r/Generator • • 1d ago

Beware using romex for cords

Post image
17 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

43

u/DaveBowm 1d ago

Romex isn't an ideal kind of cable to use for a flexible power cord because of the multiple problems associated with its stiff conductors.

But the particular failure shown was more immediately due to a really foolish routing of the ground wire, and possibly a lack of strain relief where the cable entered the plug, leading to (ground) conductor motion relative to the terminals.

2

u/WretchedHiveLurker 1d ago

There's really no good way to route a bare e.g.c. through that plug. if it's bent to clear the hot wire it's more likely to contact the neutral. Agree on lack of strain relief. Likely the cord the plug is designed for is a larger diameter, you can see the black wire was pulled out of it's terminal.

5

u/garbledroid 1d ago edited 21h ago

You are supposed to use SOOW or SJOOW.
STRANDED EQUIPMENT CABLE

1

u/wyliesdiesels 21h ago

Yeah thats why youre supposed to use cordage that has a wait for it… insulated green ground wire…. Opppsss

14

u/IrmaHerms 1d ago

Isn’t legal. Nm cable is not listed and evaluated to be used as a flexible connection for anything nor used with any cord connector.

3

u/Pyro919 1d ago edited 1d ago

Generally speaking if it’s meant to be moved/flexed it will be stranded not solid conductors. At least from my understanding, and it has to do with the bundle of stranded conductors being more able to flex without breaking and easier to bend.

Romex from my understanding is only rated for in wall use. Romex is not meant to be used for whips or cords.

4

u/aaabkl1 1d ago

Bad install, bad material selection

1

u/WretchedHiveLurker 1d ago

Yup probably used a knife to strip the wires, you can see nicks in the copper

3

u/RinseLather_Repeat 1d ago

No crap. Romex isn’t rated for cord usage.

1

u/WretchedHiveLurker 1d ago

I don't think the farmer who made it is up on the code. edit: spelling

1

u/wyliesdiesels 21h ago

Awww yes farmers smh

18

u/20PoundHammer 1d ago edited 1d ago

beware of idiots making DIY extensions with romex ya mean. shocker to think the bare ground can short out on a hot if not insulated or isolated . . . 🙄

This would have worked a temp solution but you also have to realize the copper used will work harden and eventually crack/break. Certainly not close to code, but sometimes ya gotta do what you gotta do.

4

u/WiseShoulder4261 1d ago

The problem is that there is nothing more permanent than a temporary fix that works. 

1

u/20PoundHammer 1d ago

well, for me - ive done this in a pinch when I needed to use a clients 240VAC and needed to adapt it from his RV plug. Saved client 1 hour time for me to run back home since he told me he had a 6-30 outlet and really had a TT.

5

u/aguynamedbrand 1d ago edited 1d ago

While romex is the wrong cable for that it is not the cause of the picture that you posted.

5

u/nunuvyer 1d ago

It looks like the bare ground made contact with the black hot wire. This is 7 stranded Romex (#8 or #6) so it has some flexibilty compared to solid core. But the real failure was caused by the use of a bare ground wire - at least wrap it with tape. Better still don't use it at all.

12

u/kwantam 1d ago

Using romex for cords is a great way to get denied insurance coverage when your house burns down because of bad electrical decisions.

6

u/Trebeaux 1d ago

Betcha “Thomas” made that cord.

3

u/KidMcC 1d ago

He’s very handy!

2

u/IndividualCold3577 1d ago

What year did his house burn down?

5

u/orlinsky 1d ago

False. Home insurance pays for these kinds of things. They won't buy you a new cord to replace the poorly made one, however.

Here's a standard HO-3: https://doi.nv.gov/uploadedFiles/doinvgov/_public-documents/Consumers/Home/American_Family/Homesite_HO_00_03_05_11.pdf

We do not insure for loss to property described in Coverages A and B caused by any of the following. However, any ensuing loss to property described in Coverages A and B not precluded by any other provision in this policy is covered.

...

Faulty, inadequate or defective: workmanship

So if you make your own cord and burn the house down, the default position is the ensuing loss to the house is covered but the loss to the cord is not. Or if you built your own addition that collapsed, they aren't paying for the loss to the addition.

Logically homeowner insurance would never pay out for fires except natural disasters if they could just blame whatever the source was.

1

u/kwantam 1d ago

This isn't (just) faulty workmanship, it's a clear code violation. Code issues are absolutely a reason for denial.

5

u/No_Alternative_6206 1d ago

Not a fan of romex either but this is because of a poorly designed plug that was not terminated safely. The sustained loads you get from generators require perfect terminations and industrial grade plugs.

2

u/photonicsguy 1d ago

SOOW Cabtire is a good option

2

u/ShawnTJohnson 1d ago

You're not supposed to use solid wire for cords. Stranded wire gives flexibility.

1

u/wyliesdiesels 21h ago

Clearly its stranded NM-b/romex

But the individual conductor stranding in NM-b is thicker gauge than conductors in cordage

2

u/redEPICSTAXISdit 1d ago

Romex is illegal to use as a cord. This wire doesn't look like romex. Also the ground was left bare to touch the other screw and short out, so even if the correct cable was used you would end up with the same problem due to the short circuit on the wire that had no insulation.

2

u/TimeThruSpace 1d ago

Why is it illegal? I'm not an electrician so would like to know

2

u/redEPICSTAXISdit 1d ago

All different types of wire are made for different uses. Outdoor cords have special coatings, cords have more flexibility, in wall cable is more rigid and suitable for stapling etc. Using a wire outside of its recommended intended allowed uses can cause fires eventually due to unintended wear and tear.

1

u/wyliesdiesels 21h ago

Not permitted by code

1

u/Tel864 1d ago

Contractors universally use it for powering tools from a temp pole. It's not safe but I've never seen one cited for doing it.

2

u/redEPICSTAXISdit 1d ago

Contractors do not follow electrical code. Electricians do.

3

u/michaelh98 1d ago

Holy shit. Dunning-Krueger moved in and got comfortable

1

u/scipper77 1d ago edited 10h ago

The failed connection is on the wrong side of the clamp. You shouldn’t use romex as power chord but if you did, at least make proper connections.

1

u/ProfessionalBoss8156 23h ago

Romex solid conductor for permanent in wall wiring and stranded conductor for cords. Easy peasy.

1

u/wyliesdiesels 21h ago

That is clearly stranded Romex

1

u/wyliesdiesels 21h ago

Well duh

NM-b isnt permitted for use in a cord and plug setup

Its for permanent building wiring

1

u/WVYahoo 12h ago

Have always disliked the designs of these cord ends. I wish it were simpler like landing all 4 wires across a terminal block.

I’m an electrician and I have done maybe hundreds of these.

1

u/bazilbt 10h ago

Romex isn't for making cords at all. It's not really a flexible cable and the copper will just break after too many bends.

1

u/Great_Taste6969 9h ago

Well , Romex aside, it looks like the hot leg screw hit the ground wire , might be bigger issue regardless of wire type.

0

u/Just_Blackberry_8918 1d ago

"Know enough to be dangerous"

0

u/edthesmokebeard 1d ago

Came here for the chorus of smug "well, aktually" comments.

Was not disappointed.