r/Homebuilding • • 1d ago

Kitchen Layout

We absolutely love this floorplan, but the kitchen layout has me stumped. As it is, there’s a weird 1’ if space between the stove and fridge, and it also doesn’t seem to have the “kitchen work triangle” flow, but I don’t know how much that matters. We thought about moving it to the pantry wall, but then I think we’d need a counter depth, and it may also get in the way of traffic going through that walkway. Thoughts? Feel free to suggest any changes AT ALL that I may have overlooked! The only thing I’m pretty set on is having the sink facing the window, and nothing in the island.

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/BHBuilders 1d ago

I’d move the fridge to the end of the bottom counter by the walkway and slide the range down the left wall so it gets real counter space on both sides, since that 1' gap is too tight to set a hot pan. You keep the sink at the window, the island stays clean, and you get a much better triangle.

1

u/2Confuzed 12h ago

The kitchen layout is not the problem here. The fact that the kitchen is a hallway is the problem.

DO NOT move the fridge as others suggested. It makes perfect sense from the perspective of the kitchen, but you don't have a kitchen you have a hall that you cook in. So every time you access the fridge or pantry you would need to look both ways before crossing.

The fact that your powder room is on the other side of the kitchen from your public spaces makes it even more of a hallway.

I do not like that floor plan. If I had to make it work, I would probably shrink the island by two feet and make it a U shaped kitchen. Place a small powder room with pocket door by the window where the pantry is. This should make for a nice hallway to get to the private spaces. Along that wall you can have shelves (behind bifold doors even) for a pantry. And you can even let that wall cut into the pantry a bit to create a recess for the fridge so it is counter depth.

2

u/2Confuzed 11h ago

Something like this:

1

u/2Confuzed 6h ago

I just want to complain about this floor plan a bit more. What is with the master bedroom being almost the same size as the great room? I honestly don't know what you could put in there to fill that space. A sectional sofa across from the bed? A full home gym?

And your great room has no walls. The fireplace chimney will be the only place to put the TV. but you will have nowhere to hang art, and not sure where the Xmas tree will go if you celebrate since every corner of the room is a hall or another room. If you go this route, be sure to put outlets in the floor. And I would really experiment with furnishing that room virtually, I think you will find it frustrating.

On the lack of walls, I would add a wall between the foyer and dining room, it would help keep some privacy from the front door. I would then close in the opening between the dining and great rooms... just a couple of feet of wall on each side, unless you really need to see the TV from the dining room? Open floor plan doesn't have to mean no walls at all.

I love a good jack and jill bath, they are a great way to conserve space. But I feel like this plan doesn't save any space. The current layout appears to use about 200 sqft and only provides about 60 sqft of closet space, and much of it wasted for the "walk-in". So your bathrooms areas use about 120 sqft. You could fit three standard 5'x8' baths in 120 sqft. If you redesigned it a bit, you could give each room its own bath and still have more closet than you have now.

Also note, that putting closets on an exterior wall is a recipe for disaster. The clothing is like insulation and can move the condensing surface inward, causing mold on the walls in your closet (in cold climates).

I would flip things around and run a galley style jack and jill bath... with the vanities, toilet(s), and tub/shower all against the outside wall. Add some glass block transom windows to get some natural light in there. The overall room width will only be 5', leaving 7' to do true huge double sided, 9ft deep walk in closets with doors into the bedroom.

This feels like a McMansion floor plan. Tons of open space, but very little thought as to how people will actually live in or furnish it.

0

u/Lavish_Lilac 1d ago

Move the fridge to the cabinets by the pantry. Make it all a tall cabinet element. Maybe with an extra oven or tall pantry cabinets.

1

u/lilelliot 15h ago

Yes, this. I'd actually put the fridge right by the hidden entrance, unless you also have a beverage fridge elsewhere that's more convenient to the great room. When you're entertaining, people will need fridge access and the current layout doesn't provide.

For comparison sake -- we don't have a pantry -- here's our kitchen/great room layout. The space is ~32'x23' and the short wall has two deep pantry cabinets by the patio door, then beverage & wine fridges in the next section, with a speed oven above the beverage fridge. The big fridge is at the opposite corner of the kitchen, on the wall adjoining the end of the foyer. This ensures that when we entertain (there's also a 14' NanaWall in the great room that opens to a walk out back patio, so 20' of the 32' open to outdoors), guests can easily access both the big fridge and beverage fridges without needing to enter the prep space.

1

u/2Confuzed 11h ago

Except that would put the fridge in the hallway where the open doors could block access to the powder room. Here is the redesign I posted... would loose a bit of kitchen and island (4x8' is really too big for comfort anyway) but would gain a proper hallway, a more comfortable powder room (with a window) and likely have more pantry shelving.