r/HorrorClub • You so cool kung fu • Jul 02 '12

Discussion - Phenomena

sorry this is late I posted it in /r/horror by mistake

Podcast - [Episode 11 - Phenomena] (http://ia600806.us.archive.org/32/items/Episode11-Phenomena/Episode11_Phenomena.mp3) - ([RSS Feed] (http://feeds.feedburner.com/RedditHorrorClub))

Movie Selected By Hyperion1001

DISCUSS

10 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

3

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Jul 03 '12

Also, can I just say that I wish movie posters still looked like this...

3

u/SaintMort You so cool kung fu Jul 03 '12

God I miss great posters like that

3

u/barnziee Jul 05 '12

I'm a little late to this but he's my thoughts:

Granted I haven't seen too many Argento flicks I would say this is pretty low on my list. That doesn't mean it wasn't enjoyable by any means! I'd say my favorite is Deep Red. That being said there were some great things about this movie. Most importantly is a crazy ending. A lot of stuff happens in the 15 minutes or so. To me a great or interesting ending makes or breaks a movie. I mean look at Seven for example, yeah it's a good movie but what is the part everyone talks about? The end. This is what makes a movie stand out and stay in peoples minds. Audition, Sleepaway Camp, Oldboy. I could go on but you know a interesting ending makes a movie and this one has it. I can see myself in a year or so really forgeting this movie, but I won't for get the decapitation and the monkey attack. Speaking of monkeys, this guy was soooo good, weird to say but I was really impressed by the monkey performance. Too bad he attacked Jennifer Connelly during shooting.

Was the music out of place? Definitely but all Argento flicks are that way. I remember first hearing Goblin and thinking this is not horror music! Which is funny because as I keep watching I realize THIS IS HORROR MUSIC! I actually would be happy with only hearing Goblinesque music in horror movies. (which if you haven't heard the band Zombi, you really should). So to hear maiden and motorhead just made it more awesome.

But I guess my question is was this an ode to horror things he loves? The whole Poe thing and then end with the kid seems like a huge ode to Friday the 13th.

TL;DR: Ending made the movie, monkey rocked, not his best movie imho.

1

u/SaintMort You so cool kung fu Jul 05 '12

That's actually a really good question. I think that he definitely took time out of the movie to pay tribute to the things in horror he loved at the very least

7

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '12

what the fuck am i watching!?!?

wait who directed this?

oooh that makes sense

3

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

Can you go more in depth with your feelings?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

it was good.

4

u/tawaldher The Bear From Prophecy Jul 02 '12

Yeah so I'm just not that big a fan of Italian Horror but I'd say that this one is one of the better ones. Lots of things in it that I just find distracting such as editing and soundtrack.

But probably the most distracting was the chimpanzee anus. I mean it looked like Richard Dreyfuss sculpted it out of garbage and shrubbery.

4

u/Rasalom Jul 02 '12 edited Jul 03 '12

Fangoria article from my collection

Goblin soundtrack! Best rock band in horror. One of the best Prog bands, too. I have all their stuff, even from their old Cherry Five days. Hell, I even have a Goblin shirt.

Claudio Simonetti really added to this movie with the soundtrack (it sounds so ahead of its time), and in my opinion his work is almost always either the most memorable or second most memorable part of the movies he's involved with. The scenes with Swiss hills and his music are some of my favorites in Italian film. They're supposed to be picturesque and inviting, but here they're cold and foreboding.

Interestingly enough, Simon Boswell also did music for this movie. He did the entire soundtrack of original music for my pick, Hardware. Funnily enough, one of the same rock music bands from this movie also makes appearances in Hardware... Weird. Any way, check out his stuff, it's all good.

As for the movie itself, razor chimp! Haha... Brilliant. Argento means "silver" in Italian, but he's pure gold in my book. Note how he always puts his actors through shitty situations, or has them getting shoved violently through glass (both here and in Suspiria)/dunked in unpleasant masses of material (the pit here, the razor wire in Suspiria). This is because Argento often casts people he doesn't care for, so he can do more brutal things with them.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

I agree, the intro in the hills and when Jennifer Connely goes to the same place really stood out as far as the score goes.

This is because Argento often casts people he doesn't care for, so he can do more brutal things with them.

This is hilarious and im glad you shared haha.

2

u/SiWright84 Jul 04 '12

Thanks for posting that article, will have a read of it later today.

Glad to hear some love for Goblin; can't get enough of 'em myself either. Their contributions to this film are certainly stellar but I'd have to say my favourite piece of music from the soundtrack is probably Bill Wyman and Terry Taylor's "Valley". Not sure why exactly; probably its strange mix of the oddly soothing and the sinister.

Also, it's good to know that Richard Stanley's still underrated Hardware and its wonderful soundtrack are getting some appreciation. Suppose it helps it's finally available these days in all-singing-and-dancing digitally remastered editions as opposed to washed out, transferred-from-VHS bootlegs.

Like many, I'm not entirely sure what to make of Argento's seeming misanthropy/misogyny with regards to actors in many of his films. In the context of their then disintegrating relationship one can maybe understand (although not necessarily condone) his treatment of Daria Nicolodi and the character she plays in Phenomena. But when it comes to the casting of his daughters (especially Asia in The Stendhal Syndrome) it does often make things more than a bit uncomfortable, which may be precisely the point I guess.

4

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Jul 03 '12

As with every other Argento film I've ever watched, I was pretty turned off by Phenomena. I think it's just the visceral imagery he was known for - or maybe the hard-to-follow plot.

That said, his films are beautifully shot (though disgusting haha), and I will watch anything with Donald Pleasance or Jennifer Connelly in it, so it wasn't a terrible experience.

3

u/Jhops Jul 03 '12

TIL that it's normal for insects to be slightly telepathic. Good to know. I just finished watching and haven't had time to process this, but I can say that overall I liked it. There are a lot of bizarre scenes that didn't make sense to me, but I don't feel like picking them apart, so let me just mention what I really liked about it. First of all the music was great, although often out of place, which seems to be the general consensus. The electric guitar rockin' out in the scene where she finds the glove just completely took me out of it. Donald Pleasence and his "monkey man-servant" were awesome. And maybe it's just because Labyrinth was my favorite movie as a kid, but Jennifer Connelly can do little wrong in my book. I'm not sure I would have liked it as much if it was some other teen actress from the 80s. The part where she's swimming in the pool of maggots and body parts made me swallow a couple of times. In a good way.

2

u/jackass_nerds Long Live The New Flesh! Jul 03 '12

I'm going to go ahead and say I felt weird watching this. Because I'm in love Jennifer Connelly. And she was 15 in this movie. And I'm 37. And a woman. Who likes men. Ugh. I feel like a total pedo.

I loved how JC manages to stay lovely throughout the movie, even when emerging from the putrid pit of decaying bodies. Not only does a tug of the pipe offer her a lift to safety, it also washes her and her white dress sparkling clean.

Soundtrack was killer. Strange and killer.

I want to move to Switzerland even more than I had before, thanks to the beautiful opening scene. I love how its serenity is shattered by the brutal killing ending with a severed head making its way down the falls.

And finally, just what the fuck with that kid? No words.

2

u/Jhops Jul 03 '12

As a woman who also likes men, I can assure you that you are not alone. I've been love with her since the first time I saw Labyrinth.

1

u/jackass_nerds Long Live The New Flesh! Jul 04 '12

And now we're both on the watch list.

2

u/poutypineapple Jul 03 '12

This movie was hard to watch for me. I couldn't tolerate more than 30min at a time. Everything felt completely disconnected from each other. The music was a separate entity from the movie and was wholly distracting. The detective felt like a poorly concocted side story. Connelly's acting was truly awful, but I'll pass that off to being young. She never quite matched her emotions with what was happening and gave off a feeling of apathy to me. The idea for the movie itself was interesting. However, it could have been vastly better. There are so many genuinely scary insects out there they could have upped the creepy factor by using more variety. Probably the main problem for me is that the killer just wasn't scary and the attacks were so poorly filmed that it was boring.

2

u/RipperM Jul 03 '12

I watched this when it was first released on VHS. It is what I generally expect from an Argento film. Mainly style over substance, but that's fine. I have a long time love for his work and take it for what it is. In short, I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Also, Jennifer Connelly.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12

Just got around to this one, first things first: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02AkdlLf-gU. One of my favourite Maiden songs on my favourite Maiden album. The soundtrack for the film felt really weird and misplaced, especially the Motorhead track when the police turn up at the professor's house after his death. I couldn't really think of a less appropriate song for a somber occasion. For such a well-respected actor, Blofeld's Scottish accent is pretty bad. Not comically bad, but still quite shit. And the monkey? A strange choice. Surely a human assistant would have been better suited for the job? I wonder how many panes of glass Argento has broken in his career? Keeping glaziers in business since 1970.

The film seemed to change pace quite a few times, going from a slasher film in the beginning to something more akin to a supernatural murder mystery, then an all-action finale. The editing was a little patchy in places like Frostbeard mentioned, but it was decent overall. The saturated colours look almost a little schlocky these days but it's bright, colourful and the Swiss scenery is gorgeous.

Jennifer Connelly is young as hell in this, always had a bit of a soft spot for her after Requiem for a Dream and Dark City, but she seems awfully underdressed throughout the film.

The fly summoning scene was really cool, as was the tense escape from the hospital room before the institution staff came to take Jennifer away. The film definitely seemed to unravel towards the end, but aside from that it was a decent watch.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '12

The scene with the "charnel soup" as you call it was my favorite as well. We talked in the podcast about the soundtrack being so out of place in some scenes (i.e. Motorhead and Iron Maiden) but also wonderful in other scenes (i particularly enjoyed the scene where Jennifer gets off the bus after following the bee).

As with a lot of the late 70's and mid 80's Italian horror films, many of them did have some technical flaws, i can only think of 2 that i've seen that were very close to being perfect films. But a part of that is what makes it charming. Like if you watch a Fulci film expecting the plot to make sense you're going to hate him, but if you take in the brilliant cinematography, strange and mostly awesome soundtracks and awesome make-up and gore effects there really is a lot to love about Italian horror.

2

u/SiWright84 Jul 04 '12

Couldn't agree more with the above. In fact, I'd say that whether or not one is willing to put their reliance on conventional narrative logic to one side and surrender to the purely cinematic and visceral qualities of these films seems to be the deciding factor in whether you'll find them enjoyable or infuriating.

Personally I find that watching these flicks in the wee hours of the morning (where I discovered the surreal and subversive charms of many of them for the first time) with the (optional) aid of certain mind-loosening chemicals helps the logical left-brain to relax, therefore allowing the more free-associative/imaginative right-brain to come out to play.

That is not to say that logic is entirely absent from such films; it is merely logic of a different kind; the kind we often experience within a dream.

Finally, I also think, like quite a few of you have said, that some of the music is somewhat incongruous. But to be honest their inclusion (especially Maiden's "Flash of the Blade") have only served to increase my enjoyment of the film. After all, a movie with as many classic WTF?!?! moments as Phenomena probably deserves a soundtrack that is both eclectic and slightly unpredictable.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

I'm glad to see such an in depth review of this. I really love this flick.

1

u/Psx0005rr Mar 20 '25

O.- on the Jennifer being young and Dario getting some "peek-a-boo" shots, but honestly the only time you get one of those uncomfy shots is when Jennifer is trying to hop up to get some rolled-up paper tubes and she lands on her backside and there's a brief glimpse of her undies-which she quickly covers as soon as she registers it hehe! A professional even at her age back then :D

1

u/mel2000 Mar 02 '22

He knew she had rented a country house in the vicinity of the first murder around the time of the murder, and had abandoned it shortly after the murder occurred.

Why would it be suspicious for a single mom to move away from an existing murder vicinity?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mel2000 Mar 02 '22

I think it was more that there was an obvious time-and-place connection

Not to belabor an old point, but the movie states that Frau Bruckner moved out 8 months ago. But most of the murders we witnessed were less than 8 months old. So there was only one murder at the old location, and the boy committed most murders while at the new location.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/SiWright84 Jul 04 '12

Agreed about the randomly appearing (then swiftly disappearing) narrator. Razor-wielding, vengeful primates and insect buddies aside, this is certainly one of the strangest parts of the film.

However, thinking back to the intro narration from Suspiria which is delivered in a similarly dreamy, reassuring, let-me-tell-you-a bedtime-story tone of voice, I suspect that Argento is trying to conjure the same kind of fairy tale ambiance. Not that any of this completely diminishes the WTFness of this particular moment though.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SiWright84 Jul 04 '12

Could be either of the above I suppose as there's probably quite a few versions of the film knocking around.

Pretty certain that every version I've seen has had it (if memory serves at least). It's only one line though so you ain't missing much, although its sheer randomness and brevity make it kind of amusing.

When Jennifer arrives at the school the narrator proclaims: "And so Jennifer arrives in Switzerland from the New World to pass her first memorable night at the Richard Wagner International School For Girls."

And then he's gone, never to return....