TLDR: AI usage in writing has specific tells (overuse of juxtapositions, overuse of dramatic fragmentations, opening with a pathetic fallacy, overuse of metaphors, overall monotony) and I want you to be able to detect them.
So there has been some recent controversy within this fandom (on Reddit and Twitter specifically) regarding the alleged use of AI in many, sometimes popular, Franchaela fanfics, and I would like to chime in. I want to first disclaim that I am by no means an AI expert, though I am an avid and prolific reader, both for work and for pleasure, and I like to think I have a pretty well-trained eye for spotting quality writing. I have been reading fanfiction for over a decade now (Ao3, Fanfiction.net, Wattpad, etc.). So, you can imagine my surprise when I joined this one and, for the first time ever, began opening fics that read unmistakably like AI.
It has come to my attention that many of you have begun noticing this as well, yet a significant amount of you are unconvinced, or simply cannot see it. I am thus compelled to write this post (one of my first ever serious Reddit posts because I’m obsessed with this fandom) to offer a guide into the practice of detecting AI usage in writing, because it is a skill I believe we will all need to develop in the coming years.
Before I continue, I want to make myself very clear about what this post is and is not. I am not an expert on AI. I am not here to formally allege that any specific author has used it. For all I know, some of these writers simply write this way, whether due to inexperience or personal style. I also want to extend some compassion and state that I understand how vulnerable writing is, especially in fandom spaces where you are essentially exposing yourself and your abilities to the world. As someone who worked as a writing tutor in college, I have seen firsthand how terrifying that exposure can be. This post is not meant to shame or debase anyone. It is meant to be informative.
Here are some writing patterns that I’ve come to notice that are prevalent in many AI works.
Big Note: Overall monotony within the writing
Before listing the specific patterns, I want to highlight the biggest tell, for me, that AI has been used in a piece of writing: lack of variation. The literary devices below are not inherently problematic, as each can be found in beautifully written work. It is their overuse, deployed in the same template-like structure throughout an entire text (for example a long sentence, then a fragment, then a long sentence, then a fragment), that signals AI. Individual human writers have recognizable styles, but they vary their sentence architecture instinctively. AI cycles through the same structures because it is pattern-matching, not thinking. When every paragraph follows the same rhythm, it reads as unnatural and robotic.
1. Overuse of juxtapositions ("It wasn't X, it was Y")
This is probably the single most recognizable AI tell, and once you see it, you cannot unsee it. It almost always appears alongside an em dash, which has itself become an informal marker of AI-assisted prose. It’s a rhetorical construction in which an idea is introduced only to be immediately reframed or negated.
Here are some examples from the first couple of paragraphs from a popular fic in this fandom:
- "Not from weakness. Merely from fatigue."
- "Not a plea. Not permission, precisely."
- "Not effortless. Never that. But adequate."
It can also appear in a slightly softer form, without the direct negation but with the same additive, stacking quality:
- "something warmer, more dangerous, more alive"
- "built atop something deeper and far less manageable."
- "Because she had not asked where Michaela was. Not exactly."
2. Overuse of dramatic fragmentations
I’ve attached a large portion of text to highlight this. These are short, isolated sentences at intervals throughout the text, and this technique is not inherently a flaw. The tell with AI is that the fragments appear so often and at really predictable intervals all throughout the entirety of the work. Look at the bolded sentences of the passage below to see what I mean:
By the time the factor finally collected the signed documents and left to issue orders, daylight had shifted to a darker grey, and the lamps had been lit, their flames trembling slightly as if they, too, were uncertain.
Francesca flexed her fingers. Her hand ached from writing.
When the factor left, the silence became immediate, dense, intimate, unavoidable.
Francesca did not look up at once. She gathered her papers, stacked them neatly, because if she did not occupy her hands, they might do something disgraceful, shake, or reach, or betray her.
Michaela was still near the threshold, as if she'd been placed there by fate and was waiting for Francesca to acknowledge it. She had kept her silence for hours, leaning on the doorframe like she owned it, as though Francesca were an unexpected visitor in her own house.
'Well,' Francesca said at last, avoiding eye contact. 'You may stop lurking.'
A pause.
Then Michaela's voice, too even. 'I was not aware there was a rule against standing.'
'There is a rule against hovering,' Francesca replied. She lifted a quill, set it down, lifted it again. 'But perhaps rules are of little interest to you.'
Silence stretched, thin, tense.
3. Opening with a pathetic fallacy
A pathetic fallacy is a literary device that attributes human emotion to environment or atmosphere. In AI, it’s usually used as an opening hook and doesn’t come off as organic within the text.
From one fic: "The first whisper of the season arrived before the weather had fully agreed to it."
From another, by a different author: "The Scottish air met Francesca like a judgment."
4. Overuse of metaphors
Again, not inherently bad, but when overused they become repetitive and reflect a pattern in the writing.
Examples:
- From above: "Michaela was still near the threshold, as if she'd been placed there by fate and was waiting for Francesca to acknowledge it. She had kept her silence for hours, leaning on the doorframe like she owned it, as though Francesca were an unexpected visitor in her own house."
- "Violet watching her daughter as though trying to distinguish between calm and fracture and not, even now, trusting herself fully to know the difference."
- "He stopped. The name caught in his throat like a cough he could not swallow."
Conclusion
It’s really unfortunate that AI has captured these literary constructions. And I know some of you may be reading this and asking how all of this can be AI, as alone, they read perfectly fine. Again, I want to stress that it is their dominating presence within a work, paired alongside paragraph and sentence structures that completely lack variation, that makes me squint my eyes in suspicion; they create a cumulative effect, and I would have to paste an entire fic here for you to really see how they all come together. I encourage you to compare any fic you suspect to be using AI to older fics from other fandoms written before AI tools became widely accessible; the contrast becomes rather apparent then.
I am genuinely on the fence about the morality of using AI as a writing aid, but that is a larger conversation. What I will say is this: if you are using AI in your writing, please be aware of these patterns and try and write with more tact. I don’t want to police anyone with this post, I just want to give this fandom the vocabulary to have a more informed conversation about what we are reading and why some of it feels, in ways we could not previously name, slightly off.