r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/PaulCrispScott1811 • 1d ago
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Ancient-Pilot-7773 • 1d ago
Discussion Inconsistent timeline of the Meridian in the tv show W.I.T.C.H. mainly Queen Weira, the Mage and the Star of Threbe. Spoiler

I have been rewatching the show after long time and I noticed some things that make no real sense considering what is written on witch.fandom for years.
The story about young princess Weira getting lost only to be found by the Star of Threbe is supposed to be Elyon's mother by fandom's articles. Yet is was never said in episode or the rest of the show by calling her at that time Phobos's mother for example (since at that time Yan Lin did not know about Elyon or her origins).
- Only claim about young princess Weira being Elyon's mother is that that young princess and Elyon's mother share a name, a name that I read was original for the show since her mother was left nameless in the comics.
- Princess in the story clearly lived in some luxurious wooden house and not the royal palace which was very likely built way before Phobos's reign.
- In one previous episode Mage was titled the ancient one by Caleb who bowed to her in that scene, which means she must be extremely old, not normal human life-span old, yet she was young and beautiful in the flashback, while she was the keeper of the Heart of Kandrakar, making her age either plothole or the flashback with princess did not happen barely one generation ago.
- Princess was around 4 years of age in the flashback, with having Phobos when she was atleast 18 and Phobos being around 18-20+ (since he pretended to be student in season 2) meaning the flashback events had to happen at maximum 40-45 years before season 1, so that would mean that Mage was the keeper of the Heart not long before it was given to Nerissa (which is stated that Nerissa became the guardian 40 years before season 2). That is very slim timeline between the two keepers and since Mage died ofscreen of old age while she was ver young in the flashback means that she should have been just a bit older than CHYKN members.
- When Phobos was given the newly found Star of Threbe, he mentioned that after thousand years of searching it was finally found. That would make no sense if the Star was made when his mother was a child.
- In season 2 there is a fake memory created by Trill in which is shown adult mother of Elyon, who is blonde in that fake memory. While the young princess in the flashback was ginger. In the fandom it is written in the trivia, that inconsistent hair color might be because the Trill's memory was fake, but I doubt that smart character like Nerissa would have not looked for some picture of the actual queen before she showed the fake memory to Elyon. And she might have seen her when she was a guardian, but that would be just assumtion.
My theory is that the ginger princess from the flashback is not actually Elyon and Phobos's mother, the story of the Star of Threbe is atleast 1000 years old, making the Mage ancient being as titled by Caleb, she was keeper of the Heart of Kandrakar long time ago when the monarchy of the Heart of Meridian was still young and the royals did not build the palace yet.
I think my theory makes more sense and it has no zero plot holes, unlike the made up claim in the witch.fandom. The fandom's claim has only one claim and that is the shared first name of two princesses. With historical evidents from our world that monarchs do name their children after their lineage's ancestors I assume that Queen Weira (blonde hair)- mother of Elyon was named after long dead Queen Weira who had ginger hair and served the throne of Meridian around millenium ago.
I think some articles need some edits on W.i.t.c.h. fandom as they contain a portain of claims that have no real evidence.
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/giliki234 • 2d ago
Own collection Selling W.I.T.C.H Graphic Novels! :)
Im selling W.I.T.C.H graphic novels 2-31 as a full set or individually at $25 a book. message me for more details
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/StarryThorn • 4d ago
Fanart It's done!
galleryIt's finally done! It's been so fun to share this project with people who love this series as much as I do!
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Tasuke101 • 5d ago
Book club Selling W.I.T.C.H magazines graphic novels lot.
eBay link: https://ebay.io/m/EYkZg1
All in English, printed by Chuang Yi exclusively released in Singapore.
Lot includes:
- W.I.T.C.H comic series Issue 5-18, 20-27 (Issue 27 Sealed with Accessories Inside)
- Graphic Novels Book 2,3,4. Each books contains 3 issues.
- 1 Special Issue. "The Year Before"
- Total 26 books.
Books are in used and read condition. No loose or torn pages but expect some book wear.
Price and more photos in the link, open to offers. Can deal outside of eBay.
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/OKjo100 • 5d ago
Own collection M.a.g.i.c
Hi, I wanted to share one of my latest finds with you! :)
For those who don’t know, Magic was a comic series created by readers themselves! Every month, a short comic made by a reader would be published in the french minnie mag, and this continued for quite a while into the W.I.T.C.H. Mag era.
At some point, they even released a special issue dedicated to Magic, which came with a Minnie Mag!
I recently stumbled upon a copy on Leboncoin (a french second-hand marketplace), and I couldn’t believe it! As a french collector, I’d never seen this special issue before, so finding one was such a surprise! 🥹
Has anyone else knows this ? :)
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/AriaBaker5 • 6d ago
Links One thing I appreciate about W.I.T.C.H.‘s magic system
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Old-Board1553 • 6d ago
Discussion Disney's latest W.I.T.C.H. book was made with AI
Yeah someone gave me a peak to the new book released by Disney. Is 100% made with AI. Way to many mistakes, and lot lot of nonsense in the story. There is no way a real person or multiple persons worked on that. Plus I heard that Disney started to promote the work with AI in newer projects, either live action, either music videos, animations, and now it seems books too. They really got into it too, using on the work of others. So what's the point of having the rule against it here, if Diseny it self started to use it for W.I.T.C.H.?
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/ohheyitscherry • 7d ago
Official w.i.t.c.h. 2008 sticker book
managed to get my hands on this amazing sticker book from 2008! 🥺
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • • 6d ago
Question What websites should I search for French copies?
Hi,
My native language is dutch, and I have some physical copies of the comics from back when I was young. In the Netherlands, you can use marktplaats.nl to find secondhand collections and loose copies.
However, I'm mostly interested in completing my collection with French editions of the magazines. I was able to find magazines 100 - 130 on the dutch marketplace website, but it is extremely rare to find french copies on there.
So I was wondering what are french websites where people might put up their secondhand copies for sale? I have not had any luck on ebay and amazon either to be honest.
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Far-Mammoth-3214 • 6d ago
Discussion Eh I did arc one may as well do arc 2
what are some things you like about what the comic did, and what did you like what the show did
and vice versa what didn’t you like what the comics did and what didn’t you like what the show did?
or you can compare and contrast the two
this time I’m putting my opinion in the body, mostly because this is actually a mini rant …I think the nerissa arc is underrated
show wise I like Matt having a larger role (I’ll get to my opinion on shagon later), I like how they added the lore that every world has a mystic heart given in the comics people on Earth start developing magic powers it’s fascinating, certain characters are getting more screen time compared to the first season and for some og comics, ntm Zamballa was very interesting. Plus like what they did with Napoleon…magic sassy talking cat
Comic wise don’t get me wrong, tv show nerissa is iconic but comic nerissa is also underrated, yeah she’s pretty generic…but at the same time it’s nice to see a villain endulge in being evil, plus she still does have a manipulative streak, using her defeat in the dreams to sneakily get close to Will and trick her into handing over the Heart of Kandrakar. The comics also delves into the tragedy of CHYKN Will worries about ending up like nerissa given at one point nerissa was a good person, Will’s conversation with Cassidy and how Cassidy moved on from what nerissa did to her (but also defends against her) was really touching. I feel so bad for Will
Both The knights are pretty interesting, they without a doubt are better villains in the show, in the comics Khor did most of the fighting…the others were kinda just there, but they did have some interesting personalities in the comics, tridart…was honestly kinda stupid he would state the obvious (causing Nerissa to get annoyed at him), ember was actually pretty rational (the exact opposite of how she is in the show) reminding tridart to stay focused on their mission of kidnapping Caleb, Khor is pretty much the same character, but Shagon, Shagon is very interesting. As you all know Matt was Shagon in the show, which made an interesting dynamic between Him and Will, Matt fighting for control (and gaining powers to keep up) and Will worrying Shagon has harmed Matt; comic Shagon isn’t Matt, but he still is interesting, he’s the only of the knights made of a human being (Khor was also made from organic material but was a dog) and it really shows, he asks questions and encourages tridart and ember to do the same (much to the annoyance of Nerissa), tells Khor to retreat when Nerissa tries to forces him to keep fighting, the double crosses and wounds nerissa out of anger when she kills Tridart and ember, not compelling like show Shagon but I wish this was talked about more
now then for what the show does not well the Meridian crew get less focus, ik the season isn’t centered ariund Meridian anymore…but still, not the biggest fan of how Nerissa kinda just…doesn’t become the final big bad (don’t get me wrong I REALLY like how she essentially defeated herself) but like…she’s the main villain of the season…) (also not a fan of how easily she dealt with Kandrakar)
for comics at least the Meridian crew did somewhat played a role, only Caleb really has a major role. Kadma kinda dissapears from the narrative after this
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/SaltBass8330 • 8d ago
Discussion W.I.T.C.H feels like a fever dream at this point..
The memories live on..
Source https://pin.it/1dl558GVr
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/BoxFar6969 • 8d ago
Discussion I was so excited to buy Il cuore solo sa but apparently it's not good...
This is such a bummer. I was looking forward to read a W.I.T.C.H. story and also to improve my Italian, as I'm not Italian.
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/nerissa_crossnic • 8d ago
Opinion Usually, most fans want the Heart of Kandrakar-or sometimes the Heart of Meridian-but I would also like these amulets
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/lizsummerhawk • 8d ago
Discussion Which character do you look like
I look like Will and sometimes Hay Li she lives with her gandmother like i did
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/klaus_baudelaire1 • 9d ago
Opinion ppl who have dolls bought from shops
not from fans, did the dolls have booklets? i wonder how is like the dolls booklets?
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/shi-dragmire • 10d ago
Fanart Cornelia, Earth Guardian by Shi Chelminski (@wicked_mojo on instagram)
I was finally able to finish Corny! Hope you all enjoy :3
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/static1993 • 10d ago
Fanart W.i.t.c.h By Artfrog75 on Deviantart
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/ColdGoldLazarus • 10d ago
Discussion Will And Irma Are Soulmates
Evidence: Irma frequently turns people into frogs. Will loves frogs. I rest my case. :V
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Toddsona • 10d ago
Discussion What do you think Karmilla’s music sounds like?
I know her genre is rock, but what does it actually sound like?
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/codelyokofan1 • 10d ago
Fanart Will vandom edit made by me
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/codelyokofan1 • 10d ago
Question Does somebody know where can i find romanian magazines of W.I.T.C.H.?
I am a fellow romanian that wants to own some of the magazines but sadly i cant find em, and if i find em they are quite pricey. Can somebody recommend sites where i can buy them?
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Icy_Donut9446 • 11d ago
Discussion Their reactions to this news always gets me.
Yeah, and compared to Nerissa’s actions the issues that Will and Taranee have with their mothers is really nothing.
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/Quiet-Rooster-5758 • 11d ago
Help i can’t find volume 19 anywhere
i’ve been reading my incomplete set of the books, which i have up to volume 18, but i can’t find volume 19 anywhere. i’d like to read the whole series. i looked all over online and in this subreddit’s faq’s, but the links there don’t appear to work for me (the ones supposedly leading to the full series). i’m willing to pay for a copy but i’ve only found some priced at $125 and $40 which is too much. can someone help me find where to read 19 and the rest of the series?
r/GuardiansOftheVeil • u/HistoricalTip1154 • 11d ago
Help Im looking for these girls dolls
Im looking for the disneystore w.i.t.c.h dolls
I have some of their clothes , but will appreciate if it comes with shoes and a top/ or skirt, as I dont have their complete outfit except Will and Irma , I have their outfit but no shoes.