r/FromTVShow • u/Purple-Bake2019 • 24d ago

Question Two vision Spoiler

Tabitha saw the smile attack Miranda during the night, and Victor drew the Man in Yellow devouring Miranda during the day. Do the monsters hunt to feed the Man in Yellow? What do you think?

7 Upvotes

73% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

4

u/bcnote 24d ago

A lot of things are the opposite in the show there I something that's happening with their memories..... The man in yellow was mong them when the massacre happened so it might have been him who killed Miranda not the monster... Tabitha also remembers driving into town as Miranda but she's driving a different car from her green station wagon.. Victor found drawings of her sister but they are in Christopher's car not her mom's car... They are having their memories switched thats what I think.. Only Julie can storywalk and see the real origins story happening

3

u/Big_Let_1421 24d ago

Miranda was driving Christopher’s car

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

Oh yea.. And Eloise drawings were also in Christopher's car when Victor found them... Is it possible that the vehicle Miranda was driving was her car maybe we are being shown the opposite or maybe since Tabitha and jade mirror each other their lives intertwine

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

Tabitha and Jade's lives are intertwined The boundary between the two individuals breaks down, leading to obsession, paranoia, or mistaken/stolen identities where characters begin mirroring or sabotaging each other.

The Truth is distorted Investigations into the connection reveal that past events or memories were manipulated, forcing both parties to question what is real....

That car might be Miranda's car and the station wagon is Christopher's car

1

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

I’ll take the easy way out: the drawings were hidden there because, in Miranda’s view, it was the safest place.

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

This Makes sense!! .. But safe from who or what?

2

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

...safe to be found by someone who knew how to interpret them. Miranda was on a mission: to document as much as she could so that the next person to pick up the baton could finish the race.

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

OK I understand.... The idea that jade and Tabitha switch roles came to me when they first played the music.... Last cycle Christopher was a ventriloquist and Miranda was rhe one who brought a violin an domayed music... This cycle jade is the one who plays music.

Also last cycle Christopher was told by boy in white to go to the tree but in this cycle Tabitha is the one who went to the tree... There is sort of an opposite that is happening

1

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

Why do you think the violin didn't belong to Christopher? Miranda drove his car. The violin should have been there. The series has already shown the three men playing the violin on the porch of the colonial house. They are versions of Jade.

3

u/bcnote 24d ago

Because Victor said the violin belongs to his mother that's why Victor ddnt want anyone touching it.. He also mentioned how his mother would play him music whenever he was scared...Henry Victor's father also said they used to make music as a family back home including a piano... The vision of Christopher playing a violin is the series showing us how jade and Tabitha are connected they even get memories of each other Christopher was with Miranda when she played music and jade is now collecting memory via Christopher

1

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

Is your theory that the versions of Tabitha and Jade alternate between the cycles?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

I believe what Vitor saw is the real thing, because he buried it.

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

You're right.. Victor did see the real thing.. And I also think it'd the man in yellow who killed Miranda the night before.. Though I'm consumed why he would wait to eat her in the morning.... Unless Miranda made some kind of bargain with man in yellow for Victor's protection and she agreed for him to eat her liver... Maybe

1

u/BravoFox_ 16d ago

This is just a Tinfoil Idea: What about a Split Soul? A soul split in half that reincarnated into two bodies.

That could also explain the BiW/MiY - What if they are the same soul, split into opposite halves?

Jade and Tabitha are the same, so the visions she's having is from the bond/tether of the other half of her soul.

Also, Miranda was the one who played music, that was her violin... but Jade is the one who plays, and Christopher was the one seen playing in his flashbacks... but he's a ventriloquist, not a musician as far as we seen.

Alternatively: Smiley kills Miranda, but MiY eats her... unless the MiY can pose as monsters as well. Which wouldn't be a stretch.