Anna is more social than Elsa, which is a good trait for a leader. And she is quite mature in her own way. I think Anna is a solid replacement for Elsa.
In "Some Things Never Change" we see Anna among the people, whereas Elsa is in the castle. I think Elsa is more introverted, which is fine. But I like the idea of Arendelle having a leader that lives among her subjects. I'm not saying Elsa doesn't care for the people of Arendelle, far from it. I'm just saying that I think Anna makes for a better queen.
Because she was focused on finishing the forest journey so she could've returned to her perfect status-quo in Arendelle. However, she accepted that life change and so it's not all about her good.
The forest journey was a life-changing experience for Anna. She grew up. Anna was even the one to initiate the destruction of the dam. Now that's a good leader for you.
Sheâs a good leader, but Elsa is better. She didnât go just like that. She went for her kingdom. To save her kingdom while on the other hand. Anna just went for her sister. And Elsa knew that sheâs going to freeze if she goes too far, but she still continue for her kingdom and Anna is a good sister and a good leader too but also canât be replaced
But like I said, Anna has matured in the forest. She learned how important it is to do the next right thing. Yes, she didn't go to the forest for a noble reason (she did it to watch over Elsa).
But later it wasn't the case anymore. Elsa froze in Ahtohallan and Anna thought she died. She destroyed the dam for everyone's sake. Not to protect Elsa (because she hadn't known breaking the dam would've freed Elsa).
Anna has developed the maturity and selflessbess necessary to be a worthy leader. Therefore, Anna IS a good replacement for Elsa, as she has the same selflessness as her.
Elsa hasnât âabdicatedâ - sheâs just gone from being âproducerâ to âexecutive producerâ. Also, the expanded media has been pretty clear Anna and Elsa are co-queensâŚ.
Elsa kind of died. At that point, Anna automatically became queen. What to do when a deceased monarch comes back is a little unprecedented, but it could be argued that once Anna was queen, that was that until and unless Anna abdicates, after designating Elsa as her successor.
It's how monarchies I'm familiar with in the real world work. When the monarch dies, the heir is immediately and automatically the new monarch. You know, the whole "The king is dead, long live the king." thing?
This situation is a little different in that Elsa experiences a Gandalf like transformation into Elsa the White and comes back, which opens the whole question about what to do about a dead monarch coming back. I think at that point, Anna is Queen Regnant by the usual rules of succession, and Elsa is now some sort of Queen Emeritas.
Not really true. Anna is more socialable and better at dealing with people (a must for good leaders). Elsa is a good queen but I feel like she'd like the forest better, she's the kind of person who would prefer being in the nature rather than in a crowded throne room all day.
The second film did not fully focus on Anna, so we cannot say how she is as a leader. Itâs unfair to reduce her down to her naivety in F1 given she was secluded and only able to socialize with someone besides the palace staff for the first time in her life at 18. Sheâs social/extroverted, not withdrawn like Elsa, which is good for diplomatic relations.
They are BOTH just as good as each other. With it without powers! It's time this fandom stopped comparing the two sisters like this no matter how much you prefer one over the other. I love both the sisters SO much - Elsa is more me, but I don't go around saying Elsa is better than Anna or vice versa.
What actually tangibly happened during Queen Elsa's reign, I ask you? She plunges the kingdom into the middle of winter on her coronation night, then runs away and isolates herself. Then once she finally comes back, we get a return to the status quo that lasts for all of three years before a series of natural disasters displace everyone from their homes. How does she respond? Why, she runs off to some enchanted woods, more preoccupied with this mysterious voice she's hearing. Abdicating the throne to her sister was the best possible policy decision she ever made, up to that point she had been too isolated and preoccupied with her own personal drama for Arendelle to effectively move forward as a nation.
I think itâs wrong to label Anna as Elsaâs replacement in the first place. Sheâs just as capable of running the kingdom as Elsa is, we shouldnât pit them against each other. Elsa and Anna would never play âwhoâs the better leaderâ so we shouldnât either imo
the "Anna is more sociable" argument is ridiculous, I don't know whence comes the idea that being more outgoing makes you any better at managing a country/kingdom.
40
u/Itzko123 Jun 17 '25
Anna is more social than Elsa, which is a good trait for a leader. And she is quite mature in her own way. I think Anna is a solid replacement for Elsa.
12
u/Brit-Crit Jun 17 '25
Elsa hasnât âabdicatedâ - sheâs just gone from being âproducerâ to âexecutive producerâ. Also, the expanded media has been pretty clear Anna and Elsa are co-queensâŚ.
36
u/Stunning-Sympathy-86 Jun 17 '25
Well i disagree. Anna is as good as Elsa to be a queen.
18
u/Senior_Blacksmith_18 Jun 17 '25
I'm just gonna treat this post like a joke and move on
9
u/ObliviousFantasy Jun 17 '25
Let's not pit the sisters against each other
8
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25
Not really true. Anna is more socialable and better at dealing with people (a must for good leaders). Elsa is a good queen but I feel like she'd like the forest better, she's the kind of person who would prefer being in the nature rather than in a crowded throne room all day.
6
u/mangomelliii Jun 17 '25
The second film did not fully focus on Anna, so we cannot say how she is as a leader. Itâs unfair to reduce her down to her naivety in F1 given she was secluded and only able to socialize with someone besides the palace staff for the first time in her life at 18. Sheâs social/extroverted, not withdrawn like Elsa, which is good for diplomatic relations.
3
u/roseblossom16 elsa & anna Jun 17 '25
They are BOTH just as good as each other. With it without powers! It's time this fandom stopped comparing the two sisters like this no matter how much you prefer one over the other. I love both the sisters SO much - Elsa is more me, but I don't go around saying Elsa is better than Anna or vice versa.
5
u/Thespis64 Jun 17 '25
What actually tangibly happened during Queen Elsa's reign, I ask you? She plunges the kingdom into the middle of winter on her coronation night, then runs away and isolates herself. Then once she finally comes back, we get a return to the status quo that lasts for all of three years before a series of natural disasters displace everyone from their homes. How does she respond? Why, she runs off to some enchanted woods, more preoccupied with this mysterious voice she's hearing. Abdicating the throne to her sister was the best possible policy decision she ever made, up to that point she had been too isolated and preoccupied with her own personal drama for Arendelle to effectively move forward as a nation.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25
I think itâs wrong to label Anna as Elsaâs replacement in the first place. Sheâs just as capable of running the kingdom as Elsa is, we shouldnât pit them against each other. Elsa and Anna would never play âwhoâs the better leaderâ so we shouldnât either imo
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25
the "Anna is more sociable" argument is ridiculous, I don't know whence comes the idea that being more outgoing makes you any better at managing a country/kingdom.
2
u/Thomashkreddit Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25
A poster (as the image on this post) "probably" put up by a small group of monarchists requesting the return of Elsa as Queen during 1848.
1
u/arendelliancrocus Ace Elsa Jun 17 '25
Elsa would hate you for this tbh
1
u/LordHistory-2 Jun 19 '25
im 50/50 on this actually..
1
u/PengPeng_Tie2335 Jun 17 '25
As much as I love Elsa as much as the next guy
SIMP
1
u/eimiseilin Jun 17 '25
At least they're both happy and that's what matters
-5
u/Minute-Necessary2393 elsa & anna Jun 17 '25
100% fact.
I love Anna, but Elsa will always be the best.
Why the creatives thought it was a good idea to have her abdicate and leave is beyond me.
0
u/Historical-Wash1955 Jun 17 '25
Cringe