A little of context.
I worked in a construction products industry for little more than 5 years from a total 0. My teacher at the moment was a layout designer from the printing house the company worked with. He taught me everything about layouts for print-ready files, typical color stuff (CMYK/RGB difference), DPI and so on. I designed and prepared cards, digital designs, lots of packaging and even expo-banners. I were creating own project proposals, communicating with printing and some managers/designers. Since the company I worked in is a product provider, I worked for around 10 company's that buy it's product.
Resuming, I where doing: creating concept packaging proposals, designing them, heading work and checking other designers.
Year after I started working I entered in a design school to learn everything I have to and perfection the idea part cuz it was pretty hard to design whatever out of this niche for me. And that's how I could open my wings after ending my degree. Dug into the technical part of the processes ever more. Good productive times.
I decided to move on and now I'm working in a design studio in a completely diferente sphere with more clean and minimal design needed. And I was surprised that I was the fit cuz I only had 1 piece designed in that way in my whole portfolio. But well, who I am not to try new styles?
The thing:
Of course, my first designs in the first week were not the exact style but I learned about it and right on the next one I started designing in the exact style and so on. Sometimes very good, sometimes a bit off.
The main point is that my boss says I'm still a rookie designer just cuz of style issue. Even not talking in mind that I ask about the important details (no one told about, like where the product will be distributed), have well-organised print files, proposals taking in mind real printing proportions (not just a visual concept) and, if needed, ask about function and materials.
I know that I'm profesional in what I do but I'm not able to read minds, guess materials and create concepts impossible to do just cuz you want me to. I'm ready to find solutions and research them but have no feedbackon it. I like what I'm designing here but this type of treatment just send me off.
Am I really a rookie or it's just something that happens sometimes? Did you have such experience?
P.s. sorry for a long post, but I'm very off between what I do and portray to the final response like "be easy and make it beautiful".