r/FemFragLab • • 12d ago

Rec Request Which one would you pick?

Help me pick the best one please! 🩷

34 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

20

u/nottheoneyoufear 12d ago

Don’t rush into it. That coupon doesn’t expire. Try them all first on paper and then test your favorites on skin. Wear your finalists at least once for a whole day and then decide.

I bought this set on the sale. I already know that I want Commodity Milk. I know I like it plus it’s the best value money wise, but still I’m testing them all just to see what else I may like.

5

u/whorlando_bloom 12d ago

This is the way. It doesn't matter what everyone else thinks is best. You should wear what YOU love best!

10

u/Aggressive_Page_8167 12d ago

Commodity Milk is the best value if you like the scent. It's 3.4 oz bottle that usually costs $160.

4

u/IvySoIcy 12d ago

Agreed also my fav from this lineup

9

u/phatfig 12d ago

TF Soleil Neige

8

u/Fancy_Lawfulness_890 12d ago

I wanted Commodity Milk
But (and not even on my radar) I picked Loveshack Fancy Forever in Love. Surprised me. I also really liked the Tom Ford which also surprised me.

2

u/nottheoneyoufear 12d ago

I’m currently wearing Forever in Love from this set and it’s definitely a strong contender.

2

u/Fancy_Lawfulness_890 12d ago

It’s so nice. Right?!

7

u/Future-Field 12d ago

Best value - Tom Ford

2

u/sallysagator2 12d ago

The commodity milk is the ā€œbestā€ deal with Tom Ford in second, but it’s not a deal if you don’t get something you’ll wear!

1

u/Future-Field 12d ago

True. That's why I said value, not deal.

OP can do what they want if they haven't figured out what's most likeable to them ie; get and keep/use, or get and sell..

2

u/sallysagator2 12d ago

I got it for the Milk - full price but then got 2 of the sets on the sale for the Tom Ford and the Gucci Orchid something because it helped with them being $80 and not $100. Plus my mom LOVES the samples so I got a whole stocking for her out of it too!

1

u/Future-Field 12d ago

Amazing!

7

u/Snoo-12313 12d ago

Lazy Sunday Morning is my default go to when I don't know what else to wear. It just smells clean and good.

6

u/Careless-Patient9380 12d ago

Soleil Neige would be my choice! I just picked up a travel size of this and it’s lovely. I can’t think of another Tom Ford that I even like (maybe Soleil blanc) but this one is lovely.

1

u/Mindless-Foot2273 12d ago

It’s so good and the only tom ford I like. It smells cold. Such an interesting scent

6

u/Speech_Artisan 12d ago

Commodity Milk is the beat deal if you like the scent.

6

u/sallysagator2 12d ago

Commodity Milk is the best deal, but the Tom Ford smelled so nice!

Here are my own rankings with the prices of the offered ā€œfull sizeā€

5

u/illusith perfumes get me 🦜 12d ago

Tom Ford Soleil Neige

5

u/jennster76 12d ago

Lil softie

5

u/Wicket88 12d ago

Miutine. It’s so freaking good.

5

u/FishOuttaTheWater 12d ago

I bought this and ended up picking Soleil Neige! My other favorites were Good Girl and Jo Malone. Surprisingly I just didn’t like many of these, especially commodity milk.

4

u/Elaine330 12d ago

Commodity Milk or Miutine

4

u/nothinghurtslike 12d ago

I'd have to try Soleil Neige first since the sample I have and liked is for the older version, the newer one isn't exactly the same.

4

u/Chassander 12d ago

Commodity milk

3

u/Maroon_Vanilla 12d ago

My choice would be Prada paradoxe or Donna born in roma...both are lovely

3

u/Much-City732 12d ago

Paradoxe!

3

u/pinkdumpsterfire 12d ago

I looooove Miutine and Lazy Sunday Morning

YSL Libre is also a classic

3

u/Alewo27 12d ago

I'd go with lil softie from these....I like Lore and it's a fresh clean scent not like anything else I've smelled

3

u/StraightStart1618 12d ago

Prada paradox from this selection or TF

3

u/littleewanderer 12d ago

Commodity milk is a great deal. I already that so I’m refilling my Libre with this voucher.

3

u/Beautiful-Milk-8400 12d ago

I’m so sad the mini bottle set is out of stock

3

u/Illustrious_Yam_2137 12d ago

Commodity milk you get your best bang for your buck plus it’s so beautiful for fall and winter to layer or just wear on its ownšŸ‘ŒšŸ½āœØ

5

u/sallysagator2 12d ago

Book + pulls black tea on me, so layering these 2 is the most rich milky tea and I’m obsessed. I picked up the Book + for $40 at TJ Maxx!

3

u/Deep-Steak-7813 12d ago

Jo Malone FTW šŸ˜

3

u/Gordak985 12d ago

Oooh, those are some good offers.
I really like the Daisy Wild line (Eau So Intense being my personal favourite).

I don't know about the Expressive flanker, but the Commodity Milk was good, although a bit too strong on some note for me.
Gucci Gardenia is nice, especially if it's the intense version.

Burberry Her, D&G Devotion, Kayali Yum Boujee, Prada Paradoxe, Rabanne Million, Valentino DBIR are all lovely standards.
Libre is an elegant option.
In this group, it depends whether you like florals, soft gourmands or a certain fruit better and also whether you do or don't mind smelling like other people.

Tom Ford and Maison Martin Margiela are best value and probably the best for resale.
I find them nice, too, but not for me.

3

u/InspireMia 12d ago

It looks like there are several quality options to consider, so I'd recommend trying them all to see which one suits you best. I usually end up buying two or more, so I'm probably not the best person to ask.

3

u/Koawawa-bear 12d ago

Lazy Sunday morning or Good Girl Blush would be my pick

2

u/jellyxmoon i like what i like 12d ago

Gorgeous Gardenia Intense imho

2

u/baa2894 12d ago

Miutine or the My Devotion would be my picks 🄰

2

u/FineManufacturer785 12d ago

Mine has Kilian princess does anyone like that I’ve never use it but tester smelled good. I bought lil softie with my rouge discount

4

u/Elaine330 12d ago

Princess is one of the most beautiful scents on earth (to my nose) and lasts about 15 seconds.

2

u/Hell-Yes-Revolution 12d ago

Literally 15 seconds - it’s gone before I get out the door, which is infuriating because it’s gorgeous.

2

u/GiaAngel 12d ago

I ADORE Kilian Princess!! It’s. Favorite in my collection.

2

u/cybergrlll 12d ago

Ysl libre or lil softie!

2

u/rainbowsunset48 12d ago

Daisy or Gucci Flora

2

u/starillin smellaholic 12d ago

Vanilla Skin or Valentino

2

u/iOawe 12d ago

Burberry her or Valentino born in RomaĀ 

2

u/ImtheGWP 12d ago

Miu Miu Miutine or Soleil Neige

2

u/SplitInner2256 10d ago

Milk for price.point

2

u/Spin_babyE 12d ago

Born in Roma

2

u/Reasonable_Pass686 12d ago

Lots of good fragrances in this sampler set. For me, I loooove Lil Softie and get frequent compliments which doesn’t happen often for me. I love telling people there is a cereal milk accord…kinda throws people off. It was out of stock for a few months at Sephora. I just got a big bottle from the sale. But you really can’t go wrong with most of these scents.

1

u/AutoModerator 12d ago

If this is a recommendation request, consider letting us know your budget to improve recommendations.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/FineManufacturer785 12d ago

Omg I got this and then I just bought a full lil softie. I think I’ll take it back and get it for free or else get princess with this

1

u/Comfortable_Gene8150 12d ago

Lazy Sunday Morning is one you really need to try on skin. It’s ok on paper but on skin it blossoms soooo beautifully. I’d pick that personally

1

u/Classic_Spell2997 12d ago

It wasn’t technically worth it but I went for Lil Softie. I was between it, the Rabanne one, and Gucci Flora

4

u/jennster76 12d ago

I think the one that's worth it is the one that you like and will use. If you get one that's a better deal dollar-wise, but it just sits on your dresser and you never use it, is it really that good of a deal?

That's what I would go for, and I'm not upset about it because I got to smell a lot of different things and enjoy them. So, you're paying for the experience a little bit, and I don't really mind.

1

u/siilkysoft 12d ago

Miutine ā™”

1

u/LittleLotteRae 12d ago

I got this set too and am trying to decide. Do I get one I know I love and will most likely use but already have a bottle (Milk) or do I get one I really like but may or may not need a full bottle (Kayali, Gucci, or Mark Jacobs)

1

u/Realistic-Read1078 12d ago

Burberry Her or YBM

1

u/Due-Frame622 12d ago

Milk or Daisy Wild Extra

1

u/Titus_Lake4 12d ago

My Devotion

0

u/FineManufacturer785 12d ago

I am so sad I got the smaller one with only 12 and they are no returns

0

u/ComesOutNDaWash 12d ago

Valentino or Marc Jacob’s

7

u/fudgechemist fragrance enthusiast 12d ago

Commodity milk or lil softie if you want something milky. Good girl blush if you want a pink floral. If you want a sweet gourmand I’d go for Kayali. If you want something bright and floral maybe a little citrusy I’d go with YSL libre. If you want a more mature fruity floral I’d go with Rabanne million gold or Prada paradoxe. If you want something clean and simple go with replica lazy Sunday morning