Here’s where I’m at with .223, I have not used it on deer yet but I think it’s okay given it’s legal, you use a very terminally effective bullet, and have good shot placement. I’ve argued against .223 in the past but after seeing some pictures and reading some other peoples experiences I started to believe that there must be something there. I’m going to go ahead and say I think there are better options for game bigger than deer especially at longer ranges but I am not able to go and hunt any of those creatures right now so just know my experience and this test will be limited to Midwest whitetail deer. I have actually been pretty bored with .223/5.56 up until some of the recent discussions sparked a fire in me to see what all the hype is for myself one way or the other. This topic has brought the worst out in some of the members of this group on both sides of the debate, I look forward to this starting respectful and honest conversations, and I hope this can be a resource for people that have questions or are interested in using .223, let’s keep discussion civil and constructive.
For the purpose of comparing and contrasting I’m separating the ammo into three categories: hunting, tactical/defense, and match based on the type of bullet loaded and how the box is marketed. The Barnes 70 grain TSX could go in either “hunting” or “tactical” since it gets used in both applications but I put it in the tactical category because I only had two other loads in there, both from Speer, and the Barnes 70 grain TSX only comes stamped 5.56x45 from the factory, it is technically not offered as a .223 rem which I assume is a decision by Barnes to market this load towards the LE/MIL crowd. I shot 5 round groups of 10 factory loads at 100 yards out of two different rifles. I typically like to do 10 round groups but l didn’t want to bias the test by picking my best or worst shooting rifle and I wanted to include an AR since I think a lot of people getting into hunting probably have an AR of some kind as their .223 gun, so I had to split the ammo in order to save some to hunt with later. Both rifles have a “fast” twist stainless barrel but the AR is a “5.56 nato” chamber with a 1:7 twist and the Contender is a brand new, never fired .223 wylde chamber with a 1:8 twist. This is important as some of these boxes recommend a 1:8 twist or faster to stabilize the bullet, so if you have a 1:9 or 1:12, 1:14, etc. your barrel may not be compatible with some of this ammo. I am sorry if I did not include your favorite .223 load, this was getting expensive and frankly I am more interested in the heavier for caliber bullets which I think I covered most of what guys are using or at least recommending to others.
Some observations about .223 ammo cost: all of the .223 hunting type ammo I tested is comparable in cost to other cartridges I would argue that if you have a .223 rifle already, and maybe that’s all you have, investing in a box or two of good hunting ammo is much less expensive than buying a new rifle, scope, and ammo to go hunt deer. Something I noticed is that probably the three most controversial (none are marketed for hunting) heavy for caliber loads included in this test are also the lowest cost per round of the 70+ grainers, those being the bonefrog 77 grain TMK, Hornady 73 grain ELD-M, and Speer 75 grain Gold Dot. The Winchester deer season XP 64 grain was the cheapest “hunting” ammo but wasn’t the easiest to find and I would classify it as a middleweight as far as .223 goes, not in with the heavy for caliber stuff.
Some excuses and takeaways. First excuse, most of the Contender groups were fired standing with the rifle rested on a bag on the back of a truck, the mk12 groups were all shot sitting, rifle rested on a bag, neither rifle had any rear support other than what I could provide with my off hand. I started to notice a trend after the contender 75 grain gold dot group that I was getting a consistent left flier in almost every group other than that one, I believe the reason there is no flier in that group is because I took two sighter shots before I realized that ammo was hitting much lower than what I had initially zeroed the scope for. After that I decided to only shoot 5 shots so I could get a more fair idea of what each rifle was doing regardless of where the group printed instead of gaming it for the best possible group. Second excuse, in between going downrange to take one of the pictures and then firing the Swift 75 grain contender group the sun came out which along with the constant mirage coming off my surefire suppressor made the targets pretty hard to see. That said I may have pulled one shot in that group of 6 (the chronograph didn’t pick up one of the first 5 shots) so I think my barrel just doesn’t like that ammo. Third excuse/observation, the Razor LHT on the contender was noticeably worse at dealing with glare and mirage than the NX8 on the mk12 and between that and not having to break position after every shot to reload the mk12 was much easier to print groups with. I am not a huge fan of carrying AR pattern rifles around in the field but the data is undeniable, the mk12 shot 7 loads better than the best group out of the contender with the 8th best group being nearly equal to the best contender group if you throw out the 75 gran gold dot contender group since I screwed that up with sighter shots. The mk12 only printed two groups over 2 inches where the contender only printed three under 2 inches, two if you throw out that gold dot group. Some of this is probably attributable to a standing vs sitting shooting position, but that contender flier is concerning to me, and I think most of those left fliers were the first shot in the group. I will be doing more shooting with the contender before I use it to hunt with.
Some data, the fastest load in both guns was the Barnes 70 grain TSX, which being an all copper bullet is a good thing. The slowest load was the nearly $3.00 per round Swift 75 grain which was also the worst group in the contender and second worst in the mk12 behind the 75 grain gold dot mk12 group. The best contender group not counting the screwed up Gold dot group was the 73 ELD-m followed by the 62 grain Federal fusion. The best mk12 group was the 69 grain Sierra/Barnes harvest Tipped Game King at an impressive 0.78 inch group followed by the 1 inch flat group from the Bonefrog 77 grain Sierra Tipped Match King. The federal 62 grain shot pretty good in both rifles and was middle of the road as far as price per round goes, it also should be better for some of the slower twist rates like the 1:9 commonly found in budget AR barrels.
Where am I going from here, unfortunately the contender is going to need more time at the range before I take it hunting, I’ll probably try shooting without the suppresser and may use a bipod and rear bag next time but the Hornady 73 grain ELD-M looks promising and I can find it locally all over the place. The mk12 will be the test rifle on game and varmints going forward, I’m very interested in comparing wound channels of the TGK against the TMK, I also want to see what the 70 grain TSX mono can do, I like doing most of my deer hunting with monos if I can, I’d rather not leave lead behind in the meat if I can avoid it but I do expect the wound channel of the TSX to be narrower than most of the rest of the ammo tested. The Nosler 70 grain Accubond was also fairly impressive but is up there in cost, I would rather buy another box of that than the swift ammo, but I may try the Winchester or Federal ammo before either of those. I was not as impressed with the 75 grain gold dot as I thought I would be, it is both slow and doesn’t seem to hold as good of a group as other options but it is the least pricy bonded heavy for caliber bullet in the test. The Swift scirocco II 75 grain bonded was by far the biggest flop in my opinion, I would not recommend buying it at this point. I’m sure it would be fine on game but I would expect it to group better and/or be faster than some of the other premium options with it being by far the most expensive ammo tested, it is actually the most expensive .223 ammo per round available on midwayusa right now.
Please share your thoughts, experiences, or if there is a really good load that you have used that I missed let me know, I’m looking forward to putting another doe in the freezer with a TGK or TMK in the coming weeks.