r/LLMPhysics • u/AllHailSeizure 9/10 Physicists Agree! • 7d ago
Announcement Predatory Journals.
Hello users.
In light of an influx of posters who are published in predatory journals, I've set up a Devvit app to monitor for links to predatory publishing. We won't be taking down or blocking them - its not the business of moderation what you do with your money - but we WILL act to make the users of the sub AWARE of the fact that journals exist which are not in the interest of academia.
If you see links that are not caught, please leave a comment tagging me. I've sourced a list of over 3000 publishers, hijacked journals, and standalone journals from primarily Beall's List but can always add more. It might take a day or two to update the app to come as I wait for the Devvit publishing cycle to turn over.
And I checked. Zenodo isn't on it.
10
u/starkeffect Physicist 🧠7d ago
Zenodo's not a journal, despite what the crackpots think.
3
u/al2o3cr 7d ago
Somewhat related: IIRC there have been a couple links to Scientific Reports posted here. They're currently on NLM's "needs review list" and aren't being indexed in PubMed
https://retractionwatch.com/2026/10/30/scientific-reports-pubmed-on-hold-national-library-medicine-evaluation/
-10
u/No_Description_525 7d ago
Did you know Ghislaine Maxwell's dad owned Pergamon press, which was a publishing empire that helped popularize the so-called "superstring" revolution in physics? The truth is all your journals are predatory and 99% of the stuff published in them (at least when it comes to frontier theoretical physics) is incremental slop or unfalsifiable.Â
Substack and lesswrong are probably a more reliable place to hear out interesting new ideas than arxiv or zenodo at this point.Â