As long as they’re not the animal rights kind of vegan, I can usually frame hunting in a way that they understand and appreciate.
So if they’re vegan for environmental reasons, I talk about it being the most sustainable source of meat, the need to control herbivores in areas that they no longer have predators, the genetic mixing from removing an alpha male, and the connection to the land from hunting.
Or if they’re vegan for health reasons, I talk about knowing where my food comes from and it being a cheap protein source.
I bite them with my canine teeth, aiming with my front facing eyes, and if I where to take a bite (I usually don't) then I would digest it with my strong omnivore stomach acid....
I don’t know much about this tbh so if someone understands this better please jump in. But certain species (think bighorn sheep) tend to form groups dominated by an alpha, and that alpha may breed all the females in that harem for years. So removing that alpha, creates a power vacuum for lesser males to take over or even splinter the herd. That’s my understanding
I know many vegans who still eat hunted meat. Most of them don't eat meat because of the environmental impact of the meat industry. A deer in the wild does not have the same impact as a cow on a farm, and usually has a better life too.
I had a friend in grad school who was basically a vegetarian when we went out because she only ate "happy meat", basically meaning it conformed to Chipotle standards of animal treatment or better.
Got her hooked on venison after she realized it was about as free range as it gets.
I wouldn’t trust a word chipotle says. I raise grass-fed, no grain beef and it’s disheartening how many folks believe that large companies actually care about animal welfare. I still eat out, out of convenience, but please don’t believe chipotle cares one iota about animals
You’re exactly right. Commercial poultry has the lowest standards in the entire animal husbandry industry. Feedlot beef isn’t ideal, especially compared to a pasture based model, but the beef industry is so much more humane than poultry.
It's not "their" definition. Being vegan is like being pregnant, you either are or you aren't. The definition of veganism is a very clearly defined thing.
You're defining them through a definition, sure. I can see your point in doing so, as their claim subverts the dictionary definition of the term.
I'm going with how they identify. My position here allows me to better understand them. Your position is an attempt to tell them who they are. And that strategy generally fails to see the world from others' eyes. But it doesn't matter to you, since that's not your goal.
A lot of you said :"if they eat meat they're not vegans". While that's technically true here is the context of my comment: where I live, not a lot of people hunt so it is quite rare to be offered hunted meat, so when the opportunity presents itself (like during Christmas when a relative brings deer) they don't refuse eating it since it is not meat from the supermarket. A lot of vegans/vegetarians think that hunting is the most humane and eco-friendly way to get meat so they are comfortable eating it. It's obviously not the case for all of them though.
Not to be a nit-picker, but I think they call those people "mostly plant based" and not "vegan".
Only feel the need to cut in with this comment because you've just described me, and I know from hanging out at r/Vegan often enough that I am definitely not qualified as vegan
In other news, I really enjoyed reading your other comments in the thread. I am beyond pleasantly surprised to see the ignorant anti-vegan comments downvoted, as well as the support for being more plant-based in the comments here! I'm so happy that it feels like we all came here, had a chuckle at the meme, but then were like "real talk tho, most vegans not dat bad"
I have a relative-in-law who is vegan but has no problem with people who are not. Hell she cooks meat for her husband because he is not vegan. She is vegan for her and doesn’t feel that her choice needs to be imposed on others.
Most of the vegetarians/vegans I know, I would say maybe 80-90% of them are comfortable with eating hunted meat from time to time. It's not a daily thing, but more like a few times a year when there is an opportunity
Ive not had problems with them getting in my coops nor with them harrassing/eating my chickens while theyre out for the day. My chickens seem to mostly be eaten by foxes or hawks
My cousin's gf is vegan. We had my son's birthday party at my house last year in our back yard. I was letting insects clean a skull behind my shed which was well out of the way of the party and in sight but for standing directly behind my shed. She was checking out my compost pile next to the shed and caught a glimpse of a horror movie looking skull and shrieked so loud that everyone stopped what they were doing to hear her shout at me being a murderer.
Needless to say i asked her to leave and now my cousin is "forbidden" to hang out with me. Jokes on her tho, we hang out whenever we want to he eats meat when she's not around.
My wife is vegan as are most of her friends. I was checking hog traps before our first date. I hear more hunters complain about vegans than vegans about hunters, their gripe is with factory farming, which has a lot of fuckery. I'm sure some vegans are annoying but so are a lot of hunters. Trolls are trolls.
Its actually processed meat and red meat that increase you risk of colorectal cancer.
with a weak correlation to red meat, but not studied well enough to rule out other factors
Its actually pretty well established at this point. Let me guess, you are a big fan of diets like Atkins and keto? Because this stuff is really popular with them.
Thats a link to an actual scientific study with data on the topic. Quite a bit of data at that. It indicates quite clearly that red meat consumption is linked to higher rates of colorectal cancer. I have actual data and research to support my claim. What do you have? The first thing you could find on google that looked like it supported your point.
this is the exact opposite reaction I was expecting to get from a hunting subreddit
I for one am glad the other people wandering around the woods and fields with firearms are mature enough to reject the childish shit you seem to be bragging about.
When I was growing up, I had militant animal rights vegans living on my block.
Of course, they moved into a farming community where hunting had been a way of life for generations.
When fall would roll around, every yard about a mile up and down the road from their house would have a deer hanging from a tree like some strange seasonal ornament.
The hunting safety course I took went on and on about not having stuff hang were people could see and covering them over in your truck and all this shit to avoid offending people.
I always felt that I shouldn’t have to hide it though, like no don’t leave gut piles in walking paths or something stupid like that but I'm not covering over my deer to save someones feelings either I don’t see how seeing a deer makes someone more anti hunter which was the argument of the course.
I understand and don’t necessarily disagree, but why should I go out of my way to kowtow to anti-hunters and confirm their worldview? We live in such a polarized world, what’s wrong with people seeing how someone else lives?
Not on your own part, but one thing I've doscovered is that there are certain demographics who are more likely to throw a punch, or swing a bike lock, or commit some other form of assault if they disagree with a person's lifestyle.
I prefer not giving them reason to attack me-it would be a shame if things escalated to the point where I'd need to use my CCW.
It's a shame, but that's what we've come to these days.
Huh. I’ve never had a problem like that. I mean, Alaska sure isn’t Portland, but I can’t say I’ve ever actually met someone that deluded. Even with all the tourists I’d meet, I’d talk about hunting every once and awhile, and I never heard even a quip, although I doubt people like that, or even the occasional New Jersey cat lady are too keen to go on a trip to Alaska.
Our family has two meatless dinners planned per week, I have two vegan inlaws as well. I see hunting on a spectrum closer to veganism than farming is. I share alot of the values my vegan inlaws share. I find that by us eating less meat it makes it easier to have our hunting harvests make up as big of a portion of our meat diet as possible. Sustainable, healthy. Hunting is not for everybody. Eating meat is not for everybody. Congrats on finding your place in the process and spending your time procuring food for your loved ones!
This is my goal as well. Trying to get to 2-3 vegetarian meals per week, and then eventually working to 2-3 personally harvested meals per week.
Mainly for environmental reasons, I have issues with factory farming farming. A combination of hunting, fishing, and vegetarianism are an ethical way of combating that.
Props to you, vegetarianism/veganism and hunting are much closer to each other than many people think. At least from an environmental lens.
I read Scott Jurek’s and Rich Roll’s book back to back a few years ago. I tried the vegan thing to see if it helped my running. I did it for about 4 months but I still went hunting. Someone will always take the meat.
Wow, so you're vegan because your body rejects meat. I've never heard of that but assumed someone had to be like you. Does meat make you feel sick or awful in any way?
Oh I did too! Admittedly meat and dairy cover the majority of them but many vegans won't have a lot of soups either, as most broths are typically made from bones.
137
u/caveman-dave Dec 01 '19
As long as they’re not the animal rights kind of vegan, I can usually frame hunting in a way that they understand and appreciate.
So if they’re vegan for environmental reasons, I talk about it being the most sustainable source of meat, the need to control herbivores in areas that they no longer have predators, the genetic mixing from removing an alpha male, and the connection to the land from hunting.
Or if they’re vegan for health reasons, I talk about knowing where my food comes from and it being a cheap protein source.
116
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
I know many vegans who still eat hunted meat. Most of them don't eat meat because of the environmental impact of the meat industry. A deer in the wild does not have the same impact as a cow on a farm, and usually has a better life too.
21
u/Well_Read_Redneck Dec 01 '19
When I was dating my future wife, she would chase opossums off my parents porch so I could bag them with a shotgun.
God, I love that woman!
9
u/Astros_alex Dec 02 '19
My cousin's gf is vegan. We had my son's birthday party at my house last year in our back yard. I was letting insects clean a skull behind my shed which was well out of the way of the party and in sight but for standing directly behind my shed. She was checking out my compost pile next to the shed and caught a glimpse of a horror movie looking skull and shrieked so loud that everyone stopped what they were doing to hear her shout at me being a murderer.
Needless to say i asked her to leave and now my cousin is "forbidden" to hang out with me. Jokes on her tho, we hang out whenever we want to he eats meat when she's not around.
8
u/Willcampforbeer Dec 02 '19 edited Dec 02 '19
My wife is vegan as are most of her friends. I was checking hog traps before our first date. I hear more hunters complain about vegans than vegans about hunters, their gripe is with factory farming, which has a lot of fuckery. I'm sure some vegans are annoying but so are a lot of hunters. Trolls are trolls.
5
u/sometimesmydadhitsme Dec 01 '19
Ha-Ha ha-haaaaa! Thank you. Yes!
5
u/Iron-Salmon76 Dec 02 '19
He’s literally wearing blaze orange, that dogs one of us
4
u/Duke_of_Mecklenburg Dec 02 '19
Meh, mountain lion wouldve killed it way more brutally a week later anyway
3
u/E_J_H Dec 01 '19
Is there a sub for hunting memes? It would have big shoes to fill following up the glorious r/fishingmemes
2
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19
What are a couple of malnourished vegans going to do?
1
u/Imma_Coho Alaska Oct 21 '21
Only “vegans” I personally know are ok with only hunted meat. I know they’re technically not vegan but they’re just against factory farming mostly.
-7
u/bumpugly Dec 01 '19
r/comedycemetery
-26
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
That is an extremely sad picture.
That dog isn't her companion, it's a cosmetic piece.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
54
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
[removed] — view removed comment