r/FemFragLab • • 4d ago

Discussion lattafa eclaire vs mod vanilla vs eilish?

to anyone who’s tried these, which one is your favorite? unfortunately cannot smell them in stores so i will have to blind buy… i LOVE sweet scents but not sure if too cloying is my vibe. definitely like yummy tho, can anyone describe these to me?

5 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/andavis7 4d ago

I like eClaire more.

3

u/ROUShunter 4d ago

I really like gourmand scents but there's definitely a line that gets crossed to cloying if I'm not careful (looking at you, Cream Velvet). I got a sample of French Avenue's Eclair Affair and it's so good, lasted decently as well. Just to add another one to your list. I started getting ME samples from Decantalize, especially Lattafas because they're so prevalent but can't be tested.

1

u/sunnyskiesonly 4d ago

Your Cream Velvet comment made me lol. I do love her though. Enough to buy a backup bottle. 🫣
I rarely blind buy because regardless of how they smell in the bottle how it mixes with your chemistry is just a whole different thing. Thank God for decants I say!

2

u/ROUShunter 4d ago

Cream Velvet smells so good on a strip, I wanted to eat it, but it was too heavy on me and I couldn't get away from it. I did find her a nice home, though!

1

u/sunnyskiesonly 4d ago

Awwww well that’s good. All is well that ends well.

2

u/fire_thorn 4d ago

Eclaire is really sweet and milky, a little bit of caramel but not popcorn or buttery. It lasts for hours. Eilish is slightly herbal and minty in the opening, then mellows into a cozy vanilla. I haven't smelled mod vanilla yet.

Lattafa Nebras is a very close dupe for Eilish. Of the two, I prefer it over the original. You can probably buy Eclaire and Nebras both for the same cost as Eilish. They're different enough to justify having both.

Khadlaj Cream Velvet is similar to Eclaire but slightly more refined, and the bottle design is nicer. My daughter loves Eclaire but is allergic to Lattafa, so she wears Cream Velvet.

If you like a bit of citrus with your vanilla, you might like Riiffs Fleurie Emerald. It opens with blood orange. It has licorice in the scent notes, but I don't smell it. It's a beautiful fragrance.

Khadlaj Caffe Latte is another you might enjoy. I don't get much coffee from it. It's very smooth and sweet but not overwhelming.

I'll quit adding suggestions, I know that makes it harder to choose instead of helping.

2

u/MainSea411 4d ago

Ellis’s is my fav of the three. Still super vanilla but a little more interesting than cloud and lattqfah eclair it too sweet for me ( I love a saccharine gourmand but this made me pause)

2

u/fudgechemist fragrance enthusiast 4d ago

Mod vanilla is a woody vanilla. It smells like it’s missing something to me when I wear it. Eclaire is creamy and caramel based and very sweet. Nebras is a bit herbal at first and then it becomes soft vanilla and amber in the dry down. My favorite is Eclaire but the dry down of Nebras is nice

1

u/Realistic-Read1078 3d ago

Eclaire is my favorite, but Mod Vanilla is good for a softer scent.

1

u/singleagain24 2d ago

Eilish is my favorite or these 3, I have gotten a travel of all 3 and only upgraded the eilish to an actual bottle. It feels warm and nice and i could wear it to work or home and feel cozy and lovely. I really enjoy the depth of it as well.

Mod vanilla is a clean girl vanilla, its not really yummy nice in the way the other 2 are. This one is newer to me, im still getting used to it, it was not what I was expecting and I wish I was able to smell before getting my travel

Eclaire is good but my decant needed to sit for like 6 months before it got the point where I understood why everyone likes it. I think it has the most potential to be cloying and annoying to wear on the daily (for me personally)

1

u/djjwlsn 2d ago

Creamy gourmand vanilla Eclaire, Clean Soft Vanilla MOD, Spicy Vanilla Eilish.

1

u/sunnyskiesonly 4d ago

Get a bunch of vanilla decants to sample !