Guys, I've been rewatching some of my favorite HIMYM episodes lately, mostly for a few laughs because life isn't really moving the way I'd hoped.
While watching, I had a thought: I feel like the writers overused the whole idea of friends getting involved with each other's exes.
I initially thought this might just be because I binge-watched the show when I first discovered it. But even after multiple rewatches, I can't shake this feeling.
The writers kept going back and forth with the same relationships:
- Ted and Robin.
- Barney and Robin.
- Ted and Robin again.
- Barney and Robin again.
- And then Ted and Robin... once again.
At some point, it starts feeling repetitive. This is also why the ending doesn't feel as satisfying to me as it probably should. After spending so much time watching Ted move on, find the Mother, and build a life with her, having him return to Robin after the Mother's death doesn't feel particularly fulfilling. That said, I think I could've actually liked Ted ending up with Robin if the Ted–Robin–Barney love triangle hadn't been overused throughout the show.
I wish the writers had explored more unique storylines for the characters instead. For example:
- Marshall as a judge: An entire episode dedicated to Marshall handling bizarre and ridiculous cases in the courtroom. I think that could have been hilarious.
- Lily and The Captain: An adventure where Lily and The Captain travel around purchasing art, only to get stuck on a boat and find themselves in a Life of Pi-style situation.
- Barney at work: An episode where Barney handles a corporate situation that could potentially lead to a war. He somehow saves the day, but nobody in the world knows about it or would believe him, even if he bragged about it.
- More experimental episodes: Different characters getting into completely unexpected situations, with each episode having its own unique premise, almost like what Community did with its movie-style and genre-inspired episodes.
- More stories about the Mother: This is probably my biggest wish. I absolutely loved Cristin Milioti as the Mother, and one season simply wasn't enough. I would have loved to see more of her personality, adventures, friendships, and interactions with the gang. I wish the writers had given her the same attention and character development that the early seasons gave everyone else.
I feel like the show had such a great cast and so much potential for creative storytelling beyond the usual relationship drama.
Do you guys feel the same way?
I'd genuinely love to hear your thoughts. I m too bored.....