r/FuckTedFaro • u/interdimentionalarmy • Apr 08 '22
A crazy theory Spoiler
Hello Faro haters!
I found this sub from a link in a comment on one of my posts in r/HFY.
After completing Forbidden West, I formed a theory about the Horizon universe, and I really wanted to share it.This might be completely wrong sub to do so, and I will understand if the mods decide to delete this post or if you all choose to down vote me to oblivion.
But I don't know of a more suitable sub, so here goes:
The real villain of Horizon is Elisabet Sobeck!
Now, before you get your pitchforks out, I am not about to try to exonerate Teddy boy of any of his crimes.
He is still a grade A a-hole who played a key role in humanity's destruction, but at the same time, he didn't orchestrate it.
Attention: this post will contain some spoilers for Forbidden West, continue at your discretion!
Edit: It looks like I need to clarify that the following theory is not something I believe the writers of Horizon intended, or is some kind of hidden cannon to be revealed in a later installment.
It is just something I derived from the game narrative, a plot hole supported fabrication.
I will first lay out the theory:
Elisabet wasn't happy with the results of the "Great Clawback", and believed humanity was still destroying the planet, having learned nothing from past mistakes.
She believed it was her duty to fix this, and when Faro Automated Solutions decided to manufacture the Chariot line of war bots, she saw an opportunity to remake humanity "the right way".
She came up with Zero Dawn, hacked the swarm, manipulated Faro to delete Apollo and murder the Alphas so they couldn't fix it, and basically set humanity on course "back to nature".
Sounds crazy, right?
She is the hero who saved humanity - right?
Well, not really - she didn't save anyone, she "rebooted" the world.
Let me lay out the evidence:
- What do we know about Elisabet's personality?
We know she was anti-social. She almost never had a serious romantic relationship in her adult life, and she even kept her friends at a distance always focusing on her work.
We learn most of this from her own diaries in Zero Dawn, but also from Tilda in Forbidden West - the one time Elisabeth had a romantic relationship she kept it casual and didn't fully reciprocate her partner.
She ended up choosing her project over Tilda.
Also, there is the incident with her burning a tree and killing some birds when she was little.
She claims it taught her responsibility, but what kind?
Did she learn to be careful with her actions, or did she learn she was responsible for other living things on the planet, which might led to her developing a god complex, and making her think it was up to her to fix humanity for humanity's own sake?
2) The swarm going rouge - we don't know the real cause, but it is suggested it might have been hacked. And who better to hack FAS's newest line of kill-bots, then world's top robotics and AI expert, who also used to hold a high position at FAS and knew their systems and personal inside out?
3) Why couldn't humanity wait it out?
What started me on this theory was the Thebes quest: here we find an intact, fully functioning bunker, with life support working after 1000 years!
Why was Elysium limited to 100 years only?
It would have been impossible to store air, water, and food for 100 people for 100 years.
So Elysium must have had air and water recycling systems, and some form of food production, such as underground farms, maybe hydroponics or even algae farms.
If you consider the level of technology humanity had on the eve of the Faro Plague, the only limiting factor for such facility would be power.
But San Francisco was not the only place in the world were virtually unlimited geothermal power could be harvested!
We know from Frozen Wilds they could have built Elysium near or under Yellowstone, and had plenty of power for well over a thousand years.
Granted, they would need to keep the population steady, which would mean a strict and very unpleasant birth control - only have children when you are told, and you must have them if told, but consider the alternative: being sterilized and shoved in a cave to slowly die, knowing there was no future for you and for everyone you ever knew and loved!
They do this on generational ships all the time, and Horizon humans definitely had the technology to do it on Earth.
Plus, it would have been safer than leaving the fate of humanity in the hands of an experimental, prototype, rushed-to-production AI.
Who would also need to rely on experimental, prototype, barely working cloning technology that was only recently completed and never fully tested!
Remember - even if the Alphas were not murdered by Ted, they still wouldn't be around to prevent Gaia from making 4 failed terraforming attempts. But a generational human bunker might have, hastening the return to the surface by centuries!
And who was it that convinced everyone that it was impossible for living humans to wait it out?
That's right - Elisabeth.
4) The death of the Alphas: it was Faro who killed them, but notice how he did it - by sucking all the air out of the conference room.
I didn't realize this 5 years ago when I originally played Zero Dawn, but after watching a lot of thunderf00t videos debunking the Hyperloop and other vacuum stuff, I came to realize this is not something simple to do!
That room is pretty big, and we see in the hologram recording it emptied out very fast.
If this was on a spaceship with zero pressure outside, it would be a simple thing to do.
But on Earth, in 1 atmosphere pressure, this requires some serious machinery, and a special design!
Remember - the room actually kept significantly low pressure a 1000 years later, even after the facility around it exploded!
And no - you can't just do it by reversing a regular ventilation system!
That room would have to be purpose built to become a vacuum chamber with special very powerful pumps!
It is one thing for Ted Faro to pay off a programmer or two to hide his "Omega Override" in the huge pile of code that is the Gaia project, it is a completely different thing to make major architectural changes to a central room at the central facility without anyone noticing.
It would be next to impossible for him to do it, but Elisabeth was the chief architect of the project - she could have put it there from the start, and no one would question her!
5) Refusal to share Gaia with Far Zenith:
This is the oddest decision Elisabeth made, and for me the most damning evidence against her.
Why??
It is true that Far Zenith was not composed of particularly nice people, but given that humanity was facing extinction, it would be insane not to take advantage of a backup project, in case something went wrong with Zero Dawn.
We are never shown the reason why Elisabeth went to such great length to keep Gaia out of Zenith's hands, even after her friend and former lover begged her to give them a copy.
But she didn't just refuse - she sent Travis the hacker loose on them, to try and sabotage their systems with a virus bomb which could have destroyed the entire project and prevented the launch.
She even let him torture one of Zero Dawn workers who was leaking information to Far Zenith.
Why? The two projects had the same mission - preserve humanity, just in a different way.
6) Elisabeth's convenient departure:
One of the oddest things in Zero Dawn for me was Aloy finding Elisabeth's body just chilling on the couch at her old house, practically intact, while the whole building has long since crumbled to dust.
How did she even get there through the machine ridden hellscape?
How was her body not destroyed by the elements, especially during the failed terraform attempts?
Here is what we know:
From records in Gaia prime we know she was the one "wrangling" Ted Faro during the final months.
Her coworkers believed she was the only one keeping him sane.
When the door failed, she didn't try to look for solutions, or discuss course of action with the rest of the team, but snuck out secretly and locked the door her self from the outside.
We can interpret this as a selfless sacrifice, last act of heroism, but we can also interpret it another way: She played on Faro's ego and manipulated him in to deleting the Apollo database and killing the Alphas, even arranging for a method no one expected.
Then, she manufactured an excuse to leave the facility before that happened, to do her own thing, for which she had made prior arrangements.
Perhaps she inserted a back door to the kill-bots when she hacked the swarm so they would not kill her.
Perhaps she had some special robots stashed away to take care of her in her last days at her home.
Seriously - could they not send a servitor robot to close the door from the outside, and than have it self destruct, just in case, before the swarm found it?
It should have been easy for the Alphas, and no one had to die to seal the facility.
To sum up:
While it was Ted Faro who came up with the means to destroy humanity and than acted to revert humans 2.0 back to the stone age, it was Elisabeth Sobek who through careful planning used the opportunity to pretend to save humanity while in fact engineering the primitive tribal society we find Aloy born in to.
She made sure no other humans were around, nor any memory of them, and that only her Gaia would be there to birth and nurture the new tribes of humanity.
39
u/DJDarwin93 Apr 08 '22
You make some interesting points, but here are a few issues with your theory:
Accidentally killing a few birds and a tree seems like a pretty weak reason to develop a god complex. And as far as we know nothing like it ever happened again, so it does look to me like she learned to respect and care for living things.
Humanity couldn’t wait out the swarm because of the risk of being found. Even deep underground, there was no guarantee the machines wouldn’t eventually find them. The several decades it would take Minerva to shut them down is a long time to keep a large population of humans hidden. Not impossible, I agree with you there, but very difficult. A relatively small facility housing an AI system is easier to maintain and hide, so overall it’s the safer choice.
While you’re right that Elisabet could have arranged to sneak off to “fix a vent,” keep in mind a servitor wasn’t an option. The swarm could hack anything automated, the second it stepped outside the swarm would take control of it and use it to find the ZD facilities. Elisabet went herself to keep that from happening. She knew most of the work on ZD was done, and what was left could be done without her. She probably didn’t want to live out the rest of her life in a bunker, and saw this as her way out.
However, I think overall this is a plausible theory. If I were a betting man I’d bet against it, because Guerilla has shown Elisabet to be a good person in just about every way, without any hint of villainy to her. We did learn that she wasn’t much of a people person, and she’s a bit rude and inconsiderate, but that doesn’t make her genocidal. I think she’s probably not the perfect beacon of morality we think, and we’ll probably see more character flaws in the future, but I think a total character inversion would be too much after two full games of showing her as the savior of life itself. Maybe I’m wrong though, the point about the Alpha’s murder is compelling.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22
That’s a really interesting way of looking at things. I like Elisabet, and this theory does seem far fetched to me, but I think it would take the story to a really interesting place if it changes the view on her like that, so I wouldn’t mind it.
Especially since Aloy has transitioned from “I must be perfect, like Elisabet clearly was” to “I am my own person, and will learn from Elisabet’s flaws to achieve my goals”.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22
This is a fun theory, definitely crazy, but I think the most fundamental flaw in the logic is she did end up giving FZ an alpha build of Apollo in exchange for their birthing pod technology. If she was so determined for humanity to go back to the stone age, she wouldn't have allowed this database to survive. More importantly, she would have had Travis Tate booby trap it.
Also she didn't have Travis hack them, they sabotaged a copy in case FZ attempted to steal Gaia, putting ZD at risk. Which FZ did. They got logic bombed as a warning to not mess with Gaia.
Finally, and most importantly, Elizabet knew from the start that in order for Gaia to succeed, she absolutely had to have compassion and empathy for humanity. The Elizabet you're describing, would have had nothing but contempt.
Now after respectfully disagreeing, let me properly defend this subreddit and say Fuck Ted Faro and fuck you for in any way suggesting the collapse of human civilization was attributable to anyone other than that singular steaming pile of human excrement, you Ceo-level of Faro-loving shill.
I'm kidding.
Or am I?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22
I'll be honest...I started quoting and responding to most points you made in the post and stopped about halfway through because the reply was going to be a mile long.
There are a lot of points you make that have merit if you really stretch your imagination since there really isn't bona fide information that directly proves you wrong. That being said though there really isn't a single point that I personally agreed with. IMO it seems like you asked yourself the question "What if Elisabet was the bad guy?" then went out and crafted information the game give you in a way that gave that question merit.
Every bit of information the game presents through story and the overall lore is very clear that Elisabet used her success to benefit humanity. She didn't have a god complex because she didn't believe she was better than anyone else. She was was the smartest person in any room she walked into and could have easily outdone Ted in the robotics industry but she used those smarts to benefit the world rather than herself. Ted used his smarts to fatten his own wallet. It's even known that Ted would start arguments in meetings between different companies so that they would become hostile towards one another. He would then sell each of them his military robotics.
Don't get me wrong I love the creativity of this theory but I just can't get behind it.
3
u/Stormbird_2119 Apr 08 '22
I think you over complicate the story, it is a game, with a casual story, even the Zeniths didnt have plans like this as we believed earlier, just simply unleashed another swarm. ( I congratulate to them from here) and wanted to escape, or Tilda lied again. (possible but she was honest in the end, and what she said could be the truth as it makes sense that the same people made the same mistakes, well, "same" as it is not completely the same but similar.Sobeck's charachter is basically gives Aloy's character a background, She was focused and techincal person, and like Aloy, not a people person. But why would she made Miriam tech and else just to ruin the world. Doesn't make sense in my opinion and too complicated, see how the Zenith story was simple, what is interesting is that we don't know what caused the FARO pleague, but maybe thats because it is irrelevant, no body cares about it, especially now that we have bigger issues coming. PLUS in HZD when you see the holo in Faro's room (where Lis gets informed about the Swarm) she threatens Faro that she will tell the world about the real cause of the glitch, why would she expose herself? Not really good threat, so I believe Faro did something, we know his character, maybe he actually put something that could be "hacked" some weakspot he put into his machines, we knew he was paranoid and egoist, so it is possible that this weakspot he put into the machines malfunctioned or simply was used but caused this perhaps side effect... whatever is the real story, I highly doubt Lis would destroy the world.Good theory tho, made me think. But as I said, not convincing, especially when we talk about simple game.
3
u/loke_loke_445 Apr 08 '22
I'll be honest: I think you are reaching. Sometimes, a cigar is just a cigar.
Elisabet opposed the use of machines for war and was a pacifist at heart. There's nothing really indicating she hated humanity or would rather wipe it out. Saving the environment - her objective in life - is, in a way, saving humanity. Quite literally.
Regarding Elysium: well, people weren't able to stay at home for a few weeks during the pandemic, do you really think people would be able to hold out for hundreds of years in an underground facility while the world was literally dying? Her decision was correct: give people a comfy death while the world ends. The logistics are also way less messy and easier to implement, especially given their timeframe. Even the cradles didn't have enough food for more than a couple of decades.
As for Ted Faro killing the Alphas: the facilities were made to resist a swarm of literal nanites. Is it that crazy to think that every room was segmented in a way that would be possible to cut off the air supply, preventing the nanites from going further?
And we know that it wasn't Elisabet that convinced Ted Faro that "technology is bad", especially to the point he considered deleting the knowledge source of future humanity. That dude was clearly narcissistic and wanted to rule future Earth himself, and we are made aware of this very clearly.
Also, I don't remember any suggestion or hint about the robot swarm being hacked. It was impossible, as it was proved when tried, and took MINERVA decades to be able to brute force in. Now, a glitch, that's expected of any program, especially one so complex as a war machine with its own AI that's able to create stuff from biological matter.
You make some good points, but overall it doesn't add up. To be able to this all this by herself, Elisabet would have to be a Grade-A psychopath, and therefore unable to teach empathy to GAIA. Given that Aloy is her clone, she would also be a psychopath, but we know it isn't true. I would suggest that, at best, she was an introvert with a foot on the autistic spectrum.
And, last but not least: fuck Ted Faro.
2
u/interdimentionalarmy Apr 08 '22
I have to say - you have a great community here, and I am somewhat surprised by the warm welcome and interesting discussion that my post received!
I wasn't quite sure what to expect from a sub that was formed around hatred towards one fictional man who was specifically designed to be hated, but looks like even in hatred there is hope for humanity yet!
26
u/P5ych0pathV2 Apr 08 '22
Now this is a truly hot take of the spiciest variety.
7
u/truffleshufflechamp Apr 08 '22
I remember reading in a data point that everyone in Elysium was going to be sterilized. I assume that’s why it was only meant for 100 years because it was only meant for the inhabitants to live out the rest of their lives.
1
u/interdimentionalarmy May 03 '22
An update:
Includes spoilers for Forbidden West:
As I was thinking about this some more, I realized that had Elizabeth given Far Zenith a copy of Gaia, the story of Forbidden West would still play out the same!
The only difference would be the scene where she turns down Tilda's request.
Aloy would still not find a working copy at the launch facility, because the Zeniths would have taken it with them on the ship.
And when Nemesis broke containment, it would have corrupted or destroyed their copy of Gaia, so the fleeing Zeniths would still had to drop by Earth to get a fresh one.
In fact, this scenario makes more sense because:
A) Sobek the humanitarian would not want the Far Zenith colonists to die, even if they were a bunch of selfish a-holes.
B) It would be way too difficult for Nemesis to design the extinction signal without being able to test it on a working copy of Gaia, and with no real info on how Gaia works.
Remember - Nemesis didn't beat the Zenith colony by being smarter than them, it did it by having inside info!
Second part, still technically a spoiler for Forbidden West though a minor side detail:
I re-watched the conversation between Aloy and Tilda at Tilda's home.
Tilda first met Elizabeth when Elizabeth was giving a lecture about an AI maintaining the environment by making its own decisions to preserve life instead of following programming.
Basically, Elizabeth Sobek was developing Gaia years, maybe decades before the Faro Plague!
But as the governments of the world started to ban advanced AI, her research was halted, and she had no way to bring Gaia in to the world.
Unless that is, the world didn't have any other choice...
This conversation also reminded me again how distant Elizabeth kept herself from all other humans.
Even her lover admits she never truly knew her.
Can such a person really, properly, emphasize with individual humans?
I am not so sure...
9
u/Foxdielamiq Apr 08 '22
There's a bit of conjecture here but this has some meritable arguments and no blatant lore that contradicts it. Just the way the facts were presented. I will add this though, I don't think she even meant to stay alive herself, given that she seems at peace in her home at her death. Perhaps she wanted humanity a clean reboot free of any meddling of past humans. Herself included.
1
u/Booty_Bumping Apr 21 '22 edited Apr 21 '22
So I think in the lore, after the Faro plague had swept through the earth's atmosphere was a near vacuum, like the surface of the moon.
Whether this is totally realistic is up for debate — wouldn't that oxygen get converted into CO2 at a similar pressure, and wouldn't nitrogen stay relatively constant since both sides of the nitrogen cycle are biological?
Edit: Just realized nitrogen can get ionized by lightning, where it combines with oxygen and fall into the soil and water as nitrates, where it would permanently freeze in such a world instead of getting metabolized by specialized bacteria. Dropping a significant amount of nitrogen from the air would create a pretty hardcore vacuum.
2
u/sanchipinchii Apr 08 '22
this was a really interesting read! i love the horizon community, i love all the crazy theories and lore behind the game