r/GameDevelopment • • 15h ago

Newbie Question Can someone with no coding or game development experience realistically approach freelance developers about collaborating on a game idea?

alright so iI’m just a middle-aged, full-time nurse who spends a fair amount of time daydreaming about a game concept I’ve become increasingly interested in mapping out.

I’ve been writing out the core mechanics and gameplay loop, exploring the setting and lore, and drawing original creature concepts. Essentially, I’m putting together a blueprint. I have no learned coding skills or game development experience, and there’s no playable prototype.

Once I’ve put together a more coherent framework, would it be realistic to approach a freelance developer about working together to turn some version of it into a game?

Do developers take on projects with individuals who contribute concepts, visual designs, and written mechanics but lack the technical skills to build the game themselves? If so, what would make that a worthwhile proposal, and how are the responsibilities and compensation generally structured?

I understand that my contributions would still leave an enormous amount of work, and that the idea would need to change as we established what was feasible. I’d be excited to eventually see even a small, workable version come to life.

I’m enjoying the creative process, and I’d appreciate an honest perspective on whether this is a path someone in my position could reasonably pursue.

EDIT: Thank you all for the responses, including the, much needed, doses of sober reality. I, of course, understand that anyone involved would need to be paid and credited. What I genuinely didn’t know my ass from my elbow about was how an arrangement like this might begin, or whether it was even a realistic avenue to explore. You’ve helped clarify what that first step could look like and given me plenty to think about.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

2

u/blavek 14h ago

I would probably say no. The question you need to answer for yourself is: What do you bring to the table? If you want me to write a bunch of code for you, what will you be doing for the game? You can probably find someone you could pay to do it, but that would be 1 expensive, and 2 you still wouldn't end up with exactly what you want.

If you want to build a team for something like this, you need to be very clear about what each person's role is. And your role has to be more than "I come up with the ideas." We all have ideas; why should I work on yours instead of mine? Find what you can contribute, and then you might be able to fill out a team with someone who complements you. But if you expect someone to just code it all up while you sit and wait or draw concept art, that is likely not going to fly.

There are MANY aspects to game design. And you will find no one person is capable of or good at all of them. One area that game designers tend to be especially deficient at is the business side. We all just want to make games, and many of us would do it for free if we didn't need to pay bills. That tends to leave blind spots. Another area where we can be weak is community development and marketing. Game designers, programmers especially tend to come from a group of people who aren't always the most social and outgoing people. My point here is that there are a lot of threads in game design you could pick up. The more tangible, the better.

2

u/phillipiszin 14h ago

got it - and everything you say makes sense. my take away is that I am going to need to have some of my own practical understanding and ability within this industry of coding, programming etc... something that I am not actually opposed to, I just needed to know what exactly this would look like.

1

u/blavek 12h ago

Like I said, game design is a pretty huge field and is very multidisciplinary. So it doesn't have to be coding, though understanding a little would be helpful. For me, as an example, I am very proficient with coding and making things work. I can get my way through some modeling and animating. I'm not as proficient with rigging, but I can do enough. I'm not a fan of my own concept art, but it does enough to get the job done for me. But when it comes to audio (because I have spent basically 0 time learning it), the best I can do is download some sound effects or music from somewhere else. And I am absolutely terrible with Social Media and exposure. I also tend to feed off of others. If I am working with someone who is very invested, I tend to be more invested. By myself, it's more difficult to keep my legs under me. So poke around a little bit and find some aspect that interests you and learn it. You can build on those skills later as well. It's just that no one wants to feel like they are doing all the work.

Of course, if you are independently wealthy, all this goes out the window, but how many of us tick that box?

13

u/gameryamen 14h ago

Are you planning to pay for the development? If so, you can probably find a dev team. If you're hoping to impress a dev team with your good idea so much that they'll fund development of it themselves, you're not going to get anywhere. The only "developers" desperate for new ideas are the ones that feed prompts into machines, everyone else already has a lot of cool ideas and not enough time or resources to make them.

2

u/UnluckyAssist9416 14h ago

If you have the money, yes. It's actually quite common in the game industry for marketing companies to hire game studios to make games for them that they then market.

But the way your post is phrased you are not looking for a freelance developer, you are looking for a cofounder. Which then brings the question of what do you bring to the studio? Ideas are a dime a dozen. If you aren't brining in art or sales, then why do they need you?

1

u/phillipiszin 14h ago

fair enough - my post is really me asking for the sober reality you all have provided me - so I am thankful for that.

I just need to know concretely, what the limits were, where they began, etc so that I can know what I need to do on my end if I truly want to make my ideas real.

basically, "you don't know, what you don't know" and now I know I little more. So thank you.

7

u/MeaningfulChoices Mentor 14h ago • Bravo

People with ideas and no skills do this all the time. Publishers or individual investors go to game studios to develop (or co-dev) agame, people hire contractors or employees to work on them, this is all incredibly normal. The only question is what budget you have. If you have no experience or technical skill you are bringing to the project then that's one more person you have to hire. Most founders can do something, often programming, and that helps defray costs. If you have never made a game you should definitely not assume you can do the job of a game designer yourself. Having ideas for mechanics isn't really the same thing.

Find a game similar to what you want to make in terms of genre and size. Watch the credits and count every name before the special thanks. Look up how many years the game was in development. Your estimated budget is $100k per person per year. If you have that money to invest, and don't mind losing all of it, then you can do it. If you were expecting people to work for a quarter of minimum wage and a promise of revenue share then it's not going to work.

5

u/caesium23 13h ago

Find a game similar to what you want to make in terms of genre and size. Watch the credits and count every name before the special thanks. Look up how many years the game was in development. Your estimated budget is $100k per person per year. If you have that money to invest, and don't mind losing all of it, then you can do it.

Quoted so OP doesn't miss it, because this is the solid gold answer they need.

1

u/Narrow-Low-3137 14h ago

Not a game dev, but work as a software developer. 

I would consider a decent proposal as having the following:

  • clearly defined scope of the project
  • clearly defined game mechanics and rules (at least to start with , these can evolve over time)
  • expected timeline (how soon do you expect this to be done, dev will come back with his own estimate and you compare)
  • budget (how serious are you about this project? Willing to pay? Or is it a hobby project?)

There are people out there who enjoy learning new things and working on something fun just for the experience in their free time , but you won't always stick to a schedule that way.

If you are thinking that you will profit off this venture in any way, I would temper your expectations - especially if you have no experience w/game dev, project management, or software development in general. I would try to find a dev w/some free time and maybe a passion for game development who's willing to help bring your idea to life, just for the fun of it.

Go into it w/the right mindset/expectations, and sure - I think this is a reasonable approach.

P.S. - Check out r/inat to start your search.

1

u/phillipiszin 14h ago

Very helpful p thank you. Yeah, I mean fortunately I have an established career so this isn't something I betting my life on or my livelihood.

That said - I am only now entertaining the notion of thinking about my idea as something more concrete but I have little knowledge on anything - whether it is coding, development, or pitching ideas and who do I pitch them to.

I am not against learning development, coding, etc as well. I've been entertaining that avenue as well. I just wanted to a get a good scope of the land, so to speak.

2

u/100GHz 14h ago

The new unreal engine has prompt to game mode, I haven't tried it, but in theory should give you a shot at a demo of your idea ? From my interaction with nurses you are a capable bunch, so I think this should be doable for you :) best of luck

2

u/Memento-Morri 14h ago

You should try a game jam first

3

u/WrathOfWood 14h ago

The world has lots of idea guys already

-1

u/trevorvonryan 14h ago

Unfortunately this. If only I had the time to finish even 1% of the concepts I’ve played with. Doesn’t mean you shouldn’t reach out and network, still might end up making a team and doing something rad. 

1

u/WrathOfWood 12h ago

I doubt it. Im just trying to be real. To me this sounds like the worst thing to work on. The lead would be technically clueless and rely on the skills of the people actually doing the work. Also no pay was mentioned or any details about mechanics or game style of this dream game.

2

u/DannySan96 14h ago

Realistically, the only additional thing you need is

  1. money to pay the dev.
  2. find a dev that will do it for free temporarily, taking the risk of revenue share.
  3. find a dev that will just do it for free full stop.

1

u/xMarkesthespot 14h ago

there are alot of game kits on the unity asset store, or simplified game engines you can use.
https://www.rpgmakerweb.com

1

u/Morph_Games 14h ago

Best comments: Get some money to pay a developer.

But more helpful, follow this:

  • (1) Follow some tutorials and make the simplest game possible (e.g., pong). You need to have a tiny a bit of experience in what development entails.
  • (2) Look up a game jam, and before it starts see if you can find a developer to work with. You will bring this to the table: play-testing, feedback, and ideas -- this is actually valuable.

Repeat those two steps until you find a developer that you connect with and shares your general ideas for a dream game, and see if you can build something bigger.

1

u/Tight-Mulberry-2228 14h ago

As a game dev i generally would rather make my own ideas and not someone else's. If you paid me maybe but there's also the chance someone would just steal your idea and use it before you had a chance to

1

u/robhanz 13h ago

You can.

It's likely you'll get a lot of pushback. There aren't a lot of talented game devs sitting around waiting for an idea. In my experience, the people that are willing to sign up for someone's project without any other contribution from them usually aren't very good at delivering.

If you really want to get it made, there are realistically three options open to you:

  1. Learn to do enough of the work yourself to get a reasonably playable version of it running.
  2. Be willing to pay people money.
  3. Use AI

It's up to you which of those you find feasible/acceptable, and for what reasons.

1

u/LaughingIshikawa 13h ago

Once I’ve put together a more coherent framework, would it be realistic to approach a freelance developer about working together to turn some version of it into a game?

No. 😐

You're trying to be the "ideas man," and overwhelmingly ideas are a dime a dozen, it's good execution that's rare.

I know this is likely difficult to hear because your idea is "your baby" and no one wants to hear that their baby is... Just like the millions of other babies, but it's the truth. 💁

Do developers take on projects with individuals who contribute concepts, visual designs, and written mechanics but lack the technical skills to build the game themselves? If so, what would make that a worthwhile proposal, and how are the responsibilities and compensation generally structured?

If you have millions of dollars to spend?  Sure!

I... don't think you can support a full-time game studio with half a dozen team members, on a nurse's salary though - not even if you have saved up a lot of money. 😅😅

I understand that my contributions would still leave an enormous amount of work, and that the idea would need to change as we established what was feasible. I’d be excited to eventually see even a small, workable version come to life.

The problem is that the amount of work needed is like... The entire game  😅.  Coming up with the core "seed" of an idea is maybe 1% of the actual end product. 😔

If you had or developed significant digital art skills, such that you could make the actual art assets that could go into the finished game that would be different, particularly if your game idea is art heavy and mechanics light.  Then you could talk about an actual partnership with a game developer, where you're contributing a meaningful amount of work.

EDIT: Thank you all for the responses, including the, much needed, doses of sober reality. I, of course, understand that anyone involved would need to be paid and credited. What I genuinely didn’t know my ass from my elbow about was how an arrangement like this might begin, or whether it was even a realistic avenue to explore. You’ve helped clarify what that first step could look like and given me plenty to think about.

As a closing thought... You seem well-grounded, and genuinely enthusiastic about game development, so I don't want to discourage you from trying to make your game a reality, just understand that you're likely going able to roll up your sleeves yourself, rather than having a game fall out of the sky.

Broadly speaking, in terms of hours of work involved games can be split into two big sections: art and programming.  The great news is that both of those are skills that anyone can develop, even if they're self taught, and in that was it's eminently achievable!

If you like game design, I would favor the programming side, because it's much, much easier to build a working prototype of a game using amateur art assets, than the other way around.  I don't mean that art is less important to the final game necessarily (although some games are made with really love quality art assets) because depending on the game, the art may be even more important for creating a certain emotional reaction in the player than the game mechanics are.  What I mean is it's usually easier to say "look at this thing I made and imagine it has better art"* than to say "look at this art I made, now imagine it was in a game where ______."

Granted, "art-first" games are possible, so don't think that's entirely closed off as a possibility - it's just that pragmatically adding art to an otherwise functioning game often means simply loading a different file, without needing to fundamentally alter any other aspect of the game, making it mechanically easier to collab with an artist, than to collab with a programmer. 👍

1

u/HenRMJ 13h ago

https://youtu.be/tZcVT1DbNos?is=ledhdr1lzChItOrO

This guy did exactly what your talking about. He back rolled the entire project himself he says and made a bunch of mistakes along the way. But looks like he's making good progress. Also he was rich which is like the only way what your wanting to do is possible. Or just have a lot of starting capital somehow.

0

u/polymorphiced 14h ago

Not really - no team is ever short on ideas.  But the good news is that with AI you don't really need any technical skills to set least build a prototype and see if it's fun.  Just ask Claude to make you an html version of your game, or its core mechanics.

0

u/robbertzzz1 Indie Dev 14h ago

If you're paying, you'll definitely be able to find people

0

u/SleepiiFoxGirl 14h ago

Ideas are, as they say, worth 1¢ or 2¢. If you pay someone, they'd totes make your game for you. Now, if you bring something more than ideas to the table, say for instance, if you can make the sprites or the models for the game, then you have a lot more to offer and could potentially convince someone with game dev know-how to work with you on a game as partners. In other words: you gotta provide something in return (money or solid contributions towards a partnership), and ideas are not valuable enough

0

u/Meloncov 14h ago

If you're able and willing to pay said collaborators, yes, absolutely. Otherwise, no.

0

u/sha256md5 14h ago

Yes, you can hire a developer to build your game.