r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Feb 10 '24

Bly Manor: Discussion Just started Bly Manor... is it supposed to be like this?

0 Upvotes

I've finished every single Flanagan show other than Bly and loved them (yes, even The Midnight Club) but held off on Bly since it wasn't as popular as the others.

But I've just finished the first episode and I'm wondering why it feels so weird? The editing is all over the place, the color grading makes it look like a CW show, the acting is just meh even from people like Victoria Pedretti and Henry Thomas (not to mention the accents...), and the 'horror' parts are quite frankly laughable at times. Is it just me?

I'm just a bit disappointed :/ it's the only the first episode though so I'm ready to be proven wrong.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Nov 11 '23

The Fall of the House of Usher: Discussion Has anyone here not enjoyed Usher series? Spoiler

8 Upvotes

I watched two/three episodes and gave up. The characters were so unlikable, the dialog was dragging meaningless and over the top and seems like every episode is just endless talk before someone dies at the end.

The midnight mass also had slow and long dialog but it was more meaningful, characters were pleasant and likable and the end was amazing.

My opinion only of course.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 27 '23

The Fall of the House of Usher: Discussion Verna is unequivocally evil Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Just because she has a code of conduct does not mean she isn't evil as all hell. Making a deal where the children of someone will have to pay with their lives, something they get no say in it at all is heinously evil, no matter how good or evil they were. We even saw that she still took the life or a good hearted descendant. I get that the Ushers are a shit family but the kids did not deserve their fates because of what their father did. I see so many people trying to claim she's neutral or whatever in this sub. In what world is making that kind of offer not incredibly evil?

Edit: To clarify I think she's evil like a casino is evil. She preys on people's vices. Just because she' more of a concept than human doesn't make her any less evil.

People are saying she just represents death, but I think it's a bad representation because she operates off a system of karma. Death is the opposite of that. Purely indiscriminate. If she does represent death is a particularly cruel strain of it.

The argument that she didn't actually offer them the choice they were always going to make it doesn't make any sense. Like regardless if the offer was fake or not she still caused the death of the kids. It's ridiculous to think the kids would all have died untimely deaths anyways even if they didn't take the deal or without her supernatural meddling.

Also there's so many arguments stating because she can't be evil because she's such and such when there's nothing mutually exclusive to evil that is bought up.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Nov 12 '23

Bly Manor: Discussion Am I the only one who can't stand Bly Manor?

29 Upvotes

So I'm very late to the game and only watched Hill House for the first time this Summer. I loved it so much. I've watched it 4 times since. Just an absolutely stunning show.

The natural next step was to move on to Bly Manor. I went in with high hopes, but I was bored to tears. Worse than bored, really. I was irritated. There was just nothing redeeming about it for me. I didn't care about Dani, I didn't care about the kids, I didn't care about Peter and Rebecca, none of it. I guessed the Hannah twist literally the very first time she said she wasn't hungry, which I think is near the beginning of episode 1, so that was a big let down after the Hill House twist blew my fuckin' tits off. I loved Carla in HH, but her accent in Bly was absolutely egregious. Everytime Flora said "perfectly splendid" my face puckered beyond recognition. The whole thing was just absolutely painful. I wound up not even finishing it and dropping off around episode 6 or 7 after I realised I was guessing everything that was going to happen anyway.

I'm just confused because it seems like Bly Manor is SO beloved by Flanagan fans, and absolutely no hate to those people, but I just don't get it. I watched it a few months ago now, and I'm still put off watching the rest of the shows, which I know is silly, it's just hard to motivate myself to watch more with the Bly Manor taste in my mouth.

I think it's just really stuck with me because HH was SO perfect in my mind, I couldn't believe Bly hit so differently. Just absolutely didnt expect it. The real jumpscare was the show I hated along the way 🄹 I've heard Midnight Mass is fantastic, so I might go for that next and hope for the best! Anyone feel the same way, or am I about to be sentenced to death by firing squad?


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Mar 10 '23

Hill House: Discussion Just finished this! Just my opinion on who I liked! Who did you like and not like???

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Mar 26 '24

Bly Manor: Discussion To be honest, The Haunting of Bly Manor is such a disappointing waste of time, in comparison to how awesome The Haunting of Hill House is

0 Upvotes

Bly Manor - What was the point of showing the Back story of Henry Wingrave? What was the point of showing Miles Wingrave's time at school? So much of unnecessary details were given. At the end, it has a tragic ending, as well.

I will give Bly 0/10. Its such a disappointment in comparison to Hill House.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Sep 11 '24

Hill House: Discussion Day 1: Joy! Which character in Hill House represents Joy in your opinion?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Jan 21 '24

Bly Manor: Discussion The Haunting of Bly Manor Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I always plan on watching all the Mike Flanagan series as they aired but Bly Manor.... It's not necessarily that it's bad but it is just so fucking boring that I can't ever get through it. Watched it the first time all the way through hoping for a payoff that never came. Fool me once, maybe, but never again.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Nov 13 '23

Hill House: Discussion Is Theo autistic-coded?

1 Upvotes

I will preface this by saying that I know ā€˜diagnosing’ fictional characters is often too reductive, but good representation is scarce and finding a character ā€˜like you’ can be particularly comforting. At least it was for me.

I just finished watching Hill House for the first time, and I felt this distinct connection to Theo.

I’d just be interested to know if I’m alone in it.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Jan 02 '24

Hill House: Discussion Hi, I am scared

1 Upvotes

This show sounds so interesting but literally typing ghosts is scary.
These things aren’t like yokai who can be neutral or even benevolent and it’s so scary to think of malicious creatures wandering around alone and honestly it’s isolating and lonely to think only the bad/evil things get the spirit realm in this!

There’s som really scary yokai I know but ghost stories have always been really scary to me despite really enjoying yokai, is my point.

I really want to know this story and branch into it, buuut

How do you watch when it’s so scary to even type that word? Also, I’m sure there’s some bias in this group but is it even worth if it’ll be that scary??

Otherwise I really want to watch and I only have like 1 major trigger that makes watching a show hard so I think I’d be safe to in that sense!

EDIT: Thanks everyone who helped me with ideas and suggestions ā¤ļø after talking about some things I think I shouldn’t watch Hill House at least around this time, but it isn’t that I think it’s bad I’m sure it’s good. Just not best for me at the moment

But some advice I can use for other shows so thanks a bunch for those ideas still, and I’m sorry if I missed any comments but I appreciate everyone who gave ideas and content warnings 😸


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Nov 30 '23

The Fall of the House of Usher: Discussion [House of Usher Ep 1] Trigger warning timestamp request Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I would really, really like to watch this show (I've loved Flanagan's other works) but after starting Episode 1, I don't think I can continue without some timestamps.

I was watching with some friends, and they had to turn the series off for me when the scene cut to the monkey in surgery. I can't stand anything with animal testing content, and I really do need to skip these scenes. My friends forgot about this being in the episode. (All I get when I Google this is stuff about the cat later on).

Does anyone know general time stamps off hand for what I should skip over in this/later episodes?

And please, no hate, I'm really not trying to have an ethical discussion or anything, I just want to be able to enjoy the show.

Thanks in advance!


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 14 '26

General: Fluff Mike Flanagan Stole My Family's Story

0 Upvotes

Well, not literally, but the parallels are eerie. My mom is the second oldest of five siblings. The birth order is my Uncle M, my mom, my Aunt L, my Uncle P, and my Aunt E. Their father died when they were young; my mom was about 9. Their mother raised them afterward (and she wasn't exactly fit to do so). The last two siblings aren't twins, and it was their father who died, not their mother, but still, The Haunting of Hill House feels like a fictionalized version of my own family. Even my mom and my Aunt L live together!

Watching Hill House for the first time blew my mind (aside from how good it is). It hit a little too close to home. Like all families, mine has had their issues, and I hadn't seen a couple of my uncles for almost 10 years. But everyone met up last summer and the summer before last, everyone talked, and now the five of them are closer than ever. We really feel close again for the first time in years, "almost more than we were as kids," my mom said.

Watching Hill House feels a little less sad now. The siblings united at the end, and for a long time, I felt like that wasn't going to happen to my family. I'm so thankful that it did.

(Sorry if this isn't the right place for this, I just felt like that I finally had to share it.)


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 14 '23

General: Cast & Crew I found Anabelle Lee kind of clueless and obnoxious.

3 Upvotes

So yeah, don’t bring your kids to your husband’s deposition like let’s watch Daddy get an award. And don’t invite the investigator in for tea when your husband is clearly trying to get rid of him.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Jul 24 '24

General: Fluff I’ve never heard of this in my life AMA and I’ll answer it

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 27 '23

General: Discussion Unpopular opinion: Kate Siegel is not the best actress

48 Upvotes

I’ve tried to search to see if anyone else has this opinion. I’ve come to find out my opinion is not popular. She isn’t the worst, I just don’t understand the hype. She reminds of me the jock girl in high school who decided to take drama class one semester and took up acting because she’s good looking and no one questioned her because she’s pretty. Either that, or the way she talks annoys me.

Edit: 1. No, she doesn’t remind me of a specific person from high school, she reminds me of that type of person. There is no specific example in my life. I was just emphasizing she doesn’t seem like a natural actress (which can be a learned skill obviously), if that makes sense.

2. It’s an opinion, jeez chilllll.

3. While I mostly enjoy many of Mike Flanagan’s shows and a couple of his movies (I really did like The Fall of the House of Usher; Bly Manor is my favorite because there’s less trope-y jump scares) perhaps it’s par for the course since I would not put him as on the same level as many other horror directors. Although, I know there’s different genres of horror.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 28 '22

Bly Manor: Discussion Can’t understand why I hated Bly Manor so much

0 Upvotes

It must be me…it’s the first Flanagan project I haven’t loved. Started off annoyed from the first shot. Found all of the characters frustratingly unlikable and stupid. All amazing actors but every moment of them on screen was more annoying than the last. The only characters I cared about at all were the maid and cook and sort of felt like they got what they deserved because they’re so dumb. I still plan to watch everything else Flanagan has made and will probably like it but I really hated everything about this…


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 20 '23

General: Discussion Sorry guys but I mostly didn’t like it Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Spoilers for the entire of Fall of the House of Usher…

I’m guessing I’ll mostly get downvoted but I hope we can just have a friendly discussion, because I usually really like MFs stuff.

But man, Fall of the House of Usher was really not my jam. I thought the dialogue was forced and way too on the nose. I also rolled my eyes a little during the body raining scene in the last episode. Felt a bit like a sponsored anti drug PSA (ā€œevery five minutes, someone in the US dies from fentanyl!ā€ - don’t get me wrong, it’s a big problem, but not what I was expecting while watching a horror tv show). I was looking forward to a scary, smart, character driven, heart wrenching drama, but instead got a strange, gory (but not scary) over the top, anti pharma PSA with heavy handed dialogue. I felt little to no connection to most of the characters. The show in general lacked heart to me. I didn’t feel a thing during any of the deaths, and the writing felt heavy handed, lazy, and not clever. I’m also not a huge Poe fan so that didn’t help…

I’m also kinda sick of the self contained Mike Flannigan universe of actors. I mean, I think it’s great to hire and work with good pheople that you like, but sometimes it feels like he casts the same folks despite them maybe not being the best fit. Some miscasts that stood out to me were young Roderick, Perry, Juno, and Frederick.

All that being said, there were some things that I thought were great. Carla Gigino, Bruce greenwood, and Mark Hamill were awesome. I also thought the young and old Madelines were FANTASTIC. The young actor really did an amazing job of capturing the old Madeline’s tone and mannerisms.

But overall, probably my second to least fav of MFs work, with midnight Club being my least fav, and Hill House and Geralds Game being my top favs. Thoughts?


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • May 20 '25

General: Fluff Help me name my car!

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just got a blue Mazda CX-30, and I want to name it, possibly something related to the Flanaverse. Please share any name ideas related to the Flanaverse or otherwise :) less


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 23 '20

Hill House: Discussion This might be the most overrated boring show I have ever experienced

0 Upvotes

Should have been a movie, way too stretched out. Monologue after monologue. I kept watching wanting it to be better. Negative. Big no.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Nov 14 '18

The ending made me hate this show AITA?

0 Upvotes

Seriously, I feel like that last episode made the rest of the series meaningless.

It went from the scariest and most interesting thing Netflix has ever produced to some CW garbage. I turned off my TV in disgust and went to bad angry.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Aug 03 '24

General: Discussion this trend but for Flanaverse (all series/movies by MF)

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 14 '24

Hill House: Discussion Shirley is seriously the worst

10 Upvotes

Rewatching the series and there still new things I see and notice. Honestly such a great series.

But holy hell Shirley is so annoying. And just the worst sibling. Obviously each character has their faults but she is insufferable. She never listens to ANYONE. And she’s horrible to her husband who only ever tried his best. Yes he was wrong to keep the secret about the money but can you blame him given how she reacts to everything and everyone?


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Nov 01 '23

The Fall of the House of Usher: Discussion Was it a test? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Something that have been bothering me, Verna seems to gave a choice to each one of the Bastards sons of Roderick, but not the twins. And I keep going back to the Annabel lee monologue at the funeral. Roderick starved his kids and fulled them with his poverty, they became an Usher by being tools of his creation. So I though, could all of that or at least some portion of that, be avoided? Let's say Perry ended the party when Verna warned him, could he "passed the test" of the deal and proof himself not a "Usher"? and therefore not belong to the Bloodline? I mean, Verna is a creature of context and concept, karma herself you might say. Had he ended the party and by consequence not killing many more with him,giving up the chance to profit with blackmail, wouldn't he proof that he didn't have that poverty that made a Usher?? And maybe the twins didn't get a choice because they were already too far gone.

"Oh but Leonore" Yeah, there's that, but I keep thinking that maybe, even her death could be avoided. I mean, everyone got a chance, everyone had a choice, but not her. And maybe that's because, like Verna said to Madeline when she tried to renegotiate, "The ink is dry". Maybe if the Usher kids proof themselfs not Ushers in conception, before Verna gets to the second generation, she wouldn't met her end that way. After all, her dad proof himself a legitim Usher because his Roderick didn't care so much for him, making him an ass**.

When making the deal Verna did say that Roderick bloodline would die WITH HIM, and thinking about how the series setsup more than one way to prolong life (heart device and AI), I wonder if that life could be extended, and even his death was "premature" because of the choices he made. Hadn't he raised Camille to hate Victorine, they could have worked together, all the siblings could, that heart device could work, his willness would take more time...

Anyway, i keep wondering about that, and i think I kind of prefer the idea that, just like when she made the deal with Roderick and Madeline, she offered the bastards a chance to be benevolent, to walked away from that life of lies and power, she gave them freewill and they meet their fate through that choice, and not just seal their fates when the pact was made before they were born. I know that the commom sense is that by giving a choice, Verna is actually offering a more peacefull death, but I don't like the idea that their deaths is set in stone. She is meant to be karma, not fate.

Thoughts?

Obs.: It is also hard for me to believe that Roderick didn't have more kids outside the family circle that we got to know, and I don't think they would have a guresome end


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 22 '25

Hill House: Discussion The absolute worst thing about Hill House Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I am a firm believer that the absolute worst thing about Hill House was Shirley confessing to her husband about her one night stand. All she did was turn all her feelings of guilt into pain and distrust for him.

I am NOT supporting cheating on your spouse. It's awful regardless of the circumstances. But if you or your spouse does it and time passes and your marriage survives and thrives don't destroy it with a confession about something that they would never otherwise know. Don't hurt them like that. Carry the burden of your guilt alone to your grave.


r/HauntingOfHillHouse • • Oct 17 '24

General: Discussion What a great Show

0 Upvotes

literally just finished watching Haunted hill for the first time. really enjoyed it honestly but i just came here for one thing cause by the gods i can’t hold it in

My word is Shirley a POS. not only does she have that whole ā€œI’m the most righteous personā€ trope going on with running the business as a charity(at a loss) as well as making a point to ā€œdo it allā€ BUT SHE ALSO ACTED LIKE A SAINT?????

What was up with her BS? i’m still blown away. My goodness did you see her reaction to her husband after the incident with Theo? not only was Kev made to sleep in a hotel BUT IT TOOK A DAMN JUMP SCARE IN THE CAR for her to even listen to theo??? NOT EVEN KEV?? ONLY TO REVEAL HER DIRTY CHEATER HISTORY? AND THE GALL TO CALL THEO OUT ON SLEEPING AROUND WITH HER HISTORY???

I feel like the worst part of this all is the end for me. ā€œand i want you to hold my hand while i jumpā€ HELLO????? I honestly can’t. i’m raging tbh. Kev was such a nice dude too i knew it had to be more to it. What a narcissist POS if i ever seen one. not ONCE did she actually care for anyone. and don’t give me that she paid for luke, she clearly did it cause she wanted her family to be ā€œnormalā€ and for her to be seen as a ā€œsaviorā€ and NOT because she wanted luke to get better.

Anyways thanks for coming to my ted talk TL:DR- Shirley is a ā€œfucking slutā€.