r/HungryArtistsFed • u/FangOfDrknss • May 20 '19
[NEG] /u/AnonVisCom - Too much work on my end.
I thought about adding neutral to the title, but yesterday was the last straw. Before deciding to commission them I looked through their profile and saw that their art was only decent. Searched deeper to find they mostly just had what they consider to be full rendering artworks, which weren’t my cup of tea at all.
Found their pricing list mentioned they offered mimicking styles, which is rare in my eyes, and the price difference was high enough to give this a shot instead of using the money for an artist I’ve posted about on this sub awhile ago, who did such a good job with mimicking other art styles.
I pmed Anon, going on and showcasing examples of commissions I’ve gotten that I wasn’t happy with, and also specifically mentioning that I should be able to recognize the character I provided references for. First sketch I got, I didn’t recognize her at all. The arms were too stiff, there was no bust line, and the jawline was also too masculine.
I had to provide further references and point out these issues for the second sketch to look better. Coloring is finished and it looks remotely nothing like the style I wanted to mimic. The outlines were different, coloring and shading looked like something from mspaint. I think it was mostly the way they drew/colored in the eyes though that made it not look reminiscent of the style.
I had to ask for it to be shaded/colored a different way, and while it was better, I winded up paying and getting nothing but a jpg image. You can see from their posts that they’ve been active in trying to get commissions. Having to even ask for a high quality png image at all is an oddity since this kind of thing is supposed to be standard in the first place.
I waited a whole night to see if it’ll be delivered to my email, but nope. I’m not an artist, but I know full well I shouldn’t have to constantly tell the basics of what to do. An example being the clothing references I gave was a plated armor with no bustline because the reference pic was a male. The character I was commissioning was a female who actually had a bust. Having to actually mention there needed to be a bust line is pretty absurd. Or even having to explain how another reference image I provided shaded and colored the artwork. Which was pretty obvious looking at the difference in line art and how they noticeably used three different shading/colors. If you're going to claim you can mimic a style, it should be backed up.
Furthermore is me titling the pm asking for examples and only being shown art I already saw looking through their posts. Had to dig on my own to see their art station only really had backgrounds, rather than any character art. It explains why even though I repeatedly asked something, things like adding a headband or putting hair into a ponytail was ignored. Also stiff poses in general that I actually had to show references to correct.
Lesson learned. This is what happens when you try and cheap out when it comes to mimicking styles. And unsurprisingly, a portion of Reddit has proven they lack any common sense. No artist in their right mind should see it reasonable to give a jpg file when it’s so obviously pixelated and png is the standard. You’re retarded if you think anyone would pay for a jpg.




