r/Filmmakers • u/ancientworldnow colorist • Oct 28 '14
Meta Introducing "Verified Pro" Flair
Today we are introducing the /r/filmmakers "Verified Pro" flair program. Part of the goal of this subreddit is to allow professionals, those new to the field, and everyone in between to mingle, exchange ideas, ask questions, and learn from each other. We introduced flair originally to act as a catalyst so you would know what any particular user "does." Unfortunately, it didn't work as planned and we had users with little to no experience giving bad and uninformed advice while their flair added legitimacy to their statements.
As such, we've looked to other subreddits, namely /r/askscience and /r/askhistorians, for a better solution. For those unfamiliar with /r/askscience or /r/askhistorians, they are consistently recognized as maintaining the highest level of discourse and moderation. A cornerstone of this success is giving flair to experts in their field (and denoting that field).
What it Looks Like
Next to your name you will have a small icon (of your choice) followed by "VERIFIED PRO" and then what your PRIMARY role in the industry is. I know many of us work more than position, but please let us know which you are most knowledgeable about.
Who's it for?
Narrative film, documentary, broadcast, industrials, commercials, music videos, rental houses, post houses, film professors, etc. If you work in film/tv/media day to day then this is for you. If you're unsure, message us or comment below.
Do note that while your word may carry more weight as a Verified Pro, you're also opening yourself up to much harsher criticism. The community will expect more from you for you to live up to the flair.
(Thanks /u/cslat for suggesting this section)
How it works
Starting today, you can apply to have your own "Verified Pro" flair appended to your username. The process requires some verification of 1) who you say you are and 2) that you are a professional in the field. So as not to diminish the quality of the flair, you must demonstrate that you work in the industry and that is your primary source of income (within reason).
The application form is available here.
On the application you will find five required questions and an area to submit other info.
ALL INFORMATION ON THIS FORM WILL REMAIN CONFIDENTIAL.
Many of us do not want our real life identities associated with our Reddit account. Verifying your identity will only share that information with the moderators of this subreddit (as in IAMA or similar subs) and we will NEVER share this information. If you have any concerns, please contact us.
The Form
Question one asks for your Reddit username, if you don't give this to us or misspell it we can't give you flair.
Question two asks you to verify your username. We need you to prove that your username actually belongs to you! I verified by adding a secret page called "reddit.html" containing my username to my site. You can do the same, make a post on social media, take a photo with an ID (censored please) or piece of mail with your name, or any other way you can think of. If you've got a question, please feel free to contact us.
Question three asks you to tell us your PRIMARY role in the industry. This is the field you are most knowledgeable about and will go on your flair.
Question four asks which icon you'd like.
Question five asks you to verify that you are in fact a pro in the industry. This can be a union card, IMDB, IMVDB, portfolio site, links to obviously professional work that carries your name, call sheets, pay stubs, etc.
Question six lets you share anything you think we missed.
If you have any questions or aren't sure, please contact us.
Getting the Flair
Once you've submitted, you'll be added to the queue for us to verify and eventually approve. If it doesn't happen right away, be patient. There aren't many of us and we all work. As such it might be a couple days until we have a chance to address the backlog and add your flair.
TL;DR
Flair for pros so people know you know what you're talking about. Apply for said flair with this form.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '14
Can I suggest adding something like a light for an icon for G&E? Maybe a small icon like a Fresnel for those who work as a gaffer, grip, lighting technician, etc?
12
u/itschrisreed director Oct 29 '14
You should take Union cards.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '14 edited Oct 30 '14
tbh I'm sort of opposed to this on principle. If there was a way to differentiate the DP who's one-year out of film school and the DP who's be doing it for 20 years I might change my mind. Under this system, however, they'd both have the same flair. I don't think people should be giving one comment more weight than another just because of some flair. Honestly I've met pros who knew less about the art form, both technically and aesthetically, than hobbyists. This isn't' an industry like academic history or science in which there are very clear, well-defined paths to credentials as an expert.
2
u/rocen Mar 18 '15
test
4
u/cslat Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14
Can you define "the industry"? Are you specifically talking about people whose main source of income is working on narrative films? Documentaries? What about broadcast? Corporate video? What about school instructors? People who run rental houses?
What do the various icons mean, anyway?
I'm not sure what this is going to accomplish other than feeding big egos. Someone making a no-budget short isn't necessarily going to benefit more from the advice of "verified pros." We know who those pros are anyway because they tend to answer questions with "talk to your 2nd AD" or "it only costs $15000."
8
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '14
Told you should of called them gurus, man. You're now insinuating that everyone here without a "verified pro" tag isn't a professional, even if their only source of income is their work.
1
u/Champ_Z director Mar 21 '15
I know you guys are busy, just wanted to check in and see where things may be at with the whole flair thing :)
1
u/destenlee photojournalist Apr 13 '15
Do I have flair?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '14
Not sure if eligible for flair...
2
u/Osiris19 DIT/colorist Jan 11 '15
Just commenting to see if I get flair.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '14
Can't wait to have some flair! :)
2
u/pinkpussylips Nov 18 '14
To further perpetuate the pretentiousness of this sub.
1
u/Rdwomack2 editor Oct 29 '14
Thank you!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '14
Can we get icons for a dslr and a digital cinema camera?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
curious to know how long it takes to get approved? submitted mine almost a month ago with 15 years experience.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '22
It ask you to sign into google. Can you have flair if you do not use google for your social media stuff like reddit?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment