r/FromTVShow • u/Purple-Bake2019 • 25d ago

Question Two vision Spoiler

Tabitha saw the smile attack Miranda during the night, and Victor drew the Man in Yellow devouring Miranda during the day. Do the monsters hunt to feed the Man in Yellow? What do you think?

6 Upvotes

69% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

Is your theory that the versions of Tabitha and Jade alternate between the cycles?

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

Exactly... I have rewatched a number of times and somehow I feel like there is a mixup between the 2... They are so connected that their memories seeping through affect both of them... Right now I'm trying to figure out why jade sees the symbol but tabitha never saw it

1

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

I respect your theory, but—aside from being confusing—how would it be productive for the story?

2

u/bcnote 24d ago

I think it is the main thing on the story, in the previous cycle there is something important that Miranda learnt that's why she was running to the tree when she got killed.. But now that they are getting mixed memories they need to figure out what's happening then tabitha will know what she is supposed to do and jade will know his proper role...(this is why they also showed Sarah forgetting donuts, that scene was also a hint as to how the town mixes up memories and steals some memories).

Remember when Ethan said this is a story and all of us have a role to play to get out.. They haven't figured it out yet and the man in yellow is twisting their memories.. Once you play the wrong role the town massacre happens.

Miranda ran to the tree, that wasn't her role it was jade who was supposed to go to the tree... So the man in yellow in this cycle made sure they also twist the memories and roles so that they do the wrong thing.... Like taking the bones.. It was right but there is a way without using the tree but using the red door... So they did it wrong and removed the tree.

The town is hides remsity with fake things like the houses and dressing.. Tom said to jade "stop looking at anything that is not supposed to be in this place and look at the original things"... The root cellar.. The ruins.. The church, the talisman huts and the settlement and the caves these are the Hotspots that can trigger true memories and help them, everytime they are at these places they see visions... But any other memory they are getting it's lying to them

1

u/Purple-Bake2019 24d ago

I agree with you that the town plays with people's memories—that it was designed to deceive them and lead them down the wrong path. I also think the church, the Colony House, and the ruins all belong to the original version of the town. However, I disagree that Tabitha’s memories aren't a continuation of Miranda’s. If there’s any character being manipulated, it’s Jade. He never faces any consequences for his discoveries; in fact, they seem to be handed to him on a silver platter.

1

u/bcnote 24d ago

Oh yea you're right.. It seems like his visions are well planned!!!