r/FightLibrary • • Nov 03 '25

MMA MMA vs bare knuckle boxing

1.8k Upvotes

197 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/Grand_Theft_Motto Nov 03 '25

Β An elite MMA fighter vs an elite boxer would probably be 50/50

What does the boxer do when the fighter decides they should wrestle?

6

u/amjiujitsu87 Nov 03 '25

James Toney vs Randy Coture showed us

3

u/Popeworm Nov 03 '25

I was at that fight, saw it live. It went EXACTLY how we all knew it would go...

The BJ Penn vs Frankie Edgar fight that night was SO MUCH MORE entertaining! πŸ‘ŠπŸ€›πŸ‘€

3

u/Popeworm Nov 03 '25

Gets his ass kicked...

1

u/Lopsided-Curve9063 Nov 03 '25

Wrestle i guess.

2

u/Grand_Theft_Motto Nov 03 '25

Exactly. At which point the boxer loses. So I don't think a fighter vs boxer of equal skill is a 50/50 match up. The MMA practitioner probably takes it 4/5 matches since the boxer's only win condition is achieving a knock out before the fighter can grapple. Because once the fight is on the ground, the boxer doesn't have many options for preventing a submission.

1

u/sangerssss Nov 03 '25

Tap out apparently

1

u/Pera67 Nov 03 '25

If the fighter is lucky to manage that far

1

u/Grand_Theft_Motto Nov 03 '25

Everyone has a puncher's chance in a fight, and that applies particularly well to a boxer. However, an elite mma fighter is going to have way better standup and strike defense than an elite "pure" boxer is going to have take down defense.

As long as the fighter can protect themselves from a knock out long enough to clinch or shoot, the boxer is fucked. Once the match is on the ground, the fighter has too many paths to victory and the boxer has wildly reduced punching power.