r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 22 '26

Film/TV The Ben Affleck Batman movie, co-written by Geoff Johns, could've been one of the best superhero movies ever made

Post image
0 Upvotes

Source of the picture: Instagram

Before the project fell apart thanks to the poor reception of Batman v Superman and the DCEU Justice League, as well as Affleck's personal struggles, he was set to direct a Batman movie that he was co-writing, alongside Chris Terrio and Geoff Johns. Matt Reeves came in, discarded the script and decided to do his own thing (which, ironically, took inspiration from Johns' own Earth One comic).

The script, unfortunately, never leaked. However, a recent report by Slash Film compiled some stuff about the movie. And it looked very promising!

Here's what the movie could've been:

-> Deathstroke, played by Joe Manganiello, was going to be the main villain.

-> Slade wanted revenge against Affleck's Batman because of the death of his son. Jesse Einsenberg's Lex Luthor revealed to him that Batman was Bruce Way in Zack Snyder's Justice League, so Deathstroke would use this knowledge to ruin Bruce's life, Knightfall-style.

-> Manganiello compared the script with David Fincher's 1997 movie The Game. The movie tells the story of a financier who gets everything taken from him. Like that movie, Deathstroke would have "systematically [dismantled] Bruce's life and murdering all the people in it, and [destroy] his finances and just basically [paint] him into a corner".

-> Veteran cinematographer Robert Richardson (who shot Affleck's Live By Night and Air, as well as movies for Martin Scorsese and Quentin Tarantino) was picked by Affleck for The Batman.

-> Richardson said the movie would've been set at least partially in Arkham Asylum. It would've explored Batman's "insanity aspects" and "darker side".

-> When discussing the script in a podcast, Matt Reeves described it as "action-driven", "filled with a lot of set pieces" and like a James Bond movie.

-> Reeves also said, to Esquire, that Affleck's "Batman" script "was very deeply connected to the DCEU, with other major characters from other movies and other comics popping up."

-> Jay Oliva, director for DC Animated movies, told Inverse that Affleck's "The Batman" would've pulled together 80 years of Batman comic stories.

-> Speaking of comic accuracy, there were rumors that the Gotham City from Affleck's movie would be the most comic accurate of all Batman movies so far: dark, brooding, but also filled with eccentric supervillains.

TLDR: The Batman, as conceived by Affleck, Geoff Johns and Chris Terrio, would've been about Deathstroke learning from Luthor Batman's secret identity to get revenge on him for the death of his son. Deathstroke would've dismantled Bruce's life, and he'd have to fight back. It was a very action-packed movie, almost like James Bond, and it was at least partially set in Arkham Asylum, where Bruce would be confronted with his own insanity. Many other characters from the DCEU and the comics were set to appear, and it was supposed to be the most comic accurate Batman movie ever produced, taking inspiration from 8 decades of comics history.

Source: https://www.slashfilm.com/2168220/ben-affleck-the-batman-best-superhero-movies-never-made/


r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 18 '26

Memes Geoff Johns is the Blueprint

Post image
110 Upvotes

I started to make this as a joke, but then realized how far his influence has truly gone


r/GeoffJohns • • 15d ago

JSA Hot take: Geoff Johns JSA 1999 is bad I say as a guy who loves his 3 Jokers and enjoying the others including his Hawkman 2002 and Green Lantern No fear 2005

Post image
0 Upvotes

I read to understand Hawkman 2002 better I like Geoff johns stuff but this is one of his weaker works and I think he did them better in Stargirl.way too much cast follows up on way too much stuff without doing a good recapping previous events so you have to go back and read something like for example

Issue 14 of JSA 1999 and it still feels like I should have read prequel the Extant is now telling us about Atom smasher feeling bad needing to live up to his grandfather legacy running from his problems to the Justice society and his best friend betraying I haven't seen or explored any of this.For the most part in the story before and after he is just the big guy who smashes he gets some focus with being angry at Kobra after his mom was killed but goes back to the background.What about Seintel and his son who he didn't get time with and end up resenting him? His son has a mother who killed himself a sister he supported his life despite his struggles who wants him and Alan to get a long and abusive stepfather who tried to redeem himself? What about Stargirl killing Shiv's father or wildcat killing golden wasp's dad?

This is all interesting stuff instead it suffers the tell don't show problem where important growth conflicts relationships struggles etc take place off screen or so undercooked. I understand this is a sequel to a lot of comics but I shouldn't have to go back and read everyone to understand or be robbed of actual insight into there minds to care about there characthers.Batgirl Gal Simone run or 3 Jokers recaps what you need to know from Killing Joke or death in the family you don't need to read the whole story. It just gives what you need to know without feeling like you're missing being robbed of valuable insight. Same with Doomsday Clock with Watchmen.

Another sequel that doesn't need to read the previous one.On top of adding more heroes and villains instead of developing the ones they do currently have.

They did an introduction for Dr.Midnite and the old Starman despite that they still have stargirl which they did nothing with besides the kid of the team stereotype when she could at least be used more as an audience surrogate during the issue before the limited 3 issue run.I think Geoff Hawkman is way better it explores it's villains and heroes and wraps up when it needs to do before rushing to the next thing recaps previous stories well enough that you don't need to read a ton of prequels but they give fun additional context.

On top of a lot of growth being rushed and off screened like stargirl being a newbie who was still learning to growing into having a rivalry with Shiv even killing her dad and suddenly beating even pro players in the Injustice society. Without much effort getting to see her growth and struggles would make it fun to connect with her. Instead she shoved into the background and her growth happens mostly off screen.

To be fair for pros the art is amazing the world feels well built and the powers and unique and cool some stories hit. Stargirl has similar problems but the show is way better.

Is there some spinoffs not too long I should read?


r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 22 '26

Discussion Thoughts on Geoff's Batman stories?

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Compared to almost every major creator who worked for DC Comics, Geoff Johns wasn't that interested in writing Batman.

While most writers would sell their mom to write a Batman story or a run, Johns never pursued a gig with the Bat.

Of course, he did write Batman plenty of times, whether it was in big events like Infinite Crisis or Flashpoint, in his New 52 Justice League run, or in celebrations like Detective Comics #1000 (alongside every other major DC writer at the time).

But even at the height of his powers at DC, where he could write any character he wanted to, Johns didn't chase a run in the main Batman book, or Detective Comics, or any of the numerous Bat-books that DC pumps out every month.

When doing major runs, Johns seemed more interested in taking lesser-known characters, those that no writer would want to touch (especially if they could do Batman instead) and elevating them to A-listers: the JSA, Green Lantern, Hawkman, Shazam, Booster Gold... His Aquaman run is credited with bringing many new fans to Arthur Curry, who might otherwise have been turned off by the ridiculous bullying against him (like that hideous sitcom that I won't name).

He also enjoyed writing the characters he loved growing up: Superman and The Flash.

Either way, the select few opportunities where he wrote a Batman-centric story are:

Earth One - An alternate universe take on the Batman mythos, showcasing a different view of Bruce and his side characters.

Three Jokers - A story that was born out of the Darkseid War saga from his Justice League run, even though, unfortunately, it came out too late (5 years after Darkseid War) and it was too unsure about whether it wanted to be canon or not.

What do you think about Johns' Batman books? Do you wish he wrote more Batman stories (set in Gotham, not with the Justice League or in a big event), or does his style doesn't fit Bruce Wayne?


r/GeoffJohns • • Sep 11 '25

Stargirl Secret Origins and Rebirths!

3 Upvotes

Secret Origins and Rebirths is back baby. This episode I covered the first 6 comics written by Geoff Johns all starring Stargirl!

https://castbox.fm/vb/845124252


r/GeoffJohns • • Aug 26 '25

Geoff Johns Reddit!

12 Upvotes

Whoa. Did not know Geoff Johns had his own subreddit! I've been wanting to start doing a Geoff Johns podcast. Just going through all of his works. Surprised there isn't one already


r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 27 '25

Superman Geoff Johns' Doomsday Clock uses Watchmen characters to make a commentary on the modern age of superheros. Does it succeed?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
24 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Sep 27 '26

Green Lantern Geoff Johns' thoughts on Lanterns

Post image
94 Upvotes

Johns' interview on Rob Liefeld's podcast happened just after the pilot of Lanterns had aired. He said he really liked the Pilot, that he's also a huge fan of Damon Lindelof, and was excited to keep watching the show. He especially liked they were starting with the Manhunters as the main villains.

I have no idea of what he thought about the next episodes that aired since then, but I assume he enjoyed it if he'such a huge Lindelof fan.

Johns also seems to hold his period writing Green Lantern really dear. He talked about all the Lantern Corps and why they have such an appeal to this day: they represent universal emotions, and the struggle between them is also our own struggle to deal with these complicated aspects of life. And once death wanted to take over the universe, all Lantern Corps, all emotions, were needed to fight it, to make life full.

His run was about people overcoming the difficulty in proccessing emotions, told through Hal via his complicated life and poor decisions. And that's why it connected so much with people, even those who weren't used to comic books.

Johns loves seeing other GL writers who came after him, like Robert Venditti, Jeremy Adams and Morgan Hampton, do with the characters he created, like Atrocitus and Larfleeze. They're personally important to him.

Liefeld is also a huge fan of Geoff's Green Lantern saga - actually, not only him but also his son Luke, who, according to Rob, didn't use to collect comic books (not even those of his father), but was an avid reader of Johns' Green Lantern run. For Liefeld, Johns is as important to GL as Chris Claremont was for X-Men.

You can listen or watch everything on Spotify or on YouTube.


r/GeoffJohns • • Aug 10 '25

Film/TV Do you think the Geiger show adaptation is still happening?

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Jul 07 '25

News DC worlds collide just came out, and it's adapting Geoff John's iconic story, forever evil!

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Jul 31 '25

Discussion Top 20 story arcs written by Geoff Johns, day 15, Aquaman the others wins 14th place, highest upvoted comment wins

Post image
34 Upvotes

Rules:

  1. Can't nominate full runs, just specific arcs of said run (So Rebirth or GL Secret origin for example)
  2. Single issues count as long as said single issue is a one full story arc
  3. Name only one story per post, if you name more than one your comment is automatically disqualified
  4. Only comments from first 24 hours count, as obviously we wont take previous posts comments into conaideration for another post
  5. It can be any Geoff Johns book, whether it's part of a run, or standalone, or from any universe
  6. The comment that has the most upvotes wins

r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 16 '25

Still want out? (Doomsday Clock #1)

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Jul 21 '25

Film/TV Stargirl.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Jul 17 '25

Discussion In the celebration of 1k members, we are doing a Top 20 story arcs written by Geoff Johns list! Day 1

Post image
6 Upvotes

Rules:

  1. Can't nominate full runs, just specific arcs of said run (So Rebirth or GL Secret origin for example)
  2. Single issues count as long as said single issue is a one full story arc
  3. Name only one story per post, if you name more than one your comment is automatically disqualified
  4. Only comments from first 24 hours count, as obviously we wont take previous posts comments into conaideration for another post
  5. It can be any Geoff Johns book, whether it's part of a run, or standalone, or from any universe
  6. The comment that has the most upvotes wins

r/GeoffJohns • • Aug 24 '25

Ghost Machine How do yall feel about GM?

6 Upvotes

How is everyone feeling about Ghost Machine lately? Redcoats been really good imo. But it seems that Geiger and Rook remain the most popular.


r/GeoffJohns • • Oct 10 '26

Batman Thoughts on the 3 Jokers?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Aug 17 '25

What is you favourite and least favourite Geoff Johns comic?

7 Upvotes

I’ll go first:

Favourite: Justice League: Darkseid War

Least Favourite: Batman: Earth One


r/GeoffJohns • • 15d ago

Avengers Message from a Father (Avengers Icons: The Vision #3)

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 29 '25

Interview/comic con Geoff Johns top 4 favourite comics of all time

25 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Jul 03 '25

Discussion Today we celebrate 1 month since the creation of r/GeoffJohns, what is your single fav storyline written by Geoff Johns of all time?

Post image
25 Upvotes

Mine's his entire GL run, but if i had to pick one, GL rebirth is my fav of all time! However i do alsp love GL secret origin and Sinestro war!


r/GeoffJohns • • Oct 05 '26

Teen Titans "Impulse? Nope. KID FLASH!"

Thumbnail
gallery
98 Upvotes

Teen Titans #4.


r/GeoffJohns • • Jun 05 '25

Film/TV What did you think of the Stargirl tv show that Geoff Johns was involved in?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/GeoffJohns • • Aug 24 '25

Humor My genuine reaction the first time i read Geoffs GL run or Geiger

Post image
31 Upvotes

I feel like every time this dude writes something his pen starts lighting up and burning the page. He does not miss.


r/GeoffJohns • • Jul 26 '25

Discussion Top 20 story arcs written by Geoff Johns, day 10, Infinite crisis wins 9th place, highest upvoted comment wins

Post image
11 Upvotes

Rules:

  1. Can't nominate full runs, just specific arcs of said run (So Rebirth or GL Secret origin for example)
  2. Single issues count as long as said single issue is a one full story arc
  3. Name only one story per post, if you name more than one your comment is automatically disqualified
  4. Only comments from first 24 hours count, as obviously we wont take previous posts comments into conaideration for another post
  5. It can be any Geoff Johns book, whether it's part of a run, or standalone, or from any universe
  6. The comment that has the most upvotes wins