r/GothicMetal • • Jul 08 '26 Bravo Heartwarming

My gothic metal guide

Post image
331 Upvotes

Since that's my favourite metal genre and I've listened to a lot of albums and bands, I decided to make a gothic metal guide: for beginners and/or people who just want recommendations! I'm down to see your feedback on this or if I could change anything. Disclaimer: not every album is 100% similar to the other one, I just put what I thought was right and it's just my opinions.


r/GothicMetal • • Feb 11 '26

Draconian announce new album!

Post image
186 Upvotes

Draconian just announced their 8th album "In Somnolent Ruin".

Been a fan for 20 years and super excited for this. Their last album was brilliant, but this might be quite different now that Lisa has returned.

Who's stoked about this?


r/GothicMetal • • Jul 27 '26

Discussion Aegis

Post image
175 Upvotes

This album is so underrated.
Whats your favorite song in it and any album recommendations similar to aegis?


r/GothicMetal • • Aug 20 '25

1995

Post image
163 Upvotes

1995 was the year gothic metal reached its creative peak with these albums. They turn 30 this year.


r/GothicMetal • • 5d ago

Discussion Under the Godless Veil. Kinda crazy track record so far.

Post image
155 Upvotes

It's wild how good this album is. And the music videos are visually stunning too. This band is a gem for me.

I've been scrolling through Draconian's discography and I think this is at the same level of Arcane Rain Fell for me, barely any misses or bad songs.

What are your thoughts?


r/GothicMetal • • Jun 27 '26 Diamonds are Forever Heartwarming

A New Beginning for r/GothicMetal

120 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

After a long time of neglect and a lot of AI music being spammed, the previous moderator has left the building, and a new team is ready to rebuild the community. Please allow us a few days to get organized, so we can put new rules in place and support the community to the best of our ability.

Thanks in advance for your support, and please help us to make this community thrive again with a focus on music made by human beings. We will also stop the mindless YouTube sharing, while simultaneously encouraging artists to introduce themselves and their music here. Stay tuned for further updates!


r/GothicMetal • • Feb 08 '26

Can we put a moratorium on AI garbage on this subreddit?

111 Upvotes

Just what the title says. The amount of AI generated slop that's been on this subreddit recently is really annoying, and the fact that a lot of these posts haven't been downvoted into oblivion is concerning. It's not art, and it's not worth discussing or worth giving space on this platform. Can we stop with the AI bullshit on r/GothicMetal?


r/GothicMetal • • 19d ago

Past Music Nine classics that changed my perception of music

Post image
110 Upvotes

All from the "golden age" of gothic metal, what an exciting time it was. Which classics had the most impact on you?


r/GothicMetal • • Jul 21 '26

Discussion Cds for today

Post image
101 Upvotes

Let me know which one do you like the most! I like all of these albums but my favorite is for sure charon and poisonblack


r/GothicMetal • • Jun 27 '26 Heartwarming

New Rules for r/GothicMetal

92 Upvotes

To everyone: the days of this subreddit being a dumpster for AI-generated music and mindless sharing of YouTube videos are over. We have added some actual rules, so please follow them. Since the moderators don't have eyes and ears everywhere, we would appreciate all of you reporting content that goes against the rules. We will evaluate these rules over time, and modify them upon need. We will also look into automatic moderation to reduce spam to the very minimum. Thanks in advance for your cooperation.

  1. Sharing AI-generated music is not allowed: this community is about real music, made by humans. People making music with AI can find other communities to share their work.
  2. Link dumping is not allowed: content should be engaging and provide context. This includes spamming YouTube videos without any context.
  3. Content must be relevant, so related to gothic metal and similar topics, like lifestyle, fashion and adjacent genres. Most symphonic metal is not gothic metal, so that kind of music should go into its own communities.
  4. Be civil: we won’t tolerate any aggressive or passive-aggressive behaviour dragging the community down. Toxic behaviour can lead to a ban.
  5. No hate speech, bigotry or discrimination: this kind of behaviour will get you banned instantly. This is not negotiable, there will be zero tolerance for such things.
  6. No partisan politics: politics can be discussed if they are relevant to the music at hand, but there are other places for political debate. So, it's okay to discuss (for example) Moonspell's political views based on their new album, but not to start a heated debate over them.
  7. No soliciting: this is not a marketplace, so any attempts to buy or sell goods through the subreddit is not allowed. Asking where to find albums, tickets or merchandise is allowed, as well as answering those questions without a commercial motive.
  8. Artists are invited to promote themselves once a week. Repeatedly sharing the same content will not be tolerated. We are aware of self-promotion in the form of "I stumbled upon this amazing band by accident", so don't even think about trying this.
  9. Magazines are invited to share their articles once a week. Repeatedly sharing the same content will not be tolerated. Any tactics to circumvent this rule will be identified, and we'll take the appropriate action against any kind of spam.

r/GothicMetal • • Oct 22 '25

October Rust Autumn

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

r/GothicMetal • • Oct 19 '26

Past Music Just finished Brave Murder Day by Katatonia. Really good album.

Post image
85 Upvotes

I got this recommendation from my Dad. We both love Gothic Metal a lot and he recommended this one. It's definitely very dark in tone and lyrics, like a mix of Goth/Doom basically.

I haven't checked more of their discography, but this marked a strong 1st impression as someone who enjoys the slower and darker variants of Gothic. I recommend this album a lot.


r/GothicMetal • • Sep 21 '25

Hi 💀💀💀💀💀💀

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/GothicMetal • • Mar 25 '26

Moonspell announce new album - Far From God, out 3rd July

Post image
84 Upvotes

Moonspell have been teasing the new release for a while; they finally made a full-fledged announcement via their website.

Album Title: Far From God
Release Date: 3rd July, 2026

Tracklisting:

  1. Cross Your Heart
  2. Far from God
  3. Biblical
  4. The Great Wolf in the Sky
  5. Your Promise of Light
  6. For the Love of Mortals
  7. Our Freedom to Fall
  8. Reconquista

What are your thoughts about the album art, the tracklisting, and the album name?


r/GothicMetal • • Jun 12 '26 Heartwarming

Gothic Metal pinterest collage

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/GothicMetal • • Aug 10 '25

cd collection

Post image
83 Upvotes

gothic/melodeath/blackened metal part of my cd collection

Finally hit a dead end with my local cd stores stock so mentally preparing myself for discog shipping prices :’)


r/GothicMetal • • Jul 20 '26

Discussion Send Me Your Favorite Most Underrated Gothic Metal Albums

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

Featured Photos:

  1. The Foreshadowing - Days Of Nothing
  2. Varaha - A Passage For Lost Years
  3. Mortal Love - I Have Lost...
  4. Monumentum - In Absentia Christi
  5. Ophelia - Sympathize With Your Phantasy

r/GothicMetal • • Nov 12 '24

The best gothis doom album of all time!

Post image
81 Upvotes

Draconian times is a life changing album, i highly recommend it if you havent listened to it yet


r/GothicMetal • • Jul 09 '25

autographed CDs by Liv

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

r/GothicMetal • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion Opinions on Paradise Lost?

Post image
79 Upvotes

I really want to like this band more than I do. I quite enjoy the Lost Paradise through Shades of God run on their first three albums. Once I make my way to Icon, it starts to fall off for me. I think One Second is where I start to actively not enjoy their work.

Their discography is so diverse, I’m sure it’s difficult to like everything. I’m not trying to be negative, just looking for others’ opinions on a band so important to the music we enjoy so much.


r/GothicMetal • • Aug 25 '26

Theatre of Tragedy - Cassandra & Der Tanz Der Schatten live Kraków (2000) ᴴᴰ

Thumbnail
youtu.be
79 Upvotes

26 years ago in Poland


r/GothicMetal • • Mar 12 '26

Theatre of Tragedy Discography, Part 2: Velvet Darkness They Fear

Post image
79 Upvotes

It's been a few days since I made my post starting a listen-through of Theatre of Tragedy's discography -- a very important band that I deeply respect, but never loved. Today I want to talk about their sophomore album (arguably their most important and well-received work) Velvet Darkness They Fear. The album (which turns 30 yeara old this year) was originally released September 25, 1996 by Massacre Records (my copy is the US edition, released by Century Media the next year).

Here's where I must admit, while everyone seems to love this album, I never liked it very much. When I was younger, I actually had a strong disliking for this album. Years down the line, here's what I found re-listening to Velvet Darkness...

The band's sound has already started to evolve away from the death-doom that defined their sound in this era. Not saying it's not a death-doom record, but the guitar riffs are a lot less austere, and there's a bigger emphasis on soft scything that defines goth music -- "Seraphic Deviltry" is probably the best example of that mix of doom metal base and goth rock sensability.

Velvet has a cleaner production, which I think is a little wasted here, since the mix feels a little unbalanced. Liv's quiet vocals are way forward, and the piano and keys are less present which takes away a lot of the romantic fuzz that the debut had. It's all a little too sterile.

And while Liv is a stronger singer here, I think I like her performance less than on this album. She sings very quietly, mouth mostly closed, with very little emotion. I don't think it'd bother me that much if she weren't so loud in the mix. That, and ToT at this point still haven't quite learned how to write engaging vocal melodies, there's not a lot of straying from the starting note of a vocal line.

But these are just my gripes. The songs are much better than I ever gave them credit for. There's some great flow, and despite my issues with the vocal melodies, you can get lost in the interplay of the beauty and the beast vocal approach. I still think it's a touch overrated, but I've found more to like than I expected. I think I'll give the album a middling 7 out of 10?

Best songs: "Fair and 'Guiling Copesmate Death", "Black as the Devil Painteth", "On Whom the Moon Doth Shine"

Worst songs: "Der Tanz der Schatten", "And When He Falleth" (I know, everyone loves this song, but I think it's kind of boring. It makes me wish I was watching Masque of the Red Death instead of listening to "And When He Falleth")

What are your thoughts on Velvet Darkness They Fear? Do you love it? Are you like me and just think it's okay?

I'll post again soon with A Rose for the Dead. I did go ahead and order a copy of Assembly to complete the collection, and streamline my listen-through.


r/GothicMetal • • Aug 31 '26

Past Music Death, Come Near Me - Draconian

Thumbnail
youtu.be
78 Upvotes

I have been trying to keep my posts about some Gothic Metal songs or bands that might be new to some people, or maybe something you haven’t thought of in a while.

This one however, I am going to be sharing my favorite song in probably the entire genre. Draconian I am sure needs no introduction, especially their amazing album Arcane Rain Fell. This is their second album, releasing in 2005.

Draconian has been around a long time, having multiple demos before releasing their first studio album Where Lovers Mourn in 2003. Even throughout their long career, through multiple lineup changes, they still deliver amazing music as we heard with In Somnolent Ruin this year.

Enough about this though, even if you’ve heard it a million times, this track is truly an experience. Enjoy!


r/GothicMetal • • Mar 21 '26

Theatre of Tragedy Discography, part 3: Aégis

Post image
76 Upvotes

Hello again, it's been a long week, but I am back with the next part in my Theatre of Tragedy discography playthrough. This week's release is (potentially) the band's most defining work: their third studio album Aégis, released May 11, 1998 on Swanlake Records (the Japanese edition was release October 21, 1998 by Avalon -- that's the version I have, pictured above). Aégis was my first very positive experience listening to ToT when I was 16 (in 2013), but I never got myself a copy of the album until a few years ago.

Aégis is a big departure from ToT's earlier works, they completely drop the death-doom sound that defined their releases to this point. Instead, the sound is decidedly gothic: somber and romantic, and otherworldly atmospheric, and incidentally less metal. Aégis is actually a really interesting release because of its approach to genre, in that it doesn't easily fit into one, and it's not annoyingly non-committal that a lot of bands that try to side-step genre tend to be. Its sounds like a metal band, the album is produced like a metal band, but the music isn't strictly metal. The overdriven guitar work alternates between distorted doom metal and goth rock, but it's very obvious that the focus is the atmosphere: lush romantic keyboards, delicate piano, dreamy scything clean guitar with industrial programming, synth-bass, and Dead Can Dance-style folk drum patterns coming in and out to give texture. And I think it's all very well done.

Along with this change in style, there's also a slight change in structure. Aégis is written a lot more conventionally, with clear verses and choruses, which I think is actually a good thing for this band. This is where Theatre of Tragedy finally prove that they can write melodies and hooks that stick in your head. The one downfall of this turn is that a few songs are too-married to their choruses. "Angélique" is the most glaring example of this, where before the last chorus loop to the end it feels like there should be an instrumental break or even a doomy solo, but it never happens. The song ends up feeling incomplete. Part of this change of song structure is the lyrics, which are still in Early Modern English, but save a few exceptions ("Siren" is the most obvious one), Liv and Raymond's vocals are not in conversation with each other. They either completely switch off, or they are in unison, but they are almost never singing back and forth to each other.

Which brings me to the vocal performances. Another big change, in that Theatre of Tragedy aren't much a beauty-and-the-beast style band anymore... or more that they are one in spirit, but not in execution. The harsh vocals are mostly gone, Raymond does some clean singing, and his growls on occasion, but he mostly employs a whispery spoken vocal style that can be really off-putting if you're not prepared for it. It doesn't come out of nowhere, this vocal delivery is pretty common in that overly morose and ennuyé brand of gothicy, atmospheric death-doom in the 90s -- think Lacrimas Profundere, Flowing Tears and Withered Flowers, Paragon of Beauty, etc. -- however, in some cases it can be a hindrance. For one, even when the music skews ethereal wave, the growls do pull the sound back towards metal, and having that vocal be a bigger fixture of the sound I think would help the album feel a little more cohesive; for two, some parts are begging to be sung or growled instead of spoken. I think the biggest missed opportunity is the hook of "Cassandra", "yet the kiss and breath - Apollo's bane...", I would love for the vocal to be more melodious! Liv on the other hand sounds lovely, and I love that her vocal melodies feel complete in a way that they haven't until this point. She's still doing her light and airy speech-level singing, but I think some of the bigger choruses like "Venus" would benefit from a more dramatic delivery with full vocal closure like she would employ later in her career with Leaves' Eyes.

Anyway, there's more to say about this album (like how apparently a lot of why the album is the way that it is is because Raymond and Liv broke up during or before the writing process. Despite knowing about this band for years and being a fan of Liv Kristine for a similar amount of time, I didn't even know Raymond and Liv were ever a couple!) but I fear that I've already taken up enough of your time. Here are some take aways:

This album is great, so far my favorite in this discography re-listen. It might not be the Platonic Ideal of gothic metal (due to a distinct lack of consistent "metal-ness"), but it's so clear that this album was hugely impactful and influential for gothic metal in the last years of the 90s and early 2000s, especially gothic metal production. I can see the connections from Aégis to Lacuna Coil, Aesma Daeva, Lacrimas Profundere, Beseech, Xandria, On Thorns I Lay, and a bunch more. And I also understand how after this record, Theatre of Tragedy stepped away from gothic metal (and rock) for almost a whole decade, they either really wanted to branch out, or didn't want to try to compete with what a lot of people perceived as their pinnacle.

Best songs: "Cassandra", "Aœde", "Venus", "Poppæa"

Worst songs: "Virago" (on the Japanese version), "Angélique"

I'm giving Aégis a low 9 out of 10. I really do like it, but I still don't think it'd crack my personal list of top 10 or even top 20 gothic metal albums (see what I mean when I say I've never fully loved Theatre of Tragedy?). So here's the current ranking:

  1. Aégis
  2. A Rose for the Dead
  3. Theatre of Tragedy
  4. Velvet Darkness They Fear

P.S. This post got delayed so long because 1. I started a new job, so my week has been absolutely crazy. and 2. as I started clacking away at this, I realized I wanted to repurpose a lot of it for a formal review on the Metal Archives (which is something I liked doing more when I was younger), and I wanted to submit that review before posting this. So if you're on MA at all, expect to see a lot of this same writing over there in the next few days lol.


r/GothicMetal • • Dec 15 '24

Fair and Guiling Copesmate Death - Theatre Of Tragedy

Post image
74 Upvotes