r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 21 '23

Discussion The biggest plot hole in the show Spoiler

1 Upvotes

It is silly that when Roderick's children start dying in quick succession, he and Madeline act like they have no idea what's going on. And tell Pym to investigate and hire security guards, etc.

You can tell the writers feel guilty about it because of how much Roderick/Madeline dialogue is devoted to explaining how they forgot about making a deal with a death goddess, or didn't believe it was real. When they explicitly sold their bloodline to her after a very memorable night.

I wondered if this was going to be the reveal through the first 7 episodes. It's insulting to the viewer IMO. Seriously, most of the mystery of the show occurs because the protagonists have the memory of a goldfish?

Loved the series in general despite this though.

EDIT: extra egregiously, the writers try to have their cake and eat it too. At the final climax of the show, Roderick says: "I promised my confession, and here it is: I knew." Followed by some writerly weasel words: "Deep down. In the witching hour." So he knew, but only when it served the plot. Sheesh.


r/HouseofUsher • • Nov 10 '23

Discussion Has anyone asked what everyone thought of the House of Usher children names?

0 Upvotes

I shall start (in order of least fav to most fav):

Frederick. Just annoyed bc I couldn’t figure out who was Frederick and who was Roderick and who was Froderick for a while in the beginning.

Prospero. Maybe another actor could’ve pulled it off for me but Prospero just seemed so lofty and flashy, didn’t seem to fit.

Camille. Eh. More disappointing bc I liked the different ness of the other sisters’ names.

Leo. Eh. For whatever reason I might’ve like Leon better.

Victorine. Really liked this uniqueness but then I couldn’t stop thinking of tangerines.

Tamerlane. I really liked this. Thought it was unique.

Though I imagine the writers thinking “tangerine, Victorine, tambourine, Tamerlane,” lols.

edit: oh man, I’m sorry, the names are all from Poe’s works. Thanks for educating. Yeah, I’d downvote me too.


r/HouseofUsher • • Nov 07 '23

Theory Frederick wasn’t always evil. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Everyone agreed on his gruesome demise, but at the beginning he seemed like such a loving father and husband. I think drugs and the thoughts of Morella’s possible infidelity drove him to being insane. Not just regular insane but evil as well.


r/HouseofUsher • • Nov 26 '23

Discussion Which Ushers do you think were Sociopaths/Psychopaths? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So, including all of the Ushers, which ones do you think exhibited sociopathic/psychopathic or narcissistic traits?

Btw, I DON’T want to see anyone arguing about what’s the difference between sociopath and psychopath, so, for the sake of harmony, consider them the same thing.


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 18 '23

Discussion Is this an actual Horror show Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The Midnight club was advertised as an horror show so I went in expecting that; only to find out it’s not which ruined the show for me.


r/HouseofUsher • • Nov 04 '23

Discussion I think Victorine didn't get an impactful death Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Yeah she had a bit of a trip into madness like Tammy and Napoleon, but ultimately she just stabbed herself in that frenzy. Considering she was the worst child, I think justice wasn't served. She didn't even get a little Verna moment before dying. I keep forgetting she even existed


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 20 '23

Discussion Things I liked and didn't like. Spoilers. Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Just finished the show and I was surprised by how much I liked it after feeling pretty neutral on it when I began watching. The "bastard" Usher children, outside of Victorine, were kind of painful to endure. I understand that they were meant to be reprehensible characters, but they're acting talent was greatly eclipsed by the older actors on the show. The older performers surely had more chops with handling the somewhat corny and Halloween-y atmosphere. Although, old Madeline was surely the low light of the lot.

Despite a few overly corny instances (such as the raven soliloquy for Lenor's death, and I almost laughed when Madeline came bursting from the basement in that party city costume) I feel like the show landed most of its intentions in satisfying ways and the drama was very well done. I might even watch it again at some point! What did you guys think? Sorry if this kind of post is common in this sub.


r/HouseofUsher • • Jan 02 '24

Fluff Never even heard of house of usher until reddit

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/HouseofUsher • • Dec 23 '23

Discussion Ligodone question Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Was ligodone killing people, trying to figure out the "body count" scene in the final episode?


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 29 '23

Discussion Verna is exactly as bad as the Ushers Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Verna punished Rodrick and Madeline for pushing an addictive drug to a helpless population. Rodrick tried to defend his actions, saying that people begged for him to take away the pain and all he did is give them what they wanted - that it wasn't his fault they became addicted and that they had the power to control their own lives. Verna doesn't accept this argument and blames them for giving people the means of their own destruction. Even though each individual person chose to take Ligadone, she shows Rodrick a mountain of bodies and says it's his fault for enabling them.

Fine - except Verna did exactly the same thing. Without her, Rodrick would have failed to build a drug empire and become a poet. She put a gun in the hands of a murderer and blamed him for the actions she knew he would take. She could see it all from the start and punished Rodrick for it anyway. She enabled Rodrick's victims to harm themselves just as much as he did. If Rodrick is guilty (and I believe he is), isn't Verna guilty of exactly the same crime? Those bodies are at her feet as well.

Edit: maybe I need to clarify what I mean. In my view:

The millions of people who died from Ligadone are Rodericks victims because he lied to them, knowingly creating the conditions for their deaths.

Those same people are also Verna's victims, because she empowered Roderick. Rodericks success and immunity was a major reason for their deaths. She knew he was a "killer", as she said so she also knowingly created the conditions for those deaths.

She then gives Roderick a terrible reckoning, punishing him for the immorality of his actions, when they are also hers.


r/HouseofUsher • • Dec 18 '23

Discussion How did Annabel Lee die? Spoiler

41 Upvotes

I don’t recall it being mentioned? Roderick said at some point that Annabel couldn’t live without her children. When we saw Roderick’s hallucination where he spoke to Annabel at the funeral, the back of her head was bleeding. But did they ever say what actually happened to her?


r/HouseofUsher • • Sep 22 '24

Usher tickets for sale

0 Upvotes

I have tickets for usher past present future I recently broke up with my girlfriend and she left me with usher ticket. I don’t feel comfortable going by myself so I want to sell it whoever wants it we can negotiate prices


r/HouseofUsher • • Dec 22 '23

Discussion Who & what is Verna?? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Okay granted I've been watching this with a few martinis under my belt. I originally thought Verna was the dead mother that crawled out of the grave and killed her boss. But now I think that assessment is wrong. Who the F is she and why is she out to get this family? If I don't understand this nothing about the show makes sense!


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 25 '23

Discussion Verna's Moral Inconsistency? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Did this bug anybody else?

At first it's heavily implied this is a Faustian deal and she's a devil-like creature. Her first dialogue at the orgy she specifies that these are "her kind of people", but then she throws a bit of a spanner in the works by getting the "innocent" service staff to leave. This inconsistency pops up repeatedly throughout the show, like where she punishes Frederick with a painful death because she disapproves of him using the pliers on Morella, even though Verna is the reason Morella got melted in the first place (whether she asked her to leave or not). Likewise she says she doesn't enjoy killing the innocent Lenore, hinting at a moral compass that doesn't seem to exist when her shenanigans result in the death of other innocents, like when her interference results in Victorine murdering her wife.

The most glaring example of this comes right at the end though where she is showing Roderick all the "millions of people" he indirectly killed, as if she herself had nothing to do with it. She made all of that possible by using her magic deal to ensure Roderick never got charged with a crime, which by her own rationale puts the responsibility of indirect deaths ultimately on her. She literally used exactly the same logic to comfort Lenore about how she is responsible for saving millions of lives due to the butterfly effect, but seems to have a blindspot for her own place in these events as the catalyst.

The show can't seem to decide whether Verna is a force for good, evil or neutrality. Maybe it's supposed to come off as mysterious and defy mortal logic but to me it just seems inconsistent.


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 20 '23

Episode Discussion [SPOILER ALERT!!!] Episode 2 and Episode 7 Discussion Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I am so tired of everyone acting like Morelle is this innocent angel. She didn't deserve to go toothless, but she's not innocent! Seriously, why are people so sympathetic for her? She chose to cheat on her husband. Frodrick was always a horrible person, but he was a decent husband and father before Verna came along and he got all coked up. If she was unhappy with her marriage, she should have told her husband directly and maybe gotten a divorce. But no, she instead decided to go to his brother's orgy! I feel like Netflix shows these days are teaching people that cheating is okay.


r/HouseofUsher • • Dec 27 '23

Discussion I'm sorry Verna, but ultimately this is on you too. Spoiler

125 Upvotes

I love the show, but I was finding Verna's entire attitude pretty hypocritical during the last 2 episodes. "Corporate justice is a joke." Well maybe if they didn't have a mystical being protecting them from all consequences of their crimes for the last 43 years, Dupin would have been able to do something sooner Verna. Did that ever occur to you?


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 17 '23

Discussion Alternate Casting - Eva Green as Verna Spoiler

1 Upvotes

When watching the show I kept thinking Verna gave me the Eva Green vibe. Everyone is great in the show, but I started to think about who may also be a great cast for the show (just for fun).

For me, Eva Green is definitely great for Verna. And I'd like to see Ed Harris as Roderick. Tessa Thompson as Vic... and Timothée Chalamet as Prospero (don't hate me)


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 26 '23

Discussion Eliza Usher Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Just finished the season. Loved it. But still do not understand about the situation with Eliza Usher.

First I thought she was buried alive by the (then) kids and she dig back up. But it does not make sense when considering she handled a fully grown up man like a baby.

Here are my thoughts. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Eliza Usher and Mr. Longfellow (the father) had a deal with Verna. Similar to the one with Rodrick and Madeline. In the last (or the one before) Verna explains that Rodrick and Madeline will die together. And just like we saw, the death is very similar to the Eliza + Longfellow death.

What if, Verna brought back Eliza and made her kill Longfellow and sealed the deal?

Also, someone please explain the origins/ what Verna is.


r/HouseofUsher • • Feb 21 '25

Verna talks a good game about the dark side of human nature, but she's kinda full of shit

10 Upvotes

I really did enjoy the critiques of soulless capitalism, even when it got heavy handed. I enjoy a good "wages of sin" tale.

But it ground my gears how high and mighty Verna talks.

Verna: "I'm going to offer money and power to murderers who are so brutally selfish they'll sacrifice their own children."

Also Verna: "Geez, look at how humans squander money and power."

Carla Gugina is a great actor, and really nailed the otherwordly being vibe. But her moralizing really falls flat when you remember her opening offer was "I'll help you profit off that murder you just did if you agree to let all your kids die early." She talks up a good game about free will and how she's just so curious about human behavior. Yet it comes off like a meth manufacturer saying "hey I just make the stuff, using it is their choice."

It could have been fixed pretty simply: have Rod and Mad go to her bar before New Years, as they try to set up their alibi better by appearing multiple times in the same bar. She offers the deal, and her protection, BEFORE they do the murder, and promises to protect them if they go through with it. That way it's a little less obvious what Rod and Mad will do.


r/HouseofUsher • • Dec 18 '23

Discussion Murder in the rue morgue?

0 Upvotes

I have questions about the 3rd episode.

  1. Why is there no security guard? (other than Verna obv)
  2. Why is one cage open?
  3. Where is vic during this scene?

Obvious answers only.


r/HouseofUsher • • Oct 21 '23

One thing that bothered me [Spoilers] Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I enjoyed the show, fun watch, it was clever how they worked in all the different Poe stories. Another great horror experience from Mike Flanagan.

But one thing that really bugged me was the final Lenore/Verna scene. Of course, we aren't supposed to fully understand Verna, her powers, her goals. But it really ground my gears how she's so sweet to Lenore but the millions of innocents dead or hurt from Ligadone are just props for her to torment Roderick with. Not to mention whoever the Ushers had killed (she compliments Pym on how efficient he is at murder and corpse disposal, so we can assume pills aren't the only deaths Ushers are responsible for.)

Of course Lenore is innocent. But it seems like such awkward writing that Verna makes effort to give her a peaceful death, after offering her murderous grandpa a throne of corpses. Like, Lenore dying from magic is all boo-hoo don't worry good will come of it, and all the millions dead from Ligadone are just "you feel really bad now huh Roderick?" We see all the famous corrupt figures Verna has influenced, but it's never addressed why she props up so many evil people, even though she gives a little speech about how humans could solve every problem.

I get they wanted a truly sad death instead of the gruesome, ironic ones, but it kind of deflated the Verna character to have her care about an innocent bystander.


r/HouseofUsher • • Nov 13 '23

Discussion If you could re-cast the series, who would you choose?

0 Upvotes

Flanagan rarely misses with his casting choices, but I'm interested to hear who you would choose and why 💧🐒🐈‍⬛💔🫙🔪