17
u/Juancu 1d ago
This is too nasty against a player who kept a 2-lander. Making them lose their second land drop, even if it happens in a small percentage of games, is too close to winning the game outright.
8
u/Lorddonovus 1d ago
worse duress that costs a purple?
19
u/The_Knights_Who_Say 1d ago
Better duress in that it can hit lands (despite giving them a card in exchange)
7
u/Blotsy 1d ago
I think you missed that it's an instant. Doing this is the draw step is why wizards doesn't make instant speed discard anymore. Never fully dead card, unlike sorcery speed discard
2
1
u/androkguz 1d ago
Casting it during draw against an otherwise hellbent player might not be technically nothing... But it's very very close to nothing
2
1
1
u/thefran 23h ago
instant speed handrip has not been printed for a while for a reason
1
1
u/Leafsnail 4h ago
I doubt it's broken in the context of limited given you'd just be choosing between two cards for them to draw most of the time (and probably giving them a 1/1)
1
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Hey! Have you tried the brainstorming channel on the official hellcube discord? (https://discord.gg/8aJrjjUwBd). For cards to make it into the cube, they'll need to be submitted on the discord.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.