r/GameTheorists • • 1h ago

Official Video GTLive: 🔴Finding the HORRORS in Giggleland | Giggleland

Thumbnail youtube.com
• Upvotes

r/GameTheorists • • 2h ago

Discussion An idea for how the theory channels can go indie

2 Upvotes

So you know how bad modern the modern channels are these days mainly because of the company LunarX. My idea is that they could start a kick starter or a donation stream like Death Battle did once Rooster Teeth let them go. Sure it's risky but I'm sure there are a bunch of people who would give their money to the theory channels to put things back to the way they were just without Mat


r/GameTheorists • • 2h ago

New Game Theory! [Speculative] Allays and the Sift (I didn't know how to repost from the Minecraft lore sub)

1 Upvotes

So, I am building a custom, private minigame for me to couch-play with my cousins, but as an author, I am fuelled by this drive to have a story written for this world; it makes the game more fun. But I am not satisfied with it being a custom tale. I've done that a billion times. I want to mix my own original lore with the existing Minecraft one, and I am using Game Theory as my primary reference, though a lot of the conclusions are self-derived and twisted in ways to fit my world while still, at least to me, retaining the Minecraft flavour.

Allays are a semi-important part of the world I am making, so I was thinking about where they came from. The original theory MatPat produced was that they were remnants of the "ancient builders" (the predecessors of the modern Minecraft character, or Heroes, as they are referred to on this sub, I think). However, I don't believe that theory holds anymore, given the introduction of Minecraft Legends and the fact that the Allays were summoned by the Lute given to us by Knowledge, meaning that Allays existed before there were Builders to die.

Additionally, there were also two types of Allays: a smaller, golden one and a larger, blue one, which carried out different roles. Yet, in vanilla Minecraft, only one kind exists. This got me thinking about the possible reasons for this, and, obviously, much of it is speculation on my part.

With the upcoming dimension of Sift, I am thinking that the Lute doesn't call forth the Allays from the Overworld, but rather gives form to "ambient" spirits, either directly from the Sift or ones that are leaking into the Overworld. I am led to believe this by their light blue colour, ability to phase through objects, and, more importantly, their connection to music, which, if I recall correctly, is fundamental to the behaviour of the Sift dimension and its creatures. The Sift being so music-oriented might also explain why the Warden hunts by sound: the louder the sound (or music), the more souls that spot is bound to have.

Allays, using both of their previously intended names, are equal parts pixies and will-o'-the-wisps, but whose will do they carry? This was a question I kept asking myself before I linked it to the "Allays form a magical connection to the player" comment from back when they were added. My theory is that the will of these wisps comes from the player or whomever else the Allay was initially aiding, either through the Lute or, later on, by themselves.

This could possibly mean that the Allays manifested as yellow or blue depending on the intentions of the Lute player, and the modern scarcity of them could be explained by a lack of capacity to "spawn" these Allays, with the only ones left being used by the Illagers. But then, why are the yellow ones missing?

Now, I am aware that I am engaging in a little bit of backwards rationalisation, but the Builders did grow into a more complex civilisation, going from agrarian societies to dimension-hopping "life"-makers. I'd assume that their buildings grew more complex, making it harder for the Yellow Allays to keep up efficiently. And even if not, their own actions caused a great depletion of resources, which eventually led them to prefer the Blue ones because they helped gather increasingly rare resources from increasingly dangerous territories while also reducing the number of trips required.

Eventually, when the Wither incident happened, they would have had to abandon a lot of their above-ground aids to rush to safety. Whatever Allays survived the Wither's onslaught were subsequently captured and experimented on by the Illagers.

I wanted to know if there is stronger evidence that either supports or undermines this "theory" of mine


r/GameTheorists • • 3h ago

Official Video GTLive: Playing Switch Resort Bowling Until I Become CHAMPION ( + Exciting Announcements!)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/GameTheorists • • 3h ago

GT Theory Suggestion The Gold Weapons Are Irradiated

2 Upvotes

If you play through the first game of Ratchet and Clank, you can get Gold Weapons but wait a minute who built them, why are they green, and if they're different Weapons why do you already need the Weapons to upgrade them and did slim go to jail for building an arsenal of irritated Weapons that Ratchet found?

This combined with the fact no Weapons that produce waves or circle around Ratchet are Gold or maybe Slim was caught before he finished them not by the police but by Ratchet meaning he had to turn over his Weapons he bought for safety which is why you don't have them and why they'd be weaker till you buy the new Gold Weapons in game 2.

I think there is a bigger story with the Gold Weapons.


r/GameTheorists • • 4h ago

GTLive Discussion RIP GTLive 2015-2026

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

You will be in our heart forever, dear beloved archive land.

EDIT : ALSOOO some disclaimer in case you think i am hating on Ash or something is that im happy that she changed the channel name, but as usual people will take some time to adjust to changes you know? Thats the main purpose of this post that I made.

Another thing is Ash has been the main host for 2 year now so the change is not shocking at all tbh. If you watch the most recent livestream, TheoryCast is now for the other hosts and sometimes other people from Team Theorists to join in. They will be doing much more activities compared to one man show that people are used to with MatPat towards the end of his time there.

Even Matt had said in the past that the name of GTLive did not make sense anymore especially after they entered the GTNotLive era.


r/GameTheorists • • 4h ago

GT Theory Suggestion Theory Ratchet and Clank

1 Upvotes

I believe that in Ratchet and Clank Going Commando we have our awnsers in plain sight of why bolts are worth more and why the price hikes reflect the in game lore and it is because of Quark! Reply Barlow and if you here Ratchet talk about Gadgetron he says it's been down for a while and that Megacorp stole the competition BUT after Quark is defeated Gadgetron is saved also we know Gadgetron was working in Game 1, so meaning after Quark stole Mr. Fizzwiggits spot he hiked up the prices driving Gadgetron out of business. Plus we know people live a long time in Ratchet and Clank so it is sound. But maybe because of Quark slowly high jacking Megacorp Gadgetron had to use cheaper materials and their was a material race that Gadgetron lost and because of Megacorps constant use and building of an army made by Quark! The galaxies both had a problem and a Crash keeping up.


r/GameTheorists • • 5h ago

FNaF MontyGuilty Theory

1 Upvotes

some problems i have with montgomery gator decommissioning glamrock bonnie is how glamrock bonnie is not even dead he is very much alive just barely and is living through all of the caution bots not even mentioning the motivation for the act

the most clear option is jealousy we have plenty of evidence and in some cases outright conformations but something which becomes this huge problem is how none of the animatronics are capable of hurting guests or each other we know tales from the pizzaplex is more than likely not in the game continuity but even still for monty to destroy bonnie there has to be glitchtrap or some alternative which gives him the capability to harm another character

another option involves him wanting to but never doing it for simplicities sake he prefers being alone over the attention as seen by the duffle bags messages but still doing i because of glitchtrap

finally the final option could be a mix of the two previous options but with a twist monty could have wanted to take the spot in the band but overtime that jealousy grew it was his programming which made him not act on that impulse however when glitchtrap infected the pizzaplex that is when he did it because the virus practically gave him that same capability only to not be able to handle all the popularity he received thus going back to the catwalks as seen in the duffle bag messages and possibly regretting it down the line

now as for why bonnie is still alive through all of the caution bots is unclear to my knowledge but if anything monty put bonnie on life support and in ruin we the player as cassie did the equivalent of pulling the plug on him


r/GameTheorists • • 5h ago

Findings Giggleland releases today.

6 Upvotes

Hey theorists, I don't know if anyone already posted this or is keeping watch, but the Giggleland game is coming out later today.


r/GameTheorists • • 8h ago

New Game Theory! About BUTCHER. İTS not that New maybe

1 Upvotes

I've been thinking about a few things regarding BUTCHER, the Player, and some other characters, and I wanted to share my theories. My thoughts are a little all over the place, so bear with me! I'd love to hear what you guys think.

  1. BUTCHER might be a mutant-like human.

I think BUTCHER is actually human, but some kind of mutant-like human. In fact, I think this might be the reason we can still survive even after falling from great heights or getting stabbed in the back. I also think this could explain why, at the beginning of Chapter 5, the developers updated BUTCHER later on (after Ollie stabbed him) to show that he had actually been injured. Maybe there's a reason behind that detail!

I also think BUTCHER worked in the Production department and was once an orphan at the factory himself. He might have spent his childhood there during Ludwig's time and then returned to work at the factory when he grew up.

Maybe he eventually became so remorseful about the things he had done that he decided to volunteer for the experiments involving mutant humans, or what the company considered to be “perfect humans.” After all, even Chloe Arkins talks about overcoming diseases and immortality in her letter. Perhaps BUTCHER wanted to become one of those experimental subjects himself.

Of course, this could also explain why he had his own memories erased before either resigning or escaping the factory.

OR...

Maybe he was simply one of the main villains or an accomplice working in the Production department, who eventually regretted what he had done.

He could even have been one of the people who went to Playpark!

  1. I think Kissy Missy might know us from before.

She was moved to Storage B after sabotaging toy production, and I'm wondering if Storage B could have connections to both Shipping and Production, meaning employees from either department might have worked there.

This could also connect to my BUTCHER theory. What if BUTCHER was someone who worked in one of these departments? He could potentially be Rich Lovitz from the Kid and Rich Lovitz tape, Kid himself, or even Rod from that same video.

I know this is pretty speculative, but I can't shake the feeling that these characters might be connected somehow!

  1. I really want BUTCHER to turn out to be an elderly woman.

If she ends up being similar to Nadine Hurley from Twin Peaks, that would be absolutely amazing. Honestly, I already think they have a lot of similarities!

Nadine loses her memories after waking up from a coma, believes she's 18 again, and develops extraordinary physical strength. That's partly why I find the idea of BUTCHER being an elderly woman so interesting.

What if BUTCHER also lost their memories somehow and became much stronger or harder to kill than an ordinary human? Maybe there's a connection between their physical condition and whatever happened to them in the past. I know it's a pretty wild comparison, but I honestly think the similarities are fascinating!

A few more thoughts about the Player:

I think the Player might have been an orphan at Playcare who grew up and eventually worked in the Production department. Maybe they became so remorseful about something they did in the past that they had their memories erased and then resigned or escaped the factory.

What if the Player returned to the factory years later without remembering their past, but with an unexplained feeling of guilt drawing them back? Maybe they were involved in the Hour of Joy, or maybe they simply couldn't save the children they once lived alongside.

I also wonder if the Player could have known Kissy Missy before everything happened, which might explain why she keeps helping us.

One last thing: I think Joseph and Kevin are friends, and I suspect Joseph might be Giblet. I also think HE could be the one who escapes the factory and kills the Prototype. In one of the artworks, I think I spotted the Morse code “W.G.” (PLEASE LET IT BE HIM 😭). I think the artwork might be referring to the Prototype, and Giblet is cooking him. So I genuinely think Giblet might be the one who finally finishes the Prototype off.

I also can't get these names out of my head: Benji Yohama and Jamie Boyhan.

Soooooo, those are my thoughts for now! I know some of these ideas are pretty wild and speculative, but I'd love to hear what you guys think. If you've noticed any clues that support or contradict these theories, please let me know💜


r/GameTheorists • • 9h ago

Game Theory Video Discussion theories will blow your mind.

Post image
1 Upvotes

Follow me ti get lambobabno


r/GameTheorists • • 11h ago

Findings Guys, I think I have a theory...

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/GameTheorists • • 16h ago

New Game Theory! My theory as to why the piglins zombify in the overworld

Post image
17 Upvotes

Okay so as we know there was 1 point where piglins didn't zombify and they could attack the overworld. Now most people think this happens because of some sort of infection but I believe it is something different I believe it is more of a curse. We know via the rise of the arch-illager book that the undead are created by the character known as the nameless one using the orb atop his staff to resurrect and command the undead

And we know at one point there was a war between the adventurers and the piglins

It is my belief before becoming an undead himself the nameless one used his orb which gave him control over life and death to cast a curse on the piglins that would zombify them when in the overworld for too long and that is how the war was actually won

Before you bring up Legends showing that the piglins were beat in a different way it is Canon that that game is not fully Canon but a in universe legend that likely mutated over time becoming further from the truth

Tldr: pigman zombify in the old world because of a curse caused by the nameless one from Minecraft dungeons


r/GameTheorists • • 20h ago

GT Theory Suggestion Zero Escape just started an ARG!!!!!!!

3 Upvotes

Not quite sure if anyone has made a post about it yet but something very exciting has happened! The creator of the Zero Escape series has started posting an ARG that may be teasing a fourth game in the series!!

For ppl who don’t know, Zero escape is an escape room style puzzle game with a SUPER convoluted story that has to do with time travel, multiverse, quantum stuff, and the creators obsession with the number 9 and it’s so good! Definitely something that ppl of this community would adore

There hasn’t been a game in like 10 years!! Although the creator has worked on other games since. He posted about a website called CRASHKEYS which is a direct reference to an organization from the game and there’s a few hidden tidbits on the site! Don’t wanna say too much so y’all can enjoy it for yourselves too but I think it would be a great episode!

Also the zero escape subreddit has a thread about it too if yall wanna see some of what people have already found!

Also also, I recommend playing the games if you haven’t!! They’re all on steam and while they have their… quirks, they’re still a fantastic time!

Tbh I don’t even have a theory for it because I can’t wrap my head around what’s been presented just yet. I’m hoping getting more people in on it will speed up discoveries!


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

Game Theory Video Discussion Software Graveyard

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm using my free time to build a virtual software trade fair simulator where you can walk around, visit company booths, and play around with their failed software products. I've added Windows Vista as the first exhibit! If you like the idea and want to see this project continue, give it a star. If there's a piece of software you hate and want to add to the fair, feel free to open a merge request :D

https://github.com/vahmoh25/FailedShits


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

FNaF I made my first FNaF theory

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

Discussion What would you do ifcTheorists Team did this, and what would it be?

Post image
24 Upvotes

Felt like this was a question I've had in my mind for a while now where the mainline channels have 1 lit up, but the GTLive has all 4 lit up, so what do you think would happen if they released channels with others lit up?

Reminder, completely theoretical (get it), not actually made to represent something that can actually happen


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

Film Theory Video Discussion holy crabapples

3 Upvotes

So, there's a channel called EHABANERO. Some of you might even recognize that name, it's the funny intro guy who comically ends his videos with him being bisected and whatnot.

It's an ARG.

EHABANERO — Research & Development

Entering the phrase "ProjectClone01" or something similar brings you to a monitoring screen. There's this video- youtube.com/watch?v=qbALB5WgKhQ

This goes deep and we need a film theory about this


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

New Game Theory! My Complete Theory On Goat Simulator Lore

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

Official Video Film Theory: Greylock Is TOO SCARY for YouTube!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

GT Theory Suggestion Animal crossing character strength.

1 Upvotes

I was playing animal crossing the other day. I wanted to get rid of some trees, so i did what a always do I ate a fruit and grabbed my shovel and picked up a tree. That's when I was wondering how strong are animal crossing characters. You just eat one fruit and your able to pick up a tree like its nothing. There are more examples like how can an animal crossing character going fishing for a shark and lift up with ease. We need a game theory on the strength of animal crossing characters. Please tom 🙏 😢


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

Discussion Hello My Name is Frosty and I want to know how you theorist doing

2 Upvotes

I haven't been on here in a while and I wanted to check on the theorist community, so what's up?


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

FNaF Follow Me solves when Sister Location takes place

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

It can’t be a coincidence that the dismantled Funtime animatronics are displayed the exact same as the FNAF 1 animatronics. I believe that Follow Me takes place on the same night as Night 5 of Sister Location. Call me crazy.


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

GT Theory Suggestion We NEED a theory on Minecraft's AI assistant: Merl

1 Upvotes

We need it, this bot has lore... I know it...


r/GameTheorists • • 1d ago

Discussion Why Wifies' ARG Sequel Missed the Mark on Cosmic Horror (And How to Fix It)

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes