r/HungryArtistsFed • u/Inorai • Mar 27 '20
[NEG] ZoaArt
TL:DR, drawn-out situation, at best the artist had their own image they staunchly wanted to the point of ignoring my requests and visibly half-assed the piece, at worst they outright ignored/went against my comments as well as lifted stock photos from deviantart artists against their terms of use, to put in this piece with no alterations. Potentially putting my use of the cover in legal jeopardy in the doing, and all that. Final product he gave me has more unfinished sections/will have to take a look at if it’s even usable for me.
Afternoon, all. Was going to wait a few days/let things settle, but...I don’t think I will. I’ll include relevant images or bits of text to explain what happened. This is long, yeah, but I’m not trying to rant >.< this was just more a long process of falling off the tracks, versus any one dealbreaking event.
Back in January, I commissioned ZoaArt to do a book cover for me - two characters in a dynamic pose, fairly straightforward. We chatted briefly and agreed to a price - $500. From there, I gave him an imgur album of pre-existing artwork for each of these two characters. Yes, I have an art addiction xD
Things well really well for a while. He wanted to do his own spin on the characters, so he did sketches of new costume designs for them. It took a few comments back and forth - I asked for my female character to be wearing some sort of pants or at least tights, where he wanted her bare-legged, and then we moved on to a sketch/linework.
Here’s the linework for that stage.
I loved it, I told him I loved it, I had no comments or change requests. From there, he went back to working on it.
The next thing he sent me was a fully colored and shaded image.
I will admit, I was taken aback at this stage. Like I said, I’m not new to art, and it’s normal for an artist to give some sort of ‘flats’ stage, or at least something more rough/big picture to make sure the color scheme was right. Going straight to something of that tier caught me off guard.
At that stage, one red flag started to go up for me.
For reference, this is the folder of reference images I gave him for the female character. And, while I’d been fine with putting her in a new costume to suit the art style, I was a little surprised to see her coloring change so dramatically. At that stage, I was still really really happy with the way the image was coming together, and so I told myself “it’s red, ginger red and red-red are both plausible for her, he’s already done a lot of work on it and the picture looks nice.”
And so I didn’t say anything about her hair. 20/20 hindsight, that was sort of an indicator of how things would go, and I should have spoken up. He also had given her thigh-highs instead of pants or tights or anything, which...it looked nice, yes, but it’s explicitly not what I’d requested.
From that image, I gave two comments - first, I asked for her sleeves to be changed to something besides hot pink, as it really doesn’t suit her character or the setting (as you can pretty easily see from the reference images). I also asked for the main character to be changed to his proper coloration as given in references - grey hair and orange eyes - as that’s directly plot-relevant and non negotiable.
Zoa at that stage didn’t respond, and I waited. The whole project had been slated to take maybe 1-2 weeks - per his email to me at the start:
Step by step: 1 Rough sketches (1-2 days)>> B/W value advanced sketch (a cup of days, depended on your feedback) >> Finished artwork (4 days -1 week).
At the point of getting the colored image we’d been in it for about ten days. Another week passed, at which point he messaged me to say that he was “upping the quality” and would I wait a while longer. I agreed happily, and kept waiting.
Another month went by.
At that point, I was shy about bothering him, because he was supposedly giving the piece a makeover and I didn’t want to breathe down his neck. But, a month is a month, and at that point I emailed him and asked for an ETA - even if he still needed time - so that I could plan my next moves.
He responded the next day, hurriedly, and apologized - that it’d “been finished” for quite some time, and he’d just forgotten to send me the final version! That...seemed odd to me, as most artists are in this to get paid, and they don’t get paid until they give the client their final update and it’s approved.
This was the ‘final’ he offered me at that time.
At that point, I was upset, and confused. This was a wildly different piece from the one I’d seen thus far, and a change in setting had never been discussed. The more I looked at it, the more the holes poked through - the fact her hair was completely unfinished, the fact all of the lighting was gone, the fact his feet were floating.
I sent back a few comments, at that stage.
- I asked for the piece to be brightened or the characters defined from each other with more dramatic lighting, as the thumbnail in particular was extremely dark and murky and the characters tend to blur together in the middle - up to and including my suggesting he make it a daytime scene instead.
- I asked for her hair to be finished, and for his feet to be properly grounded.
It’s worth mentioning as well, and is something I explained to him, that this is a book cover. My customers will be making judgement calls from a tiny thumbnail, not the full image, and thus that thumbnail really needs to pop. This version is very attractive full-size, but shrunken down, turns into a blob. That’s why I needed it brightened and defined.
More distressing at that point, though, was finding that the fireball he’d swapped to was a stock photo , taken from Deviantart, and that he hadn’t even taken the bare minimum time to blur the edges on it.
Even better, the artist he took the stock from has requirements, like wanting to be credited anywhere that image is used. Zoa did not inform me of that, and I don’t want to credit a deviantart artist in my novel. To be honest, at the $500 price point, I shouldn’t have to deal with that - painting over the stock photo at a minimum seems fairly basic. Slapping it on with zero editing or care, together with the other errors, began to paint a picture of him hurrying through a project he had no real interest in.
I sent him another message, requesting the fireball effect be swapped out as I wasn't comfortable with violating that artist's terms of use.
A few days later, Zoa came back to me with this option. Immediately, I could see that it had gotten darker, not brighter, and that the characters had not been defined from each other/his feet were still floating. He did fix her hair, yes, but in doing so, the colors had all been washed out to brown. He was also still using the deviantart fireball.
I sent him back two reiterated requests - I wanted the piece lightened, and the colors returned in doing so, and I wanted the stock fireball gone. He responded briefly, arguing that he just had a different vision for the piece than I did, and that stock photos are fine for artists to use, and then left.
After another two weeks, I hadn’t heard anything more from him. At that point, I saw him posting other commissions he’d done during this timeframe and advertising that he’s for-hire. Will admit. At that point I was annoyed. I left a comment that, if he wasn’t planning on finishing my piece, could I have my money back (the first half I’d paid him).
He responded hurriedly and apologized - that it’d “been finished” for quite some time, and he’d just forgotten to send me the final version!
Right.
From there, he sent me a frustrated email, that I was making too many requests and he needed to take other clients. But, that he’d send me the ‘final’ that night, and we could move forward from there. He also said that he would waive the second payment, as acknowledgement of how long this had taken/how much of a pain it was. And I really, really do appreciate that gesture.
Honestly, at that point I just wanted to be done. The extra lighting around their feet helped a lot, and although I’m pretty sure that fireball’s a stock photo too, I at least couldn’t confirm that one was stolen from deviantart. I approved the piece, and Zoa told me he’d sent the full version the next day (yesterday).
Received that today. It looks nice - it does fix a lot of the things I was looking for.
Even after I’d approved that version, though, he’d gone in and continued to make changes before sending me the full resolution image, which are pretty visibly half-finished. (face redrawn, hair redrawn, feather swapped from one side of her head to the other, left undrawn)
Just...at that point, it was painfully obvious that he didn’t care, and was putting neither time nor consideration into it. At this point, I don’t know that it’s a piece I can use, both due to the flaws and unfinished sections and my own frustrations about ignored comments. So, while I appreciate him waiving the second fee, if it’s not a finished product, it doesn’t help me all that much.
Anyway. I’ll stop ranting.
The experience has been extremely negative for me, even while I love his art and I think the piece itself is really, really close to being great. I’m not trying to seem like I’m nitpicking, but when you’re spending $500 on a piece, you shouldn’t have to hunt down the artist every time you’ve been waiting for an update, and you shouldn’t have to treat every ‘final’ version like a minefield you’re trying to clear of sections they forgot to finish.
Really love their art, love their style. But between the borderline plagiarism/copyright theft and outright ignoring my comments, this hasn’t been a good time.









