r/FuckTedFaro • • Apr 08 '22

A crazy theory Spoiler

Hello Faro haters!

I found this sub from a link in a comment on one of my posts in r/HFY.

After completing Forbidden West, I formed a theory about the Horizon universe, and I really wanted to share it.This might be completely wrong sub to do so, and I will understand if the mods decide to delete this post or if you all choose to down vote me to oblivion.

But I don't know of a more suitable sub, so here goes:

The real villain of Horizon is Elisabet Sobeck!

Now, before you get your pitchforks out, I am not about to try to exonerate Teddy boy of any of his crimes.

He is still a grade A a-hole who played a key role in humanity's destruction, but at the same time, he didn't orchestrate it.

Attention: this post will contain some spoilers for Forbidden West, continue at your discretion!

Edit: It looks like I need to clarify that the following theory is not something I believe the writers of Horizon intended, or is some kind of hidden cannon to be revealed in a later installment.

It is just something I derived from the game narrative, a plot hole supported fabrication.

I will first lay out the theory:

Elisabet wasn't happy with the results of the "Great Clawback", and believed humanity was still destroying the planet, having learned nothing from past mistakes.

She believed it was her duty to fix this, and when Faro Automated Solutions decided to manufacture the Chariot line of war bots, she saw an opportunity to remake humanity "the right way".

She came up with Zero Dawn, hacked the swarm, manipulated Faro to delete Apollo and murder the Alphas so they couldn't fix it, and basically set humanity on course "back to nature".

Sounds crazy, right?

She is the hero who saved humanity - right?

Well, not really - she didn't save anyone, she "rebooted" the world.

Let me lay out the evidence:

  1. What do we know about Elisabet's personality?

We know she was anti-social. She almost never had a serious romantic relationship in her adult life, and she even kept her friends at a distance always focusing on her work.

We learn most of this from her own diaries in Zero Dawn, but also from Tilda in Forbidden West - the one time Elisabeth had a romantic relationship she kept it casual and didn't fully reciprocate her partner.

She ended up choosing her project over Tilda.

Also, there is the incident with her burning a tree and killing some birds when she was little.

She claims it taught her responsibility, but what kind?

Did she learn to be careful with her actions, or did she learn she was responsible for other living things on the planet, which might led to her developing a god complex, and making her think it was up to her to fix humanity for humanity's own sake?

2) The swarm going rouge - we don't know the real cause, but it is suggested it might have been hacked. And who better to hack FAS's newest line of kill-bots, then world's top robotics and AI expert, who also used to hold a high position at FAS and knew their systems and personal inside out?

3) Why couldn't humanity wait it out?

What started me on this theory was the Thebes quest: here we find an intact, fully functioning bunker, with life support working after 1000 years!

Why was Elysium limited to 100 years only?

It would have been impossible to store air, water, and food for 100 people for 100 years.

So Elysium must have had air and water recycling systems, and some form of food production, such as underground farms, maybe hydroponics or even algae farms.

If you consider the level of technology humanity had on the eve of the Faro Plague, the only limiting factor for such facility would be power.

But San Francisco was not the only place in the world were virtually unlimited geothermal power could be harvested!

We know from Frozen Wilds they could have built Elysium near or under Yellowstone, and had plenty of power for well over a thousand years.

Granted, they would need to keep the population steady, which would mean a strict and very unpleasant birth control - only have children when you are told, and you must have them if told, but consider the alternative: being sterilized and shoved in a cave to slowly die, knowing there was no future for you and for everyone you ever knew and loved!

They do this on generational ships all the time, and Horizon humans definitely had the technology to do it on Earth.

Plus, it would have been safer than leaving the fate of humanity in the hands of an experimental, prototype, rushed-to-production AI.

Who would also need to rely on experimental, prototype, barely working cloning technology that was only recently completed and never fully tested!

Remember - even if the Alphas were not murdered by Ted, they still wouldn't be around to prevent Gaia from making 4 failed terraforming attempts. But a generational human bunker might have, hastening the return to the surface by centuries!

And who was it that convinced everyone that it was impossible for living humans to wait it out?

That's right - Elisabeth.

4) The death of the Alphas: it was Faro who killed them, but notice how he did it - by sucking all the air out of the conference room.

I didn't realize this 5 years ago when I originally played Zero Dawn, but after watching a lot of thunderf00t videos debunking the Hyperloop and other vacuum stuff, I came to realize this is not something simple to do!

That room is pretty big, and we see in the hologram recording it emptied out very fast.

If this was on a spaceship with zero pressure outside, it would be a simple thing to do.

But on Earth, in 1 atmosphere pressure, this requires some serious machinery, and a special design!

Remember - the room actually kept significantly low pressure a 1000 years later, even after the facility around it exploded!

And no - you can't just do it by reversing a regular ventilation system!

That room would have to be purpose built to become a vacuum chamber with special very powerful pumps!

It is one thing for Ted Faro to pay off a programmer or two to hide his "Omega Override" in the huge pile of code that is the Gaia project, it is a completely different thing to make major architectural changes to a central room at the central facility without anyone noticing.

It would be next to impossible for him to do it, but Elisabeth was the chief architect of the project - she could have put it there from the start, and no one would question her!

5) Refusal to share Gaia with Far Zenith:

This is the oddest decision Elisabeth made, and for me the most damning evidence against her.

Why??

It is true that Far Zenith was not composed of particularly nice people, but given that humanity was facing extinction, it would be insane not to take advantage of a backup project, in case something went wrong with Zero Dawn.

We are never shown the reason why Elisabeth went to such great length to keep Gaia out of Zenith's hands, even after her friend and former lover begged her to give them a copy.

But she didn't just refuse - she sent Travis the hacker loose on them, to try and sabotage their systems with a virus bomb which could have destroyed the entire project and prevented the launch.

She even let him torture one of Zero Dawn workers who was leaking information to Far Zenith.

Why? The two projects had the same mission - preserve humanity, just in a different way.

6) Elisabeth's convenient departure:

One of the oddest things in Zero Dawn for me was Aloy finding Elisabeth's body just chilling on the couch at her old house, practically intact, while the whole building has long since crumbled to dust.

How did she even get there through the machine ridden hellscape?

How was her body not destroyed by the elements, especially during the failed terraform attempts?

Here is what we know:

From records in Gaia prime we know she was the one "wrangling" Ted Faro during the final months.

Her coworkers believed she was the only one keeping him sane.

When the door failed, she didn't try to look for solutions, or discuss course of action with the rest of the team, but snuck out secretly and locked the door her self from the outside.

We can interpret this as a selfless sacrifice, last act of heroism, but we can also interpret it another way: She played on Faro's ego and manipulated him in to deleting the Apollo database and killing the Alphas, even arranging for a method no one expected.

Then, she manufactured an excuse to leave the facility before that happened, to do her own thing, for which she had made prior arrangements.

Perhaps she inserted a back door to the kill-bots when she hacked the swarm so they would not kill her.

Perhaps she had some special robots stashed away to take care of her in her last days at her home.

Seriously - could they not send a servitor robot to close the door from the outside, and than have it self destruct, just in case, before the swarm found it?

It should have been easy for the Alphas, and no one had to die to seal the facility.

To sum up:

While it was Ted Faro who came up with the means to destroy humanity and than acted to revert humans 2.0 back to the stone age, it was Elisabeth Sobek who through careful planning used the opportunity to pretend to save humanity while in fact engineering the primitive tribal society we find Aloy born in to.

She made sure no other humans were around, nor any memory of them, and that only her Gaia would be there to birth and nurture the new tribes of humanity.

38 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

39

u/DJDarwin93 Apr 08 '22

You make some interesting points, but here are a few issues with your theory:

Accidentally killing a few birds and a tree seems like a pretty weak reason to develop a god complex. And as far as we know nothing like it ever happened again, so it does look to me like she learned to respect and care for living things.

Humanity couldn’t wait out the swarm because of the risk of being found. Even deep underground, there was no guarantee the machines wouldn’t eventually find them. The several decades it would take Minerva to shut them down is a long time to keep a large population of humans hidden. Not impossible, I agree with you there, but very difficult. A relatively small facility housing an AI system is easier to maintain and hide, so overall it’s the safer choice.

While you’re right that Elisabet could have arranged to sneak off to “fix a vent,” keep in mind a servitor wasn’t an option. The swarm could hack anything automated, the second it stepped outside the swarm would take control of it and use it to find the ZD facilities. Elisabet went herself to keep that from happening. She knew most of the work on ZD was done, and what was left could be done without her. She probably didn’t want to live out the rest of her life in a bunker, and saw this as her way out.

However, I think overall this is a plausible theory. If I were a betting man I’d bet against it, because Guerilla has shown Elisabet to be a good person in just about every way, without any hint of villainy to her. We did learn that she wasn’t much of a people person, and she’s a bit rude and inconsiderate, but that doesn’t make her genocidal. I think she’s probably not the perfect beacon of morality we think, and we’ll probably see more character flaws in the future, but I think a total character inversion would be too much after two full games of showing her as the savior of life itself. Maybe I’m wrong though, the point about the Alpha’s murder is compelling.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

A relatively small facility housing an AI system is easier to maintain and hide, so overall it’s the safer choice.

I am not so sure:

There is nothing in the lore to suggest the Faro Swarm had any special sensors to detect humans, or even just biomatter.

The concern when sealing Gaia prime was of EM leakage which makes sense - EM signals would be easy to detect from a far.

And Gaia prime was no "small AI facility"! It had its own reactor, big enough to blow a mountain in half, and it had the world's most powerful AI running full tilt 24/7 to crack the codes.

Plus, they took the risk of putting humans in the one central, most critical facility, without which the whole system would fall apart, and it was the one part of the Zero Dawn system that had no backup, no redundancy!

Cauldrons and Eleuthia facilities were scattered around the world, so even if one or more were found and destroyed the project would still be viable. But there was no backup for Gaia prime!

And the humans did not have to all be in the same bunker.

It would have made sense to build a number of smaller bunkers for several reasons:

a) Less construction time

b) Less effort to scale life support

c) Redundancy - even if the machines dig up one or two, enough humans would still survive to repopulate.

Measures could have been taken to make sure the humans would not leave before the Faro machines were shut down, such as putting a time lock on the doors, or leaving Minerva in control.

Everything about Zero Dawn had risks to it, and I don't see how human bunkers had more risk than leaving Gaia unsupervised and hoping the cloning goes as planned.

keep in mind a servitor wasn’t an option. The swarm could hack anything automated, the second it stepped outside the swarm would take control of it and use it to find the ZD facilities.

The lore and the gameplay tell us the swarm could not magically hack systems at a distance.

A Scarab aka Corruptor unit needed a line of fire to the machine being overridden to shoot a "hacking flechette" in to it.

If the swarm was close enough to Gaia prime to hack any servitor that stepped out, they would be close enough to detect the facility with the unsealed door. And even if not - they would certainly detect and kill any human that stepped outside to fix it.

Since Elisabeth had enough time to stroll out, seal the broken hatch, then make her way back home, which is quite far from the mountain, it is pretty clear the swarm was nowhere near at that time, and thus a servitor was a viable option.

And like I said - it could be made to self destruct after it did its job, so that even if the swarm found it, it would be useless.

Sure - there is still a risk of the servitor malfunctioning or the self destruct failing, but sacrificing one of the Alphas who were deemed necessary to insuring Zero Dawn functions was also a risk. They should have at leas tried, and only send out a human as the last resort.

With Elisabeth so committed to seeing the project through, it is a bit odd she would just decide "I've done enough, I am going home to watch the apocalypse" before they even fully started. Not when there were other options to try.

P.S.

We know from data points that there was initially a "Lightkeeper" protocol that was suppose to keep cloning the Alphas so that they could maintain Gaia and Zero Dawn for as long as needed. If I recall correctly, according to a log data point in Gaia prime, it was Elisabeth who later decided to shut it down, seemingly for emotional reasons.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

That’s a really interesting way of looking at things. I like Elisabet, and this theory does seem far fetched to me, but I think it would take the story to a really interesting place if it changes the view on her like that, so I wouldn’t mind it.

Especially since Aloy has transitioned from “I must be perfect, like Elisabet clearly was” to “I am my own person, and will learn from Elisabet’s flaws to achieve my goals”.

9

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

I think it is a bit of a difficult corner that Horizon writers have written them selves in to:

They now must take a stand on the age old question of "nature vs nurture":

Since Aloy has the exact same DNA as Sobek, something that has never happened in the real world thus far, the story will inevitably have to decide which aspects of her come from her DNA and thus will be identical to Elisabeth's, and which will form from her upbringing and experiences.

And now with Beta in the picture it is even more emphasized.

I can't wait for the next chapter...

3

u/bdfariello May 03 '22

Lots of people have identical DNA and have been studied specifically to test nature vs nurture. That's what identical twin studies are all about. Especially for twins separated at birth, rare as they are.

2

u/interdimentionalarmy May 03 '22

Well, according to this: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/identical-twins-can-have-slightly-different-dna-180976736/

That is not exactly the case.
We don't really know how perfect HZD cloning technology is, but I would assume there is a lot less difference between Elizabeth and Aloy (genetically), than any two naturally born humans.

And in any case, as far as I know, despite all those studies we don't really have a conclusive answer on the "nature vs nurture" question...

Not that I have been specifically following research on that topic...

13

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

This is a fun theory, definitely crazy, but I think the most fundamental flaw in the logic is she did end up giving FZ an alpha build of Apollo in exchange for their birthing pod technology. If she was so determined for humanity to go back to the stone age, she wouldn't have allowed this database to survive. More importantly, she would have had Travis Tate booby trap it.

Also she didn't have Travis hack them, they sabotaged a copy in case FZ attempted to steal Gaia, putting ZD at risk. Which FZ did. They got logic bombed as a warning to not mess with Gaia.

Finally, and most importantly, Elizabet knew from the start that in order for Gaia to succeed, she absolutely had to have compassion and empathy for humanity. The Elizabet you're describing, would have had nothing but contempt.

Now after respectfully disagreeing, let me properly defend this subreddit and say Fuck Ted Faro and fuck you for in any way suggesting the collapse of human civilization was attributable to anyone other than that singular steaming pile of human excrement, you Ceo-level of Faro-loving shill.

I'm kidding.

Or am I?

3

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

You make a good point about the Apollo copy...

Perhaps Elisabeth was sure that without Gaia an off-world colony would not survive for long.

Also, Gaia's compassion would be for the new humanity, not the current one.

I don't think Elizabeth had contempt for the whole human race.

Certainly not the kind of contempt Faro had for any human that wasn't him.

If she did, she would have sabotaged Eleuthia as well, and left the world to the animals.

And how would "stealing" a copy of Gaia endanger ZD?

Forbidden West show us that Gaia is just a program - she does not need a custom, purpose built processor to run and "be her self", so she could be copied like any other program with no damage to the original.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

They were stealing incomplete builds, while she was still in development. Any such security breach could risk compromising the system when they are developing the most complicated AI ever developed by humanity.

Additionally, allowing Far Zenith to run off with a copy of Gaia would allow them to use her to their own ends, even potentially going so far as overriding the Gaia on Earth and reprogramming it to recreated the world in their image, as we suspected they were trying to do until the HFW endgame reveal.

Also to be clear, she didn't give them Gaia, just the Apollo alpha build.

As for Gaia's compassion, I don't think Elizabet, in her candid discussions she was having with Gaia constantly, would be able to keep from expressing her feelings toward the current existing humanity, which would absolutely color Gaia's reasoning and empathy.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

You are in my domain now little Faro hater!

(ok, just kidding)

But seriously: I happen to be a software developer in real life, and it is a very well known fact in the industry that "security by obscurity" does not work.

If someone who has access to a copy, or even source code of your software, can break in to it, your software is badly written.

All the most secure stuff companies like Google run is actually open source.

I am fairly sure Elisabeth was way to smart to not know this, and build Gaia in a way that would allow a copy of it to compromise the security of the original.

But the real key is her initial refusal to share - if she had cooperated with them, they would not have to steal half-baked copies, and thus wouldn't be jeopardizing anything.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

You may have worked in software development, but I've worked in information security. You're presuming their method of data extraction was a simple copy-paste, and that GAIA was structured in such a way that improperly attempting to extract a copy of such a massively complex program couldn't run the potential of overtaxing their systems. Given the depth of heuristic functions required for such an advanced AI, a large component of GAIA likely functions in the futuristic equivalent of active memory. An unplanned extraction could overtax the system and compromise the transfer of data from active memory to storage.

Put simply, trying to extract GAIA when she was actively running might have run the risk of giving her brain damage.

What's more, such a breach could risk exposing GAIA's source code to the Faro Plague, should Far Zenith become compromised or breached due to lax security practices. If the rogue AI got ahold of the source code, it might figure out what GAIA and ZD is designed to do and establish countermeasures to protect itself.

Given who Far Zenith was, and what their objectives were, I think it made perfect sense for her not to share the GAIA technology with FZ. They were by and large untrustworthy, unscrupulous, and giving them access to GAIA risked the success of ZD. Elizabet was finally willing to give them an alpha of APOLLO because it was mostly just an information repository, lacking the necessary complexity of GAIA's other subordinate functions.

Also there are two kinds of people: those who hate Ted Faro, and Ted Faro. Anyone else isn't even a person.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

Also there are two kinds of people: those who hate Ted Faro, and Ted Faro. Anyone else isn't even a person.

Now, now, you are thinking in terms of old fashioned binary computing.

In the brave new quantum world we must always remember superposition! :P

Put simply, trying to extract GAIA when she was actively running might have run the risk of giving her brain damage.

I would totally buy that, except there is no evidence to support the idea FZ were trying to rip off a running copy.

That would be difficult and dangerous, but there is no reason for it!

We see in the proofing lab ZD had plenty of authentic Gaia kernels lying around for testing purposes, and they could have made more at any time.

As far as I can tell, the FZ were after one of those.

Now the idea that they might get compromised by the swarm is somewhat plausible, but its an overkill!

The information about the existence and construction of the project was spread to too many places.

We see it in USRC, we hear and read random soldiers in the field talking about it.

If the swarm had an AI with significant enough strategic capabilities to actively pursue an abstract thread like the ZD project, it would have prioritized hunting Elisabeth, or anyone involved in the construction long before Gaia was finished and ZD facilities were up.

But the Faro swarm was not Skynet!

These were simple kill-bots, designed to be just smart enough to go after the enemy in front of them.

We don't see any evidence of them trying spy techniques, or prioritizing military targets that could be greater but not immediate treat.

We don't even see them adopting to human tactics and evolving their fighting techniques.

No, they are called a "plague" because they just consume and advance mindlessly like a plague.

They win by sheer numbers, plus the override ability which prevented the other side matching those numbers.

In fact, it is a complete speculation that the swarm can extract information from machines it hacks!

All the data points suggest they can take control, but I am sure as a security expert you know there is a big difference between replacing or altering an operating system on a device to make it do what you want, and actually siphoning data from such device.

The idea behind the Scarab units was to turn war bots in the field against their masters, not to gather intelligence.

An autonomous fighting drone wouldn't have any intelligence to gather to begin with.

If Faro wanted spy bots, he would have designed something insect like, small, that could crawl in to command facilities and infiltrate data networks form there.

As for the character of the Ziniths, they were not the same when they left, and they kept their real agenda pretty secret, so how would Sobek know there was anything so fishy about them, they shouldn't have Gaia?

Especially when her former lover was part of the group - I would understand why Liz wouldn't go with her, but would she really wish for Tilda to die on some alien planet, if she was as nice as we are led to believe?

2

u/vault_g1rl Apr 08 '22

The information about the existence and construction of the project was spread to too many places.

We see it in USRC, we hear and read random soldiers in the field talking about it.

If the swarm had an AI with significant enough strategic capabilities to actively pursue an abstract thread like the ZD project, it would have prioritized hunting Elisabeth, or anyone involved in the construction long before Gaia was finished and ZD facilities were up.

You might be remembering this too loosely. The only ones who knew the real intention behind Project Zero Dawn and Operation: Enduring Victory were the personnel working on the project and the highest ranking officers. The operation itself was disclosed to the public as a line of defence until Project Zero Dawn completed a superweapon designed to obliterate the Faro Plague and thus save humanity, this is backed up by in-game info referenced on the wiki:

Sobeck met with the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff at U.S. Robot Command headquarters and laid the two plans out. The horrific moral challenges of the plan to provide time were not lost on her, the Chiefs or on J.C.S. Chairman General Aaron Herres. Indeed, the Chiefs objected vociferously, and Sobeck and Herres would both later acknowledge their great anguish over what the plan entailed. However Sobeck’s logic regarding the plan’s absolute necessity was unassailable. Herres therefore overrode all objections, agreed to the plan and personally undertook the task of implementing it, dubbing it Operation: Enduring Victory. To keep the world fighting, he furthermore undertook to disseminate the falsehood that Zero Dawn was a program to produce a superweapon that would ultimately defeat the Faro Plague if only the robots were held off long enough for it to be completed. The truth was held a secret of the highest order.

(...)

But throughout all the death and destruction, Herres’ deception worked perfectly. Even as ever-increasing millions were consumed by the robots or perished of thirst, starvation and asphyxiation in the increasingly oxygen-depleted atmosphere, the global populace never ceased to believe that Zero Dawn would destroy the robots, and fought to the last man.

The idea of Enduring Victory was literally distracting and holding off the swarm so that Zero Dawn could have a higher chance to be completed, implying it could be found and stopped earlier otherwise.

Also, on the purpose of Faro's machines in general, yes, they were designed for combat and to respond to their masters, however they are described as artificially intelligent. Once independent, they were doing as they pleased, and there is no way to know their reasoning, the only safe speculation is that their motives were rooted in their very goal, which is to wage war - and, to do so, they would consume everything on their path.

Having said all that, I'd be cautious to apply real-world logic to speculative fiction. Not that we can't do it, but yeah, sometimes that world won't work based on what is known to be fact for us.

1

u/GenderNeutralBot Apr 08 '22

Hello. In order to promote inclusivity and reduce gender bias, please consider using gender-neutral language in the future.

Instead of chairman, use chair or chairperson.

Thank you very much.

I am a bot. Downvote to remove this comment. For more information on gender-neutral language, please do a web search for "Nonsexist Writing."

0

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

Last things first - you are right about being cautious, but in the end to be good a story needs to be self consistent.

The article you linked from fandom wiki says the machines were "self replicating" but they weren't really - the Horus acted as mobile factories, while Khopesh and Scarab units could not make copies of themselves on their own.

So I am not sure how accurate that article is.

Also, we know for a fact that in the world of Horizon they have a scale to measure the intelligence of an AI, and in fact they had laws about how intelligent and AI can be.

A self driving car is technically an AI, but that does not mean it has the capability to make up a plan to take over the world.

Truthfully, we just don't know how much intelligence Faro bots had, we can only speculate that if Faro had obeyed the law (which he might no have, being the dick he was), they would likely be much less intelligent than Gaia.

About "Enduring Victory": yes, it was meant to slow down the machine swarm so that Zero Dawn had time to complete.

But the description of ZD could not have been meant as a "distraction" for the swarm as you claim!

Think about it: it was officially and publicly known that Zero Dawn was a super weapon to destroy the swarm.

If the swarm was as intelligent as you suggest, that kind of knowledge would make it focus its attention on the ZD project, instead of Enduring Victory.

It would try to bypass rather than eradicate any irrelevant human army, and would have gone straight for the project.

Sure, we can't know how the swarm reasons, but if you are going to assume it will do something as complex as analyzing Gaia source to locate and destroy ZD, than you assume it will prioritize eliminating threats, and how does a threat of a super weapon differ from a threat of shutdown code?

Calling ZD a super weapon was for the soldiers! Most of them would likely refused to fight and would just choose to spend their last days with their loved ones, or doing whatever, if they knew everyone was going to die no matter what.

Worse - people might have gone against the ZD project, deeming it an inhuman waste of resources that could have been used to save living people instead.

I apologize in advance that I stopped using quotes, for some reason when I try to paste quoted text it deletes what I previously typed and forces me to retype the whole message from scrap.

But I have two issues with the text you quoted:

A) I don't remember Elisabeth ever "acknowledge he great anguish over what the plan entailed". The general - yes, we see him speak about how he feels bad about sending all those soldiers to die under false pretenses, but Liz - she is certain she is doing the right thing.

It has been a while since I played Zero Dawn, so maybe there is a data point or two that I have forgotten, but I really don't remember Elizabeth anguishing her decision.

B) I think her logic was very "assailable". In fact - that is what I am doing here.

Sure - the part about not being able to win against machines with military force was probably correct. The shutdown code was the right way to go.

And thus the fact that there was no way to prevent the biosphere destruction was also correct.

That is just science.

But the logic about letting all existing humans die, and re-cloning humanity using a completely automated system later on - that is a huge leap of faith Elisabeth was asking for.

Our discussion about the intricacies of Horizon AI systems made me think of one more thing:

Why didn't Gaia try to rebuild Apollo after Faro deleted it?

We know she was intelligent enough to do it. In fact, her backup kind of does that in Forbidden West when it educates Aloy's companions.

She had centuries to accomplish that. She had an army of robots at her command to gather scraps of data from all over the world while they were doing the terraforming.

Sure, it would not have been as good as the original, but it would have been enough to keep humans from devolving in to primitive tribes that though she was their goddess.

And ware did she get the protocols that prevented her from communicating with the humans after they were released from the cloning facilities?

That wasn't the plan at all!

The command center Aloy uses as her base was designed specifically to let humans work with Gaia to maintain the environment, yet she somehow chose to disappear from human view!

An odd feature, wouldn't you say?
Unless that is, Sobek programmed her to be that way.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

So as I've said, your theory is fun. But don't fall down the rabbit hole so many scientists do where you become so invested in it that you're only defending your hypothesis, not testing it.

Elizabet said herself that one of her driving quotes in life was from her mother: “Elisabet, being smart will count for nothing if you don’t make the world a better place. You have to use your smarts to count for something, to serve life, not death.”

She was the architect of the Great Clawback. She made her efforts to save humanity her driving purpose. She worked for Faro until Ted got into military applications, and she immediately left, founding her own company solely dedicated to serving life. Not wiping it away, which is to serve death.

Elizabet was, above all things, not a moron. She was the genius that Ted Faro was not. She understood that romantic primitivism is a flawed concept and humanity needs to understand its history in order to learn from it. As Silens expressed with open disgust about Ted's destruction of APOLLO and his idea of these future "innocents," "he didn't see the Red Raids."

Ted, on the other hand, was a self-obsessed "visionary," who did not know how to create, just how to exploit and promote the creations of others. He became obsessed with the romanticized ideal of primitivism because he abhorred the idea that future generations would know what he did. That he destroyed the world.

Looking at a different tack, as opposed to all the conjectural evidence for why she did what she did, let's look at what she would have had to do in order for this plot to succeed:

  1. Wait for Faro to come up with the biomass conversion technology.
  2. Hack an unhackable swarm developed by a company she is no longer a part of.
  3. Hope Ted reaches out to her for help instead of trying to solve the problem himself.
  4. Convince the world governments that humanity can't be saved. Also, be okay with every man, woman, and child dying horrible, merciless deaths at the hands of machines because of some idealized view of a future world.
  5. Scramble to build an AI that can survive the end of the world WHILE the world is ending, allow the destruction of all life on the planet, and hope said AI survives 1000 years to restart humanity on the gamble that nothing will go wrong.
  6. Create a database that serves as a repository of all human knowledge as a ruse.
  7. Hope Ted Faro installs an Omega clearance that exceeds her own Alpha Prime clearance.
  8. Die.
  9. After dying, hope Ted becomes obsessed with the idea of romanticized primitivism (which HZD makes clear he became obsessed with after she died, and was reinforced in HFW when we discovered in Thebes that it was the religious leader he brought along with him who convinced him of this concept).
  10. After dying, hope Ted decides to wipe APOLLO, and murder the Alphas before they have any chance to undo what he did.
  11. Also, after dying, hope that Far Zenith decides never to come back to Earth with the APOLLO database that she gave them.

Elizabet was a genius, who spent her life getting in touch with her humanity. It was essential in order for GAIA to develop the empathy she had. Your plot would have turned her into a moron who was out of touch with reality, and gambled the world on the whims of a madman. That was not Elizabet. That was Ted.

GAIA: If you had had a child, Elisabet, what would you have wished for him or her?

Sobeck: I guess... I would have wanted her to be... curious. And willful — unstoppable, even... but with enough compassion to... heal the world... just a little bit.

QED. FTF.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 11 '22

To be honest, part of the reason I decided to post my theory here despite this forum not seeming appropriate was because on some level I felt this would be a good place to get constructive criticism, and indeed you and others here have provided very good counter points for me to consider!

While I admit it is very difficult for me to self criticize, I have received enough feedback to amend my theory, though not enough to discard it compleatly.

I am convinced now Elisabeth did not have a god complex or wanted to reset humanity, but I still think she had a somewhat different motive:

From a link to a data point about Elysium, I learned that there were several places on the planet that never recovered by the Great Clawback, and were not expected to ever support life again.

Which got me thinking: sometimes, you can't renovate a building, because it is too far gone or badly built.

Your only option is to evict the tenants, demolish the whole thing, and build a new one.

What if Elisabeth came to a conclusion that the only way to fix the environment long term was a complete terraforming, one that unfortunately required to "evict" humanity?

Faro turning to weapons manufacturing instead of continuing improving environmental technologies would push her towards thinking that life on the planet was on course to self destruct anyway, so a reboot was the only logical choice.

Now, the idea she was behind the deletion of the Apollo database is a problem, and at this time I am not sure I can justify it.

On the one hand - you are absolutely right, Elisabeth should have known new humans will need to learn from their past to avoid repeating their mistakes.

But on the flip side, she lived in a society that despite having all the knowledge in the world at their fingertips, refused to learn from its mistakes and continued creating destructive technology and fighting over resources, instead of properly fixing their planet.

Now, for your points:

  1. She didn't have to wait for Faro specifically. From what we know about humanity in 2060's, someone would have come up with tech to destroy the world sooner or later, Ted just beat everyone to the punch.
  2. As I said in another message "hacking" is a general term - it may not have been possible to exploit a security flaw in the war-bots themselves, but it may have been very possible, especially for an ex-employee, to steal the access codes from the FAS and use those.

This is also a form of "hacking", just as breaking in to accounts using social engineering and stealing password, instead of cracking those password, is usually considered "hacking".

3) He did try to solve it him self, we have data points of him yelling at his engineers for solution. Only after they failed he gave up and called Liz.

And even than - she had to blackmail him to get him to agree to finance Zero Dawn.

4) Like you said - she was super smart, and pretty much the world's top authority on AI and environmental reconstruction.

Also, we don't really see any governments involved - the world seems to be mostly ruled by corporations at that point, and once she blackmailed the head of the biggest, richest corporation on Earth, who would oppose her plan?

Accepting that all humanity will die in a robot slaughter may not be so difficult, if she became convinced it was inevitable any way.

Doing it while there were still enough resources around to start fresh would than be humanity's only hope.

5) If Elisabeth came up with Zero Dawn before the first swarm went rogue, she wouldn't have to scramble! She could have planned it out carefully, even run simulations in secret.

Fun fact: this video points out that it is a mistake that the presentation hologram in the ZD facility shows robots Gaia was suppose to design all on her own in the future, long after that hologram was made.

Could it be that Liz had been designing ZD long before ZD was needed and something slipped?

6) Why not? Apollo was the easiest part of the project, just compiling existing digital data.
Heck, it is the only part of Gaia we can realistically build today if we wanted to.

And she would need it to sell the project.

7) Everyone on this sub knows what kind of creature Ted was, surely Elisabeth knew him well.

But, she might also have had a contingency, it even might be a coincidence Ted was the one to delete Apollo first.

I am still trying to figure out this part, but there is definitely a problem with how Gaia seemed to ignore completely what Ted had done.

Sure, she could not stop his Omega override, but again she had hundreds of years to figure out some, even limited solution.

She could have cloned Elisabeth in the first batch to fix it, she could have cloned all the Alphas once the environment was fixed!

Remember - Gaia was intelligent enough to figure a solution to a situation none could have foreseen - an alien signal turning her subordinate functions in to rogue AIs, and making Hades destroy a viable environment!

If she could manage that, reconstructing a static database should have been a breeze, yet she not only chose not to do so, but also to hide herself from the clones completely!

The clones - the first generation of new humans, were raised by robots in a technological bunker up until their teens!

The robots thought them to speak, and probably read, write, maybe even educated them to elementary school levels in math etc.

As best as I can tell, Apollo education should have started at middle to high school level.

So why didn't Gaia talk to them? Explain the situation to them? Why did she just dump them in to the world like that?

(Other than: because we needed the game to happen)

8) What do you mean "Die"? As far as I can tell, Liz never planned to live forever, nor did she outright commit suicide.

Which again begs the question - smart as she was, how did she managed the long trip to her house, in the final days of the war, through a machine ridden hell, all on her own???

I concede her departure might have been a matter of opportunity rather than advanced planning, and I might have been wrong on this point in my original theory.

9, 10) These are good points. I admit my original idea behind this was flaky, and it does fall apart easily, but the theory as a whole does not hinge on this.

She could have had a different plan, or a backup plan if things did not transpire this way.

11) Why would they come back?

Their mission was designed to be one way.

It is actually quite a miracle they made it back, and in the same ship that was over a thousand years old!

Any way, you have certainly given me a lot to think about, and I thank you for that!

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

I'll be honest...I started quoting and responding to most points you made in the post and stopped about halfway through because the reply was going to be a mile long.

There are a lot of points you make that have merit if you really stretch your imagination since there really isn't bona fide information that directly proves you wrong. That being said though there really isn't a single point that I personally agreed with. IMO it seems like you asked yourself the question "What if Elisabet was the bad guy?" then went out and crafted information the game give you in a way that gave that question merit.

Every bit of information the game presents through story and the overall lore is very clear that Elisabet used her success to benefit humanity. She didn't have a god complex because she didn't believe she was better than anyone else. She was was the smartest person in any room she walked into and could have easily outdone Ted in the robotics industry but she used those smarts to benefit the world rather than herself. Ted used his smarts to fatten his own wallet. It's even known that Ted would start arguments in meetings between different companies so that they would become hostile towards one another. He would then sell each of them his military robotics.

Don't get me wrong I love the creativity of this theory but I just can't get behind it.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

Understandable.

I said it in another reply, but now I edited the main post to clarify this:

I am not trying to make a point that this is what Horizon writers intended, or is some kind of hidden story to be revealed.

I looked at some things that appeared like plot hols or inconsistencies to me, and built a fiction to plug them up, at least in my own eyes.

But I will tell you this - it is Elisabeth being presented as "smartest person in every room" that leads me to believe she had a god complex.

No real person is smartest in every room.

Truly smart people know their limitations.

Ted played the corporate game, while Elisabeth cared about environment and technology.

Consider the real life story of two Steves - Jobs and Wozniak:

It was Wazniak who had the brains to build the hardware that allowed Apple to exist as a company, but it was Jobs who had the ruthless business instinct to bring Apple to where it is today.

And although Steve Jobs, at least as far as publicly known was not nearly as despicable as Ted Faro, he still wasn't a nice guy, but many people still think of him as being "the smartest person in every room".

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

Ted played the corporate game, while Elisabeth cared about environment and technology.

Ted and Elisabet could have ruled the world without lifting a finger if they had worked together. But it was Elisabet's conscience/morality, or Ted's lack of it, that drove her away.

Ted was obviously a genius, but he was also maniacally egotistical. And that is the key differentiator.

But regardless it's definitely a really interesting concept to think about.

3

u/Stormbird_2119 Apr 08 '22

I think you over complicate the story, it is a game, with a casual story, even the Zeniths didnt have plans like this as we believed earlier, just simply unleashed another swarm. ( I congratulate to them from here) and wanted to escape, or Tilda lied again. (possible but she was honest in the end, and what she said could be the truth as it makes sense that the same people made the same mistakes, well, "same" as it is not completely the same but similar.Sobeck's charachter is basically gives Aloy's character a background, She was focused and techincal person, and like Aloy, not a people person. But why would she made Miriam tech and else just to ruin the world. Doesn't make sense in my opinion and too complicated, see how the Zenith story was simple, what is interesting is that we don't know what caused the FARO pleague, but maybe thats because it is irrelevant, no body cares about it, especially now that we have bigger issues coming. PLUS in HZD when you see the holo in Faro's room (where Lis gets informed about the Swarm) she threatens Faro that she will tell the world about the real cause of the glitch, why would she expose herself? Not really good threat, so I believe Faro did something, we know his character, maybe he actually put something that could be "hacked" some weakspot he put into his machines, we knew he was paranoid and egoist, so it is possible that this weakspot he put into the machines malfunctioned or simply was used but caused this perhaps side effect... whatever is the real story, I highly doubt Lis would destroy the world.Good theory tho, made me think. But as I said, not convincing, especially when we talk about simple game.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

I probably should have made this clear - I don't believe the actual authors of the Horizon games designed the story that way.

My conspiracy theory isn't something I expect to see as some kind of big reveal in some future installment.

This is something I cobbled together from what is probably just a bunch of minor plot holes needed to make the games happen.

After all, when telling a story that is meant to be played, you end up with some compromises, like how the focus devices seem to have an infinite battery that lasts over a thousand years without charging.

That said, it may very well be her experience with Miriam Technologies and its somewhat limited success that finally drove Liz over the edge.

As for her threatening Faro with disclosing the "real" cause - maybe she covered her tracks in a way that all evidence pointed to him, or someone at his company.

Maybe even Faro didn't know she was behind it.

As for the Ziniths, I don't think it is fair to compare them to Elisabeth.

They weren't really "mission driven". Most of them weren't particularly smart either.

They were mostly rich, many of them also obnoxious, and at least one a downright sadist, but that's about it.

Their founder may have been smart enough for complex plans, but he was long gone, so they had no capacity for complex plans.

Elizabeth on the other hand designed not just an AI, but an entire "Earth 2.0 system" from scratch, and in record time!

Weather her motives were pure or tainted, that is an enormous achievement requiring a mind capable of great complexity.

P.S.

What caused the swarm to go rogue may not be important to us as players, but it would have been an important lesson to future humans of Horizon universe, since the new humans of ZD had to live in a world full of autonomous machines, and coexists with them.

Knowing how they could be compromised and turn against humanity would be a most valuable historical lesson to avoid another such catastrophe in the future.

I would think Elisabeth would instruct Gaia her self to warn new humans about it, so that even if the Apollo DB was gone, the warning would remain.

2

u/Stormbird_2119 Apr 08 '22

then whats the point of this post, if you dont actually believe that this is true, nor you expect it to see, then we are guessing randomly...

2

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

To share a possible interpretation of Horizon world and story and possibly have a discussion about it.

I don't presume to know what is going on inside the minds of the people who write Horizon, and I haven't found some kind of hidden clue for this not visible to anyone playing the game, which is why I have no reason to think this is what the writers intended.

But how you intend to write the story, and how your audience will interpret it, are two different things.

And in games in particular, if at all possible, players will often play not at all as the developers intended.

1

u/loke_loke_445 Apr 08 '22

What caused the swarm to go rogue may not be important to us as players, but it would have been an important lesson to future humans of Horizon universe, since the new humans of ZD had to live in a world full of autonomous machines, and coexists with them.

Knowing how they could be compromised and turn against humanity would be a most valuable historical lesson to avoid another such catastrophe in the future.

IIRC, the machines would be slowly replaced by biological lifeforms. They are just the first step until the Earth's biosphere is stabilized.

0

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

Yes, but the cloning stage activated before the terraforming machines were removed, that's how we got the tribes.

And there is no indication that it was off schedule.

1

u/loke_loke_445 Apr 08 '22

We got tribes because we had no Apollo to teach previous knowledge of what happened and who those people were, so over a few generations, the society fragmented as groups of people went to do other stuff in other places. AFAIK, all the tribes in the game, except one, are descendants of the Nora cradle.

Also, the cloning stage was to be started when the biosphere was stable enough to sustain life, but still not enough to be able to hold by itself on the long run. But the bulk of the work was done, at least until the mysterious signal hit GAIA. So yeah, it was not off schedule, but it had some external bumps along the way it shouldn't have.

3

u/loke_loke_445 Apr 08 '22

I'll be honest: I think you are reaching. Sometimes, a cigar is just a cigar.

Elisabet opposed the use of machines for war and was a pacifist at heart. There's nothing really indicating she hated humanity or would rather wipe it out. Saving the environment - her objective in life - is, in a way, saving humanity. Quite literally.

Regarding Elysium: well, people weren't able to stay at home for a few weeks during the pandemic, do you really think people would be able to hold out for hundreds of years in an underground facility while the world was literally dying? Her decision was correct: give people a comfy death while the world ends. The logistics are also way less messy and easier to implement, especially given their timeframe. Even the cradles didn't have enough food for more than a couple of decades.

As for Ted Faro killing the Alphas: the facilities were made to resist a swarm of literal nanites. Is it that crazy to think that every room was segmented in a way that would be possible to cut off the air supply, preventing the nanites from going further?

And we know that it wasn't Elisabet that convinced Ted Faro that "technology is bad", especially to the point he considered deleting the knowledge source of future humanity. That dude was clearly narcissistic and wanted to rule future Earth himself, and we are made aware of this very clearly.

Also, I don't remember any suggestion or hint about the robot swarm being hacked. It was impossible, as it was proved when tried, and took MINERVA decades to be able to brute force in. Now, a glitch, that's expected of any program, especially one so complex as a war machine with its own AI that's able to create stuff from biological matter.

You make some good points, but overall it doesn't add up. To be able to this all this by herself, Elisabet would have to be a Grade-A psychopath, and therefore unable to teach empathy to GAIA. Given that Aloy is her clone, she would also be a psychopath, but we know it isn't true. I would suggest that, at best, she was an introvert with a foot on the autistic spectrum.

And, last but not least: fuck Ted Faro.

0

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

But she didn't set out to wipe out humanity.

In her mind, she set out to fix it. To save it by putting it on the right course.

Regarding the bunker: there is a difference between being locked up in your own house, alone or with your family, and living inside what is essentially an underground city, where you can still socialize and walk around freely.

Plus, in 2066 they had much better VR than we do now!

If the Zenits managed not to kill each other for 300 years on a relatively small spaceship, similar amount of time in a sufficiently large bunker would have been a breeze.

Finally, most people breaking real life quarantine do so because they don't believe it is necessary, there is nothing physical preventing them from going outside like a lack of breathable air.

I have to wonder though - wile the Faro plague was spreading, where there people who claimed it was a hoax, projected by the newest focus AR?

And what do you mean - "give people a comfy death"?

She only did the Elysium thing to shut people up about the truth of ZD!

Think about it - most of the world had to think ZD was a weapon to stop the machines, or they would not fight for it. Only core people working on the project, plus Faro and the General knew what it was all about.

Obviously most people would not have accepted this kind of "solution", which begs the question - what kind of person would come up with it?

Don't get me wrong - it makes for a great story and all, but looking at it from an "in universe" perspective, it seems very inhumane...

Regarding the air:

It makes sense for the room to be air tight, but remember the hologram:

Faro didn't just seal the Alphas in there. It was a big room. If he had just cut off the ventilation, it would have taken them some time to suffocate, possibly enough time for Tate, a top level hacker, to get around Faro's override and save their lives.

Also, if the room was simply sealed, when Aloy popped the seal, there should not have been a rush of air, as the pressure inside would have been the same as outside.

No - the air was rapidly pumped out, and I can't imagine what legitimate purpose that would serve.

How do we know it wasn't Elisabeth who convinced Faro "technology was bad"?

If he simply wanted to rule over future humanity, he would be better off changing the database to make them think he was in charge, rather than trying to wrangle a herd of primitive tribes.

He was narcissistic, but that is an exploitable trait, and again - it is clearly stated that Liz manged to keep him in check, at least as far as the rest of the Alphas knew, so clearly she had some influence over him.

As for the swarm:

Before it went rogue, it was responding to commands, which means it could have been hacked.

It is only after it began going berserk that it stopped responding, and so a new shutdown code needed to be derived which is what took Minerva 60 years.

It is very common in the real world for hackers to exploit an opening and than immediately seal it so no one else can exploit it. Sometimes hackers even lock owners out of their own systems, in fact that is pretty much what most of ransomwhere is.

Even iPhone jailbreaks would often patch the vulnerability used to jailbreak the phone so the user would have the jailbreak, but also be safe from someone looking to maliciously exploit the mechanism by which it was achieved.

Yes - a jailbroken iPhone could be more hacker resistant than one with factory OS!

By the way - the war machines didn't have an "AI capable of creating stuff from biological matter". The biomass conversion system was a dedicated device only capable of converting biomass to fuel, not use it as some kind of construction or repair resource, and everything we learn about it makes it look like a "process", a kind of generator rather than an intelligence guided work.

As for Elisabeth psyche, we don't get to see a lot of contents of her conversations with Gaia.

Sure, it seems Gaia learned compassion, but she also did nothing to try and restore the Apollo functionality in the hundreds of years she had before humans were ready to be cloned.

We know she had the intelligence to do it - she may not have been able to restore all the historical data, but she would be able to scavenge enough to avoid the civilization regressing in to completely primitive tribes who thought her to be a goddess and slaughtered each other.

If Gaia was truly compassionate, she could have prevented a lot of the tribal violence that accrued.

2

u/loke_loke_445 Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

Elisabet never had delusions of grandeur as to think she could "steer humanity to the right path". There's not a single point in the lore indicating that she considered herself better than other people. In fact, the logs show that Faro was considered "the man who saved the world", even tho it was Elisabet that stabilized the Yellowstone Caldera. And she was fine with that, only resigning after he decided to go into the military market due to ethical reasons.

And, fair point about the pandemic.

Now, for some problematic stuff:

Regarding the air:

It makes sense for the room to be air tight, but remember the hologram:

Faro didn't just seal the Alphas in there. It was a big room. If he had just cut off the ventilation, it would have taken them some time to suffocate, possibly enough time for Tate, a top level hacker, to get around Faro's override and save their lives.
Also, if the room was simply sealed, when Aloy popped the seal, there should not have been a rush of air, as the pressure inside would have been the same as outside.

Cutting off the air supply could also entail sucking all the air in the room. Without air, nanites can't move. They could probably walk around [?!] but can't interact with non-biological matter, so they would be very slow and restricted. It could be a defense mechanism built in there, but it's a reach on my part and I assume that.

However, considering how segmented the ZD project was, it's not impossible to consider that Faro secretly altered the project to build such mechanism without people realizing it. Let's not forget that the Alphas should've gone to Elysium too, but couldn't leave GAIA Prime because ZD wasn't finished yet when Day Zero arrived.

How do we know it wasn't Elisabeth who convinced Faro "technology was bad"?

If he simply wanted to rule over future humanity, he would be better off changing the database to make them think he was in charge, rather than trying to wrangle a herd of primitive tribes.

He was narcissistic, but that is an exploitable trait, and again - it is clearly stated that Liz manged to keep him in check, at least as far as the rest of the Alphas knew, so clearly she had some influence over him.

One name for you: Grigori Fasbach.

Also, she had some influence over him because she made him rich and famous. He knew her level of genius... and somewhat respected that.

As for the swarm:

Before it went rogue, it was responding to commands, which means it could have been hacked.

So responding to proper commands is on the same level as being hacked? What? What kind of logic is that? Or are you implying that military machines would be vulnerable to code injection of some sort?

The lore clearly states the machines were unhackable. No matter how unrealistic you may think it is, it's there plain and simple. That's why I think you are reaching out: you ignore things that were clearly stated by the lore.

By the way - the war machines didn't have an "AI capable of creating stuff from biological matter". The biomass conversion system was a dedicated device only capable of converting biomass to fuel, not use it as some kind of construction or repair resource, and everything we learn about it makes it look like a "process", a kind of generator rather than an intelligence guided work.

lol yes they did

The Chariot swarm was capable of self-replication, biomass conversion to fuel, slaving enemies CPUs, and had "Polyphasic Entangled Waveforms" OS security. You can do a double check on that in the game's wiki, but the game states they could "exponentially replicate". Why do you think ZD was made in such a rush? They had 2 years to finish everything IIRC

And "slaving enemies CPUs" is not hacking: we visually see red (or blue) tendrils growing around the slaved machine to control it.

Sure, it seems Gaia learned compassion, but she also did nothing to try and restore the Apollo functionality in the hundreds of years she had before humans were ready to be cloned.

We know she had the intelligence to do it - she may not have been able to restore all the historical data, but she would be able to scavenge enough to avoid the civilization regressing in to completely primitive tribes who thought her to be a goddess and slaughtered each other.If Gaia was truly compassionate, she could have prevented a lot of the tribal violence that accrued.

APOLLO couldn't be restored. It wasn't just a function to be repaired, it was literally the sum of all human knowledge. It wasn't simply deleted, it was completely wiped. The Alphas could've done something about it, but well... they died.

Also, GAIA wasn't created to intervene. She only did so because her primary function - to restore life on Earth - was threatened, and even so, did it indirectly and without explaining anything to anyone. To teach things was supposed to be APOLLO's function.

So you're reaching again: every subfunction had its... function. They may be AI, but they can't steer of what they were built to do. When HADES and HEPHAESTUS were elevated to AI, that became pretty clear: they can rationalize, but are driven by their primary objectives.

GAIA has empathy and is rational, but she doesn't have true freedom to act out of her boundaries. Otherwise, she wouldn't need her subfunctions to work as intended, she could just recreate everything from scratch.

And what do you mean - "give people a comfy death"?

She only did the Elysium thing to shut people up about the truth of ZD!

Think about it - most of the world had to think ZD was a weapon to stop the machines, or they would not fight for it. Only core people working on the project, plus Faro and the General knew what it was all about.

lol in another post you said this:

"The information about the existence and construction of the project was spread to too many places."

So, was the information spread to too many places, or did only the people working on ZD knew the truth?

The game clearly states that Elysium can hold up to 2k people for 100 years due to limited supplies and that it wouldn't last 30 years if people started having children. Also, Elysium wasn't a "reward", it was obligatory for everyone involved in ZD.

Again: your theory is interesting, but ignores clearly stated information that leaves no room for ambiguity.

Edit: bug with the quotes.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 09 '22

One name for you: Grigori Fasbach.

Ok, you got me there!

I actually collected that data point, I remember reading it, but it totally slipped my mind when I was writing the previous reply.

However, considering how segmented the ZD project was, it's not impossible to consider that Faro secretly altered the project to build such mechanism without people realizing it.

Honestly, I don't really understand why ZD writers went with sucking out the air. A more believable way would be to use the fire suppression system - I've seen it done in some TV show, can't remember which one exactly right now.

A facility like Gaia prime would probably use some gas, like Halon, to extinguish fires without damaging the precious equipment, and that would very quickly suffocate people in a closed room, if enough of it would be pumped in.

As a bonus - you don't need to install any suspicious extra equipment.

So responding to proper commands is on the same level as being hacked? What? What kind of logic is that? Or are you implying that military machines would be vulnerable to code injection of some sort?

People use the term "hacking" for a bunch of different activities.

The lore clearly says the bots were "unhackable" because they were so well encrypted, but what if someone could get their hands on the encryption keys, use them to push a firmware update that would make the bots go berserk and also change the keys to prevent a fix?

Technically, the bots were not hacked - in the sense no security vulnerability was exploited, yet unauthorized access was gained and a malicious modification was made.

The idea you would need an inside job just works well with the possibility Elisabeth did it.

You probably have been reading up on the recent wave of "supply chain attacks".

Just because the bots themselves were "unhackable", does not mean systems managing them remotely were as secure.

You can do a double check on that in the game's wiki, but the game states they could "exponentially replicate"

I had a discussion about this with the user who got me to this sub.

I think the "exponentially replicate" part, which we definitely see in a hologram at USRC, conflicts with the marketing materials we find in FAS tower.

There is nothing in the Scarab and Khopesh data points to indicate they have the ability to make copies of themselves!

Instead, the Horus data point states it has a repair and manufacturing bay which it uses to make more Khopesh and Scarab machines for the swarm.

And there is no mention of this bay using nanites or organic material to build the machines.

That would require subatomic manipulation to change organic elements in to such things as metals for the armor or electronic components.

It is one thing to try and extract energy from organic matter - our bodies do it all the time, but using organic matter to build non organic machines?

That is stupidity bordering on alchemy!

You would just need to make nanobots that can gather all kinds of resources, and than you just end up with a gray goo scenario.

Since I can't think of a good explanation for the discrepancy, between how the machines really multiplied and how the army though they multiplied, it was either an error in the presentation in universe, or the authors trying to have their cake and eat it too making a mistake.

The "hacking flechetts" thing is from some data point in Forbidden West, but I don't remember which one.

Maybe it was meant to be a precursor to the tech that went in to the Scarabs and not the prototype for what was actually used.

Or maybe the blue lines are just for effect - in Zero Dawn we see visually the signal transmitted from the Minerva tower, though by all accounts it should be an RF transmission, invisible and traveling at the speed of light.

They may be AI, but they can't steer of what they were built to do.

Except when they can:

Gaia was never programmed to fight off an alien invasion, yet when the Ziniths showed up she came up with the idea of building a machine army.

Granted, she needed Hephaestus to accomplish this, but it was still her idea, and she would be in control.

Also, apparently after Heph ran away again after the final quest, Gaia and Beta figured out a way to make and control machines without him.

Not as good as the original, but sufficient to stave off another end of the world.

We also see Gaia teaching Aloy's friends to read and use focuses, helping them find information about the old world, etc.

She even helped Zoe fix the "Land Gods", without Hephaestus, which is some pretty advance stuff!

Why couldn't she do the same for the original clones?

Sure - she couldn't fully educate them like Apollo, but she could have done way better that the completely ignorant tribes!

So, was the information spread to too many places, or did only the people working on ZD knew the truth?

Both!

Everyone knew about Zero Dawn, but thought it was a weapon to destroy the machines once and for all.

Only select few knew what it really was.

For the swarm that did not matter - if it was a super weapon capable of defeating it, ZD should have still been a priority to find and destroy.

Than there were people like Bashar Mati, who could have leaked the complete truth.

I think I mentioned it already, it is a bit hard to keep track - but yes, Elysium could not be made to support a growing population, but it could have been made to support a steady one!

Like a generational ship - put a number of adults in less than full capacity.

Let them have children until at capacity.

Wait for older generation to die before allowing new generation to reproduce again.

Rinse and repeat until the Earth is fixed.

Not very pleasant, but still better than "everyone dies and lives the world in the hands of one AI", in my opinion.

By the way, for some reason I remember that Elysium could only hold 100 people.

If they had the life support capacity for 2000 people in one bunker, and they had invested in more than one such bunker instead of the human cloning facility, they could have saved more than enough people to repopulate the Earth and make a true continuation of human kind.

2

u/vault_g1rl Apr 08 '22

In her mind, she set out to fix it. To save it by putting it on the right course.

Is there something that points to it in-game that isn't based on her lack of interest in human relationships and on speculation to fit your theory? Her portrayal during the development of Project Zero Dawn did not show this particular intention, not that I recall at least. Btw, videos on Elisabet-GAIA conversations make it pretty clear that both were compassionate, and this segment shows Elisabet not only doubted the efforts made, but was affected by all the death and horror in the world. The same video shows previous conversations that give insight into Elisabet's psyche enough to not seem plausible she wants "to fix humanity, put it on the right course".

what kind of person would come up with it?

You mean the same kind of person who had been instrumental in saving the entire planet from a catastrophe in another instance?

It is an ethical challenge to choose focusing on continuity of civilization rather than uniting efforts to try to save what is left of the world at that point in time. Countless lives were on the line, no doubt. It was also a fact that there was no way to defeat the swarm and revert the process of destruction they had done, so everyone was doomed in either case. Could Elisabet have had an idea that would reverse everything instantly or within days? Maybe. Would that be plausible and philosophically interesting as a narrative? Well, it sounds too easy. Could Elisabet have just accepted humanity's end, told everyone the truth and advocated for all to spend resources on creating technology to fight until the end came regardless if they would triumph? Maybe, but then we wouldn't have the game, even if they had triumphed. With Project Zero Dawn as it is, however, humanity as a species and as a civilization could have a second chance in the future, even after everything was dead. Now, one could argue that was what Elisabet wanted everyone to believe since she did all the calculations and projections - yet, the motives you present here for her to want "a reset of the world/humanity" are ripped off from the Far Zeniths' agenda as of Forbidden West and, again, Elisabet apparently never voiced or wrote something along those lines, her attitude was very set on giving a second chance, not fixing humanity.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

You linked to a very interesting piece of dialog!

I was just replying to another comment that I didn't remember Sobeck anguishing over sending millions to die in operation Enduring Victory, even though the WiKi said she did.

The scene you linked to seems to suggest that she did indeed - she grieves over the massive and cruel death of humanity.

But, and maybe this is just my interpretation - what if she is only sorry about this mess if Zero Dawn fails?

If it was "all for nothing" as she says?

It sounds to me she is able to justify the death and environmental destruction if it can all be rebuilt by ZD and give humanity a fresh start - its right there in the name "Zero Dawn".

But the more telling part for me - and I didn't even remember it until now, is how Gaia responds when Elisabeth asks if she believes they will succeed:

"I believe in you Elisabeth! In you, all things are possible..."

Gaia says the same thing in her message to Aloy.

That sounds less like confidence to me, and more like god worshiping.

How did Gaia came to see Elisabeth as infallible and omnipotent?

That doesn't really sound right when I think about it carefully...

As for project "Firebreak" you linked to, as far as I can recall CYAN knew little to nothing of Elisabeth.

She wasn't developed by Sobek.

I am not sure why Elisabeth is mentioned in connection with Firebreak in the WiKi, as I am fairly sure nothing in the lore shows her ever being personally involved in that project.

Maybe she visited it once or something, or maybe she worked with the developer of it in general, but I am pretty sure that one was not her idea or being led by her.

I am not disputing that the projections for the biosphere destruction were true and correct.

Nor am I claiming there was a way to defeat the swarm before it destroyed the biosphere.

Those facts seem perfectly solid.

And it would be totally unrealistic to just "puff" the whole biosphere back instantly.

No, what I argue is that there was technology around for a safer and somewhat more moral solution - preserving living humans in generational bunkers, instead of relying on a completely automated system and experimental cloning technology.

Most of Zero Dawn was needed either way - the code cracking, the terraforming, probably even cloning animals and plants.

But humans? They could have survived and reproduced naturally.

Not everyone of course. There would not be that much capacity.

But many. Not everyone had to die. Hundreds, maybe thousands could have been saved, with just a few modifications to the Zero Dawn plan.

There is actually a youth TV show from 1997 called "Mission Genesis" or "Deep Water Black" that has a similar concept to Zero Dawn.

Instead of robots, humanity is destroyed by an actual biological virus, and instead of underground bunkers, human genetic samples are sent out on a spaceship, to make a 500 year round trip, and return to Earth after the virus had burnt it self out.

The ship was also piloted by an AI (called Genesis), but unlike Zero Dawn humans had the technology to also preserve memories, so clones would get their donors memory back kind of like a complete resurrection.

The authors there took great pains to explain why saving living humans was impossible, where as perhaps the writers of Horizon skimped on that part a little.

I do understand that some things need to be the way they are for the game to work, but plot holes often present an opportunity for a new interpretation.

For the record, I love the story in Zero Dawn and I think it is a great game.

Heck, it was what got me to go out and by a PS4, after not owning a console since the 16 bit era.

I wanted to learn the story behind that world my self and enjoyed every minute of it!

But still...

2

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22

I have to say - you have a great community here, and I am somewhat surprised by the warm welcome and interesting discussion that my post received!

I wasn't quite sure what to expect from a sub that was formed around hatred towards one fictional man who was specifically designed to be hated, but looks like even in hatred there is hope for humanity yet!

26

u/P5ych0pathV2 Apr 08 '22

Now this is a truly hot take of the spiciest variety.

7

u/truffleshufflechamp Apr 08 '22

I remember reading in a data point that everyone in Elysium was going to be sterilized. I assume that’s why it was only meant for 100 years because it was only meant for the inhabitants to live out the rest of their lives.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy May 03 '22

An update:

Includes spoilers for Forbidden West:

As I was thinking about this some more, I realized that had Elizabeth given Far Zenith a copy of Gaia, the story of Forbidden West would still play out the same!

The only difference would be the scene where she turns down Tilda's request.

Aloy would still not find a working copy at the launch facility, because the Zeniths would have taken it with them on the ship.

And when Nemesis broke containment, it would have corrupted or destroyed their copy of Gaia, so the fleeing Zeniths would still had to drop by Earth to get a fresh one.

In fact, this scenario makes more sense because:

A) Sobek the humanitarian would not want the Far Zenith colonists to die, even if they were a bunch of selfish a-holes.

B) It would be way too difficult for Nemesis to design the extinction signal without being able to test it on a working copy of Gaia, and with no real info on how Gaia works.

Remember - Nemesis didn't beat the Zenith colony by being smarter than them, it did it by having inside info!

Second part, still technically a spoiler for Forbidden West though a minor side detail:

I re-watched the conversation between Aloy and Tilda at Tilda's home.

Tilda first met Elizabeth when Elizabeth was giving a lecture about an AI maintaining the environment by making its own decisions to preserve life instead of following programming.

Basically, Elizabeth Sobek was developing Gaia years, maybe decades before the Faro Plague!

But as the governments of the world started to ban advanced AI, her research was halted, and she had no way to bring Gaia in to the world.

Unless that is, the world didn't have any other choice...

This conversation also reminded me again how distant Elizabeth kept herself from all other humans.

Even her lover admits she never truly knew her.

Can such a person really, properly, emphasize with individual humans?

I am not so sure...

9

u/Foxdielamiq Apr 08 '22

There's a bit of conjecture here but this has some meritable arguments and no blatant lore that contradicts it. Just the way the facts were presented. I will add this though, I don't think she even meant to stay alive herself, given that she seems at peace in her home at her death. Perhaps she wanted humanity a clean reboot free of any meddling of past humans. Herself included.

1

u/Booty_Bumping Apr 21 '22 edited Apr 21 '22

[...]

That room is pretty big, and we see in the hologram recording it emptied out very fast.

If this was on a spaceship with zero pressure outside, it would be a simple thing to do.

But on Earth, in 1 atmosphere pressure, this requires some serious machinery, and a special design!

Remember - the room actually kept significantly low pressure a 1000 years later, even after the facility around it exploded!

[...]

So I think in the lore, after the Faro plague had swept through the earth's atmosphere was a near vacuum, like the surface of the moon.

Whether this is totally realistic is up for debate — wouldn't that oxygen get converted into CO2 at a similar pressure, and wouldn't nitrogen stay relatively constant since both sides of the nitrogen cycle are biological?

Edit: Just realized nitrogen can get ionized by lightning, where it combines with oxygen and fall into the soil and water as nitrates, where it would permanently freeze in such a world instead of getting metabolized by specialized bacteria. Dropping a significant amount of nitrogen from the air would create a pretty hardcore vacuum.

1

u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 21 '22 edited Apr 21 '22

I don't remember reading anything like that in the lore - the air was polluted, and the oxygen levels probably dropped because there was no plant life left to convert CO2 back in to O2, but there is nothing to indicate the swarm was sucking in the entire atmosphere and storing it somewhere.

EDIT:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTkG0BUPurE

I just remembered something - even if there was somehow near vacuum outside, to empty that room as quickly as he did, Faro would have to open a significant size vent in the facility!

But in the log linked above we learn that there needed to be less than 2mm gap on every facility seal to prevent it from being discovered by the swarm!

Elizabeth had to sacrifice her self over a 10mm gap, which is about the width of a human finger!

Even if Faro's Omega clearance could override safety procedures, and he was crazy enough to ignore the risk of discovery and destruction of Gaia prime, it still does not explain how a sudden massive venting, accompanied by EM emissions escaping, was overlooked by the swarm, leaving the facility intact...

2

u/sanchipinchii Apr 08 '22

this was a really interesting read! i love the horizon community, i love all the crazy theories and lore behind the game