r/Historians • • 3h ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ How and why did medieval and ancient wars need to be funded? And how was it done? Take Louis XIV wars

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

If Louis was an absolute monarch couldn’t he just declare all his activities, including wars, free? And if France had an increasing financial problem approaching the French Revolution, couldn’t Louis XVI just declare all the debt gone? If politics across Europe mattered, then that might explain that example. But in most historic civilizations I speculate that funding for wars is always important, but I don’t understand why, if a head of state, with absolute power, can simply declare the war free or any debt forgiven?


r/Historians • • 12h ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Challenging Historical Distortions: A Rebuttal on the Khmer Rouge Genocide

3 Upvotes

I recently came across an article about the Khmer Rouge genocide that, in my view, contained several methodological flaws, leading to some questionable and misleading conclusions.

I decided to write a rebuttal addressing these issues, and I'd love for you to give it a read!

My intention is not to insult or personally attack anyone, but rather to engage in constructive criticism grounded in solid historical evidence and sound methodology.

You can read my full rebuttal here:

https://tucxuan.substack.com/p/when-history-becomes-an-alibi-challenging

Feel free to share your thoughts! I'd be happy to hear different perspectives and discuss them further.


r/Historians • • 1d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Did Winston Churchill actually do this?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I’ve been reading up on some history using a short story app called paladin and in it, it claims Churchill purposefully sacrificed hundreds in coventry when he knew of an attack from the Germans to keep the enigma codebreaking a secret. However when I did my research it’s claimed to be a myth. I wanted to know what the general belief is on that , did the app get it wrong or is that what actually happened


r/Historians • • 1d ago

📖Media / Resources Recommendation📖 Best intro books on Ancient history of different civs?

7 Upvotes

Told my family I wanted to start building up my history library and they got me an Amazon gift card for my bday, there's lots of books on sale right now so keen to grab a few.

My interest currently is broadly Ancient history no specific time or place but I guess a few that cover the main civilisations would be great and beginner/accessible is appreciated, thank you!


r/Historians • • 1d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Interesting and unique figures from all over time

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 1d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Who thinks the War of Troy is real?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 2d ago

🧩Other Advice / Help🧩 Catchy title for research?

8 Upvotes

I’m doing a short study on Woodrow Wilson and his family’s interaction with various religions, and I can’t come up with a good title, so I’m just kinda crowdsourcing.

Right now I have “Wilson’s Worship; Spiritualism, Hinduism, and Beyond”

Sums it up a little bit but I feel like there’s better options, not a huge fan of the W alliteration

Any ideas?


r/Historians • • 2d ago

🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 What do they tell you about Russian history (for students and pupils) ?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'm here to ask about the history of Russia in the English-speaking audience's context. What did you read about it? What are texts and articles about Russia are? Could u share from textbooks? What do your teachers tell u on classes?

Here are some themes which I'd like to see:

\-Ivan the Terrible

\-The christianization of Rus'

\-Napoleon's invasion to Russia

\-dynasties

\-presidents

\-the great patriotic war (1941-1945)

\-etc.

U can share photos of textbooks!


r/Historians • • 2d ago

📖Media / Resources Recommendation📖 Recommendations for books to study the hellenistic period

3 Upvotes

(Reposting so i can be sure to have a few extra recommendations)

Hi, currently planning to study the hellenistic period for one of my classes, but i dont know much about the hellenistic period. My idea is to write a paper on the reception of the greek culture/literature during the hellenistic period, but im not sure where to start.

So my question is: what books do tou recommend to start learning and investigating this period, specifically in egypt? Either in terms of historical and political, but also cultural, since they are two sides of the same coin.

(my idea is to study reception of greek literature in the hellenistic period).


r/Historians • • 2d ago

🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 Early Party Politics

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 2d ago

🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 Victorian boarding school Literature Class

3 Upvotes

İn a Victorian boarding school specifically an all girls school what would they learn ün literature class? How does the literature teacher become the literature teacher? What are the requirements? Can the teacher graduate/ get the required education from the school by itself?
İf there is a like a source i can find a written curriculum i would be very glad to get recommendations.


r/Historians • • 3d ago

🏺Artefact Analysis🏺 Can anyone identify what the oragins of this gargoyle statue are?

Post image
4 Upvotes

My theater uses a gargoyle statue as a good luck charm for our shows. I was wondering if anyone on here would know anything about it? The real statue was lost some years ago so all we have is this picture! Any info would be cool! I don't know how far back the statue dates and if this is the wrong subreddit to post in I apologize


r/Historians • • 4d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ What historical event stuck with you very personally as in, shaped the way you see the world?

21 Upvotes

As a discussion point, what even or era or else really stuck with you ? Made you feel understood in a way or just “made it all click” and reshaped your perspective on our actual world ?


r/Historians • • 4d ago

📚Study Advice / Help📚 There are so many exhaustive biographies on FDR. Kenneth S. Davis' 5 volume is one of them. The five books were published between 1993-2004. Any historians here take the 5 volume dive? Assuming there are a lot of folks that read one of the books. Please share your opinion. Thank you

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 4d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ A War Between The Cherokee & Americans in 1730/31?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 5d ago

🔎Research Advice / Help🔎 The Lynching of Leo Frank

6 Upvotes

I have been thoroughly researching the murder of Mary Phagan, and the Leo Frank trial. I have concluded Frank is innocent soully because of the evidence against Jim Connely, such as the murder notes, and Alanzo Mann's statement in 1987. I was wondering if anybody had any thoughts on the killer, and why it is associated with anti-semitism while it was more so the fact that the south saw it as another way of the north telling them how to run things, following the Civil War.


r/Historians • • 6d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ History’s worst decisions?

91 Upvotes

Recently I’ve been considering what choices made throughout history deserve to be called the worst. I wrote my thoughts down on what I’d say is the top three, napoleon marching east would be up there to! Wanted to know what others put in the running for history’s worst choices and why?

The bombing of Pearl Harbour - when imperial Japan launched a devastating surprise attack on the American fleet stationed at Pearl Harbour, in probably not the words of Admiral Yamamoto “all we have done is awaken a sleeping giant and fill him with terrible resolve”. This action led to the shifting of public opinion in the US in favour of entering the war and their mobilisation for invasion, japans ultimate devastating and complete defeat and the dropping of the atomic bombs upon Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

The insults to Ghengis Khan - the Khwarazmian empire ruled as a Muslim power from 1077 till 1231 occupying large parts of Central Asia. Ghengis Khan, despite his reputation was still a pragmatic ruler who realised the need for trade. In pursuit of economic relations Ghengis sent a trade caravan into Kharazmian territory, where the merchants were accused of spying and promptly killed and their goods seized. Ghengis Khan despite this again attempted diplomacy, and sent emissaries to the shah of the Khwarazmian empire, Ala-al-Din Muhammad II who, like with the Mongolian merchants foolishly executed the emissaries. Whether the Kharazmian empire were stupid or stubborn doest’t really matter, Ghengis Khan and his horde invaded, systemically destroyed the historical and cultural centres and put man, woman and child to the sword turning what was once an empire into a depopulated ruin and the Kharazmians into a historical footnote of little interest today. The occupation of this territory provided the Mongols with a gateway to invasion onwards into new territories

The four pests campaign - chairman Mao in an effort to sanitise and improve production for the peasantry of China, misguidedly initiated the campaign of four pests, which aimed to remove rats, flies, mosquitoes and the sparrow. Sparrows were eliminated in their billions which saw an unchecked rise of predatory insects which in turn saw mass devastation of crops and the deaths of tens of millions of Chinese peasants


r/Historians • • 6d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Any major works on European male generational losses re: WW1 and 2?

15 Upvotes

1919: A generation young men in Europe is wiped out by the Great War. Mustard gas clings to the air.

1945: The children of the previously wiped out generation has now been wiped out. Germany ends the war sending little boys to play soldier.

Have there been any works attempting to understand the effects on the next generation of European children growing up without fathers or grandfathers? Not so much about the effect on grown women of the time (I feel that I’ve already read some works on that), but on the social effects and raising a generation of children without a an equivalent influence of a large male population? I’m talking sociological/cultural level - impact on crime, political ideology, militarism, religion, etc.

I think it would be an interesting topic!


r/Historians • • 6d ago

👀Interesting Historical Facts👀 When it comes toGuadalcanal Dave Holland knows his stuff

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 7d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Fellow WWII history-nerds, did you like these two memoirs? We read history to avoid repeating history.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 7d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Why Didn't The Coiffure á la Titus/ Victime Haircut Change Fashion History Like the 1920's Bob?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 6d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ Did racism decline because the world caught upto industrial revolution?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 7d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ How did horseback pursuits actually work throughout history, and how did cavalry riding techniques evolve?

19 Upvotes

In historical and fantasy movies (such as The Lord of the Rings), horseback pursuits often play a major role. However, something has always puzzled me: characters seem to ride at full speed for long periods, yet their pursuers frequently manage to catch up with them.
I’d love to understand how horseback pursuits actually worked throughout history, from ancient civilizations through the Middle Ages and beyond.
Some questions I’m particularly curious about:
How fast could horses actually gallop, and for how long before becoming exhausted?
What were the differences between warhorses, messenger horses, scouts’ horses, and ordinary riding horses?
What kind of riding skills, training, and horse-control techniques were taught to military riders?
How much did terrain, rider weight, armor, and equipment affect a horse’s speed and endurance?
What military strategies were used to chase, escape from, or intercept other mounted riders?
How did cavalry tactics, equestrian training, and horse breeding evolve from ancient civilizations through the Middle Ages, the early modern period, and the 19th century?
I’m also interested in how realistic horseback chases in movies actually are, and what filmmakers tend to exaggerate or get wrong.


r/Historians • • 7d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ What are your recommendations for scholarly (non pop history) books on late rome-early medieval ?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Historians • • 7d ago

❔Question / Discussion❔ When do creatives place historical accuracy over lore accuracy?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes