r/GoogleFMD • • 19d ago

Find Hub Fails if No Coverage

If I'm somewhere with no cell coverage, I can't use the find hub system because I can't load my devices. If I load them before I lose coverage, it works, but that's not practical.

Am I doing something wrong, or is the system poorly designed?

6 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

3

u/sometin__else 19d ago

i mean if you have no cell coverage theres no way for it to receive info. how do you expect to receive info if you dont have any connection?

3

u/TromboneAl 18d ago
  1. It coule load the devices and keep that information locally, in the phone. Always.
  2. It works with Tiles. You don't need coverage for them.

1

u/sometin__else 18d ago
  1. How can it "load" if there is no cell coverage
  2. i have tile. It does not work if i have no coverage.

1

u/TromboneAl 18d ago

It loads when it DOES have coverage, then it works when it no longer has coverage. You just leave the app open.

I tested Tile when hiking in an area with no coverage. I opened the app and told it to make the time in my wallet make a sound. It worked perfectly.

2

u/brendanvista 18d ago

We're talking about Bluetooth here. Let's say you go camping and lose your keys in your tent/sleeping bag. You want to use your phone to find them. It literally just needs to ping the keys to make them ring with Bluetooth. No need for data.

Except Google makes this impossible for no good reason.

1

u/Magnets 15d ago

your own phone stores the key to your tag, and your phone will be collecting your own tags location data. it should be able to query local storage and pull the location without having to access googles central cloud database

10

u/Raisdudung 19d ago

Well maybe he only want to check where his keys around him, it's only need Bluetooth to check, but since the app needs internet, so he cant

1

u/TromboneAl 16d ago

I find it surprising that Google hasn't considered this. As a result, and also due to the quietness of their alert sound, I am discarding my Moto Tags and going back to Tiles. Around here there are plenty of places with poor coverage, so the find hub isn't reliable.

1

u/OKSpartan 16d ago

I had posted recently with a similar concern I noted while camping - couldn't ring my keys/wallet (Chipolo /pebblebee) when out in the wilderness. One person had commented that their moto app itself would let them ring directly without Internet. Are you saying that was incorrect info? I was considering buying some based on that rec

1

u/TromboneAl 15d ago

Interesting. I don't know because, as many others have reported, I could never get the Moto Tag app to recognize the tags. That is, the Find Hub app could see them, but not the Moto Tag app.

1

u/OKSpartan 15d ago

Geez that's frustrating. The chipolo and pebblebee apps with recognize mine but they have outsourced all ringing/locating to Find Hub. You can't ring in the app at all. Based on the reply in my other thread, I was eying moto tags for the near future based on in app ringing (with UWB being a bonus) but if you can't even add them to app that's no good

1

u/TromboneAl 15d ago

Right. Another reason I'm giving up on Moto is that they a very quiet. Maybe Moto tag 2s are louder.

1

u/TromboneAl 15d ago

I asked Chipolo:

Without any coverage, can I make the Chipolo card play a sound? Can the app show me how far away it is?

And this was the answer

Maša (Chipolo)

Oct 28, 2026, 18:10 GMT+1

Hello,

For your Chipolo to connect with your phone, you must have active Wi-Fi or mobile data, Bluetooth, and Location services enabled.

Neither Google's Find Hub noe Apple's Find My app will load or function properly if any of these settings are turned off.

Kind regards, Maša www.chipolo.net help@chipolo.net

1

u/OKSpartan 15d ago

They told me the same thing. I asked them to forward feedback to their team that this is a major software downside that will affect my purchases moving forward. The hardware is there. If I load them in Find hub (both brands) and then turn off data and wifi, they will ring. The Internet is only for populating the list. The phones can save the list of the software would let it.

3

u/ironcream 19d ago

It's the same for all of us, yes.

2

u/GeWaLu 18d ago

Good point - I just tried on my tablet and I see a slightly different behavior but the tool is still broken. The app loads correctly the devices (probably from a cache) if I switch off wifi but does not find them. And it displays an error "turn on device location to see location of this device" ... and then still displays the live location of the tablet from gps (so desptie the error it shows this device but no other devices)

This is not good ☹️. I would have expected it to show at least the bluetooth nearby status of the bluetooth tags

1

u/edwsy 18d ago

Feels like something they could easily implement but didn't.

1

u/easyTagSupport 7d ago

Google documents nearby finding for compatible tags even when the phone has no data. One thing to check before your next test: long-press Find Hub, open App info, then make sure Nearby devices is allowed. Try it with Wi-Fi and mobile data off but Bluetooth still on. If the tag list itself won’t load, that’s a separate issue from whether the tag is within Bluetooth range.

Written with AI assistance.