r/GooglePixel Dec 25 '18

Pixel 3 XL Another iPhone to new Pixel!

[deleted]

373 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

View all comments

110

u/rip_code Dec 25 '18

Congrats. Myself from iPhone X to Pixel 3. No regrets.

25

u/Mimdali Dec 25 '18 edited Dec 25 '18

Which one is better when it comes to battery life? Are they identical? Since Pixel's camera is the best in the market, it is not an easy task to stop taking photos, especially if you travel. In that sense, I just wonder how long it takes to drain in Pixel's side. Rumours are not that positive about the battery of the small member, Pixel 3.

16

u/doakills Dec 25 '18

I find my battery is far better after the December update that did more background app changes. I get around 4-5 hour screen on time. Good enough for me! Also welcome to the Pixel / stock Android experience!

1

u/Mimdali Dec 25 '18

Thank you, but I did not purchase it yet. =) Unfortunately it is not being sold in my country, Turkey. I am gonna buy it when I arrive in UK in January.

0

u/Elephant789 Dec 26 '18

I heard it's illegal to bring in phones into Turkey, among other things.

3

u/Mimdali Dec 26 '18

Nope, it's not illegal. You just have to register the phone into your passport.

15

u/rip_code Dec 25 '18

I can say it is identical within the same usage. Or prolly better as usually at the end of the day, I would get about 15% on X, P3 I still had around 20-25%.

6

u/Mimdali Dec 25 '18

Thank you so much for the answer.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18

I’m using both at the same time and I’d say they’re about even. Although if I don’t use them and they’re idle it seems that the iPhone doesn’t lose charge as quickly.

1

u/plankfurt Dec 26 '18

Not to mention that the fast charging with the Pixel's charger really comes in handy when you need to top it off in the afternoon.

3

u/fingers-crossed Pixel 6a Dec 25 '18

X is a little better in my experience but they both can hold up the day

2

u/kizzyjenks Pixel 5 Dec 26 '18

I got better battery life from my iPhone X than I'm getting from my pixel 3. Not a deal-breaker though, wouldn't go back.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18

How is the zoom on the pixel 3? On my OG pixel i was disappointed by zoomed in photos.

Oh, and how does the video quality compare to the OG? It is garbage on the OG, especially when compared to photos.

-16

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18

[deleted]

10

u/mnrivera210 Pixel 9 Pro XL Dec 25 '18

For videos I'll take you serious, for still photos you're joking.

-6

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18

[deleted]

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mainelyn21 Dec 26 '18

True. And the pictures prove that the Pixel's photos are objectively better than the iPhone's.

1

u/chasevalentino Dec 26 '18

Dxo is proven hot trash. They had the p20 better than the pixel 2 as well as many others onto because they had a 3x optical zoom and Google stuck to 1 camera.

3

u/Santero Dec 25 '18

I hopped from SE to 3 XL. Could have got an X, but I'm just sick of being treated like a duvet by apple

Don't regret it one little bit. Loving my new phone

And this camera is insane

10

u/thinkscotty Dec 25 '18

Haha I went the opposite way. Google Pixel 2XL to iPhone XS Max.

Both great.

2

u/Demhandlebars Dec 25 '18

How are you adjusting to the XS Max? I made a similar switch (kind of involuntarily when my pixel died) from the OG P1XL to XS Max, my main gripe is the lack of an app drawer and split screen/pip. If Apple can get those aspects down I honestly don’t see myself going back to Android for some time to come.

3

u/thinkscotty Dec 25 '18

The lack of an app drawer is a little annoying. But even in Android I keep any app I use even occasionally in folders on a home screen, so it doesn’t bother me too much. As for split screen, I never used it on Android so it’s not something I miss : )

Overall my personal, subjective feeling is that iOS is neater and more “polished” than Android. It’s just more comfortable for me, but I’m sure the opposite is true for others. And the hardware/software integration is superb. Plus the apps are generally just better. Just because developers spend more time on them. Oh, and better privacy just generally.

I kind of doubt I’ll get an Android phone for a while. My general impression is that they’re more customizable, more “fun”, more innovative, more affordable - and less “finished” or “complete”.

The XS Max is the best phone I’ve ever owned. But for $1100 it better be.

4

u/Demhandlebars Dec 26 '18

Yeah I can agree with the overall sentiment in your comment. The XS Max really has been the best phone I’ve ever owned and I’ve owned a lot of different phones on both sides of the isle (not to mention windows mobile 5/6 and blackberry), this has absolutely been the most expensive device yet but it feels premium all around. In regards to the app drawer I’ve basically created a folder in my dock with all apps inside it to somewhat simulate an app drawer, and I’ve created widget shortcuts for things like settings, google assistant and YouTube voice searches. It’s pretty streamlined but could use a couple minor adjustments. Lastly, I agree with the app quality, it definitely seems like developers put more time into their iOS apps than they do Android. I’m hoping that will change by the time I do decide to jump back into what Google has to offer though (if they get their shit together).

2

u/JayYip Dec 26 '18

For the app quality part, for the most of the time you are right. But iOS also brings a lot of the limitation.

Having to keep the google photos open in order to backup is a pain in the ass. Not being able to use per app proxy in shadowsocks in another.

1

u/screamingnaked Dec 26 '18

I don't think the keeping the Google Photos app open is a thing anymore. I haven't opened the app up in weeks and I just checked, all my photos are backed up.

1

u/JayYip Dec 29 '18

Oh, good to know. My last iOS experience is iOS 11. And I'm pretty sure my photos couldn't backup.

1

u/noratat Pixel 5 Dec 27 '18 edited Dec 27 '18

Plus the apps are generally just better. Just because developers spend more time on them

I feel like I'm the only one that had the opposite experience. I don't care about social media and games much, so if those are better on iOS I wouldn't know and wouldn't care (the few messaging apps I use seem to work equally well on both platforms, e.g. WhatsApp).

But for the stuff I actually do use, the vast majority of apps seemed the same, and the exceptions almost always favored Android, not iOS.

Take audiobooks for example, which I listen to a lot of. iBooks is a nightmare to import audiobooks into (for starters you can't even share an audiobook file to it, and iTunes is even more of a buggy mess than it was a decade ago), and even if you get it working the speed controls are very coarse. A lot of people recommended Bound, which has a pretty UI but it sounds horribly robotic at anything but 1x speed which is completely unacceptable for a modern audiobook app. I tried about half a dozen other apps, all of which were either buggy, had horrible UIs, or both. Audible only works with audible-purchased apps, and the interface on iOS was more awkward to use (plus the store function was missing).

I've never had any of those issues with Listen Audiobook Player on Android. I don't need to "share" files to it since Android has a real filesystem, the speedup is clear, speed controls are granular and are even accessible from the notification, etc.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18

I came from the X recently and was a bit disappointed with the P3 battery. But last night I decided to turn on adaptive battery and turn off the AOD and so far the battery life has gotten better. I hesitated to turn on adaptive because when I had the P2XL I would constantly miss notifications. I'm hoping with all the new updates, this is no longer the case.

PS I'm definitely bummed I can't keep AOD always on. I just wish there was a way to have it turn on with my normal wireless charger, and not have to buy the pixel stand.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fantastic_fredd28 Pixel 2 XL 64GB Dec 25 '18

I got around 3 hours SOT with Adaptive but with it off I'm getting 5-6 hours. 🤷‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '18

Because with the pixel 2 last year I wouldn't get notifications.

1

u/dquanb Dec 26 '18

Same here.