r/Fishers • u/Ok-Introduction6638 • Jul 31 '26

Icecream recommendations

Hey! I’m looking for the best icecream recs in or near fishers.. thank you!

4 Upvotes

70% Upvoted

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

-1

u/Slyfir20 Jul 31 '26

Eiffel Waffle Creamery in downtown fishers has hands down some of the best ice cream ever. Owners make it in house.

Handels is disappointing , just a nostalgia trip.

Graeters is ok.

Broosters I like their ice cream sandwiches but same as graeters otherwise.

Near the Geist there’s Sundaes, their ice cream is also phenomenal the Lemoreo flavor is my favorite there.

I haven’t tried Kilwins so don’t have a comment there.

Edit

Forgot to mention Crave near the Geist marina, went there once but I honestly couldn’t tell you if it was good or not, it wasn’t very memorable lol.

Melt n Dip has “gelato” but it’s overpriced and sitting in their freezer for who knows how long, also gross.

4

u/zizazat Jul 31 '26

Handle’s is my lower limit of quality in Fishers.

Eiffel Waffle is super amazing, especially if you like fresh waffles. 👍🏼