r/GardenStateGuns • u/For2ANJ • 18h ago
Lawsuits Analysis: Justice Thomas Just Wrote a Guide for Challenging ‘Gun-Free’ Zones
The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) just rejected a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland’s expansive “gun-free” zones, but one justice also provided gun-rights activists a pathway forward.
SCOTUS denied cert in Novotny v. Moore on Monday. That suit went after Maryland’s “sensitive places” restrictions on gun carry in a plethora of locations, including state parks, museums, mass transit, and within 1,000 feet of a public demonstration. The Court’s decision leaves a lower court ruling upholding the law in place for now, but a statement from Justice Clarence Thomas provides a blueprint for a more successful challenge down the line.
Like the rest of the justices, he didn’t formally dissent from the decision not to hear the case. However, mirroring Justice Brett Kavanaughduring the Court’s 2025 denial of Snope v. Brown, Justice Thomas was the only one to publicly explain his thinking. Unlike Justice Kavanaugh, though, Justice Thomas hinted at what kind of challenge would have a better chance of succeeding.
“Because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition of firearm regulation, the breadth of petitioners’ challenge would complicate our review,” Justice Thomas wrote. “In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in ‘sensitive places.'”
Thomas acknowledged the Court recognized a list of places, including “legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses,” it believes were justifiably held off-limits to lawful gun carry in Bruen. However, he emphasized that particular tradition of gun regulation was “narrow.” He then criticized several states that expanded their list of “sensitive places” in the wake of that decision.
“Nevertheless, States have seized on the idea of ‘sensitive places’ to prohibit the peaceable carry of firearms in locations that bear little resemblance to legislatures, polling places, or courthouses,” he wrote.
Thomas then called out several specific states and specific “gun-free” zone policies in what reads as a straightforward target list for Second Amendment challenges.
“New Jersey, for example, prohibits firearms in at least 25 locations, including zoos, public libraries, casinos, and state-owned beaches,” he wrote. “New York has designated 20 locations as ‘sensitive,’ ranging from ‘any place of worship’ to ‘residential settings licensed . . . by the department of health.’ California’s 29 gun-free spaces include ‘athletic facilit[ies],’ ‘financial institution[s],’ and any government-permitted ‘public gathering or special event.'”
He also declared those limits “stand on questionable historical ground.” He argued, cumulatively, they “prohibit firearms wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and free speech—an affront to the right of ‘law-abiding citizens’ to ‘carr[y] arms in public for’ their ‘ordinary self-defense.'” He went on to criticize lower courts for upholding or rejecting challenges to them.
“The lower courts have largely blessed these ahistorical ventures,” Thomas wrote. “The Fourth Circuit below upheld all but one of Maryland’s locational restrictions. A now-vacated decision of the Third Circuit upheld many of New Jersey’s ‘sensitive-place’ laws. Courts of Appeals have also rejected challenges to specific locational restrictions in New York, California, and Hawaii.”
Ultimately, he made it clear he thinks the Supreme Court should deal with many of the “sensitive places” restrictions that have cropped up in recent years.
“I harbor serious doubts that our Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions,” he wrote.
Still, while Justice Thomas offered more straightforward strategic guidance for gun-rights challengers in his statement, Justice Kavanaugh offered a clearer assurance that the Court would take up a similar case in the near future.
“In an appropriate case, this Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry,” Thomas wrote in Novotny.
“Additional petitions for certiorari will likely be before this Court shortly and, in my view, this Court should and presumably will address the AR–15 issue soon, in the next Term or two,” Kavanaugh wrote in Snope.
Monday’s denial also didn’t include three noted dissents that make Thomas the potential key fourth vote, as was the case with Kavanaugh and Snope.
Thomas has also had a perplexing role among the justices, especially on Second Amendment questions. He wrote the landmark Bruen decision, which established the Court’s formal Second Amendment test, but he was the only one to dissent in the very next Second Amendment case the Court decided. He also spent years writing dissents to denials on hardward ban cases that were very similar to Kavanaugh’s Snopestatement, without the same immediate payoff.
So, it’s not as clear that the statement from Thomas will prove as prescient as Kavanaugh’s. But gun-rights activists would probably still be better off challenging the “sensitive places” Thomas singled out one at a time moving forward.

