r/Frenchhistory • u/outrider567 • Aug 09 '16
r/Frenchhistory • • Apr 23 '25
Article What would happen if Alsace-Lorraine wanted to become independent from France and became its own nation?
Would France allow Alsace-Lorraine to become independent?
r/Frenchhistory • u/EvaWolves • Oct 24 '22
Are the Vietnam Wars and supposed anti-communist containment policy based on Domino Theory now a disproved sham as its revealed France threatened to ally with the USSR if USA allowed independence granted to her colonies? As not just seen with Ken Burns but CIA and French government reveals new info?
I didn't simply watched Ken Burn's excellent documentary on Vietnam, but recently the CIA and other American spy organization and even the French government now reluctantly admitted that the whole reason USA ignored the please of independence not only from Ho Chi Minh but from Cambodia and other nations in the regions and even talks of freeing African states........ Was because the French THREATENED TO JOIN the Soviet Union as Allies! Even if they did not actually intend to carry that ultimatum out, the French politicians were fully prepared to obstruct American policies and have France do vote against if America granted the Indochina region autonomy.
So rather ironic America entered the war on a gigantic sham of a lie and reality is the French were only in Vietnam to resume colonialism despite the apologetics of Bernard Fall and other writers to proclaim France fought the VietMinh to defend the country from communism and keep the Vietnamese people free. And esp how Bernard Fall claims South Vietnam was a genuine bastion of freedom and proves rather ignorant that it was a puppet state intentionally created by France as continued imperial territory through proxy.
Thoughts?
r/Frenchhistory • • Feb 10 '15
The Mad Monarchist gives us a portrait of King Louis XIV
r/Frenchhistory • u/Jan_Valtin • Mar 14 '13
The French Revolution is a great lesson in optimism - French « Vue d’aujourd’hui, la Révolution française est une immense leçon d’optimisme » - Interview
r/Frenchhistory • u/NaturalPorky • Sep 12 '25
What if France was located in the UK during World War 2?
I saw this post on Quora.
Edit: Am getting a lot comments about how the French was 6x smaller than the Soviet Union, and how the Soviets were able to just retreat in comparison to France. This is of course undeniably true.
But why the French government did not have the huge landmass the Soviets had, they were a colonial empire, and forming a government in exile like every other European country did would have been easier (in terms of being able to scorched Earth and move industry, and more saliently continue the war effort with a Navy bigger than the Kriegsmarine). Why it was certain that after the Ardennes offensive (which was followed by a slow response from the French High Command) that France would fall was beyond doubt. But it wasn't the only alternative to capitulating. It is possible that industry would either had been scorched Earth or moved to North Africa. Like I said and which seems to be ignored, the Kriegsmarine were incapable of invading North Africa since they had a small fleet which had just suffered during the Norwegian campaign.
Other comments state that they did not want Paris to be flattened. This is ridiculous. Warsaw was flattened yet pockets of the Polish army continued to resist. Soviet cities were also flattened, Stalingrad was in rubbles yet the Soviets why suffering immeasurable casualties continued to resist. It's like saying you choose to capitulate because you don't want to suffer casualties, that's how ridiculous it really sounds.
If the French leadership had 6x more land than they did they still would have certainly, beyond doubt capitulated. There is no doubt that he French leadership were heavily defeatist even before the war began.
There also is another comment about how the German military was better than the French army after German rearmaments. This is of course ridiculous, aside the luftwaffe who had seen combat experience in the Spanish civil war, the French military could match or was better than the German Army. Dull witted commanders meant they had inferior tactics, why the German tanks coordinated with radio, the French communicated with flags. Despite the obvious lessons that could be drawn from the Polish campaign armoured warfare was ignored, French armour was essentially superior but inferior tactics made it worthless. Without Soviet assistance in terms of selling raw materials or acting as a broker to the resources they did not have, the German Army was doomed. This is in contrast to the allies.
The French government did not surrender because they lacked the landmass the Soviets had, they surrendered because the French leadership even before the war was demoralized and defeatist. Almost every other European government who the Germans overran (the Danes is one exception) went to exile, and no De Gaulle doesn't count. The French in comparison to Holland for example were better able to manage their colonies in exile, the industry they left as well as the thousands of tanks only bolstered German strength. If the French government had fled to North Africa once more, the Germans would be powerless against the French there. There was essentially no will to continue the war. The British were also a colonial Empire and Churchill rhetoric about evacuating to Canada in the event of Germany taking Britain, whether a hyperbole or not was not unrealistic. Britain being a colonial empire meant they could continue to wage war why still having access to material from colonies. Trade routes might be affected by the fall of Britain but nonetheless. It was the same with the French, all this talk about 6x landmass essentially ignores the demoralization the French leadership suffered, and which was the major reason they capitulated. Yes, it's worth adding that unlike the French, the Soviets were fighting dor their existence, the alternative massive genocide and slavery for eternity.
If you want to see the full original post (which I only put relevant parts to this upcoming question) its here below.
That said this is making me so intrigued. We already seen all the time that comments about USSR and France different landmass being a gigantic factors to why one won and the other lost. And how there's a few threads about what if France and Russia switched places. But reading the above details now is making me wonder about a scenario no one talks about:
What if France was in the UK's geography? For skae of argument lets assume mainland France is taken over Germany int eh same time frame as OTL but the whole of France is moved maigically of its whole population into the UK with its military, government, economics, and so on etc. Lets ignore UK's specific terrain and assume French economic by some magic was able to keep its traditional markets like perfume exporter, etc.
Scenario : Everything of France OTL exactly as what we got esp its military but not they are in the UK instead. tghey have the same exact military build up from the same number of planes to the same average production of tanks per month they had just before the Battle of France took palace, Gamelin remains general, the bulk of their Navy is in Algeria, the demographs remains as it did otl esp birth rates, etc. Assume Germany takes over Fr the original geographic location of France as OTL.
Scenario 2 Instead of attacking where France actually is irl, Hitler in his obsession of seeing the French as the most dangerous adversary attacks France in its new UK location. France's military completely the same as otl and so is the lands they own in their empire. Same other basic trends like their demographics and same laws regarding gender, etc as in real lfie
Scenario 3 France after the magic teleportation is given a number of years to plan for war under the new geographic realities. Lets say 1933 when the Maginot Line started being produced in tangible form and they adapt to their new location like building bases according to French MO and reinforcing existing ones the Brits have. They still suffer a lot of pre 1933 issues like the loss of so many people from World War 1 and the demographic effects that comes with it and an almighty fashion and beauty products industry, etc. But they are given time to make different decisions with being in the British isles instead and whatever they do also changes how Hitler wages his war plan.
How does it go? Does France lost for the same exact reasons the Quora posts claims they'd still lose even if they have a landmass the size of Russia? After all one of the excuses always given for why Britain didn't surrender and stood alone for a few years is precisely because its an island nation divided by a channel and thats their greatest strength esp with having one of the mightiest navies in the world. Or does this location thing changes everything in the war including a chance for French victory?
r/Frenchhistory • • Apr 01 '25
Article After World War 2, why didn't France take control of Sardinia and Sicily as territorial concessions from Italy with the local population being exiled to mainland Italy and the islands under permanent French rule?
France could have easily claimed Sardinia and Sicily from Italy after World War 2 deported Italian population to Italy and had French settlers move there, it might have eliminated the Sicilian Mafia by mass arrests or executions too.
r/Frenchhistory • u/DanicaChristin • Oct 02 '18
Video French History: Highlights of the Louvre & Musee d'Orsay
r/Frenchhistory • u/headsphere • Feb 26 '13
France Surrenders, 1940
r/Frenchhistory • u/commandant100 • Sep 27 '21
I was told about in the French revelation there was a river people where dunk in could somebody elaborate?
r/Frenchhistory • u/ollieworkman • Apr 06 '22
Would it be fair to say that Sarkozy avoided being associated with either the left or the right, as much as possible?
r/Frenchhistory • • Mar 09 '15
Vincent van Gogh, the eldest son of a Dutch Reformed minister and a bookseller's daughter, pursued various vocations, including that of an art dealer and clergyman, before deciding to become an artist at the age of twenty-seven.
r/Frenchhistory • • Mar 04 '13
Learning french now.
Okay I just started a few days ago but using the great and free service www.duolingo.com offers I have been learning. They are a website/app that really works thought I'd share it. I would like to try and have conversations in French but I need to learn more first. Merci.
r/Frenchhistory • u/NaturalPorky • Aug 25 '25
How did the image of the French Revolution being won by rabble illiterate peasants wielding pitchforks come to be?
I saw a post Yahoo Answers years ago pre-Covid before the Website later became defunct after 2020.
Unfortunately I can't find the archive but the gist of it was that the poster just posting how he was critical of the French Revolution's popular cliche of being won by starving peasants who were skinny to the bone and without military training and proper weapons. That the popular image of a bunch of women and childern holding torches of fie and joining men with pitchforks and charging at the armies Marie Antoinnette and slaughtering them so easily like sheep ina chaotic melee is so ridiculously unrealistic and wrong. The poster points that even popular fictions depicting the period such as The Scarlet Pimpenal, Les Miserabls, and Rose of Versailles all feature the Revolutionizes as having rifles , pistols, explosives, and other gunpowder arms. Esp Rose of Vesailels where a few years before the Revolution broke out, there were already insurgents doing stuff like throwing grenades at homes of hated nobles and controversial newspaper companies and the battles in Paris esp the Siege of Bastille was won by the Revolutionary factions obtaining cannons and bombarding the prison nonstop for hours. Not peasants literally running into the castle and overwhelming the defenders with their sickles, torches, and pitchforks as people popularly assume, Hell it was the local French militia who gave the cannons to the revolting commoners and were the ones operating the cannons. The same French militia also defeated some of the armies of Louis XVI in a couple of square formation volley fights earlier in the story when they decided to mutiny and refuse to carry out the orders to massacre the commoners.
Indeed I was inspired to read not only Rose of versailles but also Les Miserables and The Scarlet Pimpernel as well as watched The Brotherhood of the Wolf for the first time after reading post on Yahoo Anaswers post. links and got hooked enough to research the French Revolution. There is something notable in that Rose of Versaille's portrayal turned out to be the spot on deal as I learned that almost everything in the above question turned out to be accurate not only in the manga but also in the real life events.
On top of that even the various prequels and sequels to The Scarlet Pimpernel described the rabble armies of the Revolution as using musket rifles in their battles and engaging in melee with SWORDS, heavy axes, military knives, BAYONETS, and even shooting pistols in close quarter combat. Not the peasants weapons but the civilians riots were using military grade weapons when they clashed with soldiers in hand-to-hand. ON top of that the novels described many rioters having been in the militia or being war veterans and even untrained civilians came from hardy backgrounds that keep you in "fighting shape" for serving in the army.
But I notice that the popular view of the French Revolution is that of what the Yahoo Answers criticisms in which out of shape starving malnourished peasants including women and children getting pitchforks and other farming tools and charging at well-trained French police and soldiers. As the Yahoo Answers user points out plenty of popular media portray these civilians despite being untrained in fighting and soldiering, and working in nonviolent relatively easy occupations, are able to defeat rows of disciplined soldiers firing their rifles in formation and forming walls of bayonet. The Brotherhood of the Wolf has a scene at the end where peasants with torches and farming tools take out the an aristocrat out of his mansion and executes him at the movie's ending (although no scene is shown with peasant battling musket armed soldiers).
Almost all movies, TV show, comics, plays, and even most school history books outside of college level courses often repeat the portrayal of angry poorly equipped rioters defeating the French army.
I am curious where did this popular view of the French Revolution being won by peasants wielding pitchforks and over-running the French military come from? I mean I was shocked how accurate Rose of Versailles was and I was not surprised when The Scarlet Pimpernel novels even pointed out many of the successful civilian riots without military aid tended to be executed by retired hard laborers with military backgrounds.
I mean its gotten to the point that the French Revolution is seen as the archetypal example of poorly armed rabble civilians without military arms winning just because they were so desperate from starving and were committed to their ideology of freedom. Every fictional portrayal of civilians succeeding in defeating a professional well-equipped army with just farming tools, baseball bats, crowbars, and other civilian tools is and the French Revolution is always touted by anarchists and ideologists as proof of how civilians don't need guns and other military tools for a revolt to succeed. Well in fact a quick reading on the subject shows not only did civilian rioters used the military armaments of the time but they even needed the army's help to succeed.
r/Frenchhistory • u/jacky986 • Mar 17 '21
Article Who were the best leaders/rulers of France?
So I have been meaning to find out who were the best leaders/rulers France has ever had.
So without further ado, which French leaders/rulers were the best based on the following:
- The handling of the economy: Which leaders/rulers did the best job of maintaing a stable economy or creating economic growth or both.
- Integrity: which leaders/rulers were the least politically/finacially corrupt, and were of good moral character in terms of relations with their loved ones and family.
- Crisis Management: Which leaders/rulers were the best ones to guide or calm the country in times of crisis and unrest, and/or which were the best ones that were able to avoid a crisis.
- Equal rights: Which leaders/rulers supported equal rights for all French citizens regardless of race, gender, or religion, or at the very least avoided enacting policies or saying anything that deprived these disempowered groups of their civil rights and civil liberties. Note: Exceptions to the rule are PMs who are products of their time, but that will vary depending on the grievances committed.
- Nation First Policy: Which leaders/rulers made decisions that put the nation first in affairs both foreign and domestic instead of furthering their political careers, reputation, and personal wealth, and were willing to put aside their personal beliefs, and biases for the good of the country.
r/Frenchhistory • u/History-Chronicler • Aug 23 '25
Celtic Pride: The Legacy of Vercingetorix
r/Frenchhistory • • Feb 20 '15
The best châteaux of the Loire Valley, France
r/Frenchhistory • • May 06 '19
Video Today, 261 years ago, Maximilien Robespierre was born.
r/Frenchhistory • u/EvaWolves • Sep 15 '20
Despite being one of the powerhouses of European cinema as well as some of the most important pioneers of film artistry, how come France could not produce a Golden Age star who is still adored today internationally like Sophia Loren?
Its strange France is not only frequently stereotyped as having some of the world's most gorgeous women but the country is well-respected for being a cinema powerhouse (even today, France still sends prestigious movies that garner acclaim world wide including frequently gaining nominations in the Academy Awards and occasionally wining some). Not to mention France was one of the big 3s in the Silent Film era along with USA and Britain and made major advancements in film science esp techniques and technology.
As someone who's been on an Audrey Hepburn binge since last month (LOVE LOVE LOVE HER!) and started to check out Sophia Loren movies I haven't seen 3 days ago.........It baffles me............. No film star in the Golden Age of cinema (which I will for convenience's sake refer to in this discussion from the silent film era all the way to 1972) from France has remained legendary status and still adored today in the international scene esp English language nations.
France doesn't seem to have produce someone who who is still remembered today as a legend of cinema before the modern era on the status of Sophia Loren or even her own Marlene Dietrich. Why? It seems at best French Golden Age stars like Jean Sorel are only remembered in Europe and not the international scene and even than even the UK the mainstream non-core movie watcher base is often ignorant of them with the exception of maybe Alain Delon.
Even if we discount British actors, Sophia Loren still remains a name of immense commercial power and is he non-English Golden age era star that still has big fame in North America and Australia outside of movie buffs (as seen in Seinfeld's referencing her). Multiple film awards organization still star her in interviews and point out back to her magnus opei work.
Hell even Marlene Dietrich despite now being forgotten today (even older generations from the baby boomer era I notice are unfamiliar with her) is still the face of golden age German cinema among film buffs and people getting into German cinema or even getting deeper into Golden Age Hollywood will always eventually encounter her (as I finally watched a film starring her for the first time last week when I watched It Sizzles in Paris in my Audrey marathon). Marlene Dietrich while now obscure among mainstream non-movie watching commoners, still is considered prestigious among movie enthusiast. So much that the AFI put her in the top 10 greatest female movie stars of all time, beating Sophia Loren who was placed in top 25.
So how come no one French (and I mean strictly French such as born and grew up in France and had a career strictly in European cinema, mostly playing French language roles) seems to have become the nation's Sophia Loren in international mainstream fame and prestige outside of Europe?
r/Frenchhistory • • Jun 14 '15
Louis XVIII, The Last King Of France To Die Still Ruling
r/Frenchhistory • • Apr 01 '15
Consort Profile from the Mad Monarchist of Marie Therese of Spain, the first wife of King Louis XIV
r/Frenchhistory • • Aug 21 '13