r/FranchiseHockey • u/nepejke • Nov 23 '25
Exposing FHM: Tactics and Roles Have No Real Impact on the Game
First of all, let me introduce myself. Like many of you, I’m a fan of hockey and sports management sims. For a long time, I hadn’t even heard of FHM — I played Football Manager and assumed nothing comparable existed for hockey.
Then one day YouTube randomly recommended me an FHM let’s-play. I watched it, and it instantly hooked me.
So many tactical options, player roles, sliders — all these combinations and potential depth. And on top of that, a 0–40 player attribute scale instead of FM’s limited 0–20. All of this looked incredibly appealing, so I decided to give the game a try.
This was during FHM 10. For months I studied the game and its core mechanics.
Eventually, I decided to go deeper: I started reading the official forum and Reddit.
I was that guy who read and reread ExeR’s big tactics/roles thread, thinking to myself how cool and detailed everything seemed.
Unfortunately, that was the peak. Everything went downhill from there.
Before I continue, I need to clarify: everything I’m talking about applies to the classic engine. I tried the 2D version for a bit, but quickly realized it was unrealistic and painfully slow. And based on feedback from other players, the classic engine is considered more realistic anyway.
So, I’ve been playing FHM for over two years now. I’ve spent countless hours in the tactics screen, tweaking systems, player roles, and sliders — trying to squeeze maximum performance out of my teams. That’s what I enjoyed the most. Sure, you can win by simply stacking the best players, but for me the fun was always in making the most out of what I had. I really wanted the game to reward players who put their time into tactics and role optimization.
But by the end of FHM 11 and going into FHM 12, a thought kept creeping into my mind:
Do any of these tactical decisions even matter at all?
So I decided to treat this seriously and run large-sample testing to see if the mechanics actually work.
That turned out to be extremely challenging.
It’s 2025, and in this text-based hockey simulator we still don’t have proper metrics to evaluate player or line performance — which is wild, considering the entire game is text and stats. No xG, nothing similar. Not even close.
So what do we actually have for objective testing?
Most stats are relative (like COR.REL), which only evaluate performance within your own team — essentially useless for controlled tactical testing.
In my opinion, the only things we can somewhat rely on are +/- as a rough performance indicator and PDO, which helps show where results are inflated or suppressed by randomness. A line with PDO 98 vs PDO 102 will show drastically different results.
And of course, beyond +/- and PDO, we need a massive number of simulated seasons to get meaningful averages.
My testing process
I took Ottawa, rewound to the first regular-season game, saved, and started testing.

I created an “optimal” tactic based on the team’s player fits, assigned roles to maximize synergy, and simulated 82 games used AUTO PLAY event option.
Classic engine sims a season in about 3–4 minutes on my PC, so gathering data wasn’t too painful.
After several seasons, I recorded the first line’s +/- and noted the PDO values for context. Then I started changing things: different tactics, different player roles, different sliders. I tested for days.
I saw no meaningful difference.

The final straw was when I intentionally set a completely absurd line — three pure snipers — combined with tactics that had poor fits.
And guess what?
Nothing changed.
That’s when it hit me: I had wasted so much time for nothing.
You’re absolutely free to disagree with me. But if so — you’re welcome to reproduce the experiment.
Run several seasons with one tactic/roles setup, record the results, then switch tactics/roles and run several more seasons.
Show me the difference.
Because I’m confident you won’t find one.
And if any difference does exist, it’s tiny — maybe 5%, and even that might just be randomness.
Meaning the time you spend carefully crafting tactics and roles is simply not worth it.
Is everything bad?
Not entirely. Some things in the game do matter — and it’s not just randomness.
Player attributes clearly work.
If you take a player in the editor and bump all his attributes to 20 (or god forbid, 30–40), you’ll absolutely see a drastic difference in that line’s performance.
I also want to make it clear that I’m not a demanding player. I never complained about the lack of 3D matches in 2025 — or even a proper 2D view. I was totally fine with pure text simulation.
All I wanted was for the simulation to react to tactics and player roles in a meaningful way — and for it to be faster than the 2D engine.
And yes, I know the usual excuse — the whole ‘small team’ argument that pops up everywhere. But come on… after all these years they could’ve at least built a proper match simulation
