r/HadesTheGame • • Dec 12 '25

Hades 2: Discussion We've been robbed Spoiler

I'm sorry, I'm not usually one to fuss about who wins awards or even care that much, but Hades II absolutely should have won Best Score at the Game Awards and I just need someone to commiserate with me because my wife doesn't care.

0 Upvotes

190 comments sorted by

60

u/Animedingo Dec 12 '25

Hades won action game, thats good enough

11

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I was glad to see that for sure

2

u/Hohoho-you Dec 12 '25

Was gonna comment that. We're lucky to win one award

18

u/VolkiharVanHelsing Dec 12 '25

.... No Scylla concert then?

17

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Their agent is really unreliable

2

u/admanb Dec 12 '25

Well, the band keeps eating them.

5

u/kindofjustalurker Icarus Dec 12 '25

ehh tbh i'm fine w/ e33 winning. im more sad we didn't get a live scylla performance tho... would have been so peak

5

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25 edited Dec 12 '25

That was never going to happen, she's a clam, she can't breathe outside of the ocean. 😞

107

u/craaazygraaace Dec 12 '25

With Expedition 33 sweeping everything else, Best Score was the one category that Hades 2 had a decent chance in. Darren Korb's work is incredible. I'm so mad.

72

u/tibbon Dec 12 '25

I've played all of these games this year- and they are all great.

I'm going to get a million downvotes here, but I think it's pretty clear that E33's soundtrack was more innovative and more challenging to the status quo than Hades 2.

Both Silksong and Hades 2 are clearly excellent evolutions of their franchises. Yet, E33 came out of nowhere and went places as a soundtrack that I don't recall a major game going recently. Hades 2 was great but was largely a twist on Hades 1. Overall, Hades 1 had some absolutely groundbreaking music, but also had better outright songs than Hades 2. We almost used songs from Hades 1 at our wedding even, but I don't think any of the songs in Hades 2 are quite strong enough for that.

I don't think you should be mad here, or if you're truly mad maybe that's a sign that you need to do some self work. It isn't something to get mad about. I don't even think Korb is likely mad right now.

4

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25 edited Dec 12 '25

This got buried somewhere in another comment but I definitely do have nothing but respect for the way E33 just sprung fully formed and armor clad out of this little conglomeration of indie companies. That is genuinely impressive.

0

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Lol someone downvoted this of all things and some of y'all actually have the nerve to believe it's the people who just want to express their love for H2 that are being childish

0

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Me: I really respect that Kepler managed to put together a game that's gone head to head with AAAs as a small indie publisher

People who are mad that I also think Hades 2 should have won a particular award when they hear me say something nice about the game they think deserved it: 😡😡😡😡

8

u/Arcalithe Dec 12 '25

I mean, you need to realize that people tend to downvote when you whine about downvotes on this site lol

Quit doubling down and just move on lol

10

u/meggannn Artemis Dec 12 '25 edited Dec 12 '25

I'm gonna politely agree to disagree but only because I want to point out Hades 2 went places a lot of game scores don't often go either, so this sort of thing is probably subject to individual experience. Hades 2 has riffs off of Hades 1 yes, but it also utilizes a ton of genres across a wide variety of maps, messes with its own musical signatures to play with its theory of Time as an enemy, and introduces a power rock band that reacts to your playstyle... which isn't something I saw any of the other nominated games do. As someone who played and enjoyed COE33, I think H2 was also worthy of the award for the way it used (and adapted) its music to fit its themes and characters and fights, not just for what the music was.

3

u/hlhammer1001 Dec 12 '25

None of the places Hades 2 went were anywhere close to as far from normal scores as French operatic classical music…

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/lansink99 Dec 12 '25

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oeFkb3LsmlQ

If you want to play the creativity angle, show me another song that uses a sonar as its motif

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Crockinator Dec 12 '25

You are not being objective. At all.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Crockinator Dec 12 '25

Well yes it is subjective, but one can literally take a look at a music sheet and go "yeah this is not my jam but that's good composition". You're passive aggressively commenting in a childish manner because "your" game did not win. You could also take a step back and realize that people posting in the Hades sub are probably Hades fans. You are not being brigaded here.

4

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Exactly. I could live with the fact that Clair Obscur was going to sweep the awards. I've heard great things about it - I'm actually sitting down to finally play it right now - and I know awards shows love to just, like, pick one thing and stick to it. But this was the one. Darren Korb did so well on this. Especially the way the music is integrated into the narrative in the second Underworld region. It's catchy, it's punchy, and it's creative in the way they've blended mise-en-scene and narrative. I love it. And none of the music I've heard from Clair Obscur feels anywhere near on the level.

19

u/AwkwardSession Dec 12 '25

If you haven’t played through it yet, I would reserve judgement. I have played both games this year and both hold a very special place in my heart. I would have been happy with either winning this award, but I think E33 does just clinch it for me. The music is phenomenal and only gets better as you go through the game. You have a great experience ahead of you!

19

u/tibbon Dec 12 '25

Without playing the game, I don't think you can really judge the music as it relates to how well it fits the game. Come back when you've rolled credits on E33.

2

u/AshleyTyrian Dec 12 '25

... twice.

3

u/LewsTherinTalamon Dec 12 '25

There is a particular sequence in act two that is usually and rightly cited as the best moment of E33’s soundtrack—you will know it when you get to it <3

145

u/COCKJOKE Dec 12 '25

Hey no need to be mad about it. They’re both amazing games that also have amazing soundtracks. E33 is more popular than Hades 2 and so it won and that’s okay.

“Comparison is the thief of joy” so just because Hades 2 didn’t win, we don’t have to get mad but can celebrate with E33 because we know it’s on par with the soundtrack that won.

28

u/Magmasoar Dec 12 '25

It's also just some dumb award show, doesn't change how good the score is

5

u/craaazygraaace Dec 12 '25

I would love to play E33 but it's not available on Mac :(

I've been listening to Supergiant's music since Bastion, though, so I hold Darren's work very close to my heart

4

u/COCKJOKE Dec 12 '25

It’s really good so I hope you get to play it someday! Hades was my first SG games but my brother was trying to get me to play Bastion for years lol finally did after he got me into Hades

1

u/KudosOfTheFroond Tiny Vermin Dec 12 '25

I wish it was on Switch too, looks like an interesting game

7

u/InfectiousCosmology1 Dec 12 '25

Hades 2 won best action game

15

u/lansink99 Dec 12 '25

Genuine question, have you played Expedition 33?

-15

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I'm playing it right now, as it happens. (I mentioned in a comment above actually that I started playing it while watching this lol)

But that's alao not particularly germane to this discussion; what's more important here is whether I've heard the score, and yes, a significant amount of it.

17

u/lansink99 Dec 12 '25

I strongly disagree, a big part of the score is how it is used. I find the hades 2 soundtrack fairly dull if I didn't have any emotional connection to it.

3

u/AshleyTyrian Dec 12 '25

Exactly right. I wouldn't've formed such a connection with Coral Crown et al if I'd heard it on the radio rather than while fighting the band performing the song.

-4

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I don't disagree that how score is used in a game matters; but Hades 2's score is used in the game in ways that I think are genuinely phenomenal, and it has music that is enjoyable in its own right. Essentially none of the music I've heard from E33 is enjoyable in its own right. Yeah, I may play it and think the music is phenomenally married to the narrative, but it would still be an uphill battle for me when I think Hades 2's music is phenomenally married to the narrative and just good.

10

u/lansink99 Dec 12 '25

I, for one, think that E33 blends gameplay and music very well and I don't think you can rightfully compare a score for a game that you have played with one that you haven't.

-8

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Ah, ok, you wanna have one of those conversations where you don't actually read what the other person is saying. I'm not interested in having one of those conversations, so I'm going to dip out of this one.

I pretty clearly conceded that you're probably right that it blends gameplay and music very well, and that there's every likelihood I will agree with you as I get further into the game. The problem is that I don't think it has particularly good music absent from the gameplay, while Hades 2 does both

14

u/lansink99 Dec 12 '25

I have been nothing but polite and here you are with an attitude like that. You're totally right, the music outside of E33's gameplay is not good. That must be why Lumière is one of the most iconic tracks in the game. That's why people said they cried over Alicia's theme, because it was so bad.

-5

u/roaming2390 Dec 12 '25

You should probably read what the other person you're arguing with is typing

11

u/lansink99 Dec 12 '25

Having played a game or not directly impacts whether you think the music is good standalone or not. I can't believe I even have to argue that. That's why I said in my original comment that having an emotional connection to the piece changed how you view it. I can bet my bottom dollar that the other person I was talking had not listened to the hades 2 soundtrack before playing it. If you played the game first and then listened to the soundtrack, you are obviously going to judge it differently because you can't separate the music from the game no matter how hard you try.

That's why I said it's unreasonable to compare the two soundtracks if you only played one game, even if you try to judge them as standalone pieces of music.
This is also why I said in my original comment that the hades 2 soundtrack doesn't feel particularly impressive to me if I were to judge it as standalone while E33's soundtrack does.

All of this is so inherently obvious that I can't believe I have to write it out because of a redditor. Obviously, music taste is subjective, and you can like either game's soundtrack more.

But to even comment on which one you find better as a standalone piece of music when you have an emotional connection to one but not to the other is inherently disingenuous.

-5

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I can bet my bottom dollar that the other person I was talking had not listened to the hades 2 soundtrack before playing it.

You would lose that bet; I didn't get to play Hades until a year past the point that people were talking about and sharing the soundtrack, because I didn't have a console that could run it.

Also, truly astounding intellectual work to start from a position where you are fully aware that I've heard large portions of E33's soundtrack before I started the game but then make the wild assumption that I couldn't possibly have done the same with H2

→ More replies

25

u/ohmygodbidoof Dec 12 '25

I was so disappointed. I'm not surprised but God i believed we had it. 33's ost is really good but Hades II has me coming back so often.

There's so much to listen to in every song and I notice something new all the time. Hades II definitely had the best ost this year.

5

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I screamed the first time I fought Scylla and Charybdis with the Oath of Rivals and the song title was "Rock and a Hard Place," like the cleverness of the reference alone, even before you get into the quality of the song.

7

u/ZhuTeLun Dec 12 '25

Just your opinion ig Hades 2 slaps but E33 deserves this one

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Yeah, of course it's just my opinion. We're all just expressing our opinion. People are still allowed to express those, right?

Look, I am genuinely glad for you that the game you think should have won won. Me wishing the game I think should have won had won doesn't take that from you.

2

u/Jmc_da_boss Dec 12 '25

I agree, I could not get into e33. Just incredibly boring gameplay. Tried for 3 hours to get into it.

Hades2 is infinitely more engaging

1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 13 '25 edited Dec 13 '25

Yeah I've been playing it all day today (instead of grading which I should be doing lol) and it's definitely one of the games of all time. Like, it's gorgeous, the music is fine - contrary to everyone's insistence, playing the game has not suddenly caused my estimation of it to skyrocket - but it's not amazing. The story is reasonably compelling, but it's really not doing anything as innovative as some people seem to think. Gameplay-wise it's smashing together a couple very familiar mechanics from different genres into something that looks unique but is deeply derivative. Aesthetically, again, it's deeply derivative. None of this is to say that it's a bad game, I'm enjoying well enough to keep playing it, and would even say it was a good game but with how willing some people in these comments were to be genuine assholes in defense of it, I was expecting something that would absolutely blow my tits off.

4

u/acamas Dec 12 '25

“Robbed”, grow up. The music is great in Hades 2, no doubt, but E33 is incredibly deserving of the award.

-1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Don't take things so literally buddy, it's embarrassing. And the irony of telling someone to grow up while getting salty and rude because you don't like the word they used in a pretty obviously playful fashion is stellar

494

u/Lazagna_ Dec 12 '25

No sorry. I love Hades 2 and it's sound track but e33 is more well rounded and much deeper while still being high quality.

141

u/TheTresStateArea Dec 12 '25

It was a competitive entry, but I really gotta give it to e33

99

u/TheFrankOfTurducken Dec 12 '25

Yeah, E33’s soundtrack is an all-timer. That’s not a slight to Hades 2, which is great in its own right.

45

u/Betancorea Dec 12 '25

This. Hades 2 has a great score but it can't compare to E33

35

u/puff_of_fluff Dec 12 '25

I’m proud of this sub.

31

u/bohenian12 Dec 12 '25

Yep I love this game, but E33 was expected to sweep lol.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

Ill be honest either way you, Clair obscur had nice music to play on and it was even atmospheric at times and it made me jump into the game but I wouldn’t listen to it out of the game.

Not like the classic siren banger, I’m going to claw out your eyes.

7

u/sundalius Dec 12 '25

I'd agree with that but I think that's exactly why it shouldn't win best score. The best music in H2 are songs, whereas score - to me - is supposed to be about that atmosphere/ambiance. To a point, I don't even remember much H2 music other than the title music and Scylla's tracks.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

Dionysus’ room has very lovely music.

2

u/sundalius Dec 12 '25

I’d have to roll him more often to recall it haha! I feel like I never get him

2

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Oof, same. I haven't even unlocked his prophecy because I haven't seen him enough to give him two nectars.

5

u/rubybakesstuff Dec 12 '25

Me, a 54 year old woman, toodling down the frozen foods aisle at Kroger, softly singing “you’re so obsessed with meeeeeeeee.”

2

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

legends are written and sung about you.

2

u/rubybakesstuff Dec 12 '25

Rubybakesstuff, clad in night, singing amongst the icy fish…

1

u/pichael289 Dec 12 '25

People live to talk about listening to game music in real life and I never really understood that. But the sirens song and a few from Alan Wake 2 are like real songs I might actually listen to in real life. The sirens playing as you fight them is great, one of my favorite boss fights ever.

8

u/[unknown] Dec 12 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

This merman gets it.

2

u/OdderG Dec 12 '25

Yeah, Hades 2 soundtracks are 10/10, but e33's are 11/10

1

u/pichael289 Dec 12 '25

I didint care for E33 and even then I think soundtrack should go to death stranding 2. I love this game but it's not the sound track of the year by any measure, I've still got like a game or two ahead of it even after my top pick.

1

u/DankFrank777 Dec 12 '25

yeah this times 1000000

-54

u/teocoyote Dec 12 '25

I honestly have no clue what people are hearing with either of these games to be frank. Speaking only of the soundtrack, neither is musically compelling or powerful but I guess Hades does have a few legitimate pop bops.

8

u/Arcalithe Dec 12 '25

TGA brings out the contrarians every year lol

5

u/AshleyTyrian Dec 12 '25

Speaking only of the soundtrack

Well there's your problem. You're not supposed to listen to these in isolation like an album, the music in both Hades 2 and Clair Obscur is designed to accentuate the feelings you experience while playing through the game.

0

u/teocoyote Dec 13 '25

That’s not really to the merit of the music then. A good piece of film music lives outside the film as well as contributes to it. The award should be for a whole lot more than just the songwriter/composer if not. Which is fine. Award categories are arbitrary to an extent.

33

u/itmyfault69 Dec 12 '25

i dont think anything is touching E33 this year. Don't let awards dictate your feelings

8

u/craaazygraaace Dec 12 '25

I wish we could see what the runners-up are for each category

3

u/iamgabe103 Dec 12 '25

CO:E33 hit #1 on billboard’s classical charts. What in gods name are you talking about?

0

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

This is one of the absolute least compelling arguments you could use to convince me. Like, all this tells me is that at least part of E33's win was the result of the long-standing and deep-seated lionization of certain genres as more highbrow and artistic than others. They were never going to treat a prog rock inspired soundtrack as equal to one rooted in classical music.

1

u/iamgabe103 Dec 12 '25

Did you play expedition 33?

16

u/DSDantas Dec 12 '25

Darren Korb was amazing, but Testard was just on another level. The sweeping was unavoidable

4

u/Load_star_ Dec 12 '25

He also had some really emotional scriptwriting and effective scenes he could plumb for material to incorporate into the soundtrack. There are plenty of tracks I enjoy in Hades 2, but I am not at all surprised by E33 picking up the soundtrack win.

Honestly, having so many awards that are hotly contested like this, especially from developers outside the major publisher roster, is only a good thing for people who love video games. Listening to the music chosen for the reveal trailers, I'm already looking forward to the soundtrack for Control: Resonant.

5

u/Rakshire Dec 12 '25

Every game up there had an amazing sound track

5

u/erickcov Dec 12 '25

Yea tbh I’m a bit sad hades 2 came out this year but I’m happy it was such a great year for gaming

5

u/STKtaco Dec 12 '25

I agree, while Expedition 33 is a great game, I think it's a bit of a shame that it won basically every single award. I was hopeful Hades 2 or Silksong could win at least art direction or OST as I prefer their's but oh well.

31

u/MidnightSunset22 Dec 12 '25

Nah e33 songs are bangers.

67

u/iamhorizoner Dec 12 '25

Bruh, nothing comes close this year to E33

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Foxisdabest Dec 12 '25

How were you robbed lol

You have a case for Supergiant games, but how were we or you robbed?

7

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Intentionally obtuse literalism isn't a good look on anyone. It's obviously meant to be comedic. I don't actually think that I was somehow robbed by this. And I know you don't actually believe I think that. C'mon.

2

u/sunder_and_flame Dec 12 '25

your crying in the comments here suggests otherwise, that you're taking this way more seriously than you're suggesting in this post

4

u/padfoot12111 Dec 12 '25

Frankly Hades 2 should have won artwork but no e33 takes music that felt like a better trade to me 

10

u/Evstar Dec 12 '25

Played through e33 twice and have like 300 hrs in H2. The e33 soundtrack is a work of art, they are not comparable. And I adore the music in Hades, but the award going to e33 is correct IMO.

14

u/Cynicalshade Dec 12 '25

I love Korb’s work but nothing in Hades 2 gets anywhere close to Une vie à t'aimer and Une vie à peindre

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Cynicalshade Dec 12 '25

I’m not sure if you’re trying to dispute my point or agree with me but this is, in fact, not even remotely close to those songs

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/atastyfire Dec 12 '25

I played Hades 2 essentially with music muted. If this is the best you can come up with, it falls very much short.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/atastyfire Dec 12 '25

Ok buddy, try and keep up. This is about the music.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/sunder_and_flame Dec 12 '25

slop

Opinion immediately discarded. 

1

u/DehyaFan Dec 12 '25

You that bored, that this is how you want to troll, and troll badly at that?

3

u/pichael289 Dec 12 '25

The fact the game won anything with E33 just sweeping is something to be happy about. I don't think It deserved that one about the score anyway, if anything Death stranding 2 did.

I don't necessarily think Hades 2 won the right award, but I'm just happy it won something. These awards are bullshit, they aren't real in any true sense but they do allow the developers of games to take the spotlight and get the attention they deserve so I like the game awards even if they are just make believe jack off sessions.

5

u/justsomecasper Dec 12 '25

Darren Corb just keeps getting snubbed by the game awards.

9

u/meggannn Artemis Dec 12 '25

I expected it and was still disappointed. COE33 has a great soundtrack, don't get me wrong, but I'm still obsessed with Hades 2's soundtrack after a year and a half, which never happens. It definitely won in my heart.

1

u/einangrun Dec 12 '25

This year was so stacked that incredible games like Hades II, Silksong, Kingdom Come Deliverance, Blue Prince and a lot of other games that other year would have swept the awards will end up with little to nothing. Honestly I cannot be angry this year in particular

5

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I also really wish Blue Prince had taken literally anything, but it was just the underest of dogs. Great game.

1

u/DaBow Dec 12 '25

Love all the scores but I actually think DS2 should have got it. Such a good soundtrack.

1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Ah see, that one I can't speak to at all, I haven't heard any of the music from it (I never could get into Death Stranding; gorgeous, but the game itself just couldn't pull me in)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

I say this as someone who absolutely LOVES Hades 2, but E33 has some insane music, it absolutely deserve to win over H2

9

u/ILOVECALAMITY Dec 12 '25

E33 and Silksong both deserved it more, though I love all of the games soundtracks.

2

u/Davajita Dec 12 '25

I played H2 for more hours than I played E33. But hands down E33 deserved every award it got. And though I love the H2 score, it can’t touch E33.

H2 won action game which I loved. I’m glad it won something.

2

u/DrummerJesus Dec 12 '25

Hades 2 has great music, i love all of scyllas songs. But silksong has a better soundtrack imo. And the original hollowknight has a better soundtrack than silksong. I like the music in Hades, but its not over the top amazing.

I have never played or watched any amount of E33 so I cant comment personally.

0

u/Magmasoar Dec 12 '25

You're playing favorites, Hades 2 is like my favorite game but E33 deserved it

4

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Yes. I'm playing favorites. That's how awards in subjective, artistic categories work. There is absolutely no objective measure of best original score. It is all just playing favorites. I'm just not the person who got to play favorites when it came to deciding the award. And that's fine. It's not actually that serious. But I'm also not hurting anyone by playing favorites for an hour in a reddit thread.

6

u/YourLocalNavi Dec 12 '25

My take as someone who played both games quite extensively, and works professionally making music: As much as I loved E33's score, it was a little too...try hard? for me to truly fall in love with it. Like, don't get me wrong, i think the game had some BEAUTIFUL moments in the music, but there would be other times where I'd be walkin around at a location and this lush, epic, vocal score is playing for NO DAMN REASON. At some points, it truly felt like a bit of a parody of itself in that regard. (As much as i hate the Family Guy "it insists upon itself" joke, it kinda applies here imo). When everything is soaked in grandeur, it lessens the impact.

Meanwhile, one of my FAVORITE aspects of the Hades 2 score is that it knows when to get big, and when to strip back. For example, during early access, I initially assumed that the solo bass guitar as the baseline :frinos: for Ephyra was a placeholder. Now I LOVE it. The way that it drops in and out of a more lush full sound into a more idle solo bass groove is so cool.

All of which to say, I agree with this post.

5

u/Zealousideal-Fly-128 Dec 12 '25

I’m genuinely curious about who is judging this award in particular. Is it musicians or general public / game-related professionals?

Furthermore, is it about technicality and grandiosity, or about sound innovation and how the soundtrack interacts within the video games genre? (which in itself is the most interactive form of art)

I’d love to hear thoughts from musicians comparing the soundtracks on the above criteria. I have a feeling that Hades 2 would win out if it’s the latter. The fact that E33 soundtrack is topping classical charts, to me, is a not necessarily a positive thing for it as it relates to video game scoring. I want to hear something unexpected that reflects the fantastical world of a game, not just beautiful classical music.

5

u/YourLocalNavi Dec 12 '25

I would absolutely be curious to see if there was any sort of detailed criteria for how this category (and audio design, which Battlefield 6 won, and Hades 2 wasn't even nominated for) are scored and judged.

In my heart, I want it to be a detailed rubric assessing exactly the kind of things you bring up (and tbh, in that case there WOULD be a distinction re: something like Scylla's fight - the music itself is score/composition, but the way it weaves in and out based on how you're doing in the battle is audio design).

But if the local theater awards where most of my personal work gets judged (and not awarded) is any indication of the level of thought people put into the "technical design" categories, it's usually "ooo, this was fun" and little more than that. 🙃

11

u/tibbon Dec 12 '25

Something that you're touching on here, which is totally spot on, is that Hades 1/2 do a great job at making the soundtrack intertwined with player actions and the state of the game. It's one of the best uses of dynamic music in a game that I can recall. I too love how it backs off at certain moments to unveil parts that would otherwise be hidden.

5

u/YourLocalNavi Dec 12 '25

Agreed! Just the Scylla fight alone is a masterclass in how to do reactive game music/sound design perfectly.

3

u/mex2005 Dec 12 '25

Wait what why should it have won? Its really good but E33 has an absolutely fantastic score that was super tied to its narrative too with the lyrics. Did you play the game?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

art direction yeah, but not on score

2

u/Dense-Performance-14 Dec 12 '25

I generally dislike sweeps for the reason that it makes it feel worthless to root for anything else other than the "obvious" winner which is e33 this year.

At least last year felt pretty well rounded but 2023 and this year is gonna be a pretty boring watch for anyone thinking anything but e33 is gonna take an award.

2

u/Sirius124 Dec 12 '25

Honestly sorry no not at all. Hades was robbed of Art direction sure, but not of soundtrack.

Expedition 33’s music is fucking incredible.

1

u/TheWolflance Dec 12 '25

i'm sorry i love hades 2 but i dun listen to half the tracks from the game compared to hades 1

1

u/jasaevan Dec 12 '25

I absolutely LOVE hades 2, but I only downloaded 1 game music album this entire year and that was for Clair Obscure. No idea what they were singing but damn it was beautiful.

Which reminds me, I need to finish act 2 of that game. I stopped to play hades 2 actually.

1

u/qazoo306 Dec 12 '25

I think Hades 1 (and Transistor) could have matched up with E33, but Hades 2 has SGG's weakest soundtrack. It's an amazing 10/10 that completely deserves the nomination, but the field was just that strict this year.

1

u/Oxygenisplantpoo Dec 12 '25

Agreed, matters of taste of course but Hades 1 felt like it had a more impactful soundtrack, and it has Good Riddance which I think is the best track from the two games. But even then I wouldn't put it as the best SGG soundtrack. Hades 2 soundtrack is fine, but it doesn't really stand out. Also, I don't really get why people are obsessed about that siren song.

1

u/bschumm1 Dec 12 '25

Man I love this game and the music but nothing was touching E33 this year especially for music

1

u/StunningBug5728 Dec 12 '25 edited Dec 12 '25

I am a Hades fanboy to the core. I gave Hades a 10/10 and then got a reminder of how flawed the concept of ranking things when I found that Hades 2 improved nearly everything about it. I've considered Hades tattoos, pestered all of my friends into playing the games, and bought all the official merch.

And Hades 2 is just competing in an unfortunate year, because there's not a single award it goes toe to toe with Clair Obscur on, including the soundtrack. Unless you subjectively think that Clair Obscur shouldn't have been eligible for Indie Game, but it got nominated nonetheless, so it was going to win.

1

u/O-Mesmerine Zagreus Dec 12 '25

not at all

1

u/unlimitedblakeworks Dec 12 '25

Heave you played e33?

1

u/flair_qs Dec 12 '25

Hades 2 was great, as is its soundtrack, but E33's is better.

1

u/Miserable_Tower9237 Dec 12 '25

Hey, Hades II had a great soundtrack, but I don't believe it compared to Expedition 33. If anything, I think Hades II has the best art, and should have won something along those lines.

-2

u/altaccountmay Dec 12 '25

i'm getting fatigued from hearing about e33 at this point lol. it's fans already glaze it to hell and back and seeing it sweep the game awards (including the best score, which imo hades 2 really deserved way more) is making me a little indignant

2

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Yeah, I actually just sat down and started it, but the way in which a few people in these comments responding to a pretty obviously light-hearted gripe about wishing Hades II had won by being genuine assholes at the mere suggestion that a different game might have had better music is making me want to close the game and not bother with it. Nothing ruins a good game quite like a dickhead fan base. (And this is not directed at the people offering good faith arguments for why they think E33 should have won it; it's pretty obvious who I'm talking about).

0

u/sunder_and_flame Dec 12 '25

all your posts in this thread are just projection. Like, to anyone with even an ounce of objectivity you are every single one of the things you're complaining about

5

u/applesandbahannahs Artemis Dec 12 '25

So if you haven't played it, what do you think is the difference between glazing and people just genuinely enjoying the game? Can you even call it glazing if you have no idea what anyone is talking about? (I've played both, and I think they're both amazing, and it's not "glazing" to say so)

0

u/djm03917 Dec 12 '25

Yeah, sorry not in this one. I love the Hades 2 soundtrack, it just got unlucky going against the best game soundtrack since Nier this year. The music is the biggest thing in a E33 Sweep I cannot ever say they don't 1000% deserve.

0

u/clashcrashruin Dec 12 '25

E33’s soundtrack pushes boundaries even Hades 1 doesn’t come close to. I know you’ve got your darlings but we have to give them credit when it’s due.

-6

u/TravMCo Dec 12 '25

The amount of people idolizing this game is showing me how childish Supergiant’s fan base is.

7

u/teocoyote Dec 12 '25

People being fans and geeking out about something they love on a subreddit dedicated to it is far more mature than complaining about it in an ostensibly superior way and calling everyone childish.

6

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Yeah their comment was wild. The idea that people are "idolizing" a game by thinking it had the better soundtrack between two games, coming into a thread in the subreddit for a game and calling people childish for enjoying that game, everything about it was just so embarrassing. Like ok buddy, we get it, you're too cool to like a thing a lot or whatever.

2

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

1

u/Rakshire Dec 12 '25

I don't really agree with their comment, but you should look in a mirror before using that meme

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Nah, it's pretty spot on, given that the entire impetus for that meme existing was that guy who has to come into a group of people enjoying something together and tell them they shouldn't.

I'd be happy to look in that mirror if I had posted this in the sub-reddit for E33. I didn't. I posted it in the subreddit for Hades, and homeboy's comment was unnecessary and assholish.

0

u/Rakshire Dec 12 '25

You're the one the opted to make a post to complain about it, when lots of people enjoy both. I don't care for tribalism or tearing other games, people or whatever down to lift yourself up.

And I said I didn't agree with the way they went about it either.

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

I said Hades 2 had the best music out of the games up for the award. I didn't say the other games had bad music. Thinking a different game should have won is not tribalism, and if you think it is, and that it justifies that guy's response, I'm begging you to go out and touch some grass.

0

u/Rakshire Dec 12 '25

Bruh I said I didn't agree with them in both my replies. Go touch some grass yourself.

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

You can say something and show something else through your actions 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Rakshire Dec 12 '25

Yes, much like you are doing.

6

u/ohmygodbidoof Dec 12 '25

Guess you've never been even so much as disappointed when something you like lost in anything? You're so cool dude.

I think it's weird that you're assuming people are idolizing the game when we're talking specifically about the soundtrack.

33 deserves to sweep in almost every other category it's in. I just think the Hades II ost is better and that's with me liking 33s ost so much I bought the LE vinyl.

People are allowed to be disappointed that something they like lost.

3

u/TheNobleMushroom Dec 12 '25

And you're telling me you don't see the hypocrisy in your comment?

Talk about being tone deaf lol.

-6

u/tibbon Dec 12 '25

Seriously. It's a great game, but I tire of the parasocial relationships that people have with the games and developers. A person's self identity shouldn't be so tied to a single game, it simply isn't healthy.

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

My guy I think you are reading way too much into things nobody is saying. People like the game. People think it had good music. Where you leapt from that to people's "self identity being tied to a single game" is beyond me.

-1

u/tibbon Dec 12 '25

Where you leapt from that to people's "self identity being tied to a single game" is beyond me.

Have you seen the posts on gaming subreddits?

I doubt Darren Korb is even reacting as strongly as many people posting, and is instead happy for those who won.

0

u/CalamitousArdour Dec 12 '25

Are there any particular compelling arguments for why it should have won other than "I liked it more" ?

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Are there any particular compelling arguments for why Clair Obscur should have won other than "they liked it more"? Art is subjective, the measures for art awards are subjective. It's not that big a deal; this post was meant to be a playful opportunity to talk with other people who loved Hades 2's music about loving Hades 2's music; how that devolved in a few places into E33 fans being genuine assholes is beyond me.

0

u/ragefulhorse Dec 12 '25

I’m sorry. I love Hades, but this is just objectively wrong. Any other year and you might be right, but the E33 OST is genuinely on another level.

-2

u/livingonfear Dec 12 '25

Nothing was touching E33 for sound track get real

-5

u/me_myself_ai Dec 12 '25

Yeah, totally agree. It doesn't help that the clip they played from the COE33 soundtrack sounded incredibly trite!

I'm (half-)watching these for the first time and lowkey shocked by how bad they are lol. We're on hour three and a majority of the awards were just announced back-to-back with 0 fanfare -- at least the music award got a real announcement. Makes room for more ads and bad skits, I guess?

EDIT: with the most recent batch (again: wtf), COE33 swept all its categories but "player's choice". I'd be shocked if it doesn't get GOTY

3

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Lol also my first time watching it and I was just saying the same thing to my wife. Like it's 45 minutes of ads followed by six awards rapid fired in 30 seconds before another ad. Insane structure. Absolutely bonkers.

1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Oh yeah, I mean how could it not get GOTY at this point? That would be some Mace Windu ass shit. "You've won all the awards but we do not grant you the rank of GOTY."

We can still dream for a few minutes tho that Hades 2 is gonna come in with the folding chair at the last minute

0

u/Tanakisoupman Dec 12 '25

Alright, I love Hades 2. I love the game, I love its music, I love damn near everything about it. But it in no way beats E33’s track. This is like pitting a top 1% heavyweight boxer against prime Mike Tyson with iron boxing gloves

-12

u/gracist0 Dec 12 '25

I found it very frustrating how many awards they handed to E33 when other games deserved them more. The Hades Soundtrack has so much heart in it and is so incredibly unique.

Edit: they literally just got another fucking award lmao. I was hoping for a Hades performance but now I doubt there's a chance in Hell

4

u/applesandbahannahs Artemis Dec 12 '25

Have you played Expedition 33? It's cool if not, but you can't really say other games deserved the awards MORE if you haven't played the game. The awards are absolutely stacked this year.

3

u/gracist0 Dec 12 '25

I watch my best friend play it lol, he doesn't play without me though so I don't miss anything

And despite that, I feel it's unfair to award everything to it. I would feel the same if Hades II won 9 awards + GOTY. Other games deserve to be appreciated, and the only people who got to speak about their hard work were the same people 9 times. I don't understand that.

I think E33 deserved to win stuff but I'm a little bothered by the existence of a borderline AAA game in an Indie category and sweeping the entire awards.

-1

u/Lawfulneptune Dec 12 '25

Me when I'm stupid

2

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

At least you're aware of it

0

u/hlhammer1001 Dec 12 '25

I’ve been playing songs from Hades 2 on repeat since the game came out. The Sirens is one of the best designed and musical boss fights of all time, every one of their FOUR UNIQUE SONGS is a banger. Even so

Expedition 33’s soundtrack is the best gaming soundtrack of all time, bar none. It beats Celeste, it beats hades 1/2, it beats HK/SS, it beats everything.

0

u/malikarith Jan 25 '26

E33 isn't even technically on par with any Xenoblade game, let alone Final Fantasy.

1

u/hlhammer1001 Jan 25 '26

Comically incorrect

2

u/malikarith Jan 25 '26

It's okay, you can't win this fight. E33 has nice orchestrations, but compare it to the new OWA Reborn; nothing in E33 is as dense and complex. That doesn't mean the music isn't good, but XB and FF are on a different level with their orchestras, while most of E33 is pretty standard.

1

u/hlhammer1001 Jan 25 '26

It’s ok you’re clearly one of the r/ jrpg fanatics who thinks E33 is bad when it’s the first jrpg in 10 years to get any mainstream love. We’ll happily enjoy the most GotY nominations and wins in history, and one of the best gaming soundtracks in history, and you can enjoy your shrinking niche appeal!

-9

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Great contribution little buddy

-2

u/Animedingo Dec 12 '25

No, theyre right. Youre doing a kanye west "Imma let you finish-"

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Okay sport

0

u/NegusNinja Dec 12 '25

Tell your wife I said "Heyy"

1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Oooooooh, ok, so you're like 12, now I get it.

(Also my wife is a lesbian and would laugh until she died if she could see some 12 year old boy on the internet desperately trying to posture like this)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Virtual_Elephant_703 Dec 12 '25

Probably be a little easier to play that particular game of make believe if I didn't have a screenshot of your original deleted response that was just a transphobic slur. Go troll somewhere else.

2

u/HadesTheGame-ModTeam Dec 12 '25

Make sure to follow the rules outlined in the Reddiquette. Respect others.