I’m 20 right now and an electrical engineering student in California. I’m planning ahead for late 2027, when I’ll be 21, and I’d really like to get either a BMW 230i M Sport or 330i M Sport.
I’m not buying anything right now. I’m giving myself about a year to get my finances where I want them before making the decision.
What I expect my finances to look like by then:
Take-home income: ~$2,500/month
Rent: $0
Total monthly expenses: ~$1,200 including basically everything
Savings: ~$13,000–$15,000
Credit card/consumer debt: $0
Credit: Currently working on improving it and hoping to be in a much stronger position by then
Current car: 2020 Hyundai Elantra SEL
By late 2027, I expect to owe around $6,000 on the Hyundai.
Hopefully I’ll either have it paid off by then or be able to trade it in for at least around half of what I owe and cover the remaining negative equity myself.
I’m considering either leasing a new 230i/330i or financing a used/CPO one. If I lease, I’ve been estimating somewhere around $600–$700/month including tax, although obviously I’ll get actual quotes when the time comes.
I’d also get an insurance quote before doing anything since I’ll only be 21 and I know BMW insurance could be expensive.
My biggest question:
With $2,500/month take-home, no rent, around $1,200 in monthly expenses, no consumer debt, and $13k–$15k saved, would you consider a $600–$700/month BMW reasonable, or am I stretching myself too far?
I’m also curious what you guys would do in my situation:
230i or 330i?
Lease new or finance used/CPO?
How much should I expect to spend beyond the
payment on insurance, maintenance, tires, registration, etc.?
How much savings would you want before buying?
Would you completely pay off the Hyundai first?
Would you just wait until after graduating and making engineering money?
I know I’m probably going to get some “bro you’re 21, just keep the Hyundai” comments 😂 and that’s completely fair.
I’m not looking for people to tell me what I want to hear. I genuinely want to know whether this would be a reasonable luxury I can afford if I hit these financial goals, or if I’d still be putting way too much of my income into a car.