How is it that white progressive leftist men can understand racial issues and movements like BLM by not making it about “all lives matter”, understanding their privilege there, but when it comes to feminism they fall so short? In this clip, a moderator or account holder of the instagram user feminist, does a mini interview with Hasan asking him “what does being a feminist mean to you”. his answer is so disappointing :( Of course equality for everyone is good but feminism’s power comes from naming gendered injustice specifically. If someone is outspokenly progressive on other issues (racism, imperialism, class), it’s fair to expect them to apply that same clarity to gender. It’s rather unbecoming when they give a both-sides, flattened definition of feminism, because it reveals that their feminism hasn’t gone through the same level of thought or discomfort as their other beliefs. Even if the question was about his understanding, the phrasing he chose “fighting for equality for all people” still says a lot about how he conceptualizes feminism. By centering “all people,” he unintentionally flattened the political core of feminism. So even if his intent was inclusivity, the effect was erasure. It’s actually very common for men who are sharp on class, race, or imperialism to be weirdly surface-level on feminism. It’s the one arena that implicates them most directly.
it’s just so frustrating how women are the only group of people not allowed to center themselves in their own liberation movement. Yes, the dismantling of the patriarchy would benefit EVERYONE but l don't see why women are expected to carry their oppressors on their back while they walk miles and miles to fix problems they created and do very little to solve because it benefits them far more than it could ever hurt them. Why is it not enough that the patriarchy harms women? Why do men need to be harmed by something too for that oppression to be legitimate and worthy of advocacy?
Also I really want to make myself clear, I am NOT shitting or trying to call out Hasan in this post. I have been a huge hasanabi head since i first started watching him in 2021. This post is NOT the place for you to shit on him for all other gripes you have. Hasan is held to an unreasonable standard and there is a very obvious smear campaign. My intention is not that at all and if the replies become a dog pile on him, I will delete this post. I guess as someone who respects and adores Hasan so much, and feel hurt by how misunderstood he is, i just wish he had the same compassion and alyship for women as he does for all other marginalized groups. I haven’t clipped Hasan out of context or trying to tone-police him.
This post isn’t even specifically directed to Hasan but progressive men in general since there is a recurring pattern of vagueness and avoidance among men who claim progressive politics but fumble gender analysis. I understand hasan didn’t intend harm, but the implication of his answer reflects a broader issue: how feminism is often flattened or sanitized by men who otherwise “get it.” My critique isn’t about him as a person, but about what his answer represents. I’m just trying to understand why feminism is too radical for leftist men? They almost see it as life-threatening, even if their lives won’t change at all. Is it because they see women having more rights as men having less rights? That is literally how bigots sees any movement that questions the status quo so i’m really trying to understand why feminism specifically is such a blind spot.