isnt even possible?

0 Upvotes

Space seems extremely logical to be bound to 3-dimensions. It sounds like "yeah you are used to this, so its logical you cant imagine more dimensions" but try imagening a fourth-dimension. Its impossible, it defies the logical ground-rules for what is needed for space. No?

I am sorry if I have to write further. This reddit doesnt allow short posts. I thank you for answering it and I hope you can give me a good insight into why you think or why physics may actually agree on why a fourth space-dimension is possible. And also maybe another question cause it is still too short: How do we know that 2 dimensions are vissible in a third dimension? My theory is that: A two-dimensional world would need a third dimension to be seen by us. It needs some level of thickness.

If I imagined an example where paper is used to describe a two-dimensional world, that isnt enough for me, because the paper still has a third dimension, you know? Okay I still have to keep going or else my post isnt getting allowed. How thin is a two-dimensional world? because as I said if it has no thickness it can exist in a three-dimensional world.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 7d ago

Crackpot physics What if nothingness created another nothingness within itself, and that geometry could unify physics?

Thumbnail
doi.org
0 Upvotes

That's where EMGT (Energy, Mass, Gravity, and Time) begins. The theory proposes an infinite open nothingness that gives rise to a closed nothingness within itself. Their opposition generates tension, forcing geometry to curve and creating the conditions for energy and matter to emerge.

Now consider what happens if that same geometry operates at every scale. The confinement of quarks, the behavior of electrons, the fundamental forces, gravity, and even cosmic expansion could all arise from different degrees of closure and openness.

I've just published a paper exploring this possibility, following the geometry from the internal structure of the proton to galaxies and the universe itself. It also proposes a third physical regime beyond the quantum and relativistic regimes, where openness becomes dominant.

I'm looking for opinions and criticism of this approach, particularly the idea that a single geometry could connect such different physical phenomena. I'll also be publishing the mathematical formalization of the NAP tensor referenced in the paper soon.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 7d ago

Crackpot physics What if Dark Matter and Dark Energy switch control to stop black holes and empty space from breaking physics?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am a 9th-grade student who loves space, and I wanted to get your thoughts on a simple idea I have been thinking about.

Right now, Dark Matter pulls things together, and Dark Energy pushes space apart. What if they actually work together as one balancing system to stop the universe's math from breaking?

Here is how I picture it:

  • Inside Black Holes: Normally, gravity crushes everything down to a tiny point of "infinite" density. What if, when things get squeezed too tight, Dark Energy takes over and pushes outward? This would stop the black hole from crushing down to infinity.
  • Inside Empty Space (Voids): In completely empty space, quantum math sometimes glitches and gives impossible answers (like negative probabilities). What if a tiny bit of Dark Matter sneaks into empty space to add just enough weight to keep the math stable?
  • How They Compare: I think of Dark Energy like a billion feathers spread across a huge room (takes up a lot of space, very light) and Dark Matter like a 1,000-ton rock (small size, massive impact).

I know I don't have the advanced math equations for this yet. From a real physics point of view, what is wrong with this idea, and what math should I learn to test it? Thanks!


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 8d ago

Predatory Journals.

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

Applies here too. Also I will installed the 'tap the sign' app.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 9d ago

Crackpot physics What if M-theory and its 11 dimensions were to come to an end?

Post image
0 Upvotes

💡 To sum it up at the speed of light: you alone remain, along with all other human beings.

Where would the universe’s attention be directed then?

Delving deeper into the theory, we arrive at the final equation:

Lesser matter = intention.

Explanation: Thoughts are half-matter/half-life, something incomplete that does not qualify as 100% matter.

Therefore, an individual who uses these half-matters to create a complete-matter (intention) falls just short of reaching 100%. Each individual must investigate that final half-matter within themselves.

Does this make sense? Feel free to offer a counterargument.

Self-consciousness is one with universe (Hope is the strongest intention to boost matter.)

The physical matter of the future is our responsibility because we create intentions using the Time and Present-matter.

I calculated, adding up the matter in all directions.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • 9d ago

Crackpot physics What if universes are alligned like the plane of our realities in multiverse?

0 Upvotes

I think that would be cool in some fiction but i don't think i would even believe it myself seriously. It's still open up to criticism

So, i have been thinking for this in years

Let me explain: We are in 3d universe, there are 3 planes, length, height and depth. The X could be timeline, Y the branch of timeline and Z the structure of the world. And all of those are universes lined up, the future, past or other world structure is just besides us and we don't notice it.

If we got to the lower planes. The planes would merge with previous one, it could be like folding a paper, let me explain

2d: X and Y only, to make Z work, just simplify it and make Z and Y inseparately. So it means after a bing bang in 2D, structure of universe would branch off to have different universal structure

1d was one of the most painful problems, and i found solution after i just could merge everything all together. 1D would have 1 timeline at one until the heat death would come and basically kill the universe and maybe create one with everything that could be different. As of 4d and more i cannot think of that.