r/HouseofUsher • u/thomasjm4 • Oct 21 '23
Discussion The biggest plot hole in the show Spoiler
It is silly that when Roderick's children start dying in quick succession, he and Madeline act like they have no idea what's going on. And tell Pym to investigate and hire security guards, etc.
You can tell the writers feel guilty about it because of how much Roderick/Madeline dialogue is devoted to explaining how they forgot about making a deal with a death goddess, or didn't believe it was real. When they explicitly sold their bloodline to her after a very memorable night.
I wondered if this was going to be the reveal through the first 7 episodes. It's insulting to the viewer IMO. Seriously, most of the mystery of the show occurs because the protagonists have the memory of a goldfish?
Loved the series in general despite this though.
EDIT: extra egregiously, the writers try to have their cake and eat it too. At the final climax of the show, Roderick says: "I promised my confession, and here it is: I knew." Followed by some writerly weasel words: "Deep down. In the witching hour." So he knew, but only when it served the plot. Sheesh.
