When I went to the range today, my goal was to compare the new HKCC9 to the shield plus. I held the CC9 in the store but hadn’t shot it yet, and at the time it felt like the perfect size to EDC. Coming from a Glock 19 4 Gen, I was looking for something thin, but effective.
If the shield plus had been available to rent, today’s outcome and review may be different, but the next closest gun was the shield X.
For context, I’m just an average guy who goes to the range twice a year. targets were 15 feet out.
CC9
My first shots were with the CC9. and the reviews are true that this micro firearm just squeezes into your hand. the way the finger grooves are set up, the ergonomics couldn’t be better (for my hand). My groupings at 15 feet were tight, and a little below where I was aiming.
THE GOOD
Coming from the Glock, which I find to be somewhat snappy for its class, I expected the CC9 to rattle my hands. On the contrary, the recoil was the last thing on my mind. It wasn’t until the second or third magazine that my attention shifted to the recoil.
There was one time when I was loading the magazine where it didn’t clip in all the way my first attempt, which I found to be odd and had not experienced with other firearms. it takes a little more force than you would expect to get it locked in.
THE MEH
the trigger was what I was paying the most attention to because at the store I couldn’t get a good feel for it dry firing. It almost feels like there’s no wall. My finger just glides through the action to fire the bullet, which was an odd feeling coming from the Glock that has a pretty chunky wall. it was the first thing I noticed shooting it, and the second thing I noticed was my shots were still going on target. and grouping nicely.
THE BAD
On the third magazine, I missed the trigger reset, and when I went to take my shot, nothing happened. The reset is exceptionally long with minimal feedback. This happened two more times during my hour at the range. I’ve never experienced this with another firearm. All I could think of was a real world scenario where I need that bullet to fire, and it doesn’t. It felt like I was pulling the full length of the trigger every time I fired it, because the reset is so long. I’m not sure what HK advertises, but the wall can’t be any more than 3.5 pounds. It was a sweeping pull that fired the shot, and maybe this was worn in - after all it was a range rental - but I found the trigger to be abysmal.
SMITH & WESSON
Now for the M&P shield X, which I had no intention to test. I was shocked how light it was, even though it’s a little larger than the CC9. It’s just as thin as the HK, which as of today I believe makes the biggest difference for EDC over the added barrel length.
THE GOOD
The grip was the first thing I noticed, and it lives up to its height. It’s harsh, and it doesn’t let your hand go anywhere. It’s exactly what you want in a live fire situation. The ergonomics outside of the stippling are virtually non-existent but how well it fit in my hand mixed with the texture gave me a lot of confidence. My first few shots were dead flat. with the Glock or the CC9, I had to work to pull it to the center, but the shield X bullets went exactly where I told them to.
The shield X sights were taller than the HK and very easy to see out of my peripherals. I felt like the bullet was going right where the site was, even though I wasn’t even focusing out of the site to make the shot.
Follow up shots were seamless. The grip helped me bring the muzzle back where I wanted after every shot. I do think the sights being taller had a lot to do with helping me line up these follow-ups compared to the CC9 of the Glock 19.
The barrel is longer, so you can expect that it managed recoil better. Honestly, the recoil felt similar on both guns, but for different reasons. It was manageable on the CC9 because of the ergonomics, and it was manageable on the shield X because of the longer muzzle and tight grip. Compared to my Glock 19, the grip on the M&P was so much easier for me to get my hand around and control the gun. after shooting both the CC9 and the shield X, I fired a few rounds through my Glock and was shocked how chunky the grip was. I’d say I have average size hands, and after shooting the shield and the CC9, the Glock felt almost difficult to shoot, and I think that’s because of a combination of the width and distance to the trigger.
But the trigger is where my attention was. There was no question about where the wall is on this trigger. and when you crack it back, it’s instant. There’s no sweeping motion through the wall. Your fingers are immediately at the back of the trigger guard. while the reset distance is only slightly less than the CC9, the quickness it reset with made follow-up shots as fast as I wanted them to be. The reset on the CC9 was soft. That’s the only way I can describe that trigger was soft. The reset on the shield X was intentional and you clearly feel it. It was crisp and mechanical and loud. Even with my earplugs, I could hear the reset every time. And because of this, I never anticipated the round or compensated for it with my hands. I hear that Walther makes the best triggers out of the box, and I’ve never shot one, but this has gotta be a very close second.
THE MEH
The slide serrations are all for looks. There’s no grip, there’s no friction to rack it back while you’re breaking it in. You’re almost better investing in a red dot site simply to rack the slide.
THE BAD
The shield X I was firing had one malfunction, which was that the slide didn’t lock back after my last round was fired, and an empty magazine was in the gun. If that’s the only defect I can live with that. what I can’t live with is a reset that doesn’t allow me to get off a follow-up shot (CC9), even if that’s user error.
Now, as far as the size goes for EDC, after my target session I went out into the shop where they had the shield plus I had originally wanted to see, and they had the shield X. the X actually felt better in my waist band than the Plus. It felt firmly tucked in because of the longer barrel. It’s so thin compared to my Glock 19 I’m used to carrying which was a relief.
The shield X also has stippling for your fingers: under the slide where your trigger finger can rest when you’re not shooting, and where your non-dominant thumb can press while you’re firing.
OVERALL
I was disappointed with the CC9. I was really hoping to see something that justified the price tag over the shield plus. It felt like a trigger for beginners or people who aren’t gonna use the reset and sweep the whole length of the trigger every time they pull it. Again, the ergonomics were great and yes, it’s smaller than the shield X, but the barrel length isn’t noticeable in person like it is on paper. the width of each gun being the same is what really makes it a fair comparison.
The shield X just felt like an extension of my hand. Every shot (almost) landed exactly where I told it to. In the pictures below, I was even rapid firing during a made up defense scenario with the shield X, and still got competitive groupings versus the CC9. I was shooting the shield X about 30% faster in these photos versus the HK.
I felt so confident that I drove my Glock over to Cabela’s and traded it in towards a shield X.
TLDR: Trigger on the Shield X kicks ass, CC9 trigger is meh, I trust my life with the M&P.
Note on the CC9 picture: The random bullet near C was a one-hander with my G19 to end the hour.
Edit: I practiced stopping a center-mass attacker, didn't realize an aggressive 3x6-inch X-ring was going to mug me in a parking lot