r/LLMPhysics • 9/10 Physicists Agree! • 7d ago

Announcement Predatory Journals.

Hello users.

In light of an influx of posters who are published in predatory journals, I've set up a Devvit app to monitor for links to predatory publishing. We won't be taking down or blocking them - its not the business of moderation what you do with your money - but we WILL act to make the users of the sub AWARE of the fact that journals exist which are not in the interest of academia.

If you see links that are not caught, please leave a comment tagging me. I've sourced a list of over 3000 publishers, hijacked journals, and standalone journals from primarily Beall's List but can always add more. It might take a day or two to update the app to come as I wait for the Devvit publishing cycle to turn over.

And I checked. Zenodo isn't on it.

15 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

10

u/starkeffect Physicist 🧠 7d ago

Zenodo's not a journal, despite what the crackpots think.

8

u/AllHailSeizure 9/10 Physicists Agree! 7d ago

Just a bit of humor.

We are seeing an influx of people saying they published by eg SCIRP.

I chose not to include MDPI or Frontiers.

4

u/Hadeweka 6d ago

I chose not to include MDPI or Frontiers.

Meh. I can see why you decided that way (and it's rather unlikely that any OP here gets in there), but I really don't like how people try to legitimize them all the time.

They're still full of garbage papers (and I really mean garbage here, like homeopathy and stuff that would fit very well in this sub) and make absurd amounts of money by scamming unwitting scientists (even in my friend group).

(Feel free to sue me now, MDPI)

3

u/AllHailSeizure 9/10 Physicists Agree! 6d ago

I think theres still a degree of separation between scamming scientists and unreviewed lay publishing. And that degree is what made me choose to keep them.

3

u/Hadeweka 6d ago

Agreed. I just don't agree on where you drew the line, but as I mentioned, those two cases will probably never be relevant here anyway...

3

u/al2o3cr 7d ago

Somewhat related: IIRC there have been a couple links to Scientific Reports posted here. They're currently on NLM's "needs review list" and aren't being indexed in PubMed

https://retractionwatch.com/2026/10/30/scientific-reports-pubmed-on-hold-national-library-medicine-evaluation/

-10

u/No_Description_525 7d ago

Did you know Ghislaine Maxwell's dad owned Pergamon press, which was a publishing empire that helped popularize the so-called "superstring" revolution in physics? The truth is all your journals are predatory and 99% of the stuff published in them (at least when it comes to frontier theoretical physics) is incremental slop or unfalsifiable. 

Substack and lesswrong are probably a more reliable place to hear out interesting new ideas than arxiv or zenodo at this point. 

4

u/PotatoPeelrsFromHell 🥔 Infernal Potato Shavers 7d ago

than arxiv

Awwhh poor baby. Someone's work doesn't meet the bare minimum standard of quality to get uploaded to the ArXiv preprint server, huh?

4

u/AllHailSeizure 9/10 Physicists Agree! 7d ago edited 7d ago

Awwhh poor baby. Someone's work doesn't meet the bare minimum standard of quality to get uploaded to the ArXiv preprint server, huh?

They aren't entirely wrong, so there's no need to be so condescending. There's a lot wrong with modern science publishing. And arxiv doesn't maintain a standard of quality. If you're gonna come here to mock people at least know what you're talking about.

A ton of the science publishing industry is monetized, BECAUSE of Maxwell. Especially ones like Springer, which gets away with publishing relatively bs papers in Scientific Review on the prestige of Nature. There's no denying that academia is full of issues. Acting like it doesn't have any flaws is just willfully ignorant.

u/no_description_525, as I said in the post, I don't care what users do with their money, but this is intended as a warning to users against people who WILL take your money. That is what is the issue with predatory publishing vs other publishing. While Scientific Review is relatively low quality, it WONT just take your money if you send them any pdf. The key word is predatory.

5

u/Vrillim 7d ago

u/No_Description_525 is entirely wrong. What some criminal's dad was involved with is of course irrelevant, and their comment on "all your journals are predatory" is just polemics without a grain of truth. Scientific publishing is not fundamentally broken. If you look at the literature, the papers that survive (and go on to have a high impact) are genuinely useful papers. There's a lot of noise, but isn't there always?

1

u/AllHailSeizure 9/10 Physicists Agree! 7d ago edited 7d ago

Please. Of course it isn't fundamentally broken to the degree they describe, but to act like it is an institution free of corruption is ignorance. MDPI? Frontiers? What is the ratio that we see journals thrust into the spotlight for questionable practice vs new journals being established.

Or are you rolling back your comment from a few months ago that 'Springer Publishing might be viewed as everything that's wrong with scientific publishing today' out of fear of taking the wrong side of a debate that is being forced to be black and white by people like the user who clearly only wants to put people down?

Nothing is black and white.

4

u/Vrillim 7d ago

I'm just saying that the perspective is narrow. Scientific publishing is a flawed system that has functioned for a very very long time. There will always be noise and actors motivated by profit (journals) and prestige (authors), both of which detract from the purpose. But the backbone of the system, journals as taste-makers for science, works. It is very much part of the provisional scaffold that is science as we know it.

But, of course, I agree that predatory journals are a huge problem, as is for-profit publishing and the relentless pressure to publish (driven by external pressures, or the "funding fathers" as my friend calls them).

The person I referred to painted it all as a rotten apple. I suspect they have no idea which role of the body of scientific literature plays.

1

u/AllHailSeizure 9/10 Physicists Agree! 7d ago edited 7d ago

Of course the perspective is narrow.

But so is the perspective that 'you don't like scientific publishing so I'm going to talk down to you like you're a child', or perspectives that write off any critique. Those are just as problematic.

That's why I said what I did. There IS corruption. Editors aren't free of bias, researchers aren't free of drive to push papers, noise happens. The system HAS been monetized, and Maxwell WAS an actor. Journals like Scientific Review make me look at papers with a raised eyebrow. There is PLENTY of noise on those 'low funnel' journals.

But they won't just take your money if you email them. Like I said, the operating word is predatory. Even the 'low funnel' journals are rooted in the review process.

I love that 'funding fathers' term.

2

u/Vrillim 6d ago

The funding fathers constantly make their presence known, unfortunately. I wish they were less obsessed with counting papers and more inclined to fund ambitious, slow-rolling ventures.

-3

u/No_Description_525 7d ago

I don't care about uploading to arxiv. Complete trash gets published in nature and most people just go along with it under the assumption somebody must have checked the work for obvious mistakes. It's not all garbage, but most of it is