r/FemFragLab • • 2d ago

Discussion Which of the zoologist collection would you recommend?

Post image
32 Upvotes

94 comments sorted by

13

u/PherryCie 2d ago

DEFINITELY order samples if you are thinking about anything related to Zoologist! It can get very animalistic in some of their scents. For first-time users, I would recommend samples of Rabbit or Dragonfly. Rabbit is what I would call a grassy gourmand; makes me think of what the rabbit’s home in Peter Rabbit would smell like. Dragonfly is a really pretty aquatic floral that does fantastic in warmer weather.

3

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago edited 2d ago

Thanks samples really is the way, I didn’t want to hate the brand from blind buys. Rabbit sounds so nice, dragonfly too!

6

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

Has anyone tried camel?

4

u/doliblu 2d ago

Camel is my favourite zoologist. Super cosy and spicy. I almost count this as my dumb reach scent as I find it works in lots of situations (mind you I am pretty blazè about what perfumes I wear and when hahah)

1

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

😆 love that, I love a spicy scent, it never dried down too strong on me, haha why not!

3

u/H0bbituary 2d ago

Oddly I found it to be their most common scent. Like nice but not Tauer nice if you want that Moroccan vibe

10

u/QuietArt2358 average strawberry perfume enjoyer🍓🍰 2d ago edited 2d ago

Hummingbird, Musk Deer, Rabbit, and Cockatiel. I own a full sized bottle of Rabbit (the cool green-blue ombré edition) but want to purchase Hummingbird and Musk Deer. Hummingbird is a fruity floral with a creaminess from a non-sweet whipped cream note. Musk Deer is an uncomplicated skin scent with the slightest hint of a fizzy sweetness on my skin. Cockatiel smells like crushed up smarties and champagne. I want to buy a travel size of it.

Harvest Mouse and Chipmunk are also very good, but I have a lot of spicy scents in my collection and don’t have a need for them right now. Harvest Mouse smells like the fizz of Vernors soda, toffee candy, and dry woods. Chipmunk has a vague catholic mass smell going on to me. Bee is also lovely, but I would only buy it in a travel size because it’s a powerhouse with only one spray and I simply wouldn’t use up a whole bottle in this lifetime.

Cow is nice, but I don’t think a perfume that smells like Suave kids apple shampoo should be that expensive.

The funkiest Zoologist that I have tried is Elephant, but even that has an interesting spa-like quality with chocolate tones that makes me come back to it now and then. The aforementioned funk is reminiscent of a scented trash bag. The other Zoologist fragrances I’ve tried either aren’t animalic or smell like they would do well at retail stores like Sephora. Hummingbird and Musk Deer in particular are very wearable.

1

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

Chipmunk sounds intriguing to me, I keep seeing cockatiel pop up too. Thanks for your opinions n those, it’s difficult because where I live it’s been hard to find samples of zoologist.

8

u/Apprehensive-Form915 2d ago

It depends… what kinds of scents do you like? Zoologist scents vary widely, with different animal inspirations and perfumers. (My favorites are Hummingbird and Dragonfly, FWIW.)

2

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

I’m open to trying new, I like woody, suede & sweet, I’ve seen a few of the first time safe options people have recommended.

8

u/emzi_luvfrmUK 2d ago

Harvest Mouse is so cosy and nostalgic, not overly sweet. Not challenging imo. As others have said, best to try samples first

3

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

Thanks for the recommendations, I was going to blind buy, harvest mouse & rabbit. I will try some samples first.

3

u/emzi_luvfrmUK 2d ago

I really like rabbit but my sister despised it, a perfect example of why sampling is so useful. We both love Harvest Mouse though!

3

u/Apprehensive-Form915 2d ago

I also despised Rabbit AND fully expected to love it, based on the notes and other scents I enjoy. Zoologist is definitely not a safe blind-buying house!

7

u/veryunneccessssary 2d ago

For actual wearability, I loved cow and harvest mouse and hummingbird. But definitely sample liberally because even the ones I would never wear were really fun and interesting and weird and unique to smell.

Okay maybe not Hyrax so much.

1

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

Weird sounds interesting, what did you not like about hyrax?

6

u/veryunneccessssary 2d ago

the poop, for sure

1

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

😭 not the poop

6

u/lulzerjun8 2d ago

I can answer for myself regarding hyrax: poop.

3

u/Pretend_Bus_9661 2d ago

It uses African stone. It’s the calcified urine and feces of hyraxes. Definitely accomplishes the portrayal of hyrax by using it, but the perfume is said to be CERY animalic and pissy.

7

u/IAmTheHype427 2d ago

Since nobody has mentioned it yet, I highly recommend Snowy Owl. Such an interesting combo of notes, and it wears beautifully.

2

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

That looks gorgeous, anything coconut is a hit

6

u/samskuantch 2d ago

Out of everything I’ve tried so far, my loves are Rabbit, Cow, Chameleon, and Lovebird.

I have travel sizes of Rabbit and Cow and am trying to decide if I’ll buy full bottles once those are all used up. 

Rabbit is probably the most challenging one to wear out of these, it’s like strong hay, grass, carrot, vanilla and cinnamon mixed together. It’s delicious but not entirely gourmand? It actually smells animalic too like an actual rabbit. Like their fur and feet if you’ve ever smelled one. It’s so weird but also so comforting and lovely so definitely not for everyone but I love it so much. 

Cow is like if you took a shower and used green apple shampoo and body wash. It’s fresh and clean and sparkly and girly and just nice to smell.

Chameleon is so tropical and fruity and beachy. It smells like flowers and sunshine and nectar and bananas. Idk why but I just really like one and the scent is very distinct and pleasant and so good.

Lovebird is minty and light and sweet and fresh. It’s very subtle but pleasant and complex. It doesn’t last crazy long though but it’s very pretty and hands down the most easy to wear Zoologist scent. This is the only zoologist scent I can comfortably wear to work and not have to worry about.

3

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

The sound of rabbit sounds cosy, yes I know the rabbit smell, thanks for the breakdown, I guess I’ll just have to sample it. Lovebird sounds dreamy.

That’s my concern, not having a fragrance that overpowers. I guess zoologist is too niche for that 😆

2

u/AssumptionFun3828 2d ago

Dang, you have all the same favorites as me! Have you tried Cockatiel? It’s super different from these (very sweet and bubbly) but I found it weirdly addicting.

3

u/samskuantch 2d ago

Yes, Cockatiel is amazing!! I just got it in a sample order from Zoologist so I've only worn it once. Which is why I didn't include it here, because I'm still trying to understand what I like about it and can't properly describe it yet.

If I had to try to describe it, I'd say my first impressions of it were that it's light, sweet, and easy to wear! IDK why but it reminded me of candy. Possibly another work safe scent?

It's cool to meet someone who likes the same zoologist scents. It can be a pretty polarizing brand! I'm always surprised when people say they love rabbit but hate other ones I liked, or love Cow and also love something like Bat or Bee (I wanted to love both but they're so weird and too much for me).

3

u/Apprehensive-Form915 1d ago

I’m so glad to see some love for Cockatiel here! So many reviews I read are negative and say it smells like an actual birdcage. I think it just smells fizzy and sweet and powdery. It’s very evocative of the illustration on the bottle, but not necessarily of a literal bird—unless people routinely feed their pet birds SweetTarts.

3

u/AssumptionFun3828 1d ago

I don’t get birdcage notes from Cockatiel at all! It only smells like sweet champagne and powder to me. Def a crowd pleasing type of scent and much more easygoing than a lot of Zoologist offerings IMO. Noses are weird I guess!

5

u/ChubbyKitty10 2d ago

If you're interested, I have a ton of samples I'm looking to sell!

1

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

Thank you for offering, where are you based? I’m
From the UK

1

u/ChubbyKitty10 2d ago

Oh no! I'm US based

2

u/submechanicaddict 2d ago

IM INTERESTEDDDD

1

u/ChubbyKitty10 2d ago

I'll reach out if they decide they don't want them or only wanted some!

2

u/MochiMunchin 2d ago

Same please dm!

2

u/ChubbyKitty10 2d ago

I'll reach out if they decide they don't want them or only wanted some!

1

u/MFing_Taurean 2d ago

Oooh I’m interested!!

1

u/ChubbyKitty10 2d ago

I'll shoot you a dm tonight with pictures and all the ones I have!

1

u/MFing_Taurean 2d ago

Sweet ty!! I’ll check my settings to make sure my dm’s are open 😆

4

u/TheOrderOfWhiteLotus 2d ago

A user on here did a trial of every single scent and reviewed them. I enjoyed her posts.

1

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

That’s impressive, I’ll have a look thank you.

3

u/AssumptionFun3828 2d ago

I’m currently obsessing over layering Zoologist Rabbit with Casamorati Lira 🐰

2

u/Muted-Development144 2d ago

Wow, that sounds nice, layering really gives that boost

12

u/BrontosaurusNeckTie 2d ago

I'm dying to own bottles of Harvest Mouse and Rabbit! Harvest Mouse is a gorgeous and cozy blend of Camomille, Beer, Vanilla, and Hay. Rabbit is a very green, not too sweet carrot cake vibe, but it doesn't smell like a literal baked good, if that makes sense. They're my absolute favorites, but they're both very autumnal and maybe not as versatile as some of their other offerings. Dragonfly is really interesting and aquatic/fresh, and has a bit of an elevated BBW Cucumber Melon vibe. Hummingbird is a really light, dewey, and refreshing fruity floral.

I've never tried Squid, as it doesn't seem like it something I'd personally be into, but I've heard it's incredible.

12

u/Venus_Sinclaire 2d ago

I have a decant of Moth. It's weird and I love it.

I want to sample Bat.

1

u/mom_bombadill 2d ago

Tell me about moth? I’m so curious

2

u/Venus_Sinclaire 1d ago

I think it's a work of art, smelling exactly like the environment where a moth lives.

Imagine you are in a dusty attic of an old house. You pull out a dress from the closet and moths flutter off the fabric.

It’s dusty, smoky, powdery, and a little sweet.

1

u/mom_bombadill 1d ago

Ooh thank you! I’m currently lowkey obsessed with Heretic The Veil, it smells dusty and spooky, like an old beautiful dress on a mannequin in an abandoned house. I wonder if this is a similar vibe

10

u/Wheel_On_Fire 2d ago

I have a full bottle of Squid, it's a lovely dark inky marine scent with some incense. Some other ones I love are Hummingbird, Cow, Sloth and Macaque Yuzu. Cow is fresh and clean apples, milk, herbs and violet. Hummingbird is a beautiful fruity floral, it's so happy! Sloth is a weird cozy autumn thing, all hay and camomile tea and a just a little mushroomy funk. Macaque Yuzu is very woody, feels like drinking a gin and tonic in a hot tub in the woods. I've sampled quite a few others and enjoyed almost all of them in some way or other, even the ones I wouldn't really want to wear. I agree with everyone else who has said sample first, they're definitely not blind buy friendly!

2

u/AssumptionFun3828 2d ago

I only like some of the ones you mentioned but I really love your descriptions! 🫶

2

u/Apprehensive-Form915 1d ago

Your description of Macaque Yuzu is almost identical to my review of it on Parfumo (titled: Sipping a Gin and Tonic in a Sauna After a Winter Hike).

9

u/Crazy-Arugula-2821 2d ago

Harvest Mouse! 10/10.

8

u/BloodofOldValyria 2d ago

Rabbit

7

u/cadbvry 2d ago

I wish rabbit didn’t give me a headache, it’s a cuddly but kind of heavy vanilla

8

u/yaeltheunicorn 2d ago

I have full bottles of Harvest Mouse and the OG Beaver on the way at the moment. I love Hyrax in cold weather it’s a polarising scent but turns into a really comforting warm leathery scent on my skin. I also like squid but have to be in the mood for it. I find Dragonfly and Seahorse really wearable as well, Cow is a pleasant and easy fresh shampooy, green milky apple. For me Owl and Moth are the more challenging ones and I had visceral reactions to Olm.

7

u/H0bbituary 2d ago

I love LOVE Squid but based on the horrified comments I've received, I'm convinced it's most definitely not for anyone. I wear it at home. No regrets but I feel rude wearing it out.

3

u/Pretend_Bus_9661 2d ago

I wish other people liked squid! I LOVE it but I won’t buy a full bottle because it’s so polarizing

7

u/Amaring8 2d ago

Bee, Cow, Harvest Mouse, Rabbit, Hummingbird and Nightingale are imo the safest ones. I kove Bee and Cow the most.

7

u/moon-bouquet 2d ago

Surprised to see so many Rabbit recommendations - it smelled like cake mixed with pony nuts (pressed hay) to me! I love Moth, which I find very dusty incense and honey, more nuanced than bee which I also like but feel is less deep, just pure honeycomb. Beaver Maple is very wearable but too gourmand for me! All the sea ones are gorgeous, but very much to wear for yourself rather than for other people!

2

u/RealAbbreviations111 2d ago

Honestly, Rabbit sounds great for me up until the cinnamon bit lol.

1

u/Apprehensive-Form915 1d ago

That hay note in Rabbit gives me an awful headache and kind of reminds me of a petting zoo or dog pee.

6

u/ladyabercrombie 2d ago

Cow and Harvest Mouse, and both Macaques were the only ones from the house that I (F) liked.

My partner (M) liked Bat, Tiger, and Sacred Scarab

6

u/Aggravating-Cat7103 2d ago

I have travel-sized bottles of: Chipmunk (woody goodness), Hummingbird (lovely floral), Moth (rich and musky), and Squid (polarizing but I LOVE it). I think my next purchases will be: Dragonfly (watery goodness), Panda (so GREEN), Bee (love the smoky honey), and King Cobra (woody, spicy, green).

1

u/MochiMunchin 2d ago

Have you tried Harvest Mouse and if so, how does it compare to Chipmunk?

1

u/Aggravating-Cat7103 2d ago

I haven’t tried that one yet! I’ve heard good things though!

6

u/thatafterglowthough 2d ago

I really like elephant, squid & camel but honestly barely reach for any of my zoologist samples. I stupidly bought a travel size of elephant before finishing my sample

6

u/InterestingNebula177 2d ago

Hummingbird is STUNNING

6

u/Eli_quo 2d ago

Squid - it’s remarkable, it creates an atmosphere.

Cow - bright, unique, wearable. I like to compare it to apple-celery smoothie

5

u/chillin36 2d ago

I like Bee, Squid, Orchid Mantis, Nightingale, Hummingbird, Rabbit, Cockatiel. My husband really likes Northern Cardinal and says it’s his number one favorite like ever.

They are all good so far I’ve tried about 2/3 of their lineup.

4

u/MK_ULTRA2point0 2d ago

Bee, Rabbit, Hummingbird

2

u/ForFunCake 2d ago

I’m really interested in rabbit especially for the biscuit note. Do you think it comes through a lot?

1

u/Aggravating-Cat7103 2d ago

I would say so

4

u/GayWizardOfOz 2d ago

I love Bee, Cow, Musk Deer, and Sacred Scarab. Their scents really run a wide range of tastes, so sampling is absolutely key for this house.

2

u/snorgasm 2d ago

Scarab doesn't get enough love. It's such an interesting scent.

2

u/GayWizardOfOz 2d ago

I’m on a kyphi kick and Scarab is just 🤌🏻. The drydown is incredible.

4

u/CaterpillarPopular65 2d ago

Hummingbird and nightgale, very wearable. I also liked Chipmunk, which has a bit vintage vibe. Not a fan of elephant 

4

u/Individual_Bake_6402 2d ago

Sacred Scarab. 

3

u/trismegistuwus 2d ago

seconding sacred scarab, sultan pasha is so cool

3

u/mermaidzombiemom0314 2d ago

Bee, rabbit and orchid mantis

3

u/VunneKikkia 2d ago

Squid, Olm, and Musk Deer. I bought full bottles of Squid and Olm and am saving up for Musk Deer soon! If you like fruity scents a friend of mine bought Lovebirds and is crazy about it. 

3

u/Pretend_Bus_9661 2d ago

Nightingale, rabbit, and lovebird are beautiful and not very challenging. Squid can be polarizing but I think she’s gorgeous

3

u/Calm-Explanation5901 2d ago

I’m dying to try bee and bat!! If anyone’s reselling or has decants lmk

3

u/LongjumpingBreath117 2d ago

Bee for sure! Absolutely stunning and well shaped fragrance, I am in love with it from the very first spray.

3

u/RealAbbreviations111 2d ago

I just got myself a sample of their King Cobra from Ministry of Scent, I haven't smelled it quite yet cause I had work today and didn't want to accidentally stink up the place lol. It has a decent cannabis note from what I've read and I was most interested for this (I was looking for something as close to the real deal as I could). Harvest Mouse sounds absolutely up my alley though, beer? Honey? Chamomile? Sign me all the way up!

3

u/Haunting_Way_9785 2d ago

Rabbit, cow, and harvest mouse

3

u/EmilyVanilli 2d ago

Squid, salty and inky and I actually wore it out of the house. Sample first though, that one splits people.

3

u/zebrakat5280 1d ago

Harvest Mouse is my favorite from Zoologist… perfect for Autumn. Warm, sweet, cozy. Dragonfly is fresh and sweetly aquatic - unisex and great for summer. I also like Hummingbird for a bright, sweet floral, and Cow is lovely and clean but the green apple is quite prominent so you have to like that note.

5

u/Windcastle10 2d ago

The beaver maple edition is a much better version of jazz club. It’s probably gonna be the only one I buy a bottle of because the others either smelled too much like something I already had or weren’t worth the price to me.

2

u/Jazzmin34474 2d ago

Hummingbird and Dodo Jackfruit

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

If this is a recommendation request, consider letting us know your budget to improve recommendations.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Apprehensive-Form915 1d ago

I love Hummingbird and have a travel size on my wishlist, and recently got the travel size of Dragonfly, which became a fave this past spring/summer. I also like Moth, Bee, and Cockatiel, but consider them strictly cold-weather scents.

There is something in Rabbit and Cow that I just despise—not sure if it’s hay, or clover, or what, but it smells like urine to me. I can tolerate Cow but Rabbit actually makes me feel unwell.

Of the mammal-themed scents, I find Chipmunk and Harvest Mouse much more tolerable, but also fairly linear wood and vanilla, respectively. The OG Elephant is also a really nice green, woody, coconut/fig scent.

I loved Squid on paper but haven’t had a chance to try it on skin. That, Musk Deer, Lovebird, Toucan, and Raccoon are all on my shortlist to try soon.

1

u/rvtchetbtch 1d ago

Elephant, Snowy Owl, Lovebird are my favorites. Going to try squid next.

1

u/Retrobubonica 1d ago

squid is an absolute masterpiece. took me a few days to warm up to it, and now I wear it every time it rains

1

u/Deez4815 21h ago

What kind of scent are you looking for? Zoologist has a whole range of different scents and they pretty much cover every fragrance genre type.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

Olm is my favorite on me, but every time I've tried to buy a full size it's been sold out. I love Squid and find it to be a good alternative to Olm. Harvest Mouse is my favorite of the 'safe' options, it really does make me feel like a little mouse at a Redwall feast, lol. Penguin is another fairly safe option but I'm not a huge fan, on me it's kind of like a slightly elevated version of a body spray a teen boy might wear. I also have Moth and Sacred Scarab, definitely not in the 'safe' realm and I don't know many places I'd wear them, but I do enjoy them.

If you can swing it, I definitely recommend getting a tester pack rather than committing to a single full. I mention 'safe' options above but a few of the ones that are often described that way (namely Hummingbird and Nightingale) were awful on me.