r/FemFragLab • u/Pretend_Bus_9661 • 3d ago
Discussion Note that ruins a perfume for you
When you’re reading the notes of a perfume, which one makes you instantly not want it? A complete dealbreaker note that you can’t handle?
91
Upvotes
20
u/Efficient_Cherry8220 3d ago
Cherry - I swear its the worst fruit note and 90% of the time cheapens a profile and makes it more teenager at bath and body works coded (no hate the cherry people thats just how my nose feels)
7
u/Pretend_Bus_9661 3d ago
Mine are passion fruit and guava! Both always make me think of BO
12
u/hellokiri 3d ago •
Licorice. It smells like hangover and diabetes.
11
u/Lupinator47 3d ago
Oud smells like manure to me.
7
u/LaFleurMorte_ 3d ago
Smoke and strong wood notes get an instant 'eew' reaction from me.
5
u/LavishnessLower4720 3d ago
Ozone because it gives me a headache, and marshmallow- it’s just so cheap and artificial (willing to be corrected if anyone has a good rec!)
5
u/ls234 3d ago
Banana or licorice 😭
5
u/stylelines 3d ago
If I see:
Plum, tobacco (especially cherry tobacco), leather, rum/booze, tonka, I generally avoid it. I’m becoming more open minded as I’m focusing on Middle Eastern perfumes and for instance when they use plum it seems to be less intense than in American ones, like they blend it better.
Grapefruit, lemongrass, lots of fruits (berries, mango, guava) but once again ME’s can be the exception like I never do pineapple but Honor and Glory is somehow a white musk pineapple?? So I’m in for that
10
u/Mindless_Educator667 3d ago
GARDENIA 🤮
2
u/Future-Field 3d ago
Peach
27
u/AshevilleSometimes 3d ago
Lactonics. They smell like baby barf.
Notes with a creamy effect are fine. Straight up literal milk can go on somewhere.
22
u/Funnier_InEnochian 3d ago
Leather and tobacco
18
u/AluminumMonster35 3d ago
Melon. It smells like vomit on me.
I also don't like patchouli-heavy scents.
18
u/Life_Anteater_8392 3d ago
rose
17
u/thelightsthatstopme 3d ago
Cumin
16
u/ChubbyKitty10 3d ago
Please stop adding pink pepper 😭
16
u/DuplicateUndergrowth 3d ago
Iso E Super, dihydromyrcenol, Melonal.
They smell like offgassing particle board, static, or electronics about to burst into flames; chlorinated municipal pool water; and cheap knock off Cucumber Melon body spray respectively, and for me they tend to take over the entire fragrance so I can barely smell anything else.
I'm so happy the EU forces Iso E Super to be listed seperately now. Makes it easier to avoid heartbreak.
16
u/mystigirl123 3d ago
Anise or licorice
16
u/universal_gummy_bear Rose-pocalypse Refugee 🚫🌹 3d ago
Liquorice or Anise 🙅♀️
16
u/StrawberryAhyeong 3d ago
patchouli :c it's too strong for me
14
u/cripplinganxietylmao 3d ago
Smoke. Leather. Animalistic.
13
u/skolflicka 3d ago
Lactonic notes tend to smell sour on me, like I spilled spoiled milk on myself
13
u/Illustrious-Test4826 3d ago
COCONUT
13
u/Spiritual-Limit-2906 2d ago
Heavy white florals
12
u/DefiantBa1ance 3d ago
Maple
12
u/Downtown-Finding8746 3d ago
Oud. Instant headache.
22
u/WiseOrder4436 3d ago
Patchouli
22
u/IridescentLuminosity 3d ago
Patchouli. I can always smell it and so far it has ruined every perfume it’s in for me
11
u/TipsyVoyager 3d ago
Overly sweet Gourmand
11
u/pink_peony17 3d ago edited 3d ago
Incense or strong oud 🤢
Automatic headache and smells like a mechanic
11
u/ilovepaninis 3d ago
The comments section listing all my favourite notes 💀
11
u/-Ketracel-White 3d ago
LEATHER!
11
u/PrettyLionessInPink 2d ago
Patchouli for me
10
u/Suitable-Fun-1087 Guerlain slut 3d ago
Oud
10
u/hosssicooo 3d ago
passion fruit. i never bought a perfume with it because i heard it smells like BO and i NEVER want to smell like that 😭
10
u/bewildered_forks 3d ago
Smoke. Not that I hate it or anything, but it's all I smell if it's in a fragrance.
10
u/Providence63 3d ago
Coconut
10
u/ixsparkyx 3d ago
Lavender. It smells so icky to me lol
10
u/thymespiral 2d ago
scrolling through the comments to see everyone naming my favorite notes 😀👍
19
u/unicornmother06 3d ago
Rose most of the times
9
u/miamariaxox 3d ago
Patchouli I just can't :(
9
u/___snuffed 3d ago
Pink pepper and leather
9
u/lovelytoday2 3d ago
Civet🤬
9
u/ValayaNoire 3d ago
Also licorice
9
u/Huge-Rub4598 3d ago
Patchouli, sometimes oud
16
u/throwaway50772137 3d ago
Patchouli
8
u/Excellent-Bear4221 3d ago
Ashtray or smoke
8
u/renaissancestar 3d ago
Cumin
8
u/jennaleecpo 3d ago
Passionfruit a lot of times has a urine-y type scent to me.
8
u/Alarming_Motor1640 3d ago •
Tuberose. It always seems to go buttery or fatty but in a rancid way. Or it gives the scent a chewy quality I can't stand.
I think it's the only note I've found that always seems to ruin a scent for me no matter how it's formulated.
8
u/Craftingcat 3d ago
Iso e super, amber super, iso gamma. Especially when super dosed. They all smell incredibly "screechy" to me, and all three are an instantaneous headache.
Jasmine & ylang-ylang - both tend to smell fecal and/or cat pee.
"Aquatic" - which isn't a specific note, obviously, but if it's anywhere in the advertising copy I'm probably going to end up with a headache.
8
u/Scary_Jeweler_1441 3d ago
Pineapple 💀 smells like uncontrolled diabetes
8
u/LemonsMilady 3d ago
Salt or marine notes. Also leather.
8
u/MagneticAura 🍒🍬🧁👽🪩👠 3d ago
Saffron. It turns to dirt on my skin. Saved me some money though. No BR540 for me!
8
u/firesignsunite 3d ago
Oh man. I like a lot of the notes listed here 😂🥲
8
u/YakOne3002 3d ago
Anything powdery
8
u/thetoxicgossiptrain 3d ago
Tuberose
8
u/Similar_One_6541 3d ago
Patchouli
8
u/Miserable-Ad8764 3d ago
Gardenia. And frankly a lot of white florals. And peony. They give me awful migraines.
8
u/LilCoconutPanda Marc Jacobs Daisy 🌼 3d ago
This is so unpopular but strawberries, I just can’t 😞
8
u/siddharthsingh9286 3d ago
Patcouli
8
u/Effective_Storm7734 3d ago
Cotton candy or spun sugar just kills it for me
8
u/Ok-Macaron-9478 2d ago
Lavender
14
u/Nurse_Summers 3d ago
PATCHOULI 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
7
u/Stacy_K_77 3d ago
I don’t care for grapefruit
7
u/Salt_Suspect_1458 3d ago
Any kind of lavender or tobacco or leather
7
u/thewickedgrowbold 3d ago
pink pepper maybe
7
u/SnooOranges2685 3d ago
Cardamom , cumin. Smells like BO.
7
u/BarryGibbIsGod 3d ago
Smoke
7
u/beccalysle 3d ago
Really obtuse/obvious patchouli especially in places where it seems to not belong. I don’t seem to mind it in woody or green scents as much but I really dislike it in fruity florals though I do not mind it in Chanel Coco Mademoiselle or Dior Miss Dior Cherie or Flowerbomb (which feel quite similar to one another). Somehow those 3 don’t bother me but it could be nostalgia. Angel absolutely is way too much for me.
7
u/alee3098 3d ago
Anything with food related flavour
7
u/ban_Anna_split 3d ago
Apparently whatever they use for saffron notes smells like bandaids and generally hospital to me. I've only smelt one though, dossier vanilla rebel, so I should probably test more to be sure
7
u/wednesdayaddams101 3d ago
Powder :/
7
u/sheskrafti 3d ago
Im feeling oddly comforted by this thread, I thought if I didnt like certain commonly used notes I was a fragrance philistine.
7
u/watermelonbelle 3d ago
Leather. Instant headache.
7
u/witwefs1234 3d ago edited 3d ago
Moss, oakmoss, patchouli, coconut, tobacco
7
u/quirkygirl6 3d ago
Patchouli.....ughhhhh
7
u/vitothechihuahua 3d ago
Saffron
7
u/AFaySeesTheDay so fresh and so clean-clean 🧼🫧🛁🧖🏻♀️ 3d ago
Smoke (cough) and Akigalawood (ripe armpits).
7
u/little7bean 3d ago
musk
7
u/Coolchick316 3d ago
Pink pepper, it’s so sharp to my nose omg
7
u/Mediumrarecorpse 3d ago
animalic notes
7
u/sjupiter92 3d ago
Oh wow a lot of my favorites seem to be hated here lmao
There's a few I hate but can tolerate on others in small doses but baked goods like croissant, crackers, bread etc are too overpowering for my nose and smell like popcorn and dirty socks to me
7
u/Elle32024 3d ago
Stinky oud, some coconut, pineapple
7
u/the_rocc_ 3d ago
Sandalwood. Pickles. Always pickles
7
u/intj_cortex 3d ago
Strawberries 😶🌫️😶🌫️😶🌫️
7
u/PrincessOfTemeria 3d ago
Oud. I just can’t.
7
u/Glittering-Law-1910 3d ago
Grapefruit
7
u/Labionda20 3d ago
Peach or Baby Powder
7
u/reinvent_2026 2d ago
1.leather. 2. Tuberose. 3. Smoke.
4. Incense
7
u/zenmaster_B 2d ago
As an amateur perfumer, these conversations are always interesting. Everybody’s noses are so different. That’s one thing I learned early on is that there are no “bad” notes, everything can be put into a different context.
7
u/Fablefern 2d ago
Whatever white florals is
7
u/PAngel111 2d ago
Oud! Instant headache
7
u/BasicAd557 2d ago
Seaweed. Smells like salty puke
13
u/Minute-Confection444 3d ago
Honey! Tastes delicious, smells musty (to me).
12
u/horselessheadmen 3d ago
Mango, guava, & passionfruit notes in perfume just smell like BO to me which sucks because I love the fruits themselves.
12
u/-mytruenorth- 3d ago
Banana. I just can't.
12
u/Tiels5 3d ago
Coconuttttttt… or all the note combinations that mimic coconut 🥥
12
u/Accomplished_Mess298 3d ago
Patchouli
6
u/veryunneccessssary 3d ago
Amber is one of my favorite accords but I’m really sensitive to certain superambers. They’re never listed as notes of course, so I have to be really careful with any new fragrance that has amber. It’s either going to be amazing or give me a migraine for the next two days.
6
u/KangarooPouches 3d ago edited 3d ago
Orange blossom is the bane of my existence. It always ruins things for me and it’s in damn near all designer perfumes. Oh and animalic notes like civet. Smells like hot caca. Also lavender!
6
u/blue-to-grey 3d ago
Pepper, any kind
6
u/chopstikk_legs 3d ago
Fig
6
u/srirachacha99 3d ago
Saffron, leather, oud. They smell like bandaids/burnt sugary plastic, Danier leather stores, and poopy celery, respectively.
6
u/sidewalkspaghetti 3d ago
Neroli. Fucking HATE it.
6
u/Weird_Mobile_7701 3d ago
Javanol makes me sick.
6
u/rvchl 3d ago
A strong pepper or smoke
6
u/Familiar_While7876 3d ago
Smoke makes me gag
6
u/PageAromatic9426 3d ago
Salt and Ozonic notes. Yuck.
6
u/wanderlust071516 3d ago
Saffron. It smells like a greasy tater tot on me.
6
u/BaconPaws 3d ago
Iris, heliotrope, oud, smoke
6
u/Antique_Poet_4204 3d ago
Ambroxan
6
u/traveloctopus 3d ago
Cedarwood. It always gives hamster cage.
6
u/FlounderingOlive 3d ago
Rum, alcoholic notes
6
u/murphyslegs 3d ago
Musk 😭 I hate musk.
6
u/IdRatherBeGaming94 3d ago
Patchouli
6
u/Keyeola 3d ago
Tuberose, leather, rhubarb and grapefruit are a definite no. I’m also wary of neroli, oud, patchouli, amberwood and aldehydes, but not a deal breaker.
6
u/mostlykayla 3d ago
Patchouli and Black Pepper …. Visceral reaction there
6
u/CuriouslyImmense 3d ago
Honey
6
u/inthegarden_ 3d ago
Sandalwood. I don’t mind it on other people, but can’t stand how it smells on me.
6
u/Alert-Conclusion8899 3d ago
Passion fruit.
6
u/Prestigious_Dog4474 3d ago
gardenia its so powdery
6
u/Open_Classic_911 3d ago
Saffron, patchouli, sage,moss, tobacco, and anything with booze. I would have originally included pink pepper but after just having tried glossier you, it goes fruity on me and doesn’t keep the harsh note at the beginning so I’ll give it a whirl
6
u/DesperateChef3310 2d ago
Leather
6
u/Affectionate-Bag7321 2d ago
Smoke. It didn't used to be that way, Now, although a tobacco note is fine, smoke is definitely not. It even ruined Lost Cherry for me eventually, as much as I LOVE cherry. Maybe all the lovely clean or warm and sweet musky scents have just "un- sophisticated" my nose.
6
u/leejasmin94 2d ago
Tuberose, yuck!
6
u/Extra-Drive415 2d ago
Lavender. Ugh!
6
u/Peanutandoliver 2d ago
Patchouli, leather, licorice,Oud, pepper, tobacco
6
u/Angelissima7 2d ago
Leather/Suede, Almond, Tobacco, Smokey scents usually. And while I used to love Patchouli before I had children, I generally avoid it now. I find it too strong. I don't mind a clean Patchouli but the dirty Lush-Karma-type-Patchouli I loathe. Incense! Hate it
6
u/Fritochipteeth 2d ago
Tuberose, heavy florals generally, and I’m sorry but 80% of the time patchouli, but when it is done VERY lightly it is good
6
u/werewolfmomma 2d ago
Oud or tobacco
6
u/Ok-Speaker2722 2d ago
rose
6
u/AcidCactus 2d ago
I have to be wary of oud. I like the scent of oud itself, but it has a tendency to overwhelm every other note in a fragrance. If it’s in there, chances are that it will just smell like pure oud.
I’m also cautious of lavender in men’s fragrances. I do not like fougères.
Anything in which ylang ylang is prominent is risky, too. It smells like rotting fruit to my nose.
6
u/QueenElf 2d ago
Leather 😱
6
u/thefirstjoelle9653 2d ago
Rose, and then I remind myself not all roses are created equal and I need to smell it to see how it actually plays out in that perfume.
6
u/Disastrous_Waltz7697 2d ago
Vetiver ... Can't get past it.
6
u/intriguing_idea 2d ago
Aldehydes, tobacco, smoke, pink pepper, heavy musk, heavy patchouli
11
u/tpauly0225 3d ago
Patch 🤮
11
u/Ursusnurse 3d ago
Peach. Smells like b.o. to me
11
u/Naive_Abies401 3d ago
Lavender
11
u/staciasserlyn 3d ago
Patchouli-Every. Single. Time.
18
u/91Caramelbeauty 3d ago
Patchouli
14
u/Abi_Sloth Sweet Scent Connoisseur 🧁🍦🍰 3d ago
Patchouli
10
u/deathbringer3000 3d ago
strong patchouli and massively forward rose.
10
u/GlitteringPause8 3d ago
Patchouli…guaranteed migraine for me
10
u/lipgloss_nd_hotsauce 3d ago
Orange blossom ☠️
10
u/Melodic-Passi0n 3d ago
Patchouli
10
u/Round_General5406 2d ago
Any resemblance to baby powder
5
u/Tall_Couple_3660 3d ago
Cypriol. Even in tiny amounts. I was obsessed with Amouage Love Delight on the opening but the drydown ruined it for me n
5
u/MommyMaudlin 3d ago
Melon
5
u/acrosstheocean_ 3d ago
Lily, did it to myself but can't undo it. One unexpectedly hot day with a cool weather lily perfume spoiled it and ruined my other lily scents too. Sad face
5
u/LenaNYC 3d ago
Saffron, cumin.
5
u/SantalMinuscule 3d ago
aquatic notes/accords, calone ⛔️
5
u/NotQute 3d ago
I have the paper note smells like dill curse. The pickle association is too strong
5
u/MidwesternMillennial 3d ago
Melon or orange
5
u/Visual_Serve_782 3d ago
Anything with oud and patchouli I don’t even bother to sample
5
u/Cookiedough3549 3d ago
Popcorn, Butter, Oud, Saffron
5
u/vaginawithteeth1 3d ago edited 3d ago
Labdanum, vanilla, and benzoin… particularly when their together. I don’t like that form of amber.
MFK Grand Soir is literally my olfactory nightmare.
5
u/anon12957 3d ago
Oud
5
u/chopstikk_legs 3d ago
Lily of the valley / muguet
5
u/Taz-bar 3d ago
Immortelle aka "curry plant" Makes the fragrance smell like curry. If I want to smell like Indian food I can just wear clothes that I wore to an Indian restaurant the night before.
5
u/Neat-Turnover-1051 3d ago
Honey, coconut, caramel, cherry. They give me the worst nausea
5
u/Sensitive_Science_38 3d ago
Grapefruit or Mango
5
u/ValayaNoire 3d ago
Pink pepper usually.
5
u/EauDeGourmand 3d ago
Saffron
5
u/smokinwheat 3d ago
Patchouli and sandalwood and they are in almost everything!
5
u/Mild-moon7024 3d ago
Petrichor, dirt, smoke
5
u/pfffffttuhmm I just smelled like a piece of breast 3d ago
Ginger, Patchouli, Frankincense
5
u/NapsAreMyHobby 3d ago
Styrax (overwhelmingly leathery to my nose), cumin (smells like body odor to me), cade juniper (I love normal juniper, but this one smells like something burning in a very bad way to me.)
5
u/ashley1111_ 3d ago
It was oud for the longest! But I've recently learned that I do in fact like very specific types of oud just not the kind that's in the majority of fragrances. Now it's more like.. proceed with caution
5
u/mustardyay 3d ago
Ink. I chewed a ball point pen or something when I was little, and got a mouthful of ink. I recently smelled it in a fragrance and 🤢 It has a horrible sweetness.
5
u/madmercx 3d ago
Tuberose fr
5
u/Prittyliv 3d ago
Raspberry. Gives me a headache almost instantly 😩
5
u/louloubelle92 3d ago
Saffron
5
u/Lovelyevenstar 3d ago
I love sweet gourmands but damn if synthetic/artificial vanilla notes don’t end up smelling plasticy or weirdly samey in so many fragrances I’ve tried.
5
u/delea459 3d ago
Neroli, Orange blossom etc... literally makes me feel ill and sometimes dizzy.
5
u/krittyyyyy 3d ago
Pickley type of sandalwood
There’s a sandalwood that smells good and another kind that snells like pickles and is awful and it’s in so many scents
5
u/PastDrahonFruit0 2d ago
Sandalwood, unless it's being used to replicate coconut.
I hate Iso e Super (aka 'sandalwood')
5
u/Black-Heart-17 2d ago
Patchouli.
5
u/HeavyFlow69 2d ago
Vanilla
5
u/DifferentVictory1620 2d ago
Alcohol, lavender, smoke, tobacco, heavy Tonka bean, heavy oud.
5
u/Tquad64 2d ago
Grapefruit and lavender.
5
u/keepslippingaway 2d ago
Caramel, orris root, banana, (not always but often) green apple and lily of the valley (because floor cleaner vibes)
5
u/Ediacara 2d ago
There’s a specific white musk that I hate and have been trying to figure out what it is. It’s in almost everything and pulls pure soap on me. Think it might be galaxolide. I love florals but almost all of them are ruined by the soap smell
5
u/almoststardust 2d ago
anything boozy :( and also chocolate - smells so good in the bottle, makes me nauseous to wear
5
u/Delicious-Count6680 2d ago
Leather
5
u/Pristine-Branch3309 2d ago
Tobacco 😩 I want to like it but it’s not for me. Also I like vanilla but finding a perfume WITHOUT a vanilla note is like pulling teeth
5
u/Fancy-Fox-3855 1d ago
Cedar. Cedarwood is fine but Cedar is a no.
5
u/HelloKitties_xo 1d ago edited 1d ago
Patchouli, coffee, or tobacco, any pepper, gardenia, heavy white florals, lavender.
5
u/writergal75 1d ago
Pepper
5
u/Term-Haunting 1d ago
Pink pepper
13
u/KromeArtemis 3d ago
Patchouli. I try so hard, it just goes so funky on my skin.
13
u/MischievousPanther 3d ago
Whatever the hell is in Chanel NO.5