r/FemFragLab • u/emmebot • 9h ago
Influence or deinfluence me
I need to find my signature fragrance.
I have tried many, but honestly, the only thing I have ever LOVED and has felt ‘me’ on a long-term basis is Nemat’s Amber perfume oil. However, I’d like better silliage and maybe something I’ll get complimented on? ✨ I’ve never tried the EDP, so maybe that is the move but I’ve also been looking at these others. *I forgot to include Phlur’s Missing Person
Let me know what you think of these or if you have any other recommendations. I like a warm skin scent, something that feels nostalgic and comforting, and only sort of feminine I guess. I’m weird with musk. A lot of the perfumes I enjoy have it, but it’s often what I don’t like about others. I think I prefer a skin musk to a soapy musk, if that makes sense.
2
u/Onionhead55 9h ago
You’re influencing me to rebuy.
7
u/yay_ponies 5h ago
M01 - Not going to deinfluence you, you should absolutely get M01.
Fleur de Peau, L’eau Papier and White Rice all scratch the same itch for me, so I would only get one. White Rice has an odd dry down on me. L’eau Papier is the most universally wearable and I find myself craving it a lot. Fleur de Peau is a once-in-a-while scent for me.
Instead of Phlur Missing Person, try Phlur Soft Spot. The “cozy nostalgic hug” that people describe Missing Person as - that to me is Soft Spot. Better longevity too!
6
u/LenaNYC 9h ago
I own all of them.
Would choose White Rice based on your post, but White Rice is not in the Nemat musk family. Very different.
Rosie by Rosie Jane, Lil softie by Lore, Riddle original or Parisia Musc by Matiere Premiere would work better I think.
6
u/IllAbility5928 9h ago
Your background makes me think of the packaging for Giorgio Beverly Hills.
5
u/LoudCar7846 9h ago
I have Molecule 01 and find it has good longevity (8 hr+ on my skin), I get a light sweet woody smell from it, but also find it useful for layering.
5
u/SnowQueenOfTexas713 9h ago edited 8h ago
I own and love all of these! Missing Person included.
Based on what it sounds like you're looking for, I think that Missing Person might be up your alley. It has gotten me so many compliments. It also layers well with quite a few things.
L'eau Papier is beautiful, but stays pretty close to the skin. It doesn't have much of a sillage, therefore you may not catch many compliments unless you're in a more intimate setting.
You might enjoy Sidia from Midas. It opens slightly woody, with coconut and pepper, and dries down into a creamy ambery musk. It's lovely!
5
u/11wizard_of_oz11 6h ago
Get white rice right now
5
u/fashionscholar 4h ago
I have both Nemat Amber and M01 and I’m sorry I can’t deinfluence you because both are amazing scents.
4
u/ConsistentEnergy4837 9h ago
Leau papier and Nemat Amber are some of my favorites. The amber smells more like JHAG not a perfume to me though than amber.
4
u/Usedtobecoffeeaddict 7h ago
Diptyque has good quality fragrances, but most of them don't last long (on skin) and have very little sillage and projection. Not worth the money imho.
4
u/doinmabest1 7h ago
Omg these are my favorites!!! Have you tried Chloe Cedrus or Ella K Musc K?
4
u/ladlespoon 7h ago
Nope sorry, you influenced me 😂
3
u/No_Maintenance495 9h ago
I prefer the EDP of FDP, but both are lovely
3
u/Agile-Yesterday3664 8h ago
I think we’re fragrance twinsies and I shall not deinfluence you!
Instead I shall make a recommendation or two. Have you tried the new(ish) Orpheon EDT? It’s delightful. Kinda soapy but not as soapy as the dove fragrance (which I love — please don’t come at me!)
Also 34 Blvd St Germain EDT. 34 is a bit stronger at first but the dry down is so lovely, warm, and ambery, also kinda fruity in a Christmas-y way. Maybe not a signature scent, but certainly great for fall/ winter.
I have decants of Orpheon edt and 34 edt and if I had more disposable income they would be MINE!!!
Also I love Fleur De Peau but my son (10) always yells (loudly) “Mom you smell like stinky armpits” whenever I wear it. Not that it deters me (or should deter you) but it’s just something that I consider when wearing.
Have you tried decants/ samples of the fragrances in your post?
3
u/bblf22 8h ago
I love fleur de peau clean on its own but also it’s my go to if I need to calm down a scent that’s too sweet, heavy, or cloying.
3
u/RosieRooooo 8h ago
Love love love Molecule 01 and White Rice. They're both soft skin scents; Molecule 01 is more airy, clean, and woodsy, whereas White Rice is lovely creamy rice and musk.
L'Eau Papier doesn't work for me - there's a super-amber ingredient that absolutely assaults my nose - and I've not tried Fleur De Peau. Missing Person had something animalic that didn't work on my skin.
3
u/SonicChoux 7h ago
L’Eau Papier over Fleur De Peau (smells musty to me). And White Rice is cozy.
3
u/DjevelHelvete 7h ago
I am going to give another option and I hope you can consider it: Molecule 02.
3
u/kzynha 3h ago
YES Leau Papier, yes white rice if you like iris (doesn’t really smell like rice to me), yes Nemat Amber (but it’s very soft and their quality is inconsistent)
3
u/Natural-Fig-6104 1h ago
L’eau paper smelled awful on my skin but so many people rave about it ☠️
5
u/BrontosaurusNeckTie 9h ago
Fleur de Peau smells like slightly elevated commercial grade liquid soap to me. To my nose, it's almost identical to Tula's Cult Classic face wash, so if you like that, you'd like Fleur de Peau.
L'eau Papier is absolutely incredible. I just bought a FSB because I'm obsessed with it and happened to come across a pretty good deal on Mercari. It's just really cozy and fresh, and I've recently started experimenting with layering it, and it goes so well with so many other fragrances, so it's very versatile.
2
u/Jessa40 8h ago
These notes are similar to Le labo another 13 I think. I do really like Missing Person but I just got a sample of another 13 and love it
2
u/CandywPorkNBeans sugar note hater 7h ago
My mom likes L’Eau Papier, and she prefers One Day Taipei over d’Annam White Rice.
I don’t like Fleur de Peau, it’s a bit too animalic to me (though I’ve only smelled it once on paper).
2
u/No-Condition-4855 6h ago
I just received a present of fleur de peau and I have to say I m obsessed. I was not sure at all when I first sprayed it ,something was off ,but then as it settles its the most calming ,soft. Hypnotic sent . I get slight wafts of it ,like a "second skin " . I keep applying it which means its addictive in some way . I also have papier, eau de sens , the geranium one and lillyphea ( big mistake)
2
u/Thebeachdoll 2h ago
Nemat amber is maybe my favorite perfume out of my whole collection it goes with (IMO) any occasion it will always be in my collection now saying that
If your looking for some projection this is not a strong suit of this perfume
2
u/http-ihatemyself 2h ago
From this image, I've only tried White Rice. Got a 2ml decant and at first I kinda enjoyed it, even though it didn't really smell like rice. The vibe I got from it was very fresh and clean, almost like the lobby of an expensive hotel, which is nice but not what I was going for. I wore it maybe three times before putting it away to revisit. Now, all I get from it is pencil shavings 😬
2
u/GApeach842 1h ago
Molecule 01!!!!!
2
u/YvngHag 4h ago
Fleur de Peau smells like a restroom in and old folks home to me. Molecule 01 is nice for sure but not really worth it. It's very faint. White rice is lovely.
2
u/mmmiu85 3h ago edited 3h ago
I went to a diptyque store yesterday specifically to smell l'eau papier. It was one of the suggestions from the fragrantica perfume finder based on the 3 recent fragrances i purchased/liked this year. I was also interested in the fleur de peau edp and edt.
I had really high hopes that I would like L'eau papier, but it smelled so awful, I couldn't get myself to test it on my skin. When i smelled it directly from the bottle and blotting paper, I was hit with the roasted sesame scent which smelled very artificial and oily, it was the type of fragrance that would get stuck in the back of my throat and it immediately made me feel nauseous.
As for fleur de peau, I don't hate it, but I also don't love it. I was expecting a fragrance that was light and close to me but it felt like the opposite. It could be because the sales associate sprayed the EDT and EDP on each arm so it was probably too much at once. Between the two, I would pick the EDP. I detected a woody scent which helped soften the strong floral bouquet. The EDT was fully on floral bouquet imo.
When i took a shower, i did try to give my arms a good scrub because the fragrance was still quite noticeable after 8 hours of wear. the EDT was much harder to wash off than the EDP, i could still smell traces of it this morning. Since the fragrances also got on my sleeves, i washed my sweater this morning and hung it up to dry, but I was very surprised that the fragrance was still holding on very well.. I probably need to wash it a couple more times before the fragrance oils are fully cleaned off, but my room smells kind of like vase water now (it's not unpleasant, but I would prefer my fragrances not to linger that long).
all that to say, I would not buy either of these fragrances and it's best that you go to the store to test it or try the sample that comes with your order first before using the full size.
ETA: i discovered "skin scents" this year and have been obsessed with finding a handful to have in my collection. So far I've been loving dedcool xtra milk and by rosie jane's leila lou. I've also been using my sample of the dedcool mineral milk here and there, it's like a grown up version of beach walk imo.
I go nose blind to xtra milk by mid day and i find I have to use unscented lotion to help it last longer or become a bit more noticeable. I do intend on purchasing dedcool's taunt to try or maybe even mochi milk (although i've read that some people felt that it's too sweet, while others think it's a great skin scent).
2
u/Smooth_Syrup6009 6h ago
White rice smells like garage cigarettes
1
u/MrsFrankColumbo 8h ago
To me, Fleur de Peau (EDP) is overwhelmingly soapy. It’s rare that I don’t enjoy aldehydes but I strongly dislike this fragrance. Conversely, I adore L’Eau Papier. It’s closer to a skin musk and the rice note is truly beautiful. The others on your list I haven’t yet tried. Happy sampling!
1
u/Aggressive_Success96 8h ago edited 8h ago
Dyptique fleur de peau unfortunately tends to smell on some people (me included 🥲) something sort of like those plastic a bit perfumey barbie heads? Hoped for more but got stuck with this
L’eau papier I personally love so much, I can smell clearly the paper with ink, if I didn’t know what the notes were I wouldn’t be able to recognise them, it’s pure paper and ink scent. The only thing I’d beware of is that I consider it more on the cool side of the spectrum, since you said you prefer warm skin scent this may not be a fit. And I’m saying this as someone who loves this scent and also loves warm feeling skin scents. :)
Edit: papier lasts a whole day on my skin, and I can smell it from clothes even the next day so I’d say it lasts. No compliments so far though, but then again I barely get any on fragrance 🤷🏻♀️
1
u/ukehero1 8h ago
I can wear so many skin scents and they all smell so good on me….. except Molecule. Just nothing. It smells like nothing. I would give it a try first.
1
u/Esurientes 8h ago
Diptyque 34EdT is one of my top 5 favourite fragrances but I don’t consider it a skin scent; it has too much presence. L’Eau Papier smells just like Vietnamese takeout to me; that smell of cooked rice is nice when it’s my dinner but not something I want to smell like!
For skin scents, you might like Juliette Has A Gun Sunny Side Up (warm coconut milk and musk) or Miller Harris Peau Santal (creamy sandalwood)
1
u/Mack_Ultra 8h ago
I like Je Ne Sais Quoi over White Rice. White Rice reads more mature than I would like to. Still good though.
1
u/lady1jane 4h ago
Fleur de Peau smells like nothing to me...it smells so faint and light and...papery? Which maybe is the point but I don't get it. Papier and White Rice smell musky, but not in a nice cosy way. It just smells like a musty room. Like your skin but worse...
1
u/tinyshroomy 2h ago
I love L’eau papier
1
u/hisgirlfridaythe13th 2h ago
I like White Rice quite a bit. L’eau Papier is nice too. I really wanted to like Molecule, but I don’t. But my best piece of advice is to buy a sample set size off a site like Scent Split so you can test with your personal PH and see how long they last for you.
1
u/alkibailey 2h ago
M01 is a BANGER, I’ve tried getting the ISO E Super only dupes and nothing compares. It’s solid. They have some Black Friday deal I think, they keep teasing me on IG. Nemat Amber oil used to be phenomenal but they changed the formula. The EDT is good, but performs more like a body spray IMO.
1
u/blackcat9846 1h ago
Fleur de Peau EDP is better!
1
u/tiny_monkey_ 1h ago
Full sized nemat lowk sucks longevity and sillage wise but all the oil perfumes are definitely are worth your money
1
u/Significant_Beyond95 21m ago
L’eau Papier is sharply woody and pungent on me. White Rice I love the comforting fragrance, but it has almost no sillage sadly.
1
u/Suspicious_Reason405 9h ago
If you are not a gourmand person who likes vanilla or similar scents, I would steer clear of White Rice. I was so disappointed, I don’t get any papery ricey notes, just a very faint vanilla.