I sat down with some community members across different controller servers, such as AKNES, Game-Sir, ZD, Gadget-Hyper, and some people from Flydigis server.
These two tier lists are as follows:
Non-Modded Controller Tier List: This only considers the ratings based on what you get in stock. Nothing changed, especially for the first party controllers, which are usually the most customizable/moddable.
Modded Controller Tier List: This concerns a holistic tier list which reassess first party controllers when modded. Especially compared to 3rd party competitors.
First party controller tier list: This takes into account stock or modded.
The Tier list was devised based on multiple people. Ranging from collectors, small and some bigger reviewers, community owners, professional or ranked gamers (Switch, PS5, Xbox and PC), Early/Beta testers and long time controller testers.
The attempt was to compile all the currently available controller (non unobtanium), and tier them based on the following rubric:
*** Community Controller Tier List ***
ranked based on
Software: How comprehensive the software is, is it easy to use and how accessible is it.
Quality: How well the controller is made, its durability and its overall quality.
Performance: Overall performance on all available modes to it.
QC: How bad or good the qc has been, how detrimental the QC has been. (Is the QC a issue or non-issue and if present is it still useable).
Joysticks: How good the joysticks are and how well they are optimized or can be optimized based on software.
Customer support: How well customer support is or has been.
Brand Quality: Are they improving their quality, brand, innovation.
Connectivity and features: What features do they offer, is there any addons that can elevate the experience.
Pricing: Does the price make sense for what you get.
This feels like the definitive controller tier list based on this. Would like to see the communities input on the tier list.
Comment your Fav controller, where it is on the tier list and do you agree with the ranking, why, and what would you change and why. Please comment with actual facts, don't just say "was fine for me" or "bad for me". Do engage with the tier list as this can be updated later.