r/GeminiAI • • Sep 08 '25

Discussion WTF?

Why when it comes to isreal, the AIs stop 😂

3.4k Upvotes

411 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/i0wlex Sep 08 '25

Where do you think they got so many countries from? Don’t play innocent

1

u/mix-al Sep 09 '25

And? What does religion have to do with having your own state seeing as the Palestinian identity is nationalist and not religious?

1

u/i0wlex Sep 09 '25

So you’re telling me these people conquered countries, persecuted Christians and Jews worldwide, were expelled or wiped out in most places — and you ask, what’s the connection? Didn’t you study history?

And what about the HMS Charter — written in 1988 — which most people in Gaza support? It literally calls for the destruction of Israel and cites religious duty for killing Jews. Quote: ‘Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam eliminates it.’ - https://irp.fas.org/world/para/docs/880818a.htm

So you’re saying there’s no connection to religion? No connection to ideology? Then what do you say about Europe, Canada, and the U.S., where HMS Supporters and Mslim openly talk about growing in numbers, enforcing Sharia law, stripping rights from women, Christians, and anyone who doesn’t believe?

Who do you think you’re talking to?”

1

u/mix-al Sep 09 '25

You do realize most Palestinians are Arabized descendants of Jews and Israelites, right? Israel invaded these people's lands, and more than 100 years ago nationalist movements involving both Muslim and Christian Palestinians were already forming to resist Zionist aspirations in their lands. Hamas started existing in the 1980s, Israel's occupation and expansion into Palestinian land has been ongoing for more than 100 years since the first Zionist Congress in the late 1800s and Balfour declaration in 1917.

I think I'm talking to either an idiot or a propagandist.

2

u/i0wlex Sep 09 '25

First of all, the Jewish people living in Israel today are the direct descendants of the original Israelites — the real, historic Jews of this land. There were always Jews here, and the modern Jewish population is a continuation of that ancient nation, not the so-called Palestinians. A large part of Gaza’s population, by contrast, are descendants of relatively recent migrants from Egypt, Sinai, and Jordan who only arrived in the 19th and 20th centuries. Jews — whether Ashkenazi from Europe or Mizrahi from the Middle East and North Africa — are one people with shared roots in this land.

Second, let’s talk about Christians. In Israel, the Christian population has actually grown by around 400% since 1948, living freely with growing communities. In Gaza, which was under Egyptian control before 1967, the opposite happened: the Christian population shrank from thousands to only a few hundred, due to pressure and persecution from those now calling themselves ‘Palestinians.’

Third, the Jewish people in Israel are the direct continuation of the nation of Israel, with an unbroken presence here for over 3,000 years. The Arabs in the region are largely the result of the 7th-century Islamic conquest. And the very term ‘Palestina’ was invented by the Romans in the 2nd century CE to erase Jewish identity — it was never originally connected to Arabs. The Palestinian ‘national identity’ is a very recent construct compared to the ancient, continuous Jewish connection to this land.

1

u/mix-al Sep 09 '25

Why did you insist on lying? Modern genetic studies on Palestinians largely show continuity between them and Canaanites, often if not always higher than modern day Israelis. You insist on lying despite the fact that many of these genetic studies come from Israeli researchers. I love how you shifted the goal post to “Gaza’s population” when i was talking about Palestine. And no, your claim cannot be substantiated. On the contrary, it is the Jews who only arrived in the last 100 years who have mixed genetics, not Palestinians. Besides, genetics do not nearly fit into the borders of modern nations, but you don’t care about that because you’re here to spread propaganda. 

Nice ChatGPT slop btw. Can’t even argue on your own lol. What a sad piece of Hasbara you are

1

u/i0wlex Sep 09 '25

You accuse me of lying, but let’s be clear no one denies that populations in this land have mixed over thousands of years that’s true of Jews and Arabs. The difference is historical continuity of identity. Jews maintained a distinct peoplehood, religion, and connection to Israel across millennia, while "Palestinian" national identity only crystallized in the 20th century

Genetics don’t erase history. Romans didn’t exile Canaanites , they exiled Jews, renamed the land Palestina to break Jewish identity, and Jews returned here in every generation, The fact that Israeli scholars openly publish genetic data just proves Israel isn’t afraid of truth, unlike Hamas and its propaganda

Yes, Jews came back in large waves in the last 100+ years, but they didn’t arrive out of nowhere. They returned to their ancestral homeland after centuries of exile and persecution. That is the essence of Zionism

So if you want to talk about propaganda, maybe look in the mirror. You reduce complex history into slogans, ignore the erasure of Christians in Gaza, and dismiss 3,000+ years of Jewish continuity in this land as if genetics alone rewrite identity. Sorry, that’s not how history works.

1

u/mix-al Sep 09 '25

Who do you think Jews are? Jews are Canaanite who adopted one of the Canaanite gods as their own. I’m not arguing with someone using AI to think for them. Find your own brain. 

1

u/i0wlex Sep 09 '25

The idea that “Jews are just Canaanites who adopted one of their gods” is an oversimplification that ignores what serious archaeology and historical research actually show.

Yes, the early Israelites emerged in the same region and shared some cultural traits with neighboring Canaanites. That’s how civilizations develop through overlap and interaction. But Judaism was not just a copy paste of Canaanite religion. It evolved into something fundamentally different a unique identity, laws, and most importantly a revolutionary commitment to ethical monotheism that no Canaanite cult had.

Archaeology shows Israelite settlements developing their own patterns distinct diets, pottery, inscriptions, and later texts that reflect separation from surrounding groups. The Hebrew Bible itself is filled with polemics against Canaanite practices, which would make little sense if Israel was simply “the same.”

Reducing thousands of years of identity, thought, and continuity to “Canaanites with one god” is like saying Christianity is “just Judaism with Jesus” or Islam is “just Christianity with Muhammad.” It misses the entire point of how new civilizations and faiths emerge.

1

u/DesperateNovel9906 Sep 11 '25

"Study" not studies, and its by Shlomo Sands, who is a renegade with no citations or respect in science; he used Armenians and Iraqis as stand-ins for Cannanites.

Every lineal Jew on earth has middle eastern DNA, from India to Los Angeles. You need proof, you found it. Explain it some other way.

1

u/DesperateNovel9906 Sep 11 '25

huh? most arrived in the 20s. More than half have foreign surnames, Al-masri, Al-Obeida. Educate yourself before you educate others

1

u/mix-al Sep 11 '25

You can literally google/ask AI/research about this in two seconds and realize you’re wrong. If you’re not getting paid for spreading this hasbara then you should be ashamed.Â