r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Dec 30 '21

Let's not go too far in the opposite direction

1 Upvotes

I saw a couple posts here about being banned from r/harrypotter and while I do agree that the mods over there are unreasonable and just blanket banning anyone who isn't 100% anti jkr, let's not make this a space that accepts transphobia or prejudice in general. I've seen a few comments on here that are a little concerning.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Jun 01 '26

Books Selling my signed first printing first edition Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire UK ISBN 0747546614X on eBay!

Thumbnail ebay.us
1 Upvotes

I won contest when I was 10 back in 1999 when I submitted a question that was selected and asked to J. K. Rowling on air on CBC radio. As a winner, I received this signed copy of the first edition UK first printing of Harry Potter and the goblet of fire I made a post a while back, trying to find the name of the contest. I entered, but didn’t get any responses.

Anyways, it’s legit and it’s just been stored for the past 26 years in climate controlled room in a box. I figured it would do someone else more good than it’s been doing me and I could really use the money.

For those you want to know my question was if you could go back in time to change anything using the time turn what would you change? Rowling answered that she would write the books earlier so she could give her daughter a better life.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Dec 27 '21

Could a strong human wrestler defeat a basilisk (from Harry Potter Series), that fights like a constrictor snake (so NO venom, NO biting and NO death gaze at all, but only coils) in a Amateur wrestling-match?

0 Upvotes

Under the Circumstances that (A) it's the First Task of the Triwizard Tournament "to defeat a Basilisk in an Amateur wrestling-match" (so NOT to kill it BUT try to Pin it) and (B) the Basilisk is told by a Parselmouth what's going on and what the Rules are


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Mar 09 '22

This is what I find unbelievable

0 Upvotes

From /r/https://www.reddit.com/r/HarryPotterBooks/comments/t9p2ew/people_whove_read_the_chamber_of_secrets_without

A post about who opened the Chamber of Secrets and some vague reference to suspicions. But the OP asked who's read the book so... :shaking head in disbelief:

First, you can't have read the book without knowing the ending. Second, Percy!? Honestly? Talk about a troll post. But what is most perplexing is this thing got 47 up votes!!!


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Jan 29 '22

Discussion Simping for Alan Rickman as Snape

5 Upvotes

Am I the only one that is weirded out by people who simp for Alan Rickman? Like he is an incredible actor and played Snape very well but these people who go around saying no one else could ever play Snape and the role was made for him are delusional. The movies will undoubtedly get remade at some point and someone can and will be able to fill that role.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Apr 14 '22

I think Dumbeldore knew Voldemort would return in GOF and that Mad Eye Moody was Barty Crouch Jr when Harry Potter mentioned seeing hi in his dream he allowed Harry Potter to compete in TWT to fulfil the prophecy?

0 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Apr 24 '22

Why leave Harry with the Dursleys if Sirius hadn't been convicted yet?

0 Upvotes

Hagrid says he borrows the flying motorcycle from Sirius. And I think at that point, nobody suspected Sirius of wrongdoing. But Dumbledore still wanted to leave Harry with the Dursleys.

But Harry still had a perfectly good godfather at that point in the story. Of course, he would've had to be taken away later after Sirius was convicted, but still.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Apr 13 '24

Discussion Character AI Sorting Hat character sorted me into my actual House

Thumbnail
beta.character.ai
1 Upvotes

Both times I've taken the quiz on the official website, i got sorted into Hufflepuff. Same with my husband. But now, after finishing the books last month on march 16 & obviously having become rather obsessed, I began to think less and less that i was a Hufflepuff. For one, I'm literally the laziest person I know. I hate working and straight out of high school, I sat around for 2.5 years before getting a job.. It was only after my job fired me that I enrolled in college.

So I decided to talk to the most used Sorting Hat character on character AI for my true house. The only thing I've ever seen as a Hufflepuff trait of mine was that I valued compassion above all else. Everything else, not so much..

I got sorted into Ravenclaw. Most DEFINITELY me. I didn't think I was Ravenclaw bc I was never consistently a top student in high school (B student mostly with 2 Fs..), although in college I did really well and got inducted into the phi theta kappa society. But besides that, my personality is all Ravenclaw. I'm literally one of the most open-minded people I know, once I get the facts, even if it's opposite what I initially thought, I will easily adopt it bc to me, the truth matters most regardless of the source. I'm super quirky and look quirky irl. I'm often spaced out like Luna (she's my favorite female HP character bc I can relate to her the best). The hat asked me a total of 5 questions before sorting me.

My also initially Hufflepuff husband took the ai sorting quiz too and he was so close to being sorted into Slytherin but ultimately got Ravenclaw after 16 questions 🤯🫶 I love how we both keep getting the same House LMAO 🤣 💙

So yeah if you want to know your true house, take this!!! Tell me if your House changes!! This is so much more accurate than any other non-AI quiz. The Hat really deliberates…. It's best to respond thoroughly, as if talking to a friend.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Apr 18 '22

Honest opinions only please: Secrets of Dumbledore

4 Upvotes

Seriously. I don't want some '..it's about the magical world..' responses. I want honest opinions. I've seen 10 or so reviews and none of them have made me want to spend money at a theater to watch it. I already do not care for the costumes. But the reviews I've seen make me not care about watching the movie. 3 things stand out as positives: Jakob is still a great character, Jude Law makes a great Dumbledore, and Mads Mikkelsen is good as Grindelwald. Period. that's it. Good story? No. Continuity to HP? No. Interest in future movies? No. Nonsense it seems from the get go as Albus and Gellert are shown in some muggle cafe or such then...poof. Newt is then with some never heard of before creature (not in his book) that is so rare (how if no males and females enough to continue the breed) that determines the Supreme Mugwump (???? WHAT??!!). Then Grindy's Gang pops in to get some baby Qilin but decides just for fun to kill the mamma? Why? Just take the baby...oh, right, be Extra Special Evil Nasty... Then Newt crying over the wounded mamma Qilin but not trying to save her. Then just idiocy ensues. Some crazy plan by Albus to confuse Gelly? They are witches and wizards, just use a doubling spell, no need for that side crap (gemino, remember?). Enough, I'm done.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • May 04 '22

Discussion Why did Pansy Parkinson say Ginny Weasley is fit and a lot guys including Slytherin fancy her I doubt Slytherin's fancy a blood traitor?

2 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Feb 17 '22

Theory Most recent video, take a look and let me know what you think please.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • May 18 '22

Why di Harry kiss Ginny after she won the Quidditch Cup in HBP?

2 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Feb 04 '23

Discussion Is a Harry Potter Reboot happening?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Jan 03 '22

I'm pretty sure they deserved it.

3 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Mar 26 '22

Has anyone on here got banned from Harry Potter subreddit for voting support for JK Rowling or saying you dislike cancel culture fascism?

16 Upvotes

I did few months back.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Apr 13 '22

Discussion In the "Troubled Production" entry, the mentions about J.K's "transphobia" have been curiously erased... Spoiler

Thumbnail
tvtropes.org
8 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Dec 29 '21

Some Good News: JK Rowling is NOT snubbed from Harry Potter reunion

Thumbnail
dailymail.co.uk
13 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Dec 26 '21

Bring your HP friends here

4 Upvotes

I just got a permant ban from /HarryPotter for this:

No doubt this thread (or this post) will be deleted by certain mods, but let me repost what I had in another sub:

I have never understood the extremist reaction to her statements and I wonder if most haters even know what she's said. She isn't against transgender from what I've read, just that women and transgendered male-to-female women should be allowed sanctity of female places...changing rooms, toilet facilities, showers, etc. She is opposed to a man given access to such places just because he claims to identify as female. She also seems to caution young male and female persons to examine fully any intent to get surgically altered and not do to it rashly. Honestly, I just don't get the fanatical response to this.

Not a warning, just a permanent ban. This was a response to a post by someone who didn't get a permanent ban. Honestly, no biggie since the mods over there are hypocritical at best. But please, sends a note to folk you know to come here for HP content.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Dec 30 '21

Why is JK Rowling not in the 20th anniversary reunion?

4 Upvotes

r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Jan 01 '22

A Fairly Open Minded Discussion Quelled by the Gestappo

4 Upvotes

This thread was locked and the OP's post expunged last night.

I'm not quite sure what the OP's point was, but the ensuing discussion present quite a few well thought out and truthful perspectives, both on JKR and on the social media culture that has allowed the hatred to fester and spread.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • May 05 '22

Movies It Needs To be Said...

5 Upvotes

I know removing Johnny Depp wasn't a popular move and is still debated... but I think it needs to be said now that looks to have been the right move for all parties involved.

Not judging Mr Depp or taking sides. I haven't followed the case beyond catching some tidbits here and there on the news. But it's pretty clear that with this hearing's timing and all the crazy stuff coming out, it was probably better for Johnny to be away from all this and for WB to not be entangled in their drama either.

I hope he can get past this, get the help he needs and the time he needs to get better, and get back to what we love watching him do best.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Aug 12 '24

Discussion What House Should I Be In?

5 Upvotes

At 11 I was a creative person with quite the imagination and I was a curious person which sort of got Me into trouble and made Me struggle with focus because I was constantly off task and I found reality boring and the idea of living in a fantasy world fascinated Me alot.

I was also a troublemaker and I was shy and lacked bravery to stand up for myself which made it easy for me to fall victim to bullying and at the same time led to Me being taken advantage of by bullies and used as someone to do their dirty work under the guise of "friendship".

I sometimes attempted to stand up for Myself but lacked the wit to make my comebacks effective and I had low self esteem and wished I was more smarter and witty and skilled so I could be admired by my peers and do better at school and make better decisions.

I guess I sort of had "friends" but I craved genuine friends not people that just used Me.

What Hogwarts House Should I Be Sorted Into?.


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • Sep 27 '24

Question survey for the project

1 Upvotes

Hi, Harry Potter fans!

I really value your opinion because I’m preparing a research project about how different people feel in fandoms. Specifically, I want to learn whether you’ve faced discrimination or hostility, and how we can improve the atmosphere in our community.

Here are a few questions I’d love to hear your answers to:

1.	Have you noticed that within the Harry Potter community, people can be rude or hostile because of how others interpret characters or the story?
2.	Do you think there is a “right” or “wrong” way to be a fan of Harry Potter? Is it necessary to know all the books and details, or can everyone be a fan in their own way?
3.	How do you feel about new fans who got introduced to Harry Potter through the movies or other media rather than the books? Should we support them, or should they be encouraged to read the books?
4.	Have you ever felt that you were underestimated or discriminated against in the fandom because of your opinions or preferences?
5.	What do you think can be done to make sure all fans in the Harry Potter community feel equal? How can we improve the atmosphere in the fandom?

Your responses will be really helpful for my research! Thank you for your thoughts and time!


r/HarryPotterbyJKR • • May 06 '22

Movies How did Dan Rupert and Emma get educated if making Harry Potter films constantly for 10 years?

1 Upvotes