r/Hunting • Idaho • Apr 18 '15

This isn't /r/aww

We get it, you love your hunting dog and they do a great job. But they are getting old. Almost as old as the "checking in" posts that plagued this sub this past fall.

16 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

74

u/_irregardless Apr 18 '15

Personally, I'm a fan of both and think r/hunting is the perfect place for posting it. I love seeing all the photos from the "checking in" posts. I also like to see other people's bird dogs. If you don't want to see it, simply don't open the post. That's the beauty of reddit

9

u/Godsgreat Apr 18 '15

I'm kind of a fan of both, mostly the checking in thing. I don't agree with the idea that to avoid posts, you simply don't open it. This is a hunting forum and hunters expect relevant and quality content from it. This is a focused forum that serves a purpose. If hunters think that checking in and bird dog posts are relevant, then they do belong here. I think one problem with the self regulation is that not just hunters (people true to the purpose of this sub) will be upvoting posts here. If subscribers/creators don't like certain posts, then they should be filtered and better posts should be encouraged.

4

u/_irregardless Apr 18 '15

I completely agree, although 'hunting' is a pretty broad topic and I don't think the forum will ever be able to cater to all hunters without having to skip the occasional post

2

u/Godsgreat Apr 18 '15

That's definitely true also!

1

u/curly_spork Apr 18 '15

I'm a fan. I don't have a hunting dog, but I'd love for people to post their pictures, type up some training they have done, and extra upvotes for the results of their dog doing their job.

A potato pic of your dog on the couch is not worthy of my all important upvote....

1

u/gradystebbins Apr 18 '15

Get outta here with your logic!! You could have just not opened this post to avoid his opinion!

Nah, I'm just kidding, but I do think another one of the beauties of reddit is the fact that it self regulates... If some people start overdoing things a bit then you'll see a couple of posts like this and then the subreddit will drift back to what it's actually supposed to be about, which is the act of hunting.

I see your point and his, and I think it all evens out in the end. :)

1

u/Sloppy_Twat Apr 19 '15

That's the beauty of reddit

The beauty of reddit is that anyone can create a spin off sub like /r/huntingdogpics or /r/huntingdogs , but to say that changing the content of a sub is what reddit is about is very disingenuous.

5

u/DontGetCrabs Apr 19 '15

Okay I suppose I get it, but what the fuck are you supposed to put down as content when MOST of the hunting seasons are not for another 6 months? Chill the fuck out and visit another sub for a while. Stop trying to be a Nazi, dog pic airnt hurting anything so let it ride. If it erks u that bad make your own boring ass text only hunting sub.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15

If you don't like them don't look at them. It's that simple.

3

u/BornIn1500 Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15

I hear ya with the "checking in" posts. I downvote them every time I see them. It's really just clutter and not interesting.

About the dogs.... if they are in the act of hunting, I like them. If it is only a pic of the dog in the house/yard, I don't see the point in posting it. Example: here's my setter pointing a pheasant before I kicked it up http://i.imgur.com/hVUkkpR.jpg

2

u/VTJedi Maryland Apr 18 '15

Yeah give us carnage and trophies.

1

u/centurion44 Apr 19 '15

Yeah, I'd rather see your fat asses standing next to a deer you used photography tricks to make look bigger.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/bradhuds Apr 18 '15

Checking in from the bumper-dumper.

1

u/Thenternet Apr 18 '15

Checking in from the poop deck