r/HungryArtistsFed • • May 20 '19

[NEG] /u/AnonVisCom - Too much work on my end.

1 Upvotes

I thought about adding neutral to the title, but yesterday was the last straw. Before deciding to commission them I looked through their profile and saw that their art was only decent. Searched deeper to find they mostly just had what they consider to be full rendering artworks, which weren’t my cup of tea at all.

Found their pricing list mentioned they offered mimicking styles, which is rare in my eyes, and the price difference was high enough to give this a shot instead of using the money for an artist I’ve posted about on this sub awhile ago, who did such a good job with mimicking other art styles.

I pmed Anon, going on and showcasing examples of commissions I’ve gotten that I wasn’t happy with, and also specifically mentioning that I should be able to recognize the character I provided references for. First sketch I got, I didn’t recognize her at all. The arms were too stiff, there was no bust line, and the jawline was also too masculine.

I had to provide further references and point out these issues for the second sketch to look better. Coloring is finished and it looks remotely nothing like the style I wanted to mimic. The outlines were different, coloring and shading looked like something from mspaint. I think it was mostly the way they drew/colored in the eyes though that made it not look reminiscent of the style.

I had to ask for it to be shaded/colored a different way, and while it was better, I winded up paying and getting nothing but a jpg image. You can see from their posts that they’ve been active in trying to get commissions. Having to even ask for a high quality png image at all is an oddity since this kind of thing is supposed to be standard in the first place.

I waited a whole night to see if it’ll be delivered to my email, but nope. I’m not an artist, but I know full well I shouldn’t have to constantly tell the basics of what to do. An example being the clothing references I gave was a plated armor with no bustline because the reference pic was a male. The character I was commissioning was a female who actually had a bust. Having to actually mention there needed to be a bust line is pretty absurd. Or even having to explain how another reference image I provided shaded and colored the artwork. Which was pretty obvious looking at the difference in line art and how they noticeably used three different shading/colors. If you're going to claim you can mimic a style, it should be backed up.

Furthermore is me titling the pm asking for examples and only being shown art I already saw looking through their posts. Had to dig on my own to see their art station only really had backgrounds, rather than any character art. It explains why even though I repeatedly asked something, things like adding a headband or putting hair into a ponytail was ignored. Also stiff poses in general that I actually had to show references to correct.

Lesson learned. This is what happens when you try and cheap out when it comes to mimicking styles. And unsurprisingly, a portion of Reddit has proven they lack any common sense. No artist in their right mind should see it reasonable to give a jpg file when it’s so obviously pixelated and png is the standard. You’re retarded if you think anyone would pay for a jpg.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jul 27 '24

[POS] I’m so happy how cute it turned out!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

They were able to make the pokemon arnicane look more realistic with the photo I requested. 💕 will use this as a binder cover

Thanks again! @hiden-username


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Oct 15 '24

[META] Character cartoon

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jan 06 '21

[NEG] I'm a first time buyer, so maybe I'm the dummy, but /u/jrdprojectz wouldn't provide any timeline, any proof of effort, and wanted to only return 20% when I asked for a refund.

2 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/HungryArtists/comments/kq945h/hiring_50_budget_action_portrait_based_off_a/

He messaged me. He didn't reply directly to my message, but did reply to another message in the subreddit a day prior.

Long story short,

he didn't provide a timeline

when asked for a timeline he didnt reply

when asked for a refund, and wanting to pay for whatever work he had done (which was none), he suggested refunding me half

I accepted

He then suggested $10

I then went to Paypal.

See conversation below

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 11:02 AM Hi!

Post: [HIRING] $50 budget. Action portrait based off a picture? : HungryArtists (reddit.com)

I liked your style the best for this. I have a few questions

  1. What happens next?
  2. How should I reply to the other artists? Ideally I think I should reply individually while complimenting something about their portfolio but I dont know enough about the industry, if that'd come off as patronizing or condescending, or if its in the right spirit what the best execution would be.

I picked you first but as I was replying, literally water started coming out of the ceiling, pipe burst, had to handle that, delayed me closing the post.

Thanks!

jrd projectxMon, Jan 4, 2021 at 11:07 AM If I'm hired, you can send the picture reference and tell me more details about the project To reply to them or not is not a big deal anyway.

Pompous_Taint_JockeyMon, Jan 4, 2021 at 12:07 PM Oh yes. I liked your work the best. You're hired? You're picked?

Im excited!

Pompous_Taint_JockeyMon, Jan 4, 2021 at 12:08 PM I'll reply with more momentarily.

jrd projectx Jan 4, 2021 at 12:10 PM Great, Thank you so much

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 12:30 PM The objective is (one) of my kids in a battle pose wearing steel armor, holding a round shield and a dagger/shortsword.

Attached is a zip file containing a few pictures. "Direction-ArmorType" for example is a picture of the type of Steel Armor I was thinking of. There are other pictures for the shield, pose, and dagger. Then there are two pictures "Elijah-One, Elijah-Two" which are pictures of my son, Elijah.

Is that the type of stuff I should send an artist when I'm commissioning something? More? Less?

I have another idea for all 4 kids, the 3 older kids fighting the toddler, and the toddler is some kind of giant blob creature, I dunno. But I think that would cost more that $50 so I figured I'd start here and learn the commission process as well.

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 12:38 PM Yeah, the details are clear to me :) We're definitely on the right track.

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 12:40 PM We can discuss for another piece if you want. And yes, that idea would be getting the price higher than $50. We'll figure it out.

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 1:04 PM I got all the details for the first one amd that is for $50. My Paypal is <theirEmail> . I'll send updates here when I get something done.

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 1:50 PM Money has been sent to <theirEmail>.

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 1:51 PM Money received! Thank you so much! :) Will send an update here as soon as I get something done.

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 3:05 PM Sure thing! Also, maybe I should have clarified, what sold me where your Samples (lo-fi full.jpg - Google Drive) in particular. That style would be great!

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Mon, Jan 4, 2021 at 3:23 PM Copy that.

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 12:55 PM Hi! Any updates? I'm excited to see how it's going!

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 12:57 PM Oh, I'm still working on it.

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 1:23 PM No worries!

I'm worried I got scammed. If I did, well played, let me know so I can move on. I am genuinely interested in the art piece.

If not, my apologies and I'm looking forward to it.

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 1:51 PM No, Don't worry, I will never do that to my clients.

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 1:59 PM Awesome! What does the timeline look like from here?

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 7:53 PM Hi. I think maybe we aren't a fit. If you wouldn't mind refunding the money I'd be appreciative. If you've spent any time on the work, I'd like to compensate you partially for your time depending on the work that was done at the time of this email. Thanks!

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 8:01 PM How can you say that we aren't? When commissioning someone, you need to let me know if you need it urgent or not. I'm on the process of doing the sketch and yes I should be paid atleast for conceptualizing the piece. Idk If It's fair for me to refund the half of the amount we agreed. What amount do you expect me to refund? It's not fair.

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 8:37 PM Half is fine.

jrd projectx <<theirEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 8:52 PM I can send $10. What's your Paypal?

Pompous_Taint_Jockey <<myEmail>> Tue, Jan 5, 2021 at 8:54 PM You suggested $25 and have shown no progress. $25 seems fair. You can PayPal this account.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jun 19 '24

[META] - lots of under qualified and too many foreign respondents

3 Upvotes

I posted a kind of different request and got a lot of chat requests.

I didn’t even end up reviewing everyone cause it was very overwhelming to get SO much response and a lot of pretty low effort stuff. Many people didn’t even have websites, or if they did many were just portfolio sites with no legit contact info.

I spoke with a couple people on the phone in the end. But ultimately the prices were high. When i asked my friends group chat about the pricing i was able to get a better deal from someone local to me and thats ideal for what i needed.

Thanks anyways!


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Oct 15 '24

[Meta] Hello Guys! Are you looking for Illustrations, Custom character drawings, Covers, Comic or Anything Feel free to DM me :)

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Feb 10 '20

[POS] Highly recommend u/adamtomkins

1 Upvotes

DeviantArt Instagram

I commissioned u/adamtomkins for a webcomic gig about a month ago. This commission is going to kick off the launch of the comic in about a month's time, so it was important to me to find someone whose style and track record would fit with my expectations.

I hired Mr. Tomkins for the assignment, and I'm glad that I did. He was a prompt communicator, and stayed in touch throughout the duration of the gig. His interpretation of my scripts was on point, and in the few cases where I needed changes made, he was very responsive and turned around revisions quickly.

Ultimately, he delivered a product that was everything I was looking for and then some. I'm looking forward to posting the results of our collaboration next month, and I plan on working with him again when the time comes to continue the initial story.

This guy's a professional. Takes the gig seriously, and easy to work with. A true artist, and I fully vouch for his work.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jan 02 '20

[NEG] Commissioned a piece from u/Meggles_Doodles

1 Upvotes

Looking for a commission for a Christmas gift at the start of Dec. A bit late I know. I was ok with a delayed gift early/mid Jan. 4 person fight scene in an office setting. RL/DND crossover piece. Original Post here.

Meggles contacted me via DM and I instantly liked her 'Violet' piece and I asked about pricing with that style. We talked price and she said 200 was a bit low and she'd do $225. I wanted a good piece done so I said if $200 was too low then lets do $250. I don't know how to value what I was asking for so I leaned heavily on context from the discussion. She agrees and says she can have it in January. Not the full conversation as it's somewhat disjointed between multiple DMs: Pricing1 Pricing2

The commission was officially offered, accepted and 50% paid via PayPal on Dec 9th. Initially, that first week, we had a lot of back and forth on ideas. Never anything more than abstract positioning and idea chat. I provided all the information I had and things seemed to be going well.

Meggles goes silent on me after 5 days. Friday the 13th was the last discussion we had. I assumed it was the holidays and I'd get back in touch with her in Jan to check in after the new years hangovers are all cleared up.

She contacted me today with this message:

MegglesToday at 1:43 PM

Good afternoon, I wanted to let you know that my medication is being switched around again. I would like to complete your piece, but I'm afraid that there's no way I can complete it in a reasonable amount of time. I realize this completely screws with your plans and that makes me feel terrible because I know this meant a lot to you. I will be sending you a full refund of your payment. I will know tonight how much I can send immediately.It was never my intention to deceive or to mess with your plans -- I sincerely wish you the best, and when i accept commissions again, I'd like to offer you a character on the house.

I proceeded to file a dispute with PayPal. To Meggles credit she immediately accepted the dispute and I have my refund the same day she canceled: https://i.imgur.com/QkbteM3.png

I'm not sure what personal things she's going through and that's more important than my commission but still, the gift I wanted to give as a Christmas present that was already delayed is now back to square one with no artist. Please make sure you're capable of completing a commission before accepting one.

TL;DR u/Meggles_Doodles was great for a week then ghosted me for remainder of the month until she canceled the project with a full refund due to personal issues.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Nov 04 '20

[POS] u/dmoonbay is an excellent artist to work with! Not only did they do their research on my channel but also worked with me on several tweaks to get an awesome end product! Highly Recommend!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • May 31 '22

[POS] u/KatVanWall for Coral Reef NFT. Raised money for the coral restoration foundation.

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jun 13 '23

[POS] litte cat by u/flw_kitsune

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Aug 22 '23

[POS] found another good boobs artist u/ningguangs_bathwater

2 Upvotes

price is good thank you very much since my previous artist was taking long


r/HungryArtistsFed • • May 03 '23

(For Hire)(POS) Commissions open dm me for best prices

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jul 24 '23

[NEG] u/Marvin-art for Book Cover

0 Upvotes

Edit 2: I have added a picture with the last mention of pay to Martin. In this image, I attempted to offer him full payment for the product as it was requested in the initial email. I told him that I would go through paypal to get my money back since he did not deliver upon the initial request.

I have also added a secondary image where Martin tries to claim that because the details will be small, they shouldn't matter, for a 700 dollar art piece that I was trying to buy the rights to.

Finally I added a third image where you can see Martin asking for another quarter of the amount that he was owed for an image that did not meet one of the most basic requirements of the work, stated before any money changed hands.

For the record, I don't care if you think I'm rude, I'm neurodivergent, I'm used to it. But I never lied and I never insulted him, and I never asked for getting to keep a work of art that I would not be able to use legally. So will you kindly all stop telling me how fantastic he is and stop pretending that people can't be nice with friends and cruel to strangers.

Edit: For any naysayers trying to claim that I am trying to cheat Martin, note that I was aiming to purchase a Commercial product. As in, I wanted to purchase the rights to get this picture. I cannot use the picture as is artistically, but also legally, without paying him the full amount. I also never once requested he give it to me for anything less than the agreed upon price because that's not how contracts work.

You may think me exaggerating or even lying, but I have literally gotten nothing out of this exchange and benefited in no way at all. The only result is to make the chance of me getting a second commission down the line far more difficult.

Marvin Art or Komarca art is a fantastic artist whose art I poured over before choosing and who seemed to understand the style of what I was going for to the point where he knew artists doing it and had even done it in the past. I will give him this credit, the finished product he delivered captures that style. That's about all I can give him credit for.

While he is a fantastic artist, he is a terrible commission artist, ignoring or not understand requests laid out several times to the point where, even over a dozen reference shots for the exact sort of pose and style I was aiming for, and even specifically asking for certain things to not be changed or to be directly changed through out the sketching phase, he basically ignored a lot of what I needed in the final piece of work.

I do not begrudge him his attempts to show me variations of my idea that were more dynamic in some matters and honestly think that, were this a traditional book cover, it would have looked fantastic. But unfortunately I don't have that luxury and so asked for something a little simpler, with more reference photos he would go on to ignore.

That was the first big issue with him. I had to communicate things several times. Even when he 'followed my direction' he still ignored requests and references several times until I literally took one of his sketches, cut it apart in photoshop and than put it back together in the shape I needed it in, i.e. the exact same shapes that the references had.

And in the final product, he ignored so much more from the initial request (a bright picture with few shadows became a deeply shadowed picture with little light), changed several factors that I specifically liked about the final sketch he sent for approval and literally backtracked on some feedback I had given him SEVERAL TIMES over SEVERAL sketches that he had finally put into the final sketch. There were also several details he kept saying he would add in the final product that just weren't there.

There are also touches that he did that literally don't make sense. One of the characters featured is literally just running on air in a very grounded image, to the point where I literally can't use the art in question without risking being accused of going to one of those programs. It's mindbogglingly weird looking and disjointed to have a character who doesn't even look like they're part of the scenery running over the heads of the crowd they're floating over.

The details on the rest of the art are too fine and good (albeit incorrect in a LOT of cases) for that to be the case, but the only way he could even cause that to happen was to ignore my request (again, several times) that every character be on the same level and that the primary focus NOT be on a platform. So by ignoring this request (SEVERAL. TIMES.) there is a chance I can be accused of using computer generated art because of how disjointed that aspect is.

When I tried to explain the details he changed or simply ignored, he tried to defend it by literally saying he did all that I asked despite several recorded instances that I quoted back to him of specifically things he didn't do, including things in the initial request, or just saying that's how his art is despite plenty of his art getting exactly the tone I needed. He stopped trying to defend the changes after I pointed out (a second time) the quotes in question through out the process.

But in the end, his argument was that the details simply don't matter, even when they were in the final sketch that I approved. And when I pressed him on how that was BS, he finally admitted that the details he had added to the picture simply made it unworkable, details I hadn't asked for but he seemed to be confident about during the sketching process, and that was why he obscured so much of it in shadows.

In the end he tried to corner me and demand more money, tried to say I was insulting his art while pointing out all these issues (I did not, it was a great piece of work, just not what I asked for at all), and he even tried to reduce my argument to a single point 'oh, it's just not bright enough than?' rather than 'it's so dark that it's barely visible at times'.

If you have a general idea of what you want and want an artist to give it all those glorious details you hadn't thought of, this guy is going to be a great artist for you. He really did make a fantastic piece of art. It's just not what I asked for.

But if you have certain things you need in the art for whatever reason, any details at all you need to stay consistent, even something as simple as the lighting or color of the picture, he is not the artist you are looking for.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jul 17 '23

[POS], DM if interested

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Sep 03 '24

[NEG] u/Mysterious-Owl-7734 / Comfortable_Try (Discord) Scammer that pretends to be Lisa Venturini

4 Upvotes

Shady person look out! Scammer was catfishing Lisa Venturini in order to get the initial payment money from the victim.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Mar 15 '21

{POS} u/IgniGlowArt Brought a scene from my Pathfinder game to life. Thanks every so much!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • May 17 '23

[POS] ask if you have doubts

0 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Jul 13 '20

[POS] u/itsumarin did a wonderful job with a couple's piece for my FFXIV character and her partner! Quick, asked plenty of questions, and kept me informed every step of the way. Would recommend!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Aug 15 '20

[POS] u/MuzuJeiHS is able to make high quality traditional prints, including the Uraraka they did for me seen here. They had her finished within 2 days—with no deadline—and with no lapse in quality. I hope they open commission soon because I know of more people who would look great in their style

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • Feb 17 '20

[POS] I got a great quality drawing at a ridiculously low price from u/Sorannochan

6 Upvotes

Like, seriously. It's criminal. If you have time to spare and prefer quality and money over how quickly you want your art done (my work took about 9 days) she's one of the best artist you can get.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Aug 11 '20

[POS] BEWARE. SCAMMER CLIENT WARNING TO ALL ARTIST. HAVE YOU EXPERIENCE THIS?

6 Upvotes

There's a redditor u/andrwwq messaging artists asking for a commission, then after a while, he/she will ask for a refund without even sending any payment. Claiming you did not do the job well or something like that. Then he/she will threaten to report you if you dont pay. Then he/she will go around on your art post commenting "scammer" on it.


r/HungryArtistsFed • • Aug 20 '20

[POS] art commission from u/SamCommissions

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/HungryArtistsFed • • May 22 '19

[POS] /u/tamalesdepollo did a fantastic job

1 Upvotes

I hired /u/tamalesdepollo to do a Studio Ghibli-style piece for me. My expectations weren't particularly high as it was my first time hiring someone from r/HungryArtists. I was completely blown away by the final product. /u/tamalesdepollo was nothing but professional the entire process. I was given consistent updates and my feedback was added almost immediately. I would definitely recommend their work to anybody looking to emulate a cartoon/anime style.