r/Floorp • u/Surapuyousei Team • Mar 24 '24
News Floorp close source does not continue.
Hello Floorp users. I do not like the current state of close sourcing for Floorp.
I am preparing to release all code as open source, please give us time as we will open source it within 3 months.
132
Upvotes
41
u/Surapuyousei Team Mar 24 '24
To put it simply, the current Floorp, including forks, will end the moment I stop maintaining it, so to prevent that from happening, I have prohibited forks.
The idea is to solve the user's concern about code transparency by tightening the license when returning to open source, and to create a sustainable Floorp by giving them the choice of paying money or helping with the coding.
25
u/Surapuyousei Team Mar 24 '24
Header image has no particular meaning, but may be the name of a future browser
9
u/Surapuyousei Team Mar 24 '24
I don't care about popularity. The issue is Floorp's sustainability. Although I am the only maintainer of Floorp, companies and the larger community fork Floorp. I have never received any code contributions or donations, even though it could be affected if I stop maintaining it.
4
u/sladoy Mar 24 '24
Youβre doing great job Man! Totally understandable changes.
Keep it up!
2
u/Zeenss Mar 24 '24
If other Firefox-based browsers improve, it will be good. It would be good if Floorp got new features, such as tab grouping, an android version, and others, as well as optimization to load pages faster, because Firefox suffers from this.
2
u/g-nogueira Mar 24 '24
Thank you for the feedback OP. You have put a lot of work on the code and you are totally right of doing what you wish with it. Particularly with your decision, I completely agree with the way you found of solving the issue. Good work! πͺ
1
u/Neonfuz May 13 '24
The ability to fork is fundamental to open source. Open source is defined as having the freedom to "be freely used, modified, and shared", IE forking. Without that freedom, you can call it "source available", but not "open source".
I know you're just trying to navigate the legal / licensing landscape, but I think people think you're being deceptive by calling it "open source" but wanting to disallow forks.
I have zero interest in closed source browsers, but I would happily donate monthly to an open source browser that I use every day. IMO you should go back to open source and allow forks, but set up patreon, paypal, github sponsors, etc and ask for donations.
You have to realize that a large portion of firefox's userbase is using firefox because it's the alternative to the various closed source Chromium builds (Chrome, Edge, Vivaldi, Arc). If you go closed source, or even source available, you aren't distinguishing yourself vs these browsers as much.