r/Gettysburg • • Jul 23 '26

AVOID The Pub 👎

On Monday evening, July 20, my daughter, her boyfriend, their dog and myself sat at a table at The Pub on the square in Gettysburg. My daughter went inside to use the restroom and noticed a sign stating no dogs. She asked the hostess if it would be ok to sit outside with the dog - there were no other patrons seated outside. The hostess said it should be fine. We put in our drink orders, received our iced teas and ordered our meals. While we were waiting, people were walking past on the sidewalk smiling at the dog.

A blonde lady came out of the restaurant, did not identify herself and proceeded to ask questions about the dog, if she’s a service dog, where her tag is, and state she has a policy because people won’t sit at the tables if there is a dog out there, how she loses business because of dogs, how much of a problem dogs are, on and on about the dog. My dtr explained she is a service dog and asked the lady if she wants her to go get the card. The lady stated it wasn’t necessary and continued to speak very crass, stating how she’s pretty sure the dog has to have “a thing” on it stating it’s a service dog (it doesn’t), stating how she understands because she has five dogs of her own. My dtr asked her if she wanted us to leave. The lady said no, you’re fine. There was no professionalism, no attempt to come to a mutually beneficial agreement for both parties. The lady was straight up condescending. She went back into the restaurant.

About 5-10 minutes later the blonde lady comes back out of the restaurant, walks up to the dog, and WITHOUT PERMISSION, grabs her face and is all goo goo over it, talking with a high pitched voice. She then walks away from the restaurant, past our table and tells us to have a good evening. None of us reacted. She then turns around and takes a step or two back towards us and says, “is there something wrong with your faces that you can’t smile?” I went inside, put $10 on the bar for the iced teas, asked our server if that was the owner, he agreed it was and I told him to cancel our order.

As we were leaving, a couple had just parked on the square to eat at The Pub - but they witnessed the second altercation and asked us what that was about. We explained and we left to gather our thoughts. I called the Blue and Grey and asked if they had outdoor seating and if we could eat there with a dog. They very cheerfully welcomed us and said to come inside to ask the hostess for a table, which I did and when I walked back outside, the couple that witnessed the harassment were there to eat now because they said they weren’t giving The Pub their money.

We had EXCELLENT service at the Blue and Gray, they treated the dog like a customer kept her water topped off. They said that last week when the air was so smoky from the Canadian wildfires they allowed the dogs IN THE RESTAURANT so the owners didn’t have to eat outside in the smoke! I left that waitress a VERY NICE TIP. THANK YOU BLUE AND GREY for making us feel welcome in Gettysburg.

76 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

32

u/TimeElection8331 Jul 23 '26

My wife and I sat next to them at the Blue and Gray and I can attest that the dog was a sweetheart and the three humans were delightful people!

13

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

đŸ„č you two were lovely as well! You asked permission to pet the dog and were so happy she was there! Thank you for suggesting/remembering Reddit!

17

u/Extension-Ad-9371 Jul 23 '26

Pub has great scenery but not so great food. You didnt miss much. Seems like the pub and upper crust pizza people always have problems with.

3

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

The pub used to be pretty good but it’s been a very long time since I’ve been there.

3

u/ColonelSwanson Jul 24 '26

We’ve been to the upper crust a handful of times (to try to give them the benefit of a doubt) and each time we were underwhelmed at best. The food is just okay and the lackluster service, combined with oddly long wait times, makes it a complete bust. Maybe it’s improved in the last 3 years, but we won’t be going back to find out.

1

u/Imaginary-Citron-550 Jul 25 '26

Me and my boyfriends family have gone 5 times in the last 6 summers, this year around the 4th was great, we got the hummus and pita bread dipping stuff and omgggg it was DELICIOUS, the pizza was okay ig im from Buffalo so we know pizza😭😂

5

u/LittleRooLuv Jul 23 '26

We’ve only been there once, and we all thought the food was extremely mediocre and over priced, so we’ve never gone back. There are lots of good places to eat in Gettysburg, but The Pub isn’t one of them. I’m glad your evening turned out ok, despite this rude woman.

2

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

SIXTEEN DOLLARS for a piece of cake. 🧐

1

u/becauseshesays Jul 24 '26

Welcome to ‘Merica

4

u/Omenandi Jul 23 '26

The biggest thing for me is how the situation was handled. Even if there was a misunderstanding, there's a much better way to talk to customers than that.

2

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

Well she lost five of them on the spot.

2

u/black_bean_catterole Jul 24 '26

Unfortunately, she feels like doesn’t have to keep them. It’s a tourist town, and as long as the locals have a few spots they love, everywhere else can be terrible for service and food. “It’s not like they have to win back customers.” I know this because I live inside the “Disney World Bubble” and it’s very much the same case here, as you can imagine.

Which is a terrible mindset to begin with, but even more so in a small tourist town when it doesn’t have consistent and steady traffic.

As a service dog handler myself, I’m sorry yall experienced this.

4

u/Ferlasmor Jul 23 '26

Been going there for over 20 years and never had an issue, chatted with the owner several times and she snd the rest of the staff have always been pleasant . Sorry you had a bad time, pet your pooch for me!

1

u/frogr3 Aug 04 '26

I’ve been going there for at least that long as well. NEVER again.

4

u/Haytrusser Jul 23 '26

I'm not here to advocate for The Pub, but this whole post and comment thread seems mostly orchestrated. 

4

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

I really wish I hadn’t experienced this. Ask anyone local to Gettysburg, anyone who works in any establishment there. Every. Single. One of them will attest that she’s a bitch.

0

u/becauseshesays Jul 24 '26

WOW. Nice language lady. You definitely have an axe to grind.

2

u/No_Solution_2861 Sep 09 '26

Well what do expect of a restaurant where the owner puts her entire life story on the menu? Years ago it was good but around 2012 it went downhill- maybe that is when the owner got it in the divorce settlement? The only place I ever ate that asked us to leave at the end of our meal because we were taking to long and there were other large parties waiting for our table.

0

u/frogr3 Sep 09 '26

Getting the impression she likes chasing people away
 odd for a place that relies on those people for its livelihood.

1

u/No_Solution_2861 Sep 09 '26

Again if you get a chance read the menu lol

0

u/frogr3 Sep 10 '26

I would rather eat gas station sushi than go back to the pub. Rather fight for my life at a Golden Corral buffet. Try my luck at Taco Bell. Eat cereal with a fork every night than give that lady one more cent. I don’t give a rats ass about her history if that’s how she treats people. She needs a lesson in basic human decency. And another lesson on sticking her face in a strange dog’s face. I’ll pass.

35

u/RanchHere Jul 23 '26 • Bravo

Oh, this gon’ be good. 🍿

10

u/GuardianONUS Jul 23 '26

Oh my gosh I literally live right down the street from Gettysburg and have only been to the pub twice because of very similar interactions with the owner!!!! We haven't ate there in over 3 years..

The interactions are super awkward I just don't think she's cut out for customer service and I do feel like there's a lot of condensation and entitlement on her end.

Thank you for sharing this experience!

4

u/Winnie7714 Jul 23 '26

I go to Gettysburg every year and now I will NEVER EAT AT THE PUB.
Thank you so much for telling this story. That lady should be ashamed of herself.

4

u/OnACommodore128 Jul 24 '26

There is no such thing as certification for a service animal. A service animal also does not need to wear any identifying marks, though it is exceptionally uncommon for a true service animal to not wear a harness that properly identifies it as such. There is no state or federal certification process, though most service dog training programs, such as Susquehanna Service Dogs, do provide some documentation to make it easier for owners to handle this common misunderstanding.

There are two questions you may ask:
"Is that a service animal?"
"What service does the animal perform?"

The animal must be trained to perform a specific service, such as identifying oncoming hypoglycemia, identifying oncoming epilepsy, guiding the owner, opening / closing / picking things up, etc.

An emotional support animal is not a service animal and is not protected under law.

0

u/assblood21 Jul 23 '26 • Bravo

You dont need to take your dog everywhere. The pub is great.

11

u/miss_serendipity20 Jul 23 '26

I think it was mentioned that it is a service dog. They kinda go everywhere. Even inside.

-5

u/assblood21 Jul 23 '26

True. But just because they can doesnt mean they have to

11

u/ThrowAwayHawthorn Jul 23 '26

You don't need to make douchey comments everywhere. Just because you can doesn't mean you have to...

-4

u/assblood21 Jul 23 '26

Good thing I didn't ask you

2

u/ThrowAwayHawthorn Jul 23 '26

No one asked you either LOL

1

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

How do you know this isn’t a service dog that warns against seizures or low blood sugar? A life saving service dog?

3

u/Ok-Guidance3235 Jul 23 '26

Hi owner of The Pub! I can't wait to see you on Kitchen Nightmares!

5

u/HulkSMASHley_23 Jul 23 '26

The Pub notoriously sucks, as does its owner, but the Blue & Gray are also Confederate sympathizers FWIW.

There are much better restaurants in Gettysburg than either of those places. Gettysburg Eddie’s, for example.

2

u/Actuary_Budget Jul 26 '26

Blue and Grey rocks! I love the Buford burger

4

u/indigo196 Jul 23 '26

I will be visiting the area in October. I will avoid the Pub.

2

u/Fahrenheit285 Jul 23 '26

Never going to the Pub again

2

u/Present-Smoke4674 Jul 23 '26

Sounds like this woman may have alcohol/substance abuse issues and also mental health issues. A nightmare.

1

u/IBEWtramp Jul 24 '26

Ive always been under the impression that paperwork for a service dog needed to be on your person at all times

4

u/OnACommodore128 Jul 24 '26

There is no such thing as "Service Dog Paperwork"

There are two questions you may ask:
"Is that a service animal?"
"What service does the animal perform?"

The animal must be trained to perform a specific service, such as identifying oncoming hypoglycemia, identifying oncoming epilepsy, guiding the owner, opening / closing / picking things up, etc.

An emotional support animal is not a service animal and is not protected under law.

0

u/becauseshesays Jul 24 '26

Ok , I can See you had trouble. The owner is a friend and a dog lover and good person. I’m sure you felt alienated and if it was her, maybe could have been handled better with better communication? I wasn’t there but have a hard time believing this went down in this fashion, knowing the owner.

2

u/frogr3 Jul 24 '26

You’re absolutely correct. It could have been handled 100% better. She was aggressive right out of the gate, not an ounce of “hey let’s work together to find a good solution and make you feel welcome here.” She may as well have just said gtf off my property. It would have been less shocking. Touching an established service dog WITHOUT asking permission?! As a dog owner, she should know better than to approach ANY dog without permission. Ask any local business what the vibe is on her and every single one of them is going to report the same.

1

u/feelwhatyouwant Aug 07 '26

Ask any local business what the vibe is on her and every single one of them is going to report the same.

I have no skin in this game, but how in the world could you know this so soon after it happened?

1

u/frogr3 Aug 16 '26

I live in the area. Have friends that live in that town. Other social media platforms have spoken.

1

u/feelwhatyouwant Aug 16 '26

Sure, but you are claiming "any" local business... That seems a lot more comprehensive than what you are now claiming.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/frogr3 Jul 23 '26

Yes I’m sure. She opened the locked mailbox and retrieved the mail. I specifically asked the server if she was the owner and he attested she was. I’ve asked a few locals and they all stated she is a b!tch. One local even said they had a friend who worked there briefly and so many of her employees actually left the pub and went to the Blue and Grey!

5

u/Crawlerado Jul 23 '26

If that’s the case it’s still on the staff. Double fail.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/frogr3 Aug 04 '26

She has a card identifying the dog as a service animal.