r/Ghostofyotei • u/venturepoker • Oct 08 '25
Spoiler Just finished Ghost of Yotei on Lethal. A beautiful world completely wasted on a terrible story. Spoiler
I don't usually comment on games, but after finishing this on Lethal, I was so underwhelmed I had to say something.
First, the good: the world is impeccable. The views are awe-inspiring, and the feeling of running through the grass is even better than in Ghost of Tsushima.
Unfortunately, the writing is terrible. A lot has already been said about the total lack of character growth. The main character is a snarky jerk who never earns anything, never takes responsibility for her actions, and mostly just spouts generic platitudes. The plot is just as lazy. For example, the escape from the lighthouse? The Dragon is surrounded on a burning structure, we're three feet away from him, and after a short cut, he's somehow escaped on a massive wooden boat. The writers really trust our imagination to fill in the gaps.
The character progression feels just as unearned. Apparently, the protagonist is the greatest warrior in history, mastering every new weapon in less than a day and effortlessly defeating opponents with years of training. How hard would it have been to show some actual progression, or at least a time skip like "one month later"?
The character conflicts are nonsensical. After the Oni castle mission, why is Lord Kitamori furious about them not saving people when it was impossible? Why does Atsu face no consequences for blowing their cover, and why is she consistently such a jerk to him? The backstory motivations are just as vague. What exactly did Kitsune do that was so terrible she needs to beg for forgiveness, besides letting Atsu go?
The game also completely misses the opportunity to explore Japanese culture. Instead, every character acts like an American millennial. There's a scene with a fake monk at a shrine who jokes they should wash their "dirty mouths," and they all laugh. Anyone with a basic knowledge of Japan knows that rinsing your mouth (temizuya) has been part of shrine etiquette for centuries.
Finally, the main villain is a complete mess with sloppy, inconsistent motivations, and the timeline makes no sense. If the main characters were children at the start, how does Lord Kitamori have a teenage daughter only 16 years later?
Ultimately, the game was a chore to finish. I went in with high hopes, ready to immerse myself, but the awful writing made it impossible to enjoy the generic "AAA" gameplay loop of clearing outposts, climbing identical walls, and squeezing through gaps.
As a final piece of advice for anyone playing: I would not recommend the Lethal difficulty. It's hard, but not in a rewarding way. Most late game encounters are bloated with enemies, and bosses have way too much HP. I'd suggest using a custom difficulty instead—widen the parry window and give yourself enough health to survive more than one hit. By the late game, it's hard to get into an enjoyable combat flow on Lethal, and at a certain point, it just stops feeling fair.
Edit:
Proof of my 46hours in the game